WWE WrestleMania 42: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
What if Pat McAfee isn't the 'higher power' behind Randy Orton after all and TKO loses their minds?
WWE's business has always been obsessed with sensationalism. Manufactured sensationalism. It's what makes the World...Wrestling Entertainment wheel go round and round. No off season, no significant breaks, no respite. It's an endless loop of drama. Unfortunately for Triple H, a lot of the drama has happened via injuries, poor ticket sales and corporate meddling heading into WrestleMania 42.
TKO could be about to make things worse. Much worse.
Look, one of the biggest dangling carrots for this piece probably won't happen for legal reasons (rather than common sense!), but these are nightmares - they don't necessarily need to be drenched or even sprinkled in reality. This is simply the worst of the worst that could come true for WWE when they hit up Las Vegas for the second year running.
There are glaring problems with characters like Cody Rhodes, Pat McAfee, Jade Cargill, Rhea Ripley and more heading into the event. Meanwhile, John Cena may be asked to do something rather embarrassing on the grandest stage, creative could get cold feet on one of their biggest rising stars, at least one main event may struggle to live up to the hype and more.
Then, there's the featured graphic you've presumably clicked on for a reason. That's a true 'worst case' scenario for many a wrestling fan, and not only because it'd bring back the done-to-death McMahon family melodrama and push it to the forefront of WWE programming.
You might not have any fingernails left after chewing on these scares.
Get Surfshark for the bargain price of just $1.78 per month! Valid only until April 19th!
https://get.surfshark.net/aff_c?offer_id=1030&aff_id=1691&url_id=2561
10. Several Women’s Title Matches Sag
The women's division isn't in fine fettle heading into WrestleMania this year, not really. On paper, there should be plenty to get excited about, but the storytelling for some of these matches has been dreadful. Specifically, Jade Cargill vs. Rhea Ripley has been trundling along offering nothing worthwhile on episodes of SmackDown.
Both AJ Lee vs. Becky Lynch and Stephanie Vaquer vs. Liv Morgan look a little more inspired, but all 3 have the potential to drag along across both nights at ‘Mania. Being honest, it's Vaquer vs. Morgan which might have to do most of the heavy lifting here, but WWE don’t want apathy or for these bouts to come across as outright boring come the weekend.
Yeah, good luck with that.
There's a very real chance that fans will only make some noise if Ripley beats Cargill for the Women's Title, or for Vaquer's 'Devil's Kiss' signature move (assuming she does it). There really doesn't appear to be enough juice behind a grudge bout like Lee vs. Lynch either. On the whole, WWE has done a woeful job of selling these title showdowns as must-see or worthy of the 'Mania platform.
None of these can hold a candle to epics like Rhea vs. Becky or IYO SKY vs. Bayley from 'Mania 40. Similarly, 41's Triple Threat between Ripley, SKY and Bianca Belair feels like a lifetime ago for the women's division. How on earth did we get here?! It's not outlandish to predict some yawns in the house for this trio of 'blockbuster attractions', and that's a real shame.
9. The ‘Demon’ Takes Another Loss
Finn Bálor’s ‘Demon’ hasn’t been seen since losing a Hell In A Cell match to Edge back at WrestleMania 39. A full 3 years on, what if he's about to taste another loss to Dominik Mysterio? Where would the character go from there? It’s already on thin ice due to that Edge defeat and the situation with Roman Reigns back at Extreme Rules 2021.
Yet more misery could kill the persona off completely.
Bálor himself has been rolling his eyes at WWE suddenly bringing the character out of cold storage so suddenly, and it hasn't been sitting well with some that the company missed out on the surprise element here. Surely it would've been more thrilling (and gleaned some amazing facials from 'Dirty Dom') had this particular 'Demon' been one of 'Mania's biggest shock moments?
That's gone now, because the 'Demon' has been announced in advance. There's no going back - WWE chiefs can't exactly say they were only kidding, then act like they're doing everyone a favour by double bluffing on demonic goodness come Sunday night. That'd just be stupid.
Speaking of stupid, it'd be ridiculous if Finn's alter ego took another bashing for no good rhyme or reason. Creative painted themselves into a corner with this 'Demon' announcement and Judgment Day splintering, so now they've got no choice but to see it through and have Bálor's face painted menace run completely over the top of Mysterio.
How could Finn even show face on Monday's Raw after 'Mania if he lost, y'know?
8. WWE Gets Cold Feet On Oba Femi
No, this surely won’t happen, but what if someone pops a hand up backstage and wonders if it’s too much too soon for Oba Femi. So, Triple H looks around, sighs, strokes his chin and finally decrees that Brock Lesnar has to go over so he’s strong for Gunther in the summer. What a disaster that'd be!
Everyone knows that WWE should just strap a rocket to Femi. He’s 27 years old, has all the tools, is connecting with the fanbase and should be the priority here. Brock can withstand defeat and move on perfectly fine. This is Brock freakin' Lesnar we're talking about. One defeat to someone as credible as Oba isn't going to wreck his entire mystique.
