10 Comic Book Heroes Improved Through Retcon

No matter how often their origins get changed, these amazing heroes never-ending battles rage on.

Jason Todd Robin Red Hood
DC Comics

Much more than villains, superheroes have often remained fairly static and unchanged throughout the decades. Other than modernizing to keep with the times, the continuity of the company, or editorial whims, there are many heroes that look basically the same as they did when they debuted. However, there are some heroes who have not only evolved, but have changed drastically through the passage of time.

A few have been created to apply to a specific cultural stereotype that no longer applies and have become more fully realized characters. Others have “died” and returned as different characters through retcons or rebirths. And others have been several people using the same name over time. A few of these heroes are world-famous, while others are only known to the most knowledgeable comics fans.

Whether they have the name recognition of Superman or Batman doesn’t diminish the incredible story behind each of these characters. They evolved from characters who represented a specific time, to characters of today and characters that will endure into the future. Some characters simply fade away, but these characters are renewed and will shine on for many days to come.

10. Carol Danvers

Captain Marvel Carol Danvers
Marvel Comics

Carol Danvers was a young girl who dreamed of the stars. She joined the Air force to become a pilot and pay her way through college. Her military service included spy work that had her cross paths with Logan, Ben Grimm, Nick Fury, and others. Retiring to become the captain of security at NASA, Carol soon became suspicious of Dr. Walter Lawson, secretly Kree Captain Mar-Vell. Becoming subjected to a Psyche Magnetron, Danvers was transformed and gained superpowers from Mar-Vell’s Negabands. Taking the name Ms. Marvel, she became a popular feminist superhero.

Ms. Marvel joined the Avengers and did well until she was subjugated and violated by the extra-dimensional being Marcus. Escaping, she was violated again when mutant terrorist Rogue stole her powers, psyche, and personality. Carol got the memories back thanks to Charles Xavier but never the feelings. She went to space with the Starjammers and developed vast cosmic powers as Binary. Returning to Earth and losing much of her power, she took the name Warbird and rejoined the Avengers. An alcohol problem nearly cost her that job, but she got help from Tony Stark.

Time as Earth’s most popular human superhero in the House of M and the revelation that she was the daughter of a Kree super-soldier caused Carol to fully embrace her heritage as Captain Marvel, making her one of the most powerful heroes in the Marvel Universe.


9. Arsenal

Roy Harper
DC Comics

Roy Harper was originally the son of a park ranger who died. He was raised by his friend, Navajo Indian chief Brave Bow. The young Roy was an archery prodigy and impressed Green Arrow with his skills. Knowing he was dying, Brave Bow asked the hero to look after the boy. The Emerald Archer trained Roy and made him his sidekick, Speedy. The young bowman also joined other sidekicks in the Teen Titans.

After the Titans broke up and Ollie was hard traveling with Hal Jordan, Roy turned to drugs for comfort. Enraged, Arrow fired Harper. Roy got clean with the help of Black Canary and went on to become a spy, Outsider, and Justice Leaguer. He also had a daughter with assassin Cheshire.

In the New 52, the future Arsenal was raised by Big Bow of the Spokane Indians in Seattle and was accused of Bow's murder, which he couldn’t refute because he was blackout drunk. The Titans had forgotten about their time together because of the villainous Mr. Twister and did not reunite until years later. Instead, Roy joined the Outlaws with Red Hood and Starfire.

Harper was killed at the Sanctuary by Savitar, although it was staged to look like Wally West had committed this act. Roy returned to life when the Multiverse was reset at the end of the Dark Metal Saga but declined to inform any of his former friends or teammates. He set down his bow and signature trucker cap and started hitchhiking.


8. Scarlet Witch

Scarlet Witch Marvel Future Fight
Marvel

Wanda Maximoff was of Romani-Serbian descent and was the twin sister of Quicksilver. Originally believed to be mutants, they were rescued by Magneto from an angry crowd and pressed into his first incarnation of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. The pair joined the Avengers and Wanda used her “Hex Bolts” that seemed to alter probability around her. She also began to learn true magic with Agatha Harkness. Wanda fell in love with and married The Vision and they “had” twin sons, which were actually magical pieces taken from Mephisto, who reclaimed them. Harkness made her forget the children, for a time.

Hardships and truths piled up on The Witch. She gained “Chaos Magic” and reality manipulating powers which led to a breakdown that caused the deaths of several Avengers teammates and the dissolution of the team. Quicksilver convinced her to create a reality where mutants ruled, and it worked until Earth’s heroes rebelled. Before she set things right, Wanda said: “No More Mutants” - which depowered over 90% of the world's mutants, killing hundreds.

