WWE Trades Ruthless Aggression For PG | Wrestling Timelines

By Michael Sidgwick /

January 22, 2010 | “Goodbye” Piggy James

WWE

Pro wrestling in the U.S. is a simple morality play. A baddie cheats, the goodie loses unfairly, the goodie gets the baddie where they want them on a level playing field, the good guy wins. This isn’t how it needs to go, necessarily. As was the case with Bret Hart in 1997 and Hangman Page in 2021, a great artist is capable of playing a complex character. In the 21st century, the increased influence of puroresu shapes a storytelling trend in which dream matches are fought over the idea of who has best mastered the craft. But what wrestling can’t do, almost invariably, is handle sensitive material in any kind of unifying or progressive way.

Advertisement

In late 2009, Mickie James is relentlessly bullied by the LayCool team of Layla and Michelle McCool. Because you are not able to see Mickie’s ribs through her skin, the impressively athletic woman meets WWE’s definition of fat, for which she is ridiculed in various segments. On the January 22, 2010 SmackDown, LayCool throw a “goodbye” party for James. It’s the usual, nasty fare. After beating her up alongside Layla and Beth Phoenix, McCool says “Looks like it’s feeding time, Piggie James!”

A cake, which is decorated in the shape of a pig, is smeared over Mickie’s face. Her head is then doused in jelly as hundreds of thousands of young women, tortured by constant projections of what a good body is meant to look like, look at their own with a pang of terror and disgust. WWE might be able to justify this, if, for example, Mickie James is launched into a prominent spot, or if the company from this point forward reimagines its approach to presenting women. Neither of these things happen; while James wins the WWE Women’s title at McCool’s expense at the Royal Rumble on January 31, she loses it a month later on February 23.

Advertisement

WWE actually throws a shoot goodbye segment for James on the edition of SmackDown taped on April 22, on which she is pinned by Layla in a tag team match. James does not become a new positive role model for young girls suffering from body image issues. She is released from her contract that very day.

The storyline is horrendous, and it feels like WWE is having far too much fun telling it.

Advertisement

June 28, 2010 | Baloney, Fudge, And Mustard

WWE Network

The PG Era of WWE does not work without one man: John Cena.

Advertisement

By 2010, John Cena is far and away WWE’s biggest star. He has been the biggest star in the company for several years, and now, he is virtually the only main event-level act. Shawn Michaels retired in March. His opponent on the night, the Undertaker, is in his last year as a full-time attraction. Triple H is off television as he focuses on his corporate career, and will also only return on a part-time basis. Batista went on hiatus in May, and will not return until 2014, when he makes some appearances as a part-timer.

Cena’s presence is even more pronounced, and as a babyface, he has never been more neutered.

Advertisement

The kids love him. They love him for his superhuman strength, his character’s values, and his room-dominating charisma. The grown-ups in the room see right through him. He is not Hulk Hogan. Hogan was corny, but he was still a pro wrestler who could sell big and convince an entire arena to fall under his spell. Cena brushes off big moves and shrugs at big losses because he’s here to have fun and he always gets his win back. Many despise him and his cringeworthy attempts at comedy. The absolute worst material is spewed out on the June 28, 2010 WWE Raw.

Cena presides over a different era of WWE, in which you get welcomed to Monday Night Raw by the master of ceremonies. Cena, as the mascot of a company that is now a show about a wrestling show, does a take on the Rock’s stand-up comedy act. It’s awful. When the anonymous Raw General manager rules that Cena must wrestle Mark Henry, The gurning Cena, who is not allowed to swear, says “Baloney, fudge, and mustard! My life is being ruined by the internet! I haven’t flipped out this bad since my mom cancelled my subscription to Warcraft!”

Advertisement

This is horrendous on several levels. The material is wretched. The fake swearing is childish. The reference to a viral YouTube video is a desperate attempt to reach the kids. If Cena is being earnest, he is literally behaving like a child; if he’s trying to be funny, he isn’t, and he is treating an upcoming match against a man marketed as the strongest alive like a joke.

But how can WWE possibly be such a dark and sleazy place when this unfunny cornball is the star of the show?

Advertisement

October 19, 2010 | Stand Up For WWE

WWE.com

WWE’s image clean-up operation was going reasonably well.

