10 Batmen Who Aren't Bruce Wayne

When The Dark Knight got the what-if treatment.

Flashpoint Batman Thomas Wayne
DC Comics

We all know the story, two doting parents take their only son to a night out at the movies, only to be tragically gunned down in front of him. This moment forever changes the boy, leading him down the path that would culminate in him donning the cowl of The Batman and waging his one-man war against crime in Gotham City.

Part of what makes Batman resonate with readers is that his powers don't define him. Anyone could be Batman, given a seemingly bottomless bank account and a couple decades of intensive training (or even just an obsessive hard-on for justice and an alternative fashion sense). He can't leap tall buildings in a single bound, he isn't faster than a speeding bullet, but he's got a will more powerful than a locomotive.

Really, there isn't anything stopping someone from putting on hockey pads and a Halloween mask and calling themselves The Batman (except Christian Bale that one time). If they believe it, who's to tell them they're wrong? Batman helps inspire us to be the people we can be through drive and determination, the best of ourselves. He displays the height of human potential.

At his core, Batman is just that, a man adopting the visage of a bat, doing everything in his power to save his city from injustice, and so are these men.

10. Harvey Dent - Legends Of The Dark Knight Annual #4

Harvey Dent Batman
DC Comics

Citizen Wayne is narrated by an unnamed police officer investigating the deaths of Harvey Dent and Bruce Foster Wayne. The story is inspired by and includes multiple references to the classic 1941 film Citizen Kane.

Through the officer's investigation we learn that in this universe, The Waynes are confronted by Joe Chill in Crime Alley but only Thomas is killed trying to protect his wife and son. Bruce grows up alongside his best friend Harvey Dent who both idolize Bruce's father. Thomas’ death instills a strong sense of justice in the boys.

Harvey becomes District Attorney and Bruce focuses his efforts on running his family's newspaper. The men hope that through law enforcement and journalistic truth they can take Gotham back from crime boss Sal Maroni but Bruce believes Dent is too aggressive in his approach.

Dent becomes frustrated with the limits the law imposes on him until Maroni horribly scars Dents entire face with acid. Seeing no other recourse but to operate as a vigilante, Harvey becomes Batman and begins his crusade to stop Maroni.

What's odd is there isn't really a reason for why Harvey chose a bat as his totem. He just shows up one day in full costume with no explanation. We can only assume he just happened to already have the outfit for... other reasons.

In the stories epilogue we find our unnamed narrator has been Dick Grayson all along. After uncovering the truth and being inspired by Dent and Wayne, its implied he becomes Batman's successor in this reality as well.


9. Thomas Wayne - Flashpoint

thomas wayne batman
DC Comics

In the Flashpoint timeline, the catalyst to all of DC’s recent retcons, Thomas and Martha Wayne didn't die on that fateful night in Crime Alley, Bruce did. Driven by the guilt of not being able to save his son, Thomas gives up his medical career and decides open and operate a casino. Oh right, he also becomes Batman.

Bruce's father is a far more brutal and unforgiving Dark Knight. Batman not only avenged his son's death by killing his murderer with his bare hands, but he has also done away with Poison Ivy, Hush, and Scarecrow. Oh, and he also split Killer Croc’s skull with a freaking machete. Not a nonlethal bat-machete. A machete.

The only villain Bat-Dad seems unable to bring himself to take down permanently is The Joker. The reason for this indiscretion becomes abundantly clear when it's revealed that while Thomas’ guilt created Batman, Martha's grief and disdain for her husbands inability to save her son drove her insane. This madness manifests itself by turning her into her ex-husband's greatest adversary.

Just think of how much of the Batman mythos could be avoided if the Waynes could only talk out their feelings. Too bad psychiatry isn't one of Alfred's many skills.


8. Kal El - Superman: Speeding Bullets

Bruce Wayne Batman
DC Comics

Instead of being found by the Kents and being raised in Smallville, infant Kal-El is found by Thomas and Martha Wayne and raised as their only child. Super-Bruce enjoys a relatively normal childhood for an alien who was adopted by billionaires.

The same familiar tragic events play out at the Monarch Theater, right until the moment after the Wayne’s deaths. In a rage, young Bruce’s Kryptonian heritage manifests in a blast of heat vision, killing Joe Chill. Apparently even little Kal is more of a badass than main continuity Batman.

Bruce has repressed any memory of the night of his adopted parents deaths, as well as his powers. Instead of focusing his efforts to save his city, he withdraws himself, rarely leaving Wayne manor. He finds himself haunted by the seemingly endless stream of tragedy in Gotham but is unsure what to do about it.

During an attempted burglary of Wayne Manor, Kal's powers manifest again. Finally realizing his true origin, his mission becomes clear.

As Batman, Bruce uses fear, intimidation and as his God-like power to subdue Gotham's constant crime wave. While most of Gotham's citizens accept this new vigilante as a savior, Lois Lane see's Batman as no better than the criminals he terrorizes.