Hunter earned some scorn for putting himself between these powerhouses on a recent edition of Raw, but such scorn will turn to praise if he puts all of his chips behind Femi and says: 'He's the one. He's the future we're building towards'. Lesnar is clearly useful from a box office standpoint, but he's yesterday's man in terms of getting pushed ahead of everyone else.
If it's true that Brock plans to wind down his wrestling career over the next 12-18 months, then it's crucial that he puts some future stars over in a big, big way on his way out the exit door. WrestleMania 42's clash with Oba will tell everyone how serious the company is about putting building blocks in place.
Oba can't lose. He simply can't. This is too important, and a win over Brock would do wonders for him.
7. John Cena Lies About The Attendance
John Cena is back mere months after retiring with a loss to Gunther at Saturday Night's Main Event on 13 December 2025. In reality, 'Super Cena' might only be there to welcome everyone to both nights then announce the combined attendance on the Sunday. Good luck with that if he is, because everyone and their granny knows that this has sold worse than ‘Mania 41 in the same venue.
Eyes will be glued to the weekend to see how WWE plays this. It'll be interesting to see if they plan to tell quite the fib on camera, and use Cena’s connection with the audience to get through it. 'It wasn't us who said it, it was John'. One can see Triple H mumbling his way through that sort of explanation during a rare podcast interview in the future.
Or, 'The Game' would just pie the question entirely and pretend he doesn't know what anyone is talking about. WrestleMania 42 was a rip-roaring success at the gate, and why would you suggest otherwise?! That doesn't tell the full story. Also, Cena must be mindful of his relationship with the audience and how they view him post-retirement.
He'll get the kind of fanfare and adulation WWE wanted Hulk Hogan to get during his cameo spots for years, but some of that goodwill might wash away if he claims that the company broke records in Allegiant Stadium when everybody knows that certainly can't be the case.
This is a rare position for the promotion's bigwigs to be in. Let's see how they handle the heat.
6. Sunday Sees In-Ring "ManiaHausen"!
Danhausen has done a wonderful job of recovering following his woeful debut at Elimination Chamber. However, there are only 6 matches on the Sunday compared to 7 on the Saturday at this year's 'Mania, so unless WWE plans to add another in then that’ll leave some time (on paper) for a segment.
Sure, it could be the usual Hall Of Fame stuff on stage, or it might be Danhausen cutting a promo and doing some supernatural tricks. He’s screwed if it’s the latter, especially if that brings WrestleMania to a screeching halt just to waste time. Learn your lesson here, WWE.
"ManiaHausen" would struggle if it's on Sunday's format sheets. At most, Danhausen should be showing up during Saturday's opening 6-man tag-team effort to curse IShowSpeed (or something silly like that). Or, maybe he'll appear in some backstage skits to promote something alongside another off the wall character such as R-Truth.
Neither of those spots would eat up too much time, and therein lies the problem/worry: Danhausen getting a full blown entrance akin to Chamber, then grabbing a mic and awkwardly delighting in saying nothing of note would kill all of 'Mania 42's momentum; keeping the energy levels high should be a mission statement this weekend.
WWE's writers are starting to get into the groove with this spooky sideshow gimmick, but let's not trade logic for reckless ambition. It'd be much better if any remaining time for Sunday went to another match rather than some going nowhere talking heads skit no-one asked for in the first place.
5. Weekend Main Event Can’t Live Up Hype
CM Punk vs. Roman Reigns is the match chosen to headline the entire weekend for a reason. It’s the one Triple H believes carries most interest, and it’s also a nice moment for Punk getting to headline WrestleMania in a singles setting. That's the latest 'making up for lost time' friendship moment between those guys.
However, Cody Rhodes vs. John Cena didn’t live up to the billing last year. So, what if 2026 sees a repeat of that rather than the blistering Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes bout from ‘Mania 40? Flopping when he's been handed everything he ever wanted is true nightmare fuel for Punk and his fans, because he’s waited a long, long time for this chance.
Too long, some might say.
Roman likes to start his bouts slowly during the 'Tribal Chief'/'OTC' era. That's kinda his thing, so it's not outrageous to guess that he and Punk could take up to 5 minutes after the bell to actually lock horns and kick the match off properly. Fair enough, but the action that comes next has to be of a very, very high standard to maintain interest from the live crowd.
Cody and Cena lost the people early in 2025, then Travis Scott's entrance midway through killed the crowd. Fingers crossed this Punk vs. Reigns mega-match lives up to the hype and that Punk (in particular) has been keeping some powder dry to blow everyone's socks off on Sunday evening.
He hasn't wrestled a match since late-February, so this 'Mania match will either totally rule or stumble badly. We'll all know fairly early which one it's going to be.
4. Cody Rhodes Gets Booed Hard
The Rock's face was a picture when fans started to turn against him and cheer for Hollywood Hogan back during their 'Icon vs. Icon' special at WrestleMania X8. Smartly, and knowing he'd never be able to fight against that kind of backlash, Rocky leaned into it and both he and Hogan switched roles. That was the right thing to do, because nostalgia for Hulkamania was king in 2002.
