10 Best Comic Book Detectives (That Aren't Batman)
There are many characters that use observation and deductive reasoning who aren't the Dark Knight.
Right next to the physical heroes, the fighters, and the strong men have always been the intellectual heroes, the thinkers, and the detectives. The detective hero predates the superhero by several years in comics. Superman creators, Jerry Seigel and Joe Shuster, had their earliest successes creating occult detective Dr. Occult in 1935 and Slam Bradley, a private investigator that appeared in the first issue of Detective Comics in 1937.
Of course, any list of comic book detectives has to have Batman at the very top of the list. For all his physical skills and martial artist training, it is Bruce’s brilliant mind that truly makes him the hero that is able to stand toe to toe with magical beings and demigods. His skills of observation allow him to see the smallest clues or tiniest details that others might miss. His powers of inductive and deductive reasoning are so keen he can solve seemingly impossible cases with few clues. Wayne truly lives up to the moniker the World’s Greatest Detective.
Batman is not alone in the pantheon of great detectives in comics. Some of them are characters that also possess an array of incredible powers that may overshadow their skills but all are created in the mould of the hard-bitten detective: follow the facts and pursue the truth, wherever it takes you until justice is served.
10. Hellboy
Conceived in 1574 to an Archduke of Hell and a human female, Hellboy is a Cambion that was pulled from Hell by Nazi occultists and Grigori Rasputin in East Bromwich, UK. He was discovered by a group of Allied Forces including Professor Trevor “Broom” Bruttenholm on December 23, 1944.
Taken to a New Mexico Air Force Base and raised as normal as possible by the Professor, Hellboy was given “honorary human” status by the United Nations and became a member of the Bureau for Paranormal Research and Defence to specifically combat occult threats. After many successful missions, he became known as the world’s greatest paranormal investigator.
As an adult he had matured barely out of his teenage years, Hellboy became the lead agent for the BRPD along with aquatic Abe Sapien and pyrokinetic Liz Sherman among others. They had to search for the missing Professor Broom in the Arctic only to find him in time to witness his death. Hellboy again encountered Rasputin who encouraged Anung Un Rama to embrace his “destiny.” Liz burned the “Mad Monk” to cinders.
Created by writer/artist Mike Mignola, Hellboy fought Morgan Le fey when he learned that his mother was a direct descendant of Arthur Pendragon and the rightful king of England. In his hands, Excalibur became a flaming sword. He was killed fighting a witch army and sent to Hell but returned.
9. Martian Manhunter
J’onn J’onzz, the Martian Manhunter first premiered in Detective Comics #225 in 1955 and was created by Joseph Samachson and Joe Certa. J’onn was a dedicated Manhunter or police officer on his native Mars and had a wife and young daughter who he lost to a virus that was engineered by his brother Ma'alefa'ak. Scientist Dr. Saul Erdel accidentally aimed a device at Mars and transferred J’onn through time and space to Earth. Erdel died of shock when J’onn shape-shifted but their shared mental link healed the alien’s mind and informed him of his new home.
After learning that Mars was a dead world thanks to the plaque his brother started, J’onn took the identity of the Bronze Wraith and fought crime with the Justice Experience. He also established the human identity of police detective John Jones in the city of Middleton and established himself as someone who will not let a case go until justice is served.
His green-skinned form was eventually revealed and he began operating as the Martian Manhunter. He became a founding member of the Justice League of America and remained part of several reshufflings of the team, being the team’s leader on occasion. He let people believe that John Jones had been killed at one point. He has also maintained multiple identities in Earth’s Southern Hemisphere where he is more famous than Superman.
8. Jamie Madrox
Jaime Madrox is a changeling, the genetic predecessor to mutants whose powers manifest themselves at birth, rather than puberty. His first duplicate was created when his doctor smacked his bottom. Forced to wear a special suit to regulate his powers and growing up in isolation after the deaths of his parents, Madrox chose to relocate to the Muir Island Research Center with Dr. Moira MacTaggert instead of joining the X-Men.
Madrox aka Multiple Man, still found himself drawn into multiple mutant conflicts, despite himself, and soon joined the government-sponsored investigative team of mutants called X-Factor, which was led by Havok. After that team ended, he struck out on his own and opened XXX Investigations, which later changed its name to X-Factor Investigations as so many of its members had been part of that team. They settled in a part of New York that became known as “Mutant Town.”