During a confrontation with Lex Luthor (who's origin is combined with Jokers') Lois helps Bruce realize that not only Gotham but the world needs someone better. A man that stands a symbol of hope and virtue that people can aspire to, a hero that operates in the light. He must become Superman


7. Elliot Ness - Batman: Scar Of The Bat

batman scar of the bat
DC Comics

This entry doesn't involve a character we would traditionally associate with the Batman mythos adopting the persona, this Batman is an actual modern historical figure. In this Elseworlds tale Bat-man is Elliot Ness, the notorious FBI agent who took down Al Capone. Ness is probably best known as being played by Kevin Costner in the 1987 crime drama “The Untouchables”.

It is very grounded in reality (more so than the film) including actual scenarios and people as well as dialogue sourced directly from Ness himself, published here for the first time, just yaknow... with Batman.

Ness reveals how, frustrated with the limits imposed on him by being an FBI agent, he began operating outside the law to intimidate criminals and gather information.

Inspired by the titular character of the 1926 film “The Bat” (Bill Fingers real life inspiration for Batman's iconic look), he dresses in a black trench coat, slacks, and a pointy-eared mask. Ness is known as the “Bat”-Man not only because of the mask but also because he has a tendency to beat Capone's men to nearly to death with a Louisville Slugger.

Even if this isn't the best Batman story ever, it still serves as a pretty informative history lesson. It goes to show, probably more than any other entry on this list, that at his core Batman is nothing more than a man with the drive to go above and beyond to make his home a better place.


6. Damian Wayne - Batman Vol. 1 #666

Batman 666
DC Comics

In the one-shot story Batman 666, we get a glimpse of a possible future where Bruce Wayne is killed, leaving his genetically modified, super assassin, possibly demonic son Damian, as Batman. Damian, the son of Bruce and Bruce’s some-time lover/all-the-time psychopath, Talia Al-Ghul, must toe the line of hero and villain, attempting to deny his own dark nature while respecting his father's vision of justice.

It seems Bruce was the softie in the Wayne clan, as again, Damian's methods are far more brutal than his fathers, having broken his dad's "no killing" rule multiple times. This escalation is attributed to a much darker and more dangerous Gotham. (as if it wasn't enough of a hellhole before)

Damian takes the advice he’d gotten from his father that “victory is in preparedness” by having booby trapped every single prominent building in Gotham. He may also have literally sold his soul to the devil in return for Gotham's survival although the story is vague on what that actually entails. Needless to say this is not your father's Dark Knight.

Damian has little regard for others opinions of how he follows his fathers legacy. He's hunted by Barbara Gordon (now police commissioner) and is shown to have frequent contention with Conner Kent. (now Superman)

While he does feel some regret for not following his father's iron clad moral code, he protects Gotham in the most effective way he knows, concerning himself more with results rather than being able to sleep at night (or during the day).


5. Azrael - Knightquest

Azrael Batman
DC Comics

After Gotham was left without a Dark Knight, DC decided to tweak the villain Azrael and place him on the side of the leatherwinged angels. Azrael is the perfect representation of "edgy" 90's comics, who's batsuit had more actual edges, blades, belts and pouches than could ever be practical.

Jean-Paul Valley is a genetically modified and brainwashed member of the "The Sacred Order of Saint Dumas" a religious cult that utilizes Valley as an assassin, code named "Azrael". After encountering Batman and realizing hes being manipulated by The Order he begins working with the Bat-Family.

Our new Batman hadn't been completely freed from The Orders manipulation and his mental state begins to fracture even further. Hallucinations of his father and St. Dumas urge Azrael to match his enemies viciousness. A parallel could be drawn between these visions and Bruce's haunting memories of his parents that motivate him.

Azrael's grasp on reality loosens as the safety of bystanders becomes less of a priority and he murders villains with abandon. He has difficulty focusing on anything outside of his war on crime, something that could also be attributed to Bruce.

Bruce recovers and must take the Batman persona back from Valley by force. Feeling responsible for Azrael's psychotic break, Bruce does what he can to help Jean-Paul recover.

Azrael serves to show that while anyone could be Batman, not everyone should be. He also helps illustrate the fine line Bruce walks every time he puts on the cowl.


4. James Gordon - Superheavy

Jim Gordon As Batman
DC Comics

This time its Bruce's oldest ally, James Gordon, taking his place. You might think that Gordon is too old and frail for the burden and you might be right if his batsuit didn't look like it was designed by Tony Stark. While some may doubt Jim's ability, no one doubts it more than himself. He has trouble feeling like he's living up to his predecessor.

Gordon's Batman is not only different from Bruce because he wears a 10-foot mech-suit provided by the Powers Corporation but also in that he isn't a vigilante. He operates only when the GCPD calls him in.

