10 Characters Who Have Broken Captain America’s Shield

Even vibranium isn't unbreakable.

Cap Broken Shield
Marvel Comics

It's one of the most iconic items in the Marvel Universe, a symbol of heroic justice and a weapon that's wiped the floor with everyone from Nazis to powerful cosmic villains. Let's hear it for Captain America's ever-reliable shield.

Cap is seldom seen without his famous vibranium disc, which made its debut way back in 1941's Captain America Comics #2, replacing the original heater shield Marvel's patriotic supersoldier was seen packing in issue #1.

Although Steve Rogers' relationship with his shield has gone through its ups and downs over the years - with the character famously abandoning it when he took on the Nomad identity for the first time in the 1970s - the weapon has served him well over the years, saving his life, and indeed the world, on countless occasions.

Throughout the ages, Cap's shield has withstood thunderous blows from the Hulk's fists, Iron Man's energy repulsor beams and Thor's divine hammer, but even the hardest metal the Marvel Universe has to offer isn't completely indestructible, and there are heroes and villains who've actually managed to break it...

10. Doctor Doom

Capshield Doom
Marvel Comics

A mind as brilliant as Victor Von Doom's was always going to figure out a way to break the unbreakable, but in the case of Captain America's trusty shield, the Latverian dictator had to resort to dirty tactics.

The popular 1980s crossover event Secret Wars saw a god-like being called The Beyonder spirit the Marvel Universe's greatest heroes and villains away to a far-off galaxy to pit them against one another in the ultimate cosmic slugfest. One of those heroes happened to be Cap, and among the villains was Doctor Doom.

In issue #11, Doctor Doom stole The Beyonder's powers and the spotlight along with them. He used his abilities to lay waste to Cap and the other good guys, incinerating the lot of them with an energy beam. Among the ash pile that was once the Avengers, the broken remains of Steve Rogers's shield can be spotted.

This being Marvel Comics, all of the death and destruction is eventually reversed when The Beyonder tricks old metal face into resurrecting the heroes and reclaims his powers. He then grants each hero one wish, and Cap asks for his shield to be restored.


9. Thanos

Thanos Cap
Marvel Comics

Only a fool would bet against Thanos seizing the full set of Infinity Gems in the upcoming movie Avengers: Infinity War. This is a feat he achieved in 1991's Infinity Gauntlet storyline, and with all six stones on his side, there's little he can't do.

That includes shattering Cap's shield, as though it were made of stunt glass, with his fist. With his glove fully stocked, the Mad Titan defeats Earth's mightiest heroes before wiping out half of the universe's sentient life with a snap of his fingers.

Captain America doesn't go down without a fight, but it isn't exactly a fair one. A gauntletted left hook from Thanos is all it took to take out his vibranium defence.

Once again, all of the death and destruction is reversed when Nebula takes the gauntlet into custody and undoes Thanos's tinkering. Don't bank on this happening in the movies, though, as the MCU has been known to deviate from the comics.


8. Ultron

Age Of Ultron Captain America Shield
Marvel Comics

Ultron came way closer to wiping out Earth's mightiest heroes in the comic books than the movies. When his robotic army laid siege on New York City in the Age of Ultron limited series, most of the good guys ended up either dead, or in hiding.

Captain America is one of the heroes who gets his backside handed to him during Ultron's invasion, and when the dregs of the Avengers hold a meeting later in the series to discuss a counter-offensive, the soldier looks less than super.

There's a powerful image of a bedraggled Cap sat amid the debris from his broken shield. Although it's never revealed who shattered the star-emblazoned frisbee, either Ultron himself or one of his Sentinels are pretty much the only candidates.

This panel featuring Steve Rogers on the deck double underlined the threat Ultron posed, and that it was far greater than that of his MCU counterpart.


7. Hyperion

Hyperion Marvel
Marvel Comics

King Hyperion is the sole survivor of a nuclear holocaust in an alternative Marvel Universe, a doomsday event that mankind instigated in a desperate bid to thwart the villain's bid for world domination. After finding his way to another version of Earth, Hyperion attempted to seize control of that one and fell afoul of its heroes.

The heroes of this world proved no match for Hyperion and he wasted the lot of them, including Captain America, whose shield was seen severely damaged alongside Thor's discarded hammer after he bludgeoned his way through the Avengers.

Although it was technically an alternative universe version of Steve Rogers that Hyperion defeated so convincingly, his shield-smashing feat still counts, as vibranium is no less durable in this incarnation of the Marvel Universe.


6. Thor

Thor Captain America
Marvel Comics

If you want to get technical, Thor didn't destroy Captain America's shield in 2003’s Avengers #63 so much as he dented it, but the impression his hammer made in the vibranium served as a reminder of what Mjolnir is capable of.