There's a real concern here that Cody Rhodes wouldn't lean into any booing at 'Mania 42. His suck up promo from a recent SmackDown, where he called fans “family”, suggests that WWE want Rhodes to persist with his heroic character no matter what. It’d be hellish if he was completely booed out of the building vs. Randy Orton from first bell to last.
Some “Cody Sucks” chants would be undeserved but aren't impossible.
Rhodes is a great babyface, but fans are growing tired of his act and it feels like it needs a breather. The reigning WWE Champion has done incredibly well to last as long as he has as a traditional baby in the modern era, and he should get plaudits for doing so. Nothing lasts forever though. That's just the way it is.
Agents will be banking on Pat McAfee's involvement alongside Randy to bring the heat for Orton. He'll likely be cheered regardless of what McAfee is getting up to around ringside. Further, select fans agree with some of the things Pat has been saying, and they've sniffed out Cody's disinterest in the story.
Ready to read how things could get even worse? You got it.
3. Pat McAfee Leaves With The WWE Title
Oh dear.
Pat McAfee wouldn't be leaving 'Mania with the WWE Title because he's champion, obviously, but it's more just that he'd be carrying the belt around for his boy Randy Orton. That happened on SmackDown, and it just didn’t feel necessary at all. Why should Randy let someone else tote a championship he covets?
McAfee's antics conjured up reminders of David Arquette walking around with the WCW World Title somehow. No, that's not meant as a favourable comparison in the slightest. At least Arquette (daft a decision though it undoubtedly was) could point to being the actual champ. Pat can't, so why is he draping the title over his shoulder instead of Randy's?
Listen, if this is all a vehicle for McAfee to delude himself into thinking Orton won the title for him then count this writer out. What a waste of everyone's time it'd be if Randy RKO's or punts Pat back to the podcasts on the next SmackDown episode after Vegas. That's the sort of rapid swerve turn WWE could make given the lay of the land in April 2026.
TKO's influence over what's happening onscreen needs to stop. They can pitch ideas, absolutely, but they honestly don't have much of a clue about what WWE fans want to see and this story shift proves it. McAfee was blatantly going for some sort of Paul Heyman alongside Roman Reigns thing with the belt on TV, but it came across like he wanted to be champion himself.
Stop it. Definitely don't do that at 'Mania!
2. Vince McMahon Is The ‘Higher Power’
This is highly unlikely, because McMahon is still embroiled in legal issues aplenty and WWE/TKO probably wouldn’t want to go near him whilst that’s hanging over his head. That said, this is pro wrestling, and strange things do happen. They have happened.
What if Vince is the one pulling the strings on Randy Orton and Pat McAfee because he doesn’t agree that Cody Rhodes should be pushed to the moon as Triple H’s boy? Also, it did feel noteworthy that Cody kinda/sorta/almost mentioned Vince during a face to face promo with Stephanie McMahon on Raw recently.
Some ears perked up after that.
Older fans will recall how rubbish the 'Higher Power' storyline was back in 1999. McMahon revealing himself to be in cahoots with The Undertaker's Ministry Of Darkness just so he could mess with Steve Austin some more was illogical and didn't really pan out. It wasn't needed to continue their feud, so felt like a wasted creative trick.
Things are different in 2026 anyway. Vince's reputation is in the mud, and he'd be an unwanted returnee for many fans watching weekly. That's before one even gets to the staggering elephant in the room about his ongoing court case and legal woes.
Tread carefully, TKO. If you pull the trigger on a Mr. McMahon comeback, then it could well sour a large portion of the audience. Maybe this sort of entry wouldn't even exist had Brock Lesnar not returned amidst controversy back at SummerSlam 2025 himself.
Vince is next level though. Again, be real careful with this sort of thing.
1. It Feels As Lacklustre As 2025
WrestleMania 41 came and went without actually feeling all that much like the biggest PLE weekender of the year. It struggled to convince, in other words. Some of the matches were great, like the opening night's main event Triple Threat and another trio smashing it in the women's division to open up the second night, but something felt off about the entire event generally.
Creatively, WWE doesn’t have nearly as much momentum going into 42 as it did 12 months ago, so the same thing could happen here too. If 2026’s event goes off the air and everyone looks around like, ‘Is that it?’, then Triple H and his writing team will be in hot water.
They need to hit this one out of the park. It's really as simple at that.
Hunter will be begging combos like Cody and Randy Orton or CM Punk and Roman Reigns to do everything in their power on Saturday and Sunday night. Those guys are gonna have to be on top form, because it's imperative that WrestleMania in execution is better than WrestleMania has looked during the build up.
Punk and Reigns will have to avoid the 'walking through treacle' feel to last year's headliner too. They won't have Travis Scott on hand to ruin things, so that's a good start.
What other nightmares about WrestleMania 42 have been keeping you awake? For more WWE, check out 11 Things We Learned From Triple H On Cody Rhodes' Podcast and WWE WrestleMania 42: 20 Things That NEED To Happen!