Jamie also began sending dupes out into the world to live lives and gain experiences and skills that he would learn upon absorbing them. One of his dupes that settled in Chicago became the “world’s greatest detective” who learned things so important and so terrible that he didn’t want Multiple Man to know them. In X-Factor #17, he chose death by cop rather than letting the knowledge be passed to Jaime Prime.
7. The Question
The original Question was created by the legendary Steve Ditko and first appeared in Charlton Comics’ Blue Beetle #1. During his Charlton run, the character followed Ditko’s philosophy of Objectivism while in his DC run he had developed a more Zen philosophy. No matter the writer, Charles Victor Szasz aka Victor Sage always had a healthy distrust of authority and a penchant for conspiratorial thinking.
Vic Sage was an investigative journalist in Hub City known for his outspoken and aggressive style. He was approached by his former professor Aristotle Roder to stop the sale of his invention, Pseudoderm, because of its toxic effects. Fashioning a featureless mask from the material and a special gas that adhered it to the skin and changed Sage’s hair colour and clothes, he became The Question.
In the series renewal at DC by Dennis O’Neil and Denys Cowan, Sage was beaten nearly to death by Lady Shiva and was then sent to Kung-Fu master Richard Dragon for training in martial arts and eastern philosophy. Unlike other “costumed’ vigilantes, O’Neil’s Question took on the corrupt politicians of Hub City and this version was less willing to kill than his Charlton counterpart. During a period when Sage had died of cancer, former Gotham detective Renee Montoya assumed the mantle of the Question. He has since returned to life during the DC Rebirth.
6. Dakota North
Dakota North first appeared in her own self-titled comic in February 1986 and was created by Martha Thomases and Tony Salmons. She was the daughter of CIA agent Samuel J. North and began her career as a freelance private investigator at a fairly young age. She was very successful, at one time supporting four branch offices across the world.
One of her early cases was when she was hired by a coalition of models to track down the identity of a serial killer who had been murdering fashion models. She was guarding models Elyse Nelson and Mary Jane Watson. She met Spider-Man while on the case and they discovered that Nelson was the killer and saved Watson’s life. She was next hired by young Power Pack member Jack Power to clear the name of his favorite author of theft, which she did with the help of the Punisher.
Recommended by her friend, Jessica Jones, Dakota began working for the law firm of Nelson and Murdock. First, she investigated who was running around as Daredevil while Matthew Murdock was in prison with the help of Ben Urich. She then aided them in investigating a series of murders conducted by the Gladiator and Murdock’s blind wife Milla who were both being manipulated by Matt’s old foe, Mr. Fear.
5. Detective Chimp
Detective Chimp first appeared in The Adventures of Rex the Wonder Dog #4 and was created by John Broome and Carmine Infantino. Bobo T. Chimp was an average but intelligent chimpanzee that was captured in Equatorial Africa in 1953 by Fred Thorpe who wanted to train him for his carnival act where it appeared that “Bobo” was solving mysteries. He later became a “helper mascot” to the local sheriff when he helps him solve Thorpe’s murder.
On A trip to Florida, Rex the Wonder Dog took Bobo to the Fountain of Youth where he gained eternal life, and the ability to speak to all living creatures in their own language, including humans, and raised his intelligence to genius levels. Bobo began to work as a private detective and did well at first but having no legal standing couldn’t enforce people to pay their bills or appear in court. When the Spectre threatened to destroy all magic, Bobo gathered a group of mystical beings to oppose him that became Shadowpact. He was later a member of the Justice League Dark.
Bobo’s intelligence is higher than 98 percent of the adult human population in the world. He is a member of Mensa and is a brilliant detective on the level of Batman and the Elongated Man. He is also a member of the Croatian Society with only of the world’s best detectives.
4. Misty Knight And Colleen Wing
Bringing together two exploitative genres that were popular in the 70s: “blaxploitation” and Asian/Kung-Fu cinema to create one butt-kicking detective duo, Chris Claremont and Marshall Rogers teamed existing characters Misty Knight and Colleen Wing to become the Daughters of the Dragon. Running the Knightwing Restorations Inc. Detective Agency together, the pair are the investigative companion to Power Man and Iron Fist’s Hero for Hire organization.
