10 Biggest Wrestling Scandals Of The 2000s

A scandalous beginning to a new decade, new century, and new millennium.

Woman Nancy Chris Benoit
VICE

At the beginning of the 2000s, WWE was an edgy cult phenomenon trying to smash WCW and win the Monday Night Wars. By the end of the 2000s, it was an industry monolith with a PG rating. Needless to say, it was a very busy decade. As top stars came and went and ratings started to decline, WWE faced a new battle for survival that had nothing to do with Ted Turner. 

This new landscape was tough for anyone to navigate, and a number of big names got caught out and put their foot in it. Scandals were all over the place in this brave new world, and they affected everyone from the smallest midcarder to Vince McMahon himself. 

These ten case studies prove that, even though the 20th century was in the rear view mirror, its love of controversy was still alive and well. Decisions made by creative teams and real-world events all got wrestling fans talking as they crammed around the water cooler. 

Just a heads up - this list deals with a number of dark topics that aren't suitable for everyone. Reader discretion is advised. 

10. Steve Austin Goes Home

Steve Austin 2002
WWE.com

In 2001, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin was a WrestleMania main-eventer, a World champion, and a top star. In 2002, he was almost persona non grata. 

The first time Austin walked out on WWE was shortly after WrestleMania X-8. Citing burnout, he took an unapproved break from the company. It can't have helped that his old rival The Rock had been given a marquee match against Hulk Hogan, while he'd been stuck with babysitting Scott Hall in the midcard. 

His more famous walkout took place in June. Upon learning that he was going to lose a throwaway match against Brock Lesnar on free TV - a business decision he didn't agree with - Austin "took his ball and went home", leaving the promotion in the lurch. 

WWE went full scorched earth on their former golden boy. He was publicly buried on TV, to the point where it felt like he was going to end up blacklisted. By the following year, however, the two sides had patched things up. 

The fracturing of Austin's relationship with WWE was emblematic of the Attitude Era coming to an end. In another world, he could still be in their bad books today. 


9. Trish Barks Like A Dog

Trish Stratus Vince McMahon
WWE Network

The 2000s were not kind to WWE's female performers. Degrading swimsuit contests; limited TV time; an overall lack of care or interest; you could fill a whole list with the nonsense these women had to put up with. For this entry, however, we're focusing on one of the most infamous moments in the promotion's history. 

Part of the build to Vince McMahon versus his son Shane at WrestleMania X-Seven involved the creepy old promoter having an affair with Trish Stratus. On the March 5th 2001 edition of Raw, Vince decided he'd had enough of his mistress and decided to humiliate her. 

In order to prove her loyalty, Vince ordered Trish to strip down to her underwear, get on her knees, and "bark like a dog". Even by Attitude Era standards, this brutal display of misogyny is hard to watch. 

Some commentators have defended the angle, including Trish herself, as it led to Vince getting his comeuppance at WrestleMania. Many others have used it to criticise the company, though, especially when it comes to its portrayal of women. There's a reason it was left out of Trish's Hall of Fame induction video. 


8. Katie Vick

Triple H Kane Katie Vick WWE 2002
WWE

Speaking of infamous WWE storylines, there are few quite as shocking as the tale of Triple H, Kane, and poor old Katie Vick. 

During a feud between The Game and The Big Red Machine in late 2002, the former made some shocking allegations about the latter. Triple H accused his rival of being involved in a drink-driving accident that killed Ms. Vick, his crush at the time. 

If that wasn't bad enough, Trips went even further and stated that, once Katie was dead, Kane... had his way with her. This was "illustrated" by a video shown on Raw, in which the then-World Heavyweight Champion donned a Kane mask and pretended to get jiggy with a mannequin in a coffin. 

This skit includes the notorious moment in which Triple H holds up a hand full of pink goo and said "I literally screwed your brains out". This is WWE's current head booker, by the way. 

The Katie Vick debacle is inherently grim and it also completely nuked Kane's character. Not only did it mess with his established backstory, but he didn't even win the feud! Bad times all around. 


7. Steph’s 9/11 Gaffe

Stephanie McMahon WWF WWE 9/11 SmackDown Steroid Trials
WWE

Just two days after the September 11th terrorist attacks, WWE hosted a live episode of SmackDown from Houston, Texas. The show was dedicated to the victims of the tragedy and served as a much-needed antidote to the fear that gripped the United States. 

This SmackDown is famous for two things. The first is the emotional rendition of the national anthem performed by Lillian Garcia, a beautiful expression of patriotic defiance. The second is Stephanie McMahon making a complete tit of herself. 

During a talking head segment, Steph bafflingly compared the deadliest terror attack in US history to her father's steroid trial. "They tried to tear our family apart," she said, speaking directly to a nation that was dealing with the death of thousands of people. 

Whether it was Steph's own idea to make these comments or it was an order from higher up the food chain, this was a phenomenally dumb thing to do. It wasn't just tone deaf, it was downright insulting to the very audience WWE were looking to uplift. The whole thing overshadowed what could have been a really special night. 


6. The Plane Ride From Hell

Ric Flair
WWE

You'd be forgiven for not remembering a single match from WWE's UK exclusive Insurrextion pay-per-view in 2002. However, everyone has heard of what it led to. 

The journey back to the US was doomed from the moment they decided to put an open bar on a plane full of wrestlers. Scott Hall, a man with a history of substance abuse, got hideously drunk and harassed both his fellow wrestlers and flight attendants Taralyn Cappellano and Heidi Doyle. Curt Hennig and Brock Lesnar got into an argument that turned into a fight. The two huge men started wrestling for real, coming terrifyingly close to bringing the plane down. 