Advertisement

While not at the level of genuine sports, the Wellness Policy is not a bare minimum sham. The wave of death has subsided, relative to the mid-point of the 2000s. But really, it is working because the mainstream media doesn’t really care all that much to probe. Wrestling exists, in a paradoxical state, as a huge niche. A lot of people care about wrestling; they are the only ones. That is until a news story develops that people might care about.

Linda McMahon, former WWE Chief Executive Officer and Vince McMahon’s wife at the time, is running for senate as a Republican, and the race is heating up. Political opponents and partisan media outlets are asking inconvenient questions and highlighting WWE’s history of wrongdoing in the expected, mucky battle. Where Umaga’s death did not register, the August 13, 2010 passing of Lance Cade is weaponised. Linda is pressed on her relationship with him and WWE’s culpability in his death. She defends herself by saying that WWE is as blameless as a studio would be in the case of Heath Ledger’s death. The pressure continues to mount; on a near-daily basis, articles are penned lambasting WWE’s less-than-sparkling history of worker’s rights. One is penned by old enemy of the state Phil Mushnick for the New York Post, which is naturally what triggers Vince McMahon into unveiling the widely-mocked ‘Stand Up For WWE’ campaign, launched on October 19, 2010.

Advertisement

Vince, feeling unfairly targeted, wants you, the WWE Universe, to set the record straight. There are 10 ways of achieving this, as set out by WWE in an official communication:

1) Forward ‘Stand Up For WWE’ videos to your friends

Advertisement

2) Upload video testimonials to YouTube and Facebook voicing your support

3) Email your friends and family stating why you are a WWE fan

Advertisement

4) Friend WWE on Facebook

5) Make “I’m Standing Up For WWE” your Facebook status

Advertisement

6) Write a letter to the editor of your newspaper

7) Share your favourite WWE stories on Twitter and Facebook

Advertisement

8) Read a story that is unfair to WWE? Email the reporter

9) Create “I Stand Up For WWE” signs or t-shirts for live events

Advertisement

10) Check back regularly for updates

Most WWE fans laugh at the campaign. Linda loses the election, which was the only way the stories were ever going away. With this doomed exercise in hubris over and done with, WWE escapes the glare once more.

Advertisement

November 9, 2010 | Michael Cole Falls Asleep

WWE

It felt good being a WWF fan in the good old days, didn’t it? And wasn’t that the point?

Advertisement

You watched in the 1980s and early 1990s, enchanted by the real-life superheroes who always won in the end. Roddy Piper would run his nasty mouth, but Hulk Hogan shut him up. Randy Savage was an intense psychopath so fast and volatile that it felt like he could attack anybody at any minute, but Hogan put him down for the three. Bobby Heenan was cruel to your favourites, but Gorilla Monsoon never entertained his nonsense.

Now imagine that Heenan is the lead commentator, is mean-spirited, and has lost nearly every last shred of his legendary comedic sensibility. You arrive then at Michael Cole: heel play-by-play commentator.

Advertisement

Heel Michael Cole is an insufferable listen, and his role means he is inescapable. Literally, barely a second passes without his sardonic, joyless, snarky voice polluting the broadcast. He hates almost everything. Inexplicably, his role is to hate almost everything. It is one of the worst, most baffling, and least enjoyable choices WWE has ever made. It is anti-feel-good. What is a child meant to make of it? Children’s television is meant to be joyful. It’s meant to take place in a vibrant, pleasant world. Cole’s nasal misery soundtracks a world stained with the dark red and blue lighting of a soul-crushing era. Cole is awful on Raw, but on the November 9, 2010 edition of NXT, he reaches a nadir. WWE no longer presents Bra & Panties matches, but the boy’s club still finds a way to be misogynistic.

Cole sarcastically describes the action on the all-women’s season of the NXT game show as “riveting!” - it becomes his catchphrase - and the running joke is paid off when he falls asleep during the show. The show is performed by developmental prospects who are barely trained. Of course the action is subpar. Cole pisses himself laughing at the botches and timing miscues nonetheless in what is a thoroughly degrading hour of television.

Advertisement

Ultimately, this version of Vince McMahon - the man who has conquered the U.S. wrestling landscape, who destroyed his WCW competition many moons ago - is too powerful, out-of-touch, egotistical, and rampantly unpleasant to produce earnest and well-intentioned family-friendly programming.

And everybody who works for WWE wants to suck up to him.

Advertisement

April 29, 2011 | Be A STAR

WWE.com

In the next phase of its clean-up operation, WWE launches the Be A Star campaign. Launched in partnership with the Creative Coalition, the national anti-bullying initiative is designed, on the surface, to “promote equality, positive social interactions, and anti-bullying awareness”. In order to actually attempt to make this happen, WWE is active in communities hosting rallies, and publishes educational material online. STAR here is an acronym for “Show Tolerance And Respect”. Longtime fans of WWE receive it as a rank, hollow, and laughable exercise in hypocrisy.

Advertisement

WWE’s history of equality is appalling. As of 2011, not a single positive LGBTQIA+ character has been presented as a positive role model. Only one black person has held the men’s World title. Almost every time an Asian wrestler has stepped foot in a WWE ring, commentators have either mentioned Pearl Harbor, talked about “sandals” when they are visibly wearing regulation wrestling boots, or used a word that rhymes with it to describe a kip-up spot. The women, when they aren’t being pushed explicitly as sex objects, are given less than five minutes to wrestle. A history of WWE’s terrible record of bullying and hazing is worthy of its own 10,000-word deep-dive.

WWE’s hypocrisy is not limited by its historical record under TV-14. Vince McMahon is notorious for bullying onscreen and off. It practically defines a man infamous for berating his staff, most notably Jim Ross, whose 2005 colonoscopy was ridiculed so pungently on national television that his wife, Jan, burst into tears watching it. It’s not just WWE’s history. The present and the future are also disgusting.

Advertisement

In the exact same year that WWE launches the Be A STAR campaign, which is insulting, cynical nonsense, Jim Ross is mocked on TV and fired as lead commentator in front of millions. McMahon is at it again a year later…

June 27, 2011 | Pipebomb

WWE.com

There is a glaring disconnect between WWE fans and the office - or rather, one set of WWE fans and the office.

Advertisement

A lot of WWE fans were first hooked, as children, by Hulk Hogan. He was their real-life superhero. Vince McMahon lost many of those fans by the early-to-mid 1990s through a combination of factors. The kids didn’t care about the scandals their parents almost certainly did not tell them about. They did care that wrestling was not cool, big, or trendy anymore.

Those exact same kids are pulled back in as high schoolers and college students in 1998 as the Attitude Era takes hold. Anti-authority badass babyfaces and buxom women appeal to their new teenage sensibilities. In 2011, disillusioned by the dreadful PG trappings, those fans expect WWE to mature alongside them all over again; after all, the promotion has done it before. The problem is that WWE, rightly, feels no obligation to gear its product towards a set of fans born in the 1970s and early 1980s. WWE exists to make money, fundamentally, and Vince McMahon feels there is more to be made, and for longer, by targeting the kids. But the adults are not going away. The WWE fanbase is divided into two competing tribes, whose volleyed war cries of “Let’s go Cena / Cena sucks!” soundtrack this civil war.

Advertisement

CM Punk is smart. John Cena is the babyface for the children. Punk knows that the adults in the room are holding out for a hero of their own, and on June 27, 2011, he wins them over with a shocking and instantly iconic ‘Pipebomb’ promo in which he savages the current state of WWE. The Pipebomb is for everybody who wants a better, more adult-oriented WWE - a meritocracy that rewards the pro wrestler in a sports entertainment world booked by and for Vince McMahon.

The Pipebomb promo is considered a defining moment of the PG Era. In terms of pure artistry, it is one of the best Raw moments ever - but in reality, this is not a ratings hit.

Advertisement

The Nexus programme, launched on June 7, 2010, was a big hit initially. Certain episodes of Raw - June 21, 2010 (3.52), July 26 (3.51) - drew stronger numbers than some on the road to WrestleMania 26. The Nexus was an effective heel unit for a brief time; the idea that John Cena was under threat by a violent heel faction resonated with fans who wanted Cena to defend WWE from them. Comparatively, the ‘Summer of Punk’ is a failure. The number for the July 4, 2011 Raw is amongst the lowest of the year. It’s a holiday, so the number is inconclusive even when you play around with percentages of people skipping TV that night altogether. What’s more damning is the 2.91 drawn on July 11, the night on which Punk returns to further build the main event of Money In The Bank. It is the lowest non-holiday number in months. The post-Money In The Bank Raw rating, after the huge cliffhanger of Punk leaving WWE as WWE Champion, is a 3.23. It’s a bogstandard Monday number in line with the 2011 average. Ultimately, the Summer of Punk is a massive deal to a small, vocal minority. WWE is condescending when they use that turn of phrase, but in this instance, it’s hard to argue.

