10 Comic Book Heroes Who Were Secretly Replaced
Even Batman needs a vacations sometimes.
As we all know, crime-fighting can be a tough gig. For one thing you have to fight criminals. It's in the name. I'm so passive I won't even ask a stranger for directions.
Not to mention the costumes (oh lord, the costumes). You have the choice of skin-tight spandex that probably provides absolutely no support. Or, you can wear a metric ton of computerized body armor that probably requires constant software updates. Seriously, how many times do you think Tony Stark has to hit the restart on that Iron Man suit?
It's a thankless job. Spider-Man is the pariah of New York City thanks to muckraking J. Jonah Jamison. Wolverine has to deal with constant romantic anguish and frequent bouts of memory loss. Superman has the world on his shoulders most days, and Batman, well… You know what? Batman has it pretty good. The dude's a billionaire, and he can quit the superhero thing at any time.
But with all those hardships, it's no wonder that superheroes need a break sometimes. When they do go on sabbatical - or die, no one bats a thousand, right? - it leaves quite a void in the world. That's why the following is a list of people who secretly replaced our favorite superheroes.
10. Daken As Wolverine
Daken wasn't born in the best of circumstances. He was the son of a woman named Itsu, who happened to be the Japanese lover of that silver-clawed minx James Howlett, better known as Wolverine. Unfortunately, for Daken, his mother was murdered by the Winter Soldier while he was still in the womb. Owing to the healing factor he inherited from his father, Daken survived the encounter. That's one of the few things Daken and his father have in common, though. Well, that and the Wolverine moniker.
Shortly after the Skrull Invasion came to an end, Norman Osborn decided to create an alternate version of the Avengers. Known as the Dark Avengers, Osborn tapped Daken to step into his father's role as Wolverine. Daken agreed and donned the tan and brown suit, and became an even grumpier version of Wolverine.
He tried and failed to kill Spider-Man. He did, however, destroy the Punisher, Frank Castle, by cutting Castle up into hundreds of tiny pieces. Don't worry because Castle's body was collected by the Man-Thing and sewn back together into a creature known as Franken Castle. The Punisher eventually tracked down Daken looking for revenge. After the two got into a brawl in a bar, Castle shoved a phosphorus grenade into Daken's chest.
After that, Daken took a break for a while. Wouldn't you?
9. Dick Grayson As Batman
Is there any more successful or popular superhero sidekick than the former boy wonder, Dick Grayson? Sure, Krypto the super dog has a few things going for him. I mean, he served in the Legion of Super pets, and he was an agent of the Space Canine Patrol, but we're not here to talk about Krypto, so stop bringing him up, would you?
So Dick Grayson was Batman for a while.
After the events of Final Crisis, where Darkseid kills (lol, not really) Bruce Wayne, a struggle ensues between Jason Todd and Dick Grayson to see who will become the new Batman.
Of course, Dick wins (I mean he's Nightwing for god's sake), and he takes on Bruce's son, Damian, as the new Robin.
Dick ably handles the cape and cowl in Bruce's absence, managing Damian's anger and maintaining a much better romantic life that Bruce ever dreamed of having.
Who are we kidding? Bruce doesn't dream of women. He dreams of bats gliding through gothic columns and billowing fog while an inner monologue shouts, "I am Justice, I am the night!"
8. Doc Ock As Spider-Man
Otto Octavius, atomic researcher, nuclear physicist, weird robot-armed supervillain, and Peter Parker body snatcher? Oh yeah, that happened.
Quickly, let's go through the events that led up to Doctor Octopus taking over Peter Parker's body.
Buckle up.
With his health failing, Octavius takes over a space station from his underwater headquarters. He then uses his octo-satellites to supercharge Earth's greenhouse effect. He then offers to reverse the effects of global warming in exchange for compliance from all the world's governments.
Then - yeah, this plan gets more complicated - Otto sends Chameleon to the United Nations posing as Al Gore.
Swear.
Ok, let's fast forward a bit here.
In a final battle with Spider-Man, Doc Ock uses a modified Octobot to transfer his consciousness from his dying body and into Spider-Man's.
