10 Batman Fates Worse Than Death

Death is the last thing you have to worry about when it comes to Gotham City...

Batman Last Knight on Earth
DC Comics / John Romita Jr.

Although not the darkest figure in DC's roster of heroes, Batman is certainly no stranger to the macabre.

Whether in the original comics from Bob Kane and Bill Finger (mostly just Finger), or the grimdark tales of the 1990s and 2000s, the Caped Crusader and his allies have either suffered or inflicted some incredible misfortunes that more than leave their mark on character and reader alike.

Now obviously the vast majority of terrible Batman-oriented fates have been inflicted by the character's rogues gallery - because of course they have - but only a select few could truly be classified in that mind-bending, terrifying bracket of being worse than death itself. Even so, a 'select few' is still way, way too many, and is enough to leave you wondering why Gothamites everywhere don't live every day with complete and utter dread dominating their every waking thought.

And it's not just the Joker either. While the Clown Prince of Crime is no doubt one of the most terrifying figures to call Gotham City home, there are others who are arguably worse, with Professor Pyg but one of many villains capable of getting extremely... creative (??), with their crime.

Batman's world is suitably scary, but every now and then it crosses a truly disturbing line...

10. The Penguin Ruins Someone's Life... Just Because - Joker's Asylum

Joker Asylum Penguin
DC Comics / Jason Pearson & Dave McCaig

A recurring theme with Batman's villains is that a lot of them are a bit insecure. The Riddler is so desperate to prove himself smarter than the Dark Knight that he arrogantly provides the clues that will lead to his own downfall, but arguably even more fragile an ego belongs to Penguin.

Oswald Cobblepot is part of Gotham's elite, but he was never truly accepted by them for several reasons, the first being that the Cobblepots had a tradition of engaging in some not so moral enterprises, and the second relating to Oswald's birdlike appearance.

Despite this, Penguin has always striven to be a member of Gotham's upper crust, wielding power and influence thanks to his criminal connections in a bid to be considered less of an outsider.

When those first two options don't work however, Cobblepot resorts to violence, as was best relayed in Jason Aaron and Jason Pearson's Joker's Asylum: Penguin, a one-shot comic from 2008.

The story sees Penguin at a fancy restaurant with a date, when he spies a chef laughing in the corner of his eye. Penguin's not sure for certain what he's laughing at, but decides it cannot go unpunished, and proceeds to make Kingpin's destruction of Matt Murdock's life in Daredevil: Born Again look like child's play by comparison - at least if Joker's to be believed (which he usually isn't, but y'know, drama).

Following the date, Penguin buys the building and closes the restaurant, leading to the chef losing his job. Cobblepot then deported the chef's partner to Romania, had his best friend arrested for a crime he didn't commit, and moved a neighbour into the flat next to him to play obnoxiously loud music day and night. He closed this man's local church, the park he loved to visit, and exploited the fact he was a recovering alcoholic, opening up a new liquor store opposite his apartment.

The Penguin literally destroyed this man's life from top to bottom, trapping him in his own personal hell.


9. Becoming One Of Pyg's Dollotron's - Batman And Robin Reborn

Professor Pyg
DC Comics

Professor Pyg was one of several new villains introduced during Grant Morrison's seminal run on Batman, and also one of the most disturbing.

Although the Flamingo (yes, the Flamingo) could lay claim to being just as freaky - the guy does eat his victims' faces after all - what Pyg does is truly the stuff of nightmares.

Rather than kill people outright, Pyg is obsessed with making them 'perfect', turning them into his own personal Dollotrons, a process which involves a brutal kind of surgery that mutilates both the body and mind.

Pyg's victims are essentially made into unsexed dolls, which entails the removal of their genitals (lovely!!), a lobotomy and the especially painful part of having a molten mask melted onto their face to render them unidentifiable.


8. Being Painfully Blasted Backwards Through Time - Final Crisis/Return Of Bruce Wayne

Final Crisis Superman Batman
DC Comics

Final Crisis is one of DC's most epic tales, and is notable for a host of reasons.

Written again by Morrison with art from J. G. Jones, the comic saw the reemergence of Darkseid as the Lord of Apokolips finally attained the Anti-Life Equation, the secret to universal dominance. In his way stood the Justice League, and a mortal he underestimated in particular - Batman.