Misty Knight was created by Tony Isabella and Arvell Jones and first appeared in Marvel Premiere #21. She was an NYPD police officer who lost her right arm after a bomb attack. She was gifted a super strong prosthetic arm by Tony Stark. Misty graduated at the top of her class from the police academy and earned a degree in criminology from the John Jay College of Criminal Justice. She is also a gifted martial artist.
Colleen Wing was created by Doug Moench and Larry Hama and first appeared in Marvel Premiere #19. Wing was descended from a family of samurai and was taught their ways by her grandfather. While in New York to meet Iron Fist, she was caught in a gang-related gunfight and saved by police officer Misty Knight. It was Colleen who convinced Knight to rejoin the world after losing her arm. Wing is a skilled samurai warrior, swordswoman, and detective.
3. Elongated Man
The Elongated Man was created by John Broome and Carmine Infantino and first appeared in Flash #112. Young Ralph Dibny grew up in rural Nebraska and dreamed of a big life in the big city. He was always fascinated by the “Indian rubber men” that were part of the side shows. Dibny discovered that they all drank a soft drink called Gingold, made from the gingo fruit in the Yucatan. Ralph distilled the fruit down to its essence and began consuming it. This gave him stretching powers.
Ralph Dibny moved to Central City and became the Elongated Man. He befriended Barry Allen, the Flash, and became a world-class detective. Growing rich through his exploits and public appearances, he met socialite Sue Dearborn and they fell in love and eventually married. Together, they traveled the world and solved mysteries together, and eventually, Dibny joined the Justice League of America.
Ralph was a mainstay of the League during its “Satellite Era” and became second only to Batman for his skills as a detective hero on the team. He stayed with the team when it was reorganized to Detroit, and to France when it became international. The pair moved to Opal City for a time and Dibny met his detective idol, Hamilton Drew. The pair were murdered in separate events but were reunited in death and became ghost detectives.
2. Jessica Jones
After eight months of imprisonment by the Purple Man and recovering from a coma after being nearly beaten to death by the Vision and Iron Man after attacking the Scarlet Witch while under Kilgrave’s control, Jessica Jones abandoned her former life as a minor superhero. She opened the detective agency “Alias Investigations” and soon found that her cases were focused on the superhero world.
One of her earliest cases started out as a missing person case but ended up involving the potential unmasking of Captain America, and the possible overthrowing of George H.W. Bush by a corrupt Democratic Senator. Jessica, along with Luke Cage, whom she had begun an intimate relationship with, undertook bodyguard duties for blind Hell’s Kitchen lawyer Matt Murdock when he was accused of being the vigilante Daredevil.
The Purple Man comes back into her life when a client requests that she find a man named Kilgrave who killed 34 people simply by telling them to stop breathing. After escaping the Raft, he tracks Jones down and starts a riot outside her apartment to attract more heroes for him to control. Thanks to a post-hypnotic suggestion placed by Jean Grey, the villain no longer had any control over the young detective and she beat him nearly to death.
1. Tim Drake
Of all the people that have held the moniker of Robin, the best detective is Tim Drake. As a small boy, Tim attended the Haley Circus and met the Flying Graysons on the day of their deaths. Years later, he saw Batman and Robin and noticed the same acrobatics as Dick Grayson had done in the circus and deduced the Dynamic Duo’s identities. At age 13, he noticed the mood change in Batman after the death of Jason Todd and deduced that Batman needed a Robin. After saving Batman and Nightwing from Two-Face, Drake began training to become the third Robin.
In Batman #617, Batman stated that, with time, Tim could surpass him as the “World’s Greatest Detective.” Nightwing has admitted that he is not as good a detective as Red Robin is, despite the fact that many would put the first Robin right behind the Dark Knight on any list.
Proof of Tim Drake’s status came in Red Robin #12. Tim didn’t believe that Bruce Wayne had actually died at the end of the Final Crisis series. He discovered Ra’s al Ghul was trying to steal Bruce Wayne's fortune and kill a number of Wayne’s loved ones. Red Robin thwarted him at every avenue. Ra’s angrily but respectfully referred to Red Robin as “Detective.”