It was eventually revealed that she and Pietro were not mutants at all, but humans who had been genetically manipulated by the High Evolutionary. She also came from a long line of Scarlet Witches and Warlocks and, having absorbed the Darkhold, was one of the most powerful magic wielders in existence.

Initially a “pretender” on Krakoa, the sorceress created circumstances that mutants could be resurrected naturally on the island, making her the “redeemer” of mutantkind.


7. Cyborg

Cyborg DC Comics
DC Comics

Victor Stone was the intellectually gifted and athletically inclined son of two scientist parents. When visiting their lab, a gelatinous creature from another dimension broke through and killed his mother, and destroyed most of Victor’s body. His father, Silas, saved the poor teen's life by grafting experimental cybernetic parts to his damaged body. Having to relearn the simplest of tasks, the now transformed youth became resentful and angry about his predicament. This attitude continued long after joining the Teen Titans. Only after meeting a group of young kids with prostheses who saw Vic as a hero and mentor and embracing Changeling's friendship, did Cyborg start to tackle his new life.

The New 52 saw Silas Stone working at S.T.A.R. Labs, and it was a New Genesis Father Box that exploded and destroyed much of Victor’s body. To save his son, Silas enlisted the aide of fellow doctors Sarah Charles and T.O. Morrow, and the trio added a number of technologies to the mix, including a Responsometer from Dr. Will Magnus, Professor Ivo’s A Maze program, and more. The Father Box revealed Darkseid’s planned invasion. As he came online, a group of Parademons attacked and Cyborg blew them and half a wall away.

Incorporating a Mother Box into his technology, Vic boom-tubed to where Superman, Batman, and other heroes were battling Darkseid and more Parademons. Cyborg used his technology to send Darkseid away and helped form the Justice League. The technological wonder befriended young hero Shazam and continually upgraded his systems and hardware.


6. Moira MacTaggert

Moira Mactaggert
Marvel Comics

Moira MacTaggert was a Nobel Prize-winning expert in the field of genetic mutation, and she was once the fiancé and confidante of Professor Charles Xavier. The scientist later opened the Muir Island Research Center, and eventually met and fell in love with Sean Cassidy - the X-Men's Banshee - and took on a surrogate motherly role to young mutant Wolfbane, aka Rayne Sinclair. She contracted and eventually died from the Legacy Virus, unable to find a cure.

It was later retconned in House of X that Moira was a mutant with the power of reincarnation and complete recall of her past lives. Her abilities allowed her to shape the course of events through her actions and how she manipulated those around her. By her third life, she comes up with a cure for mutants but ran afoul of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. She spent her next several lives searching for the best path through Xavier, Magneto, or Apocalypse.

Moira’s tenth life unfolded as she subtly manipulated forces to eventually created the island nation of Krakoa and the Resurrection Protocols that made mutants virtually immortal. She made sure that both she and Xavier had children with reality-warping powers, and she worked behind the scenes to bring Xavier and Magneto together and to create Krakoa’s financial independence as a major pharmaceutical power. MacTaggert pushed to keep Destiny or other precogs from being resurrected, but when it happened, she was discovered. Mystique robbed her of her mutant powers but, thanks to Cypher, she escaped.


5. Green Lantern John Stewart

John Stewart
DC Comics

John Stewart was an architect who was approached to be the second substitute Green Lantern when Guy Gardner was in a coma following an auto accident. Hal Jordan was initially apprehensive of the belligerent and anti-authority Stewart, but the Guardians stood by their choice. Stewart did things his own way but he was far from perfect. John lost his wife, Katma Tui, to Star Sapphire. He also failed to prevent the destruction of the planet Xanshi.

Stewart was put in charge of the Mosaic experiment on Oa where a mad Guardian had collected many alien communities together. He soon began to heal and forgive himself. Forging the Mosaic into a true society, he became the first human Guardian or Master Builder. Sadly, it all came crashing down when the Parallax-possessed Hal destroyed the Central Power Battery and the Guardians. John became a Darkstar until he was crippled and later healed by Jordan.

With Rebirth, Stewart’s first career was as a talented marine sniper. A distinguished Lantern, John was one of the Honor Guard and had been on the frontlines of every major battle the Corps engaged in. He was a mainstay of several League teams and helped design the Hall of Justice. Stewart has recently ascended to a higher evolutionary level, wielding Lantern powers connected directly to the Source.


4. Supergirl

Supergirl Comics
DC Comics

Kara Zor-El was rocketed as an adolescent from Argo City, a doomed locale that survived the initial destruction of Krypton but eventually fell to Kryptonite poisoning. Kara arrived on Earth and assumed the identity of Linda Lee Danvers. She kept her powers secret at Superman’s request until she gained control of them. After graduating, in addition to attending college, Kara held many careers but her superhero career took precedence, even over her social life. She was killed by the Anti-Monitor while saving Superman, and Crisis on Infinite Earths wiped her memory from existence.