The Dark Knight isn't able to deliver the final blow to stop Darkseid's rule, but he does weaken the New God enough to allow Superman to free the universe from his control. Bruce Wayne confronts Darkseid with a gun that fires Radion bullets, which are lethal to New Gods, breaking his one rule with the universe on the line.

Sadly, although Batman is able to get the ever important shot off, Darkseid's omega beams turn him to dust. The idea at the time was that Bruce had perished, but it was later revealed in The Return of Bruce Wayne that the OG Batman hadn't died at all, and had instead been painfully blasted backwards into the timestream, forced to fight time itself to return to the present.

The upside to this is that Bruce was able to accomplish the impossible and return in 2011, some two years after his initial demise, but any other human would've been driven insane by such a task. Bats did also have the benefit of amnesia to lessen the blow of going from the 21st century to the dawn of time, but it's still a terrifying thing to be confronted with all the same.


7. Becoming A Radioactive Zombie Skeleton - Batman Beyond

Batman Beyond Earth Mover
Warner Bros.

The DC Animated Universe was filled to the brim with darker moments, but particularly Batman Beyond. The cyberpunk inspired Neo Gotham was big on body horror, and the villains new Batman Terry McGinnis had to face each week ranged from the grotesque to the genuinely unnerving.

Of these villains, arguably the worst to suffer was the Earthmover, who made his sole appearance in the 1999 episode of the same name.

The plot of "Earth Mover" revolves around one of Terry's friends, Jackie, who suspects she's being followed. Terry eventually discovers that weird mudmen have been watching their every move, and that they're particularly violent towards Jackie's father.

Later, it is revealed that Jackie's father Bill isn't her real father at all, and that he'd adopted her after her biological dad, Tony, was killed disposing of chemical waste illegally when she was just a baby, an act Bill had pressured him into doing under the promise of a lucrative business partnership.

The chemicals Tony was subjected to bonded his body to the earth, deep underground. This turned him into what was essentially a radioactive mud zombie, a glowing husk of a man destined to spend the remainder of his days alone, while the associate who led him to his predicament got to raise his daughter, who was oblivious to the truth.


6. Mister Freeze Becomes A Spider Robot Head... Thing - The New Batman Adventures

Mister Freeze Batman Beyond
Warner Bros.

One of the best things about Batman: The Animated Series was how it humanised the Dark Knight's rogues gallery. Plenty of episodes were great at tapping into the tragedy of most of the Bat villains, but none arguably more so than Heart of Ice, the seminal story that forever redefined Mister Freeze, and turned him into a truly legendary character.

Victor Fries was the subject of several endings over the course of the DCAU Batman shows, the first of which arrived in SubZero, a 1998 film that ended with Freeze roaming the Arctic, safe in the knowledge that a procedure funded by Bruce Wayne had saved his wife.

Victor seemed to be at peace, but it wasn't to be. He returned with a vengeance in TNBA, as it was revealed that the procedure that led to his icy condition had caused his entire body to deteriorate, leaving nothing but his head intact. Fries retains his cryo suit, but when not inside of it, he navigates his surroundings courtesy of some nifty little spider-legs that sprout out of the base... and it is the exact opposite of dignified.

After years of pain and hardship Fries thought he'd finally gotten his happy ending, only to be confronted with an entirely new level of body horror that only got worse in Batman Beyond.


5. Being Endlessly Tortured By A Godlike Joker - Emperor Joker

Emperor Joker Killing Batman
DC Comics

Here's a fate that was so terrible, Batman had to have his memory wiped afterwards to ensure his mind wouldn't break.

Emperor Joker was a short-lived Superman arc where the Clown Prince of Crime was able to deceive Mister Mxyzptlk and gain his godlike powers, which you can probably imagine wasn't exactly good news for the rest of the multiverse.

The Joker gets up to a lot - like, a lot, a lot - of bad stuff in this comic, ranging from genocide to endlessly torturing, killing, and then reviving his biggest enemy over and over, and none of it is pleasant to read. The latter of course involves the Dark Knight, whose mouth the Joker sews shut and tortures, mutilates and then kills in a variety of different ways for an indefinite amount of time.

The worst part? This wasn't even Elseworlds. This was actual DC continuity.