Commissioner Gordon's always been a man of the law first and foremost but he begins to realize that Batman has to be something more, an independent force. He does what he feels he must.

Gordon is effectively fired as Batman and is set to be replaced. At the fundraiser where Gordon was meant to resign, this arcs big-bad strikes. While preparing their counter attack, its revealed that not only is Gordon replaceable, Powers has a virtual army of Bats-Mechs at their disposal.

This is pretty much the end of Gordon's stint as The Bat. Bruce returns to being Gotham's guardian but Gordon's time as Batman is important. It shows him, and us, that Batman isn't a sense of security brought about by a greater power. We cant always rely on Batman to save us. He helps us find the strength to rely on ourselves in the absence of security.


3. Terry McGinnis - Batman Beyond

Batman Beyond Terry McGinnis
Warner Bros. Animation

Terry didn't originate in a comic but the animated show Batman Beyond, taking place in the future of the DC animated universe. His story has continued in comics on and off since the shows cancellation in 2001 however, with him now existing in the main DCU.

Terry becomes a retired Bruce's successor after stumbling upon the Batcave. Terrys father is murdered by the Jokerz (a street gang inspired by the ostensibly dead Joker's legacy) and he seeks out Bruce's help in avenging his father. Bruce recognizes a fire in Terry that was seen in himself many decades ago when he made his solemn promise to honor his parents legacy.

Mentored by Bruce and equipped with a technologically advanced Batsuit, Our new Batman sets off seeking retribution for the death of his father and becomes the new capeless crusader of Neo-Gotham.

Throughout the series Terry comes to own the mantle of the Batman, not a lesser substitute for Bruce but a full fledged Batman for a new age, in some ways surpassing his predecessor. He takes on villains either from or inspired by Bruce's time as The Bat, as well as amassing his own rogues' gallery.

At the conclusion of the animated series its revealed that Terry is not only Bruce's apprentice but his biological son. Regardless of his parentage Terry had already proven himself time and time again as being worthy to be his city's protector, making this revelation somewhat inconsequential. Terry McGinnis is Batman.


2. Jason Todd - Battle For The Cowl

Jason Todd Batle For The Cowl
DC Comics

Batman was "dead" again for a time in the mid 00s, leaving Gotham without a Dark Knight and two Robins vying for the title. The bat-family is unsure how to proceed without Bruce's guidance. While Tim Drake urges a reluctant Dick Grayson to take up the mantle, Jason Todd eagerly takes his once-mentors place.

Jason, Bruce's second Robin, has returned to the world of the living after being killed by Joker in the notorious 1988 storyline "Death in the Family". Resentful of Bruce for allowing the Joker to live after murdering him, Jason views him as too merciful and doesn't share his rule against killing or guns.

Jason begins operating as a dual pistol wielding Batman, brutally dispatching criminals and leaving behind handwritten notes that read "I AM BATMAN". Dick attempts to apprehend Jason before he makes his escape back to his makeshift Batcave in Gotham's subway. There he finds Tim Drake dressed as Batman, mercilessly beats him within an inch of his life and sets out to finish off Grayson.

In their final confrontation Grayson and Todd square off, with the winner claiming the title of Batman conclusively and proving their worth. Dick is successful in stopping Jason. Todd continued his vigilante work though, in pretty much the same manner as he did while Batman, taking on the persona of Red Hood. This isn't even close to the last time Todd and the batfamily come to blows.


1. Dick Grayson - Batman & Robin

batman dick grayson
DC Comics

Dick Grayson is the character most people think of when they talk about "Robin". The orphaned son of the circus performers the "Flying Graysons", he was adopted by Bruce and became the original Boy Wonder in 1940's Detective Comics #38. Since his introduction, Grayson has been a fan favorite and considered by many to be the only true heir to the cowl.

Grayson has been one of the few characters allowed to "grow up" since his introduction. Eventually becoming frustrated with Bruce's strict guidelines to crime-fighting, he adopted the persona Nightwing. Coming into his own as the protector of Gothams sister city Bludhaven.

After the events of "Battle for the Cowl" Dick accepts the job for which he's been groomed for most of his life, (indefinitely) being Batman. With Damian as his Robin, Dick carries on Bruce's legacy. He decides that if he's going to be the Dark Knight, he's going to do it his way, leaving the Batcave as a memorial. He sets up shop under Wayne Tower in his newly designed Bat-Bunker featuring a flying Batmobile.

Not counting Terry, Dick filled the role of Batman far longer than his counterparts. He was accepted by fans as the true Batman and continued playing the part for years until the start of the New-52. Even after Bruce eventually returned to life and the Batcave, he implored Dick to continue operating as his counterpart. We don't think there's a more conclusive claim to being Batman than Bruce Wayne telling you you're Batman.


In this post: 
Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Wes is a video game and comic book enthusiast. You can just call him a nerd.