Goldust started singing to his ex-wife Terri Runnels over the PA system - and then there's Ric Flair. The undisputed king of being a tanked-up douchebag, Flair allegedly exposed himself to Cappellano and Doyle, a controversy that was re-awakened by a 2021 episode of Dark Side of the Ring.

The so-called 'Plane Ride from Hell' had dire consequences. Both Hall and Hennig were fired, while Cappellano and Doyle filed a lawsuit against WWE that was eventually settled out of court. 


5. Bash At The Beach 2000

Vince Russo WCW
WWE.com

We could have filled this entire list with incidents from WCW in the year 2000. This was the year in which the doomed company passed the point of no return, thanks in no small part to moments like this. 

Here's how Bash at the Beach 2000 was supposed to go. Hulk Hogan would beat Jeff Jarrett for the WCW Championship in a worked shoot designed to get people talking. Head writer Vince Russo would then come out and set the record straight, booking a new match between Jarrett and Booker T for the main event. Alas, this unnecessarily complicated and ill-conceived idea didn't work. Who could have possibly seen that coming...

During his in-ring promo, Russo said a lot of things about Hogan that he didn't like. The Hulkster never appeared in WCW again, and even filed a defamation of character lawsuit against the man from Long Island, New York. 

This incident is the epitome of Russo's negative traits as a booker. His obsession with fooling internet fans and not cluing people into his plans came back to haunt him on multiple occasions, none more so than this train-wreck of a storyline.


4. Eddie Guerrero’s Death

WWE Eddie Guerrero Tribute 2005
WWE

Eddie Guerrero wasn't the first high-profile wrestler to die young and, sadly, he wasn't the last. However, the circumstances surrounding his death are nothing short of heart-breaking. 

The WWE Hall of Famer had a history of addiction. He was actually released by the company in 2001, following an arrest for drink driving. This was the wake-up call he needed to get sober, but the damage had already been done. 

On November 13th 2005, Eddie was found unconscious in his hotel room by his nephew Chavo. He later died of acute heart failure at the age of just 38. At the time of his death, he was in the middle of a storyline that would have seen him become World Heavyweight Champion. 

The nature of Eddie Guerrero's death forced WWE to take a long, hard look at themselves. It contributed to the introduction of the Wellness policy just three months later, and it remains a cautionary tale about the dangers of the business. 

Then there's all the stuff that happened after Eddie died, like Randy Orton claiming he was "in hell" as part of a feud with Rey Mysterio. Way to honour his legacy, guys. 


3. Signature Pharmacy

Edge Money In The Bank MITB 2005
WWE.com

In the summer of 2007, 13 years after Vince McMahon narrowly avoided jail time through the steroid scandal, his company was once again embroiled in a drug-related PR nightmare. 

On August 30th, WWE announced it was suspending a number of its wrestlers. They had been informed by the Albany District Attorney's office that some of their talent were clients of an online steroid vendor named Signature Pharmacy. 

The names implicated in the report ranged from midcarders like Johnny Nitro and William Regal to main eventers like Edge and Randy Orton. Worryingly, ESPN reported that Eddie Guerrero had purchased multiple substances from the site just a fortnight before his death. 

While Batista, Booker T, and others all denied using Signature Pharmacy, it was too late to save WWE's public image. It was already in the pits following a string of tragedies. This was the last thing they needed. 

WWE's response was swift and strict. Wrestlers linked to the scandal were taken off TV and had future pushes cancelled. Things didn't get anywhere near as bad as they did in 1994, but nobody could be sure of that at the time. 


2. Muhammad Hassan

Muhammad Hassan Wikia3
WWE.com

It seems like every time WWE try to incorporate the news into its programming, things go very, very wrong. Case in point, the rapid rise and even faster fall of Muhammad Hassan.

Marc Copani, an American wrestler of Italian heritage, debuted on WWE TV in December 2004. Portraying an Arab-American man fed up with the treatment of "his people" in the wake of 9/11, Hassan was designed to prey on the Islamophobia that was rife throughout America at the time. Hassan was generating so much heat that there were plans to make him World Heavyweight Champion at SummerSlam 2005. Those were scrapped after the July 7th episode of SmackDown: the moment the character was doomed forever. 

As part of his feud with The Undertaker, Hassan summoned a group of masked men via prayer to lay out The Deadman with clubs and piano wire. In a stunning stroke of bad luck, this pre-taped show aired on the same day that London was rocked by the 7/7 terrorist attacks. In a stunning display of awfulness, WWE aired the segment in the U.S. regardless. 

Following pressure from media outlets and their network, WWE got rid of Hassan at The Great American Bash. He was powerbombed through the stage by The Undertaker, and never seen again. 


1. The Benoit Tragedy

Woman Nancy Chris Benoit
VICE

You probably saw this number one entry coming, but what else could it have possibly been? 

Chris Benoit no-showed the Vengeance: Night of Champions pay-per-view on June 24th 2007. The following day, his body was discovered at his home in Fayetteville, Georgia, alongside those of his wife Nancy and their son Daniel. 

That same night, WWE aired a tribute show to their fallen contractor. Then came the sickening news that Benoit had murdered Nancy and Daniel before taking his own life. 

Much has been written about why Benoit did what he did. CTE caused by years of head trauma, untreated, profound grief, and a predisposition to sadism and abuse remain the primary factors, but the fact of the matter is that three people - one of whom was just seven years old - had died. 

The days surrounding the Benoit tragedy remain among the bleakest the wrestling industry has ever seen. One overlooked aspect of this torrid affair is that Nancy and Daniel's names have also been wiped from history. They deserve to be remembered for who they were; not swept under the rug alongside the evil monster who defined their finally days. 


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.