4. Realising That Whatever Reality Exists, There Will Always Be Batman - Flashpoint

Thomas Wayne Batman
DC Comics

Now, this isn't to say that having Batman is inherently a bad thing. The Dark Knight embodies hope and perseverance as much as he does the existence of some of the most horrific criminals fiction has ever known, but you do have to admit it's just a little bit upsetting that, no matter the universe, in some shape or form, Batman will always exist.

In each of DC's realities, inevitably a moment will occur that will lead to the creation of a Batman. These Bat-men aren't always good, but even those that are usually pursue their path after being confronted by a tragedy at a tender age.

This crushing sense of inevitably was felt hardest in the Flashpoint reality, where Thomas Wayne adopted the mantle of Batman following the murder of his son, Bruce.

When a time-displaced Barry Allen informs Thomas that his son also grew up to be Batman, the feeling that greets Thomas is one of hope, because there's a chance he'll be able to trade his own existence for the son that was cruelly taken from him decades ago. However, when Thomas finds himself flung into mainstream DC continuity, he tries his best to get Bruce to stop being Batman, so upset is he by the fact his son has had to dedicate his life to crimefighting.

Crucially, the point here isn't that Batman existing is a bad thing, but rather that, in every reality, an evil so great will rise that Batman is a necessary force. It's inspiring in some ways, but more than a little dispiriting in others.


3. Having To Live Through The Zombie Apocalypse - DCeased

DCeased Batman
DC Comics

Tom Taylor is one of the best comics writers going currently, and one thing he has a particular knack for is telling stories set in grim alternate realities - first with the comics tie-in to Injustice: Gods Among Us, and then more recently with DCeased, which sees the DC universe gripped by a zombie apocalypse.

Although Taylor is great at finding the hope and resilience of superheroes when confronted by these bleak surroundings, there are few things that would make an actual zombie apocalypse liveable, let alone one where some of the zombies are also the superheroes who used to protect you.


2. The Speed Force Storms - Last Knight On Earth

Batman Last Knight on Earth Speed Force Storm
DC Comics / Greg Capullo

From one dystopian DC reality to another now, and this time it's Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo's Last Knight on Earth, a Black Label comic that bookends the duo's acclaimed Batman run from the 2010s.

Last Knight on Earth features all kinds of funky horrors, including a severed Joker head Batman has to hang out with all the time, but by far the worst thing within its pages are the Speed Force storms, which are powered by the distorted remains of all the Earth's Flashes.

Anyone unlucky enough to fall into said storms is aged up rapidly and dies, but arguably more unfortunate are the Flashes themselves, who can be seen screaming out for Bruce to rescue them, even though he's powerless to do so.

As far as imagery goes it's pretty messed up, and absolutely one of the worst fates to have been depicted in a Batman comic.


1. Becoming The Batman Who Laughs - Dark Multiverse

Batman Who Laughs Robins
DC Comics

Yeah the Batman Who Laughs has absolutely been overused since bursting onto the scene in Dark Nights Metal, and yeah, he's also more than a little bit Judge Death-y design wise, but that doesn't stop him from being a great concept for a villain.

Introduced during the aforementioned series from Snyder and Capullo, the Batman Who Laughs hails from a reality hidden within the Dark Multiverse, a plain of existence that naturally bends towards bad outcomes.

After the Joker embarked on one last rampage and got up to literally some of the worst stuff he's ever done (infecting children with Joker toxin and then murdering their parents for one), Batman snapped completely and killed his longtime foe. However, doing this released an extra potent version of the Joker toxin that permanently scarred Bruce's mind and skin, setting him down a path that would turn him into one of the most terrifying cosmic threats in the entire DC multiverse.

On his way to becoming the Batman Who Laughs, Bruce murdered all his sidekicks (bar Damian, who he Jokerised), and enlisted the help of the children Joker had transformed in his final rampage.

The Batman Who Laughs is so far gone that he would never consider this an unfortunate turn of events. However, for the part of Bruce that may have been there deep down, trapped behind that menacing Joker grin, being hurled into the sun by Wonder Woman in Death Metal should have come as a massive release.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Batman?

Batman Robin Dick Sprang
DC Comics/Dick Sprang

1. In What Comic Did Batman First Appear?

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.