The modern Supergirl crash-landed in Gotham Harbor and attacked the Man of Steel when she first met him, believing him to be an impostor. From her perspective, Kal should be a baby and she had been sent to Earth to protect him, but it was discovered that her rocket had been caught in an asteroid field for many years while she was in suspended animation. She was now “younger” than her infant cousin.

Trained with the help of Batman and Wonder Woman, the Maid of Might began a superhero career but had a number of missteps. She fell under the thrall of Darkseid, almost destroyed the Earth to bring Krypton back, and had trouble breaking free of her connection to the Red Lantern Ring. Rebirth saw her as an operative of the DEO and a member of the Justice League on two different teams.


3. Winter Soldier

Winter Soldier Rod Reis
Marvel Comics

James “Bucky” Barnes was an orphan and camp mascot on Camp Lehigh, Virginia. He soon discovered Steve Rogers’ secret identity as Captain America and became his young sidekick. Bucky also conducted side missions for the brass that the idealistic Rogers wouldn’t approve of. The pair joined other costumed heroes in a number of teams to fight the Nazis, including the Invaders. The young hero apparently died in the explosion of an experimental plane.

Barnes hadn’t died, although the explosion did cost him his left arm. He fell into the freezing water and into suspended animation like Rogers. Bucky was discovered by a Soviet submarine. A virtual amnesiac, James was programmed to hate the West and was sent to conduct strategic assassinations as the Winter Soldier. He was placed in cryostasis until he was needed again. The Soldier was given an ever-improving number of bionic arms over the decades.

Sent to assassinate the Red Skull and obtain the Cosmic Cube, the Winter Soldier ran into Captain America. The pair battled and Rogers used the Cube to return Bucky’s memories to him. James fled and went looking for his handler, General Lukin, and the Red Skull, who were the same person at the time. Barnes began to rebuild his life and right wrongs. He took over the Cap's identity when it appeared Steve had been assassinated and led the New Avengers.


2. Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman Sword Shield
DC Comics

Wonder Woman’s origin began with her mother Hippolyta, Queen of the immortal Amazons, so desperately wanting a child that she molded one out of clay and prayed to her gods to give it life. Princess Diana grew up on Paradise Island until the day Steve Trevor crashed on the island. She won the right to return him to “Man’s World” as Wonder Woman. Later, Diana is the biological daughter of Hippolyta and Zeus, King of the Greek Gods.

The Golden Age of Wonder Woman was intrinsically attached to World War II. This version joined the Justice Society as their secretary. This had been retconned to be a time-traveling Queen Hippolyta. The Silver Age one was a founding member of the Justice League, but when Crisis on Infinite Earths wiped her out of existence, her place was taken by Black Canary. A new Diana was introduced into the Post-Crisis world.

In the modern incarnation of Wonder Woman, she is a nigh-invulnerable, incredibly powerful demigoddess who did first appear in the 1940s but stopped when Congress came after the superheroes to unmask or retire. Diana’s most recent return to Man’s World was when Darkseid unleashed Parademons on the Earth and brought together the current version of the Justice League.


1. Red Hood

Jason Todd Red Hood
DC Comics

Jason Todd came from a home with a criminal father and an alcoholic mother. The boy was running with gangs from an early age to support his mom. Believing she had died and having nothing to lose, the young delinquent tried to steal the tires from the Batmobile. Expecting to be beaten, Jason was instead offered food by the Caped Crusader. Batman took Todd in and, after intense training, made the lucky young man the second Robin.

Jason was a reckless Robin, breaking rules and using excessive violence toward criminals. Discovering that his mother was still alive, he traveled to the Middle East to find her, but he was captured by the Joker, who beat his hapless victim nearly to death with a crowbar and killed him in an explosion. Batman arrived seconds too late to save his partner.

Todd was resurrected six months later by Talia al Ghul and was trained by the All Caste, Bronze Tiger, and Lady Shiva. He eventually returned to Gotham as the new crime boss, the Red Hood. After failed attempts to get revenge on Batman and the Joker, The Hood became a force for deadly justice throughout the world. He created two teams of Outsiders over time and slowly reconciled with each member of the Bat-family.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

John Wilson has been a comic book and pop culture fan his entire life. He has written for a number of websites on the subject over the years and is especially pleased to be at WhatCulture. John has written two comic books for Last Ember Press Studio and has recently self-published a children's book called "Blue." When not spending far too much time on the internet, John spends time with his lovely wife, Kim, their goofy dog, Tesla, and two very spoiled cats.