10 Comic Book Villains Who Killed Their Greatest Rival

Even the Joker gets the last laugh every once in a while.

Bullseye Wolverine Old Man Logan
Marvel Comics

With hundreds and hundreds of comics containing tales of supervillains trying and failing to kill heroes, it's all too easy for comic readers to become conditioned and expect their heroes to survive. Much like Thanos, it's inevitable that after reading countless issues of your favourite do-gooder escaping death's clutches, it starts to feel like their plot armour is so thick that there's no way they could actually be killed.

This is why it's absolutely crucial that there are occasions in which a hero's nemesis does kill them, as it not only fixes this disillusionment, but also reinvigorates the big feuds that DC and Marvel live on.

While even death has a habit of not lasting long in comic book universes, seeing seemingly invincible characters like Batman and Thor slip up and be murdered always feels like something special, even if you know it isn't a permanent affair.

It's a move that can admittedly easily be overused - as is best shown with heroes like Jean Grey, who are constantly reincarnated - but, given an intense enough rivalry and a dramatic enough death, it can also be exactly what a plot needs to have that little extra punch when you read it.

10. Lex Luthor Kills Superman - Superman #149

Lex Luthor
DC Comics

In a comic that precluded the hero's famous defeat at the hands of Doomsday, Superman #149 sees Luthor accomplish a rare feat, by actually managing to take down the Man of Steel.

After spending what is suggested to be years of time gaining Superman's trust, Lex convinces the spaceman that his life is under threat, and that the only way he can be safe is if the hero helps him build a space station that nobody else can access. Ever the kind soul, Kent agrees, and inadvertently builds his own death trap - as Luthor would trap the Kryptonian in one of the ship's rooms, and expose him to kryptonite until he passed away.

This isn't the only time Lex would be able to pull the wool over Kent's eyes - at one point in his comic career even curing cancer just to get close to the Man of Steel - it's the most successful of Luthor's various machinations, which is also exactly why it's not considered canon.


9. Sinestro Kills The Green Lanterns - Injustice: Gods Among Us Year Two

Sinestro Kyle Rayner Injustice
DC Comics

What sucks more than being killed by someone with an old-timey villain moustache? Being killed by him in a comic where this is almost forgettable, as is the cruel fate of Green Lanterns John Stewart and Kyle Rayner.

Although Hal is undeniably Sinestro’s arch nemesis, he is also the leader of the Yellow Lanterns - as thus the de facto rival of their enemies, the Green Lanterns

While many fans were understandably frustrated at two of the Green Lanterns best fighters dying without putting up much of a fight, this actually works well in the context of Injustice. Seeing the pair die tragically makes Hal Jordan teaming up with the villain all the more prominently awful, as he is essentially teaming up with the guy who has just killed two of his closest friends and comrades.

Worse yet, amongst the chaos of the series, these deaths fall almost entirely to the wayside - with Rayner's even literally taking place in the background of a panel.


8. Loki Kills Thor - Thor #3

Loki Kills Thor
Marvel Comics

The 2018 Thor comic was a classic in many, many ways, but by far it's very best moment has to be seeing Loki finally slay his brother Thor.

Although this initially sounds totally dark, the case is actually anything but.

When the pair realise that, in order to save the realms, they need the assistance of the warriors who inhabit Valhalla, it quickly becomes clear that Thor will have to go, as Loki is banned from ever stepping foot there. As such, Loki stabs Thor - in an unusually acceptable stabbing - as the pair have agreed that this has to happen in order to save the world.

While this isn't the only time that Loki has killed his older brother, it is perhaps the most entertaining time this happens, as it shows that the pair's sibling rivalry and brotherly love are inextricably intertwined.


7. The Green Goblin Kills Spider-Man - Ultimate Spider-Man #160

Spider-Man Aunt May
Marvel Comics

In the final issue of Ultimate Spider-Man, Norman Osborn finally manages what we never thought would be possible - ending the life of his long-suffering enemy, Peter Parker.

The fight initially appears to be going in Spider-Man's favour, as the web-slinger manages to beat down the hulking monster every time, even crushing him under a huge truck. When the Goblin doesn't get up, it genuinely for a moment appears as though the 'Death of Spider-Man' comic may actually turn out just fine.

Only, the Green Goblin creates one final explosion which hits Peter directly, sending him careening off onto a nearby lawn. Parker is wounded beyond recovery, and so the remainder of the comic contains his tragic goodbye to Aunt May before dying right in front of her eyes.

This is made extra heartbreaking by what he tells his guardian - that he's glad he was part of the fight that killed him, because it meant he could save May, which in his mind makes up for having never saved his Uncle Ben all those years ago.


6. Doctor Doom Kills The Thing - Fantastic Four #508

Ben Grimm Doctor Doom
Marvel Comics

Doom's feud with the Richards family is one of the most surprisingly PG rivalries in comic history, with the villain repeatedly torturing the family, but never actually killing them - although he certainly come close in storylines like Unthinkable, where he takes a child Franklin Richards with him to Hell.

This makes Doom actually successfully killing Ben Grimm in Fantastic Four #508 all the more surprising, as it seems unthinkable that Doom would succeed in a way that left one of the heroic team dead. But, after possessing The Thing and threatening to kill Johnny Storm, the remaining Fantastic Four are left with no choice but to put their own family member down in order to prevent anyone else from getting hurt.

While the Fantastic Four pulled the trigger, it was Doom that forced them to do so. Otherwise they would've been forced to watch as he killed countless people in Ben's body, so the blame for this one lies squarely on the good Doctor's shoulders.


5. Red Skull Kills Captain America - Wolverine (Vol. 3) #72

Captain America Red Skull
Marvel Comics

As a symbol of the depravity and brutality of the Nazi Regime, it seemed unlikely for a whole host of reasons that the Red Skull would ever defeat Captain America.

But unlikely isn't the same as impossible, and thus the seventh part of the first Old Man Logan series saw the villain murder his longtime foe outside the wreckage of what used to be the White House, just for that extra blow to the First Avenger's pride.

After defending his country with every last drop of energy and resilience left, we see the hero laying bloody, beaten, and broken - a prime target for his archenemy to finish off.

This leads to a scene where we see the frankly emotionally scarring image of Red Skull wearing Captain America's costume, creating seemingly just to create a permanent state of horror every time you recall the series.


4. Doctor Octopus Kills Spider-Man - Amazing Spider-Man #700

Doc Ock Spider-Man
Marvel Comics

In one of the most brutal murders of recent history, the Amazing Spider-Man #700 culminated in one of Doc Ock's harshest plots, which involved swapping bodies with Spider-Man himself. While this initially doesn't sound too bad, the Doc's body was on the cusp of death when this plan unfolds, leaving Peter trapped in the old man's fast failing body, unable to do anything as his body shuts down.

Only, Peter refuses to give up - dragging his new frail form halfway across New York to fight Doc Ock, only to instead die in his arms, having given Otto all of his memories of being Spider-Man. While it's exactly as heartbreaking as you'd expect, it also has a surprisingly profound impact on the body snatcher, as Otto goes on to be a far more heroic figure than you'd ever expect in the Superior Spider-Man series.

However, it would be revealed that traces of Parker's psyche still existed within his body, and when Otto was faced with a battle against the Green Goblin that he knew he couldn't win, he allowed the part of Peter that remained to take back his own body, with Doc Ock instead ceasing to exist.


3. Doomsday Kills Superman - The Death Of Superman

Death Of Superman
DC Comics

The funny thing about Superman is that even in a comic explicitly called 'The Death of Superman', a small part of you still genuinely thinks that the hero has to come out unscathed. But the Man of Steel is not only defeated, but killed by Doomsday in the series, marking what is perhaps the most iconic superhero death to date in the world of comics.

Which is made doubly impressive by the fact that Doomsday manages to kill the hero in literally his first-ever appearance in comics, with everything that came after it feeling almost like a let down for just how intense his initial moments on the page managed to be.

Death of Superman is semi-famous for having an insanely long fight scene between the two - which easily lasts around a hundred pages - but manages to somehow be action-packed and engaging the entire time.

Not every famous comic is entirely deserving of its popularity, but The Death of Superman is deserving of its fame and more for its punchy yet emotional storyline, and for the impact it had on the industry for years to come.


2. Bullseye Kills Daredevil - Daredevil: End Of Days

Bullseye Daredevil
Marvel Comics

In perhaps the most underrated murder of a hero in comic history, Bullseye's gory, drawn-out destruction of the Man Without Fear in End of Days goes a significant way towards making the series one of the best Daredevil comics around.

With so many superhero deaths feeling abrupt, the visceral two-hour brawl the pair engage in feels all the more dramatic, exemplified by its climax - where Bullseye shoves one of Daredevil's batons straight through his head, in a moment that is sure to have led to some genuine gasps from first-time readers.

This death is doubly underrated for how effectively it sets up the plot. Instead of just being a dramatic moment at the end of a series, End of Days uses this moment to set up a mystery that we watch both Ben Ulrich and Bullseye himself try to solve, as Daredevil's final word - 'Mapone' - leads each on a trail through Hell's Kitchen to try and uncover the truth.

A death that is both absolutely shocking and sets up a fantastic plot? You can't get much better.


1. Joker Kills Batman - Emperor Joker/Endgame

Emperor Joker Batman
DC Comics

While there have been many stories where Joker has been under the impression he's killed Batman, these stories almost always involve the Dark Knight turning out to have survived. This type of twist is actually so consistent that there have only been two 'proper' cases of the Joker killing his eternal rival; the end of the frankly bizarre Emperor Joker comic, and Batman: Endgame.

Both contain suitably tragic deaths for Gotham's protector - with Emperor Joker having Batman killed every day for the clown's amusement, and Endgame featuring Batman and the Joker dying side by side after one of their bloodiest fights yet.

Hilariously, even these two deaths don't last - they're just the two that buck the trend of Batman having faked his death, by instead having him die and be brought back to life.

This makes perfect sense in Emperor Joker, where the whole thing is so surreal that a reincarnation is arguably the least weird part of the whole thing. For Endgame, however, many fans were frustrated when it was revealed that Bruce had been brought back from the dead by Dionesium, and was very much alive - with only his memories of being Batman having passed away.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: Can You Name These Obscure Batman Villains?

Catman Batman
DC Comics

1. Who’s This Obscure Batman Villain?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.