10 Comic Book Crazes You Totally Forgot Were A Thing

Comics go through trends and crazes from time to time, and some are better left in the past...

The Adventures of Superman #500
DC Comics

Comic books have been around for nearly a century, and over the years, the publishers have done some wild and crazy things to drum up business and increase sales. After all, you can only tell so many stories about a character before they get dull and repetitive, so why not try something new every once in a while?

Over the years, the various gimmicks and crazes have come and gone, with many sticking around far longer than they were welcome. For the most part, these types of sales gimmicks die out when the customers grow weary of them, but not all disappear, and some, like variant covers, stick around forever.

While those covers may still be around, there are more than enough gimmicky covers, and tweaks to the printing process publishers have thrown at customers, and those don't get to play in the world of comic books forever — many are long gone.

If you've been buying and reading comics for more than a few years, odds are, you're aware of many of the comic book crazes that came and went. Still, some of these ten comic book crazes that were, unfortunately, a thing not too long ago, may include some you've thankfully forgotten.

10. Gimmick Covers

Wolverine #75
Marvel Comics

If you collected comic books throughout the 1990s, odds are, you haven't forgotten about gimmick covers, but for everyone else, they were ubiquitous throughout the decade. Not only were they slapped onto just about every book a publisher put together during that period, but they also helped lead to the collapse of the industry.

Marvel and DC were notorious for gimmick covers back in the 1990s, and it was pretty ridiculous. The publishers printed gold, silver, and platinum foil-embossed covers, hologram or reflective foil covers, die-cut, glow-in-the-dark covers, and more.

This practice flooded the marketplace and helped tank the industry for years due to driving the speculative market for would-be collectors looking to buy something rare only to find out there were millions made, making them anything but rare or collectible.

Technically, the craze hasn't entirely gone away, but it has changed over time. Instead of buying a foil-embossed, hologram, platinum, or whatever else kind of cover a publisher makes for a book, fans eat up variant covers, and they are far better than the old gimmicky stuff.

Variant covers released nowadays feature entirely different artwork and depending on the book, there could be more than a dozen options, each one printed in a limited quantity. This doesn't hurt collecting like the old gimmicks did, and in many ways, it reinforces it, as some variant covers are scarce and highly sought after by collectors.


9. An Armory For Everyone

Cable Nathan Summers
Marvel Comics

Guns, weapons, gadgets, and tools are nothing new in the world of comics, but back in the 1990s, things took a turn to the extreme. This was largely due to the art style of Rob Liefeld, who worked on some of the most popular books of the decade at Marvel before leaving to co-found Image Comics.

Liefeld is a talented storyteller if his decades-long career is any indication, but his art is strangely unique and often copied by others. The man loves to portray his characters in entirely unrealistic ways, often going so far as to add muscle groups that don't exist on ordinary people.

More than muscles, he loves drawing ammo pouches, weapons, grenades, and ammunition. When he put a character together, he would throw enough guns and ammo onto their shoulders, chest, waist, legs, arms, and back to outfit an entire platoon of Special Operations soldiers.

It became commonplace to see characters like Cable carrying an army's worth of supplies, and this was a commonplace sight for years. Liefeld carried the practice into his work at Image, and his style inspired hundreds of artists who followed him into the industry. Thankfully, the practice has mostly decreased, but that doesn't mean a character doesn't pop up every once in a while with an entire armory strapped to their back.


8. Polybagging Everything

Superman 75 Bagged Collage
DC Comics

As any true comic book collector knows, it's incredibly important to bag and board your books, or they will suffer the ravages of time, rendering them bent, folded, or faded. This isn't helpful if you want to preserve your books, but that doesn't mean it's a great idea for the publisher to do it for you.

Back in the 1980s and well into the '90s, publishers began polybagging any books they felt they could sell more of, which was often limited to #1 issues, key centennial issues, or something overhyped beyond belief, like the "Death of Superman" story featured in Superman #75.