One side-effect that Octavius didn't anticipate was that along with stealing Peter Parker's web-slinging body, he also absorbed the wall-crawler's memories and part of Parker's personality. After this, Octavius reflected on his life, decided he'd been quite the dick for most of it and took on the mantle of Spider-Man as a way of atoning for his former sins. (But not without making a few "improvements" of course.)
7. Jean-Paul Valley As Batman
In the early nineties, Bruce Wayne suffered a pesky back injury when Bane snapped the Caped Crusader in two over his knee. Bruce found himself paralyzed and knew he would be out of the crime-fighting game for what? Six months?
This is Batman we're talking about.
Bruce needed a fill-in to keep all of Gotham's maniac rogues in check during his absence. Now the obvious choice would've been Dick Grayson, the man who Bruce had trained and raised since he was a boy, instilling, in Dick, Bruce's rigid code of honor and justice.
Stupidly, Bruce decided to go with a brainwashed assassin named Jean-Paul Valley instead. Valley had been groomed from birth by a group called the Order of Saint Dumas to become their righteous soldier Azrael. This caused Valley's personality to conflict a bit with the stress of donning the cape and cowl.
The most significant split between Bruce and Valley came when the latter threw the villain, Abattoir, to his death, allowing Abattoir's captured and innocent victims to die as a result.
After that, Valley refused to give up the Batman persona to a now recovered Bruce. Wayne had to battle and ultimately defeat Vally to take back the Batman identity.
Next time, Bruce, just hand the pointy ears over to Robin.
6. Scott Summers As Captain America
This one takes place in an alternate Marvel universe called Earth 81122. We all know Scott Summers as the boy scout-esque leader of the Uncanny X-Men, and really who better to take up the shield if Steve Rogers were ever to perish?
That's precisely what happens on a new version of Earth. Here, Reed Richards invents a machine meant to cure The Thing of his cursed appearance. The experiment goes wrong and strips Cyclops, Jean Grey, and Captain America of their powers. Regrettably, Steve suffers the worst effects of this failed experiment as he suddenly ages one hundred years in a matter of minutes.
Horrified by having to watch his ally Rogers suffer such a dreadful fate, Scott Summers vows to take over Captain America's duties. But, Summers opts not to use Roger's ordinarily red, white, and blue costume. He instead wears a red, yellow, and white version of Cap's suit along with a yellow shield featuring a white X to keep some of that uncanny X-men flair.
5. Eradicator As Superman
The Eradicator is not a person but an ancient Kryptonian artifact built by Superman's ancestor, some dude named Kem-L. The device was built to "preserve Kryptonian purity." Kem-L later retired to Argentina, and Superman's family isn't comfortable talking about him anymore.
The Eradicator floated around space for a few hundred thousand years until it came into Superman's possession, who promptly used it to create the Fortress of Solitude. Things went along pretty well for a while until Superman got straight murked by the giant rock monster looking guy called Doomsday.
Good thing Superman had that ancient artifact designed to preserve all things Kryptonian, though.
The Eradicator shoved Supes into a rejuvenation chamber to convalesce for a minute. While Kal-El napped away, the Eradicator took human form to take on Superman's duties. He did pretty much everything Superman would, except he did it wearing a pair of yellow-tinted night driving glasses. He even stopped Cyborg Superman from killing the real Superman as Kal-El recuperated.
The early nineties was lousy with Superman posers.
4. Flash Thompson As Venom
If you don't remember Flash Thompson, he was the long-time schoolyard bully who tormented Peter Parker. The irony is that once Parker started swinging from high-rises, Thompson became the web-slinger's biggest fan. He later put aside his childish behavior, and he and Peter became good friends. Flash even served in the military, becoming a decorated war hero.
In the real world, Marvel decided they wanted to capitalize on the popularity of Spider-Man's foe, Venom. They thought the best way to do this was to shift the character into an antihero role. The only problem was that Eddie Brock had committed some heinous acts during his time with the symbiote, such as trying to kill Peter Parker by pushing him in front of a train. So, writers dusted off old Flash Thompson.
In the comic timeline, the Venom symbiote is captured by the US government and housed at the Department of Homeland Security. DHS realizes they can use the suit to create a new super soldier. So, they bond Venom with Flash and order him to complete twenty deadly missions. Flash controls the symbiote through a combination of sedatives and sheer force of will.