CM Punk does not stand a chance of fundamentally altering the WWE landscape, as alluring as that idea is to the jaded. Vince is unmoved by the whole thing, and undeterred in his vision. The kids are the future.

Advertisement

January 27, 2012 | Flatulent Natalya

WWE Network

Years later, when guesting on the Masked Man Show podcast in August 2023, high-ranking creative writer Brian Gewirtz - synonymous among wrestling fans as the man responsible for the unfunny dreck that plagues the product - blames the PG directive. “I thought it was stifling,” Gewirtz says. What Gewirtz fails to acknowledge is that WWE operated under family-friendly restrictions during its Golden Era.

Advertisement

The WWF of old told wonderful, unforgettable stories without resorting to edgelord rubbish. The epic saga of Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth - which fuelled the biggest pay-per-view buy rate of the Golden Era at WrestleMania 5, and culminated in the most feel-good WWE moment ever at WrestleMania 7 - unfolded without alienating sponsors or drawing negative press attention. It was obviously possible to do something like this from 2008 onwards; WWE was just woefully unequipped to do so, because Vince was miles past-it and nobody dared challenge him.

Because WWE no longer resembles a pro wrestling promotion by design in 2012, it is essentially law that it must attempt to be funny - and with the PG guardrails in place, Vince McMahon is at a loss. There are two dimensions to his sense of humour; he can be both brilliantly cruel and puerile. This is the man who, in the Attitude Era, booked the Big Boss Man to raid the Big Show’s father’s funeral and booked the Rock to hit his finisher on the British Bulldog on a tray of dog sh*t. He could not do the black comedy you’re not supposed to laugh at during the PG Era, which is how we arrive at flatulent Natalya.

Advertisement

On the January 27, 2012 edition of SmackDown, Natalya asks Teddy Long for a rematch with Tamina before breaking wind. She leaves the scene embarrassed as Long and Aksana quickly follow. Santino Marella enters the frame and essentially acts like the gas is toxic. There are two sounds worse than the flatulence sound effect, somehow; the eerie absence of noise made by those watching the tron in the arena, and Michael Cole’s obviously fake laughter. The latter sound defines this period of WWE. It is the sound of everybody not named Vince McMahon knowing just how bad this drivel is and failing to pretend that it isn’t.

There’s no punchline. There is no incident that makes Natalya do this. There is no sense that Natalya is doing this at the least appropriate time. Fart jokes are the oldest in the entire genre. Book a wedding or a funeral, and have her fart there. Nope: she simply does it, just in time for Santino or Hornswoggle to walk into the shot and pretend that the smell has killed them. These aren’t bad jokes. They aren’t jokes at all. Eventually, Natalya will become proud of her farts, letting rip on purpose to punish Eve Torres for her cruel treatment of Zack Ryder.

Advertisement

Incredibly, in 2012, a chaotic time known for “stop/start pushes”, this is one of the most notable examples of character development.

April 29, 2012 | It’s Not All Bad

WWE.com

WWE produces some great shows during a wretched era. It’s not all bad. It’s very far from great, most of the time, but it’s not all bad. “Uneven” is still a bit generous. Extreme Rules 2012 is a fantastic pay-per-view offering - but the veneer of PG becomes questionable. The show is highlighted by three excellent matches.

Advertisement

Sheamus defeats Daniel Bryan in a blinding, hard-hitting Two out of Three Falls bout. After the dismal stunt at WrestleMania 28, where a red-hot Bryan is defeated in 18 seconds, this brutal exercise in atonement delivers big. Bryan is rehabilitated. He plays the heel role, but his rise to babyface stardom is inevitable. CM Punk defeats Chris Jericho in another superior WrestleMania sequel.

In the main event, a returning Brock Lesnar loses to John Cena. The result is baffling, but it does not matter. The match is so graphically compelling that it becomes an instant modern classic. It also does not resemble a PG match whatsoever. John Cena is busted open the hard way in a very real, blood-soaked beat-down. This had already happened during the promotion of the match.

Advertisement

Lesnar is deliberately positioned as the real TV-14 MMA killer in a PG world. It sets him apart as the most special attraction in the promotion. Over subsequent years, this gimmick, which barely qualifies as such, leads to at least one incident of a concussion when he smashes the sharp point of his elbow in the skull of Randy Orton at SummerSlam 2016. WWE’s PG rebrand is itself a gimmick; Lesnar’s role, which is oppressive and constant, makes a further mockery of it.