DC opted to release that book in several different polybag versions, and the readers bought all of them, but it was hardly the only book of its kind. The issue with polybagging a comic is that you had to tear the thing open if you wanted to read your book instead of just collecting them.

Doing this killed the book's value, so most readers had to purchase a separate copy, so they would have one to read, and one to box up and never touch again. Fortunately, polybagged issues have mostly disappeared from the industry, and with any luck, they won't ever return.


7. Make Them Darker, Grimmer, And Grittier

Punisher MAX
Marvel Comics

These days, comics fill all manner of niches within the literary format in that they are cartoonish, dramatic, action-packed, bloody as hell, violent, and sexual. There aren't many untapped taboos left in the medium, but back in the 1990s, things changed when publishers wanted to tell darker stories.

This particular craze wasn't a bad thing (like most on this list), but it did burn bright, and then die out into relative normalcy. For decades, the publishers stuck to the Comics Code of Authority, which limited what could be shown or talked about in comics.

Adhering to the Code meant drug use, sex, and other topics, which might not be suitable for children, were kept out of comics. Marvel opted to get around the Code while it was still around with its imprint MAX and DC chose to do the same with Vertigo. The stories told within those books weren't Code-approved, and the fans loved them.

This drove storytelling for a while to create darker and grittier-toned storylines and characters. By the mid-late '90s, just about every character had their story told in a more violent manner, and it was tantamount to having the gloves come off, as characters like the Punisher gave up all limitations, letting him truly punish his victims.


6. Boobs, Boobs, & More Boobs!

Power Girl
DC Comics

One of the most pervasive problems that has been a part of the comic book industry for decades is the over-sexualized depiction of women. Comics didn't completely start out by depicting women as little more than sex objects, but it wasn't long before the books headed in that direction.

Over the years, the curves got curvier, and the boobs got bigger and bigger — many to the point that any woman who attempted to fight crime in that condition would be physically incapable of doing much of anything.

One of the reasons this was a common instance within comics is due to the belief that heterosexual boys were the primary reader of books, but that's not entirely accurate. There are plenty of girls who read the same comics boys do, and after some time, they became vocal about their disinterest in seeing women depicted as objects.

Fortunately, modern comics tend to depict women in much the same way they do men: they are muscular to near-perfection, but things are decidedly less male-gaze-y.


5. Fracturing Story-Arcs Over Different Comics

Spider Man Clone Saga
Marvel Comics

Crossovers and huge events are still around in the comics, but there was a time when they were the absolute norm. It was common in the late-20th century to feature storylines that involved characters from one team or another, but the biggest producer of this type of story in the '90s was Marvel Comics.

Before huge events like the Clone Saga hit Spider-Man's books, the comics were linear in their storytelling. When issue #255 came between #254 and #256, you could rely on the story either being a one-off or a continuation or conclusion of whatever story it was telling.

As the stories became more complex, and Marvel opted to publish multiple Spider-Man books, the linear storytelling readers had enjoyed for 30+ years was broken. You would pick up an issue of Amazing Spider-Man but would have to get Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man if you wanted to continue reading the story.

If you couldn't afford to buy the plethora of Spider-Man books at the time, you would read the next month's issue of ASM, and the story wouldn't pick up directly after the last one since it did that in the pages of another book. Marvel wasn't the only publisher guilty of doing this sort of thing, but it continued well into the 1990s, and a lot of fans couldn't keep up.


4. Putting Children In Danger To Boost Sales

Batman slaps Robin
DC Comics

If you think of your favorite comic book superhero with a sidekick, there's a good chance one name will come up above all else. Batman and Robin have been around for 80+ years, and despite the fact that Batman's work is inherently dangerous, he felt it necessary to drag a child around with him to fight crime.

It's not really a thing anymore — there aren't a lot of superheroes who have sidekicks like Robin, but in the 1940s and well into the '50s, it wasn't just normal to have a kid along for the ride, it was almost mandatory.

Robin wasn't brought into Batman's world right away; he was introduced later to try and bring more children into the book, and it worked. Kids loved seeing the bright colors on the kid kicking butt and taking names alongside their favorite superhero, and that led to a mini-explosion of the practice.