Unlike Eddie Brock, who lusted for power and revenge, Flash's only goal is to survive his twenty missions so he never has contact with the Venom symbiote again. He would eventually join the Guardians of the Galaxy, which is pretty cool.
3. Stephanie Brown As Batgirl
Stephanie Brown is the daughter of a Batman rogue known as the Cluemaster, who is basically a store brand Riddler. Tired of waiting out her dad's long stints in prison, Brown decides to take up a life of crime-fighting. Specifically, she decides to spoil all of her father's plans and starts calling herself the Spoiler. She leaves clues to her dad's crimes in hopes that Batman and Robin catch him.
At one point, Brown teams up with Tim Drake, and together they capture her father, the Cluemaster. Brown realized that she enjoyed her time as the Spoiler and decided to go full time.
Brown starts patrolling the city with Robin, and the two become romantically involved. Their romance happens even though, at this point, Stephanie is pregnant with another man's baby, and she doesn't even know Robin's true identity. Tim Drake even takes up a fake persona to accompany Brown to Lamaze classes.
Later, Brown befriends Cassandra Cain, who helps her sharpen her crime-fighting skills.
Even later, Brown spends time filling in as Robin. However, after the events of Batman RIP, Cain passes on the mantle of Batgirl to Brown. Cain does this without any of the Bat family's knowledge, and both Barbara Gordon and Dick Grayson are shocked to find a new Batgirl roaming the streets at night.
After Dick and Barabra discover that it's Brown under the Batgirl cowl, they confront her. In her role as Oracle, Barbra Gordon demands that Brown give up the Batgirl persona. Brown refuses, and the two come to a deal. Stephanie Brown can continue as Batgirl under Barbara's guidance. Brown even gets a sweet new costume out of the agreement.
2. Amadeus Cho As The (Totally Awesome) Hulk
Amadeus Cho is known as the eight smartest man in the Marvel universe. This is no small feat considering he's competing with the likes of Reed Richards and Victor Von Doom. Cho possesses what's known as a hyper mind. This hyper mind ability allows Cho to run limitless calculations in his head like some freaky supercomputer.
A Korean American, Cho grew up idolizing the Hulk. For a hyperintelligent young boy to worship a hulking green giant whose vocabulary consists of two words- 'Hulk' and 'smash'- seems strange. But, there's an explanation for this. When Cho was a teenager, he ran away from home with an adopted coyote pup named Kirby. Unfortunately, he had a run-in with the law. But, the Hulk saved him after a chance encounter.
Cho later used his kinship with the Hulk to help end World War Hulk and subdue the not-so-jolly green giant. After the Secret Wars events, Cho designed and used nanites to remove the Hulk from Bruce Banner's body. He then placed the Hulk in his own body and became a new character Cho dubbed the Totally Awesome Hulk.
In his role as the Hulk, Cho hunted down dangerous monsters around the globe, teamed up with She-Hulk and Spider-Man, and in general, was "totally awesome."
1. Victor Von Doom As Infamous Iron Man
Doctor Doom is, perhaps, one of the greatest villains in the Marvel universe. But, there was a time when Victor tried his best to reform and become a hero. Not just any hero, though. Doom stepped into the role of none other than Iron Man.
After the events of Secret Wars, Doom's face was healed, and he was feeling a lot better about himself. He even decided that it was time to put aside his evil ways. It's incredible what a glow-up can do for you.
With Tony Stark dead, Doom chose to gift the world another ironclad hero. And so, the Infamous Iron Man was born.
Of course, Doom ran into opposition as none of the other heroes of the Marvel Universe believed for a second Doom sought atonement. But, Doom went on fighting evil and ignoring the haters. He even ran into Tony Stark's hand-picked successor Riri Williams aka Iron Heart. Williams ended up as one of the few people who believed Doom.
All this animosity started to get to Doom, though, and when Tony Stark was resurrected, it was clear to Doom that his time as Iron Man had come to an end. During a battle with the Hood, Doom's face was newly scarred. After this, Doom fell back into his old habits and returned to a life of evil.
So, Doom's face was healed and he became a hero, but everyone treated him like crap. Then this face was re-scarred, and he broke bad again. There's a lesson in there somewhere. I just don't know what it is.
Watch Next
Marvel Quiz: How Well Do You Know Wolverine?