June 11, 2012 | Vince McMahon Mocks Jim Ross

WWE

The thing about PG is that the classification does not simply imply an absence of sexual or over-the-top violent content. If you are a parent or guardian doling out screen time to your small child, you also want to ensure that what they are watching has values. The material need not be expressly educational - but, ideally, it should not be mean-spirited. You don’t want your child watching a TV programme that enthusiastically ridicules marginalised communities, or people living with medical conditions or disabilities. It is unpleasant, and might arm them with a defence mechanism in a playground that is often a cruel and competitive battle for self-esteem.

Advertisement

On the June 11, 2012 episode of WWE Raw, Vince McMahon makes his grand return to programming. A sporadic presence nowadays, Vince pops in and out in order to pop a rating. He’s still playing Mr. McMahon, but this iteration of the character is a quasi-babyface. He’s a nasty big shot who makes everybody around him feel small, but he targets heels. He’s the love-to-hate Mr. McMahon here, a sort-of agent of chaos. In a show-long storyline, McMahon is on hand to appraise the job of idiot heel authority figure John Laurinaitis. McMahon gives Big Johnny an ultimatum; book a good show, or you’re fired. It is meant to be fun watching Vince make Laurinaitis squirm. Vince is the goodie. In other skits, Vince plays the life-of-the-party. It’s fun having Mr. McMahon back, isn’t it?!

Not if you’re Jim Ross, whose years-long Bell’s Palsy diagnosis Vince mocks, with horrifically exaggerated glee, in a backstage segment with Hornswoggle. This is reprehensible stuff with zero purpose. Even if Vince was playing a heel, it would be questionable in the extreme. He isn’t. You are meant to enjoy him in a “Oh, what is he like?!” sort of way.

Advertisement

Vince bullies Jim Ross because he gets off on it. He is widely and rightly criticised in wrestling circles, but this does not undermine WWE’s wider goals. The company is becoming synonymous with hokey John Cena-led fare; the ‘Unexpected John Cena’ meme is seeded this very year. Cena is the face of WWE, and he wears a gurning, beaming expression. He is the first thing people think of when they think of WWE. He’s lame and appeals to little kiddies, as the Rock pointed out in the build to WrestleMania 28.

For WWE, this is a very good thing.

Advertisement

September 3, 2012 | Team Hell No

WWE.com

WWE gets it. WWE develops an act that is liquid PG: the tag team appeals to children but is so well-performed and genuinely funny that the parents who bring the kids along to the shows can get behind them as well. It is hilarious, wholesome, and heartwarming.

Advertisement

Team Hell No is Daniel Bryan and Kane perfecting the signature, squabbling WWE strange bedfellows trope. Bryan is a wrestling genius playing a sort of perpetually enraged Seinfeld guest character; Kane, a human demon from hell, is inexplicably and perfectly cast as the rational straight man. The premise is brilliantly absurd and the chemistry is irresistible. In their best moment together, they are ordered to attend therapy to work through their differences. In a great gag, therapist Dr. Shelby’s son is proudly wearing a goat mask, overjoyed at being cast in his school play. Bryan, referred to as “goat face” on WWE TV, throws a conniption fit in his crying face. Kane and Bryan bond over their love of fury, and subsequently become an enraged, chair-wielding pair of family-friendly babyfaces.

Great as it is, this should be the launch of Daniel Bryan as a legitimate babyface megastar, and it sort of is. Bryan - a hard-working role model who had no right to succeed, a great inspirational arc for kids - becomes the fan’s choice. John Cena grants him a match at SummerSlam 2013 on this basis, and does an ultra-rare clean job. Immediately afterwards, a new stable led by Triple H and Stephanie McMahon, the Authority, is formed to thwart Bryan’s ascent. This is woefully derivative, but has potential - that is, until WWE actually decides mid-storyline that Bryan is in fact a “B+ player” and relegates him to the midcard. Dave Meltzer reports that WWE did actually hold plans to push Bryan to a permanent main event position - a storyline accelerated by the very real threat of a walkout undermining the planned Randy Orton Vs. Batista main event at WrestleMania 30 - but how seriously can you take this report?

Advertisement

Bryan wins the Undisputed WWE title in New Orleans, but even if he does not get injured subsequently, Vince McMahon has already decided on John Cena’s replacement: Roman Reigns…