Green Arrow had Speedy, Captain America had Bucky Barnes, and the list goes on. The most recent superhero sidekick who fits the description of a child who should have been in school instead of beating up bad guys is Hit-Girl from Kick-Ass. Still, Mark Millar's tale of an assassin is more of a commentary on why kids shouldn't be sidekicks than being supportive of the practice.

Fortunately, teenage sidekicks aren't really a thing anymore, and while the Teen Titans are still around, they aren't sidekicks to anyone — not anymore.


3. Variant Interior Stories

Team Titans #1
DC Comics

There was a time when the word "variant" wasn't solely limited to comic book covers, and it was a very dark time indeed. Fortunately, this was rare, but occasionally, publishers would print books that featured an altered story within the pages, making it difficult to distinguish one from another.

This was something like a Choose Your Own Adventure or the ending of the movie Clue; readers would open their books to find that their copy told a story different from their buddy's book, and the only way to get the complete story was to purposefully purchase the same comic as many times as necessary to get the whole thing.

On the surface, this was a novel idea, and it could have worked in limited ways, but for the most part, the fans didn't appreciate having to repurchase the same book over and over again. One of the biggest culprits in this practice was DC's Team Titans.

The book was a spinoff of The New Teen Titans, and the first issue contained two parts: a lead story, and an origin story for one of the new Titans. The lead was the same for all books, but there were five distinct origin stories, which meant readers needed to grab five copies of Team Titans #1 if they wanted the whole story. Fortunately, this craze didn't last long.


2. Swimsuit Issues

marvel swimsuit special
Marvel Comics

Comics in the 1980s and especially into the '90s featured a lot of skin-tight ladies, and while that craze is slowly abating across the industry, it wasn't until the Swimsuit Era that it became as obvious to readers as it is now in hindsight.

To capitalize on the success of Sports Illustrated's Swimsuit Edition, Marvel decided to put out a swimsuit edition of its major characters. Really. The books were released annually, and they somewhat told a story but were mostly about portraying all of the publisher's characters in skimpy swimwear, and it wasn't limited to female characters either.

Marvel wasn't the only publisher to do this, and several independent publishers joined in on the fun. There are swimsuit editions for characters like Lady Death and Vampirella, who honestly couldn't wear less if she tried, and many more. The issues were something of a hokey collectible, and they didn't exactly fail to sell despite how ridiculous they were.

Swimsuit Edition comics stayed around through the early 2000s, and have pretty much gone away since then. Still, every once in a while, a new swimsuit comic book will show up on a store shelf somewhere, and many a fan will grab a few Archie comics and a Batman to throw off the clerk when they embarrassingly purchase it... because they like the articles...?


1. Clipping Coupons

Marvel Value Stamp
Marvel Comics

Even if you've barely touched a comic book in years, but have a passing awareness, you likely know that The Incredible Hulk #181 is the highly coveted first (full) appearance of Wolverine. The book is one of the best scores any collector could add to their collection, but you have to be careful in acquiring one.

Marvel used to throw a "Marvel Value Stamp" inside its books, which were collectible images you could cut out of your worthless old comic book to place into a binder. Fans would do this and put them inside a Marvel-issued booklet, and they were popular.

Sadly, this means that you might think you are in luck when you acquire an issue like Hulk #181, only to find that some kid cut it to pieces on the inside decades earlier. The value of the book is drastically reduced as a result, and publishers kept up this sort of thing for years.

When Image and Valiant began selling their books int he 1990s, they did the same thing. Readers would cut out a coupon hidden inside the pages of the book, and send them in for a special issue. This usually meant a collector would buy an extra copy to leave unharmed, but not always. Fortunately, the fad has mostly passed, leaving newer books unharmed where a pair of scissors are concerned.


Watch Next


Marvel Quiz: Which Bruce Banner Said It?

Avengers Endgame Bruce Banner
Marvel Studios

1. "So You're Saying That The Hulk... The Other Guy... Saved My Life?"

Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com