The Avengers teammates came to blows shortly after the thunder god waged war on the nation of Slokovia, attacking them in an act of revenge when members of the Church of Thor were slaughtered within its borders.

Cap, Iron Man and Ant-Man were deployed to stop Thor and an epic battle commenced. It was during the heat of it that the Asgardian's hammer made its mark on the near-indestructible frisbee.

Since Thor is a good guy at heart, he soon calmed down and made peace with his teammates. One handshake later, the god of thunder used Mjolnir to hammer the shield back into shape, as any good friend would.


5. Valkyrie

Captain America
Marvel Comics

Asgardian steel has proven to be hugely effective against Cap's shield over the years. Not only did Thor's hammer leave a massive imprint on the vibranium disc, Valkyrie's sword sliced clean through it 2010’s New Ultimates #2.

At this point, you might be wondering why Valkyrie wanted to drive her blade into Captain America, since they're both on the same side. Well, she was under the compulsion of Enchantress at the time, so don't hold it against her, okay?

After the story came to a head, the bad guys were defeated and Valkyrie regained control of her own mind, it was Thor who stepped up to help Cap with his broken shield problem. The thunder god had his dwarven blacksmiths forge the weapon anew.


4. Molecule Man

Molecule Man Captain America
Marvel Comics

Molecule Man has always been a B-list villain in the Marvel Universe, which is surprising considering he's basically one of the most powerful characters in it. Owen Reece has the ability to control molecules, and since everything in the world is made up of them... well, you do the maths.

B-lister though he may be, Molecule Man brought his A game in 1982's Avengers #215 when he used his awesome powers to disintegrated Thor's hammer, Iron Man's armour, the Silver Surfer's board and Captain America's shield.

Through a combination of the Surfer's Power Cosmic and a well-aimed punch from Cap, the heroes managed to take Molecule Man down in Avengers #216 without their favourite play things. Reece falls into the 'mad' rather than 'bad' category and the story ends with the heroes convincing him to seek psychiatric help.

To make amends for wreaking molecular chaos in the previous issue, he agrees to reassemble the heroes' weaponry, including Steve Rogers's shield.


3. The Serpent

The Serpent Fear Itself
Marvel Comics

Fear Itself saw a new contender for the Asgardian throne emerge when the Serpent escaped from his prison and amassed an army to wage war on his brother, Odin.

Thor's uncle, who also happens to be the god of fear, didn't have things his own way. His plans to seize power hit a snag when Iron Man and Captain America arrived on the scene. Cap attacks via his signature move - hurling his shield like a frisbee - but what happened next was a real turn up for the books.

The Serpent caught Cap's shield and broke it in half with his bare hands.

Just as Marvel heroes rarely stay dead, their favourite toys seldom stay broken too. On this occasion, Tony Stark's technical know-how and the skills of Asgardian metalsmith Uru proved enough to repair it in the wake of the Serpent's defeat.

The shield was left with a hefty scar afterwards, which Cap was happy to leave since it added character. Somebody forgot to tell the Marvel artists it was staying, though, as the blemish had completely disappeared in future issues.


2. Gregory Stark

Gregory Stark
Marvel Comics

In the Ultimate Universe, Marvel replanted Tony Stark's family tree and gave him an older brother named Gregory, who turned out to be a bit of a git.

Gregory Stark became the new head of S.H.I.E.L.D. and a charter member of the Project Avengers, but this turned out to be a front for a diabolical scheme which involved pitting the Ultimates and the Avengers against one another.

When Nick Fury and the Avengers learned of the older Stark's treachery, they confronted him, but the villain was well prepared for a showdown. He used an army of tiny robots called nanites to imbue him with enough super strength to seize Thor's hammer, and used it to turn Captain America's shield into scrap metal.

The Avengers and a shieldless Cap eventually defeated the evil Stark, but not without a little help from their friends, the New Ultimates.


1. Loki

Loki Avengers Earths Mightiest Heroes Cartoon
Disney

As previously touched on, Asgardians have had more success than most when it comes to destroying Cap's prized possession, and that success isn't limited to comics.

Loki, the god of mischief, got one over on Captain America's shield in the season one finale of Disney XD’s Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes animated TV show. The villain used his magic, enhanced with Odinforce, to smash the weapon to bits.

Disney XD’s Marvel shows exist within their own universe, and that's just as well, because Loki's shield-breaking antics would have created continuity issues had they occurred in the comics, as Odinforce has bounced right off Cap's shield in the books.

But the comics and the animated TV shows have one thing in common: the shield is always repaired afterwards. This time, Black Panther stepped up and had it mended courtesy of a Wakandan vibranium machine.

Know of any other occasions where Cap's had his mighty shield destroyed? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw