10 Comic Happy Endings That Were Secretly Terrible
Spoiling all your cherished comic endings.
Happy endings are a rare delight in comics, serving as a sort of treat for wading through the sea of dark or ambiguous endings generally found in the industry. Arguably, they're so unusual that even endings with dark undertones can appear happy, solely because they aren't as depressing as so many others.
And so even legitimately happy endings often aren't as positive as it would initially appear, because they tend to come with negative implications that go entirely overlooked in lieu of a sense of superhero-based closure.
While they vary heavily in how subtly they're implied, more often than not writers will sneak one or two concerning suggestions into their endings, possibly just to prove that in the comic industry, you can't have nice things. Better yet, sometimes a series will end in a way that's good for most people, but absolutely terrible for one character - and it's totally blown over, with the fate of this poor unfortunate seemingly entirely forgotten about.
And so, when they're not accidentally letting murderers go free, accidentally ending the world, or accidentally making everyone in Las Vegas be homeless, these endings are pretty happy - so long as you can ignore all that other stuff.
10. Superman: Red Son
Superman: Red Son's ending is one that is sure to have delighted many fans.
Not only did we get to see how fast technological advancement would be in a world where Lex Luthor became a legitimate leader, but we also got the delightful plot twist reveal that, in this universe, Superman comes from the future, and is sent to the past just before the Earth explodes.
It's such an exciting ending that it totally distracts from how sad it is, as the implication is that Earth is permanently destroyed, and that Superman cannot fix it as he is merely part of a time loop he is unaware exists.
This means that the ending of Red Son is less exciting and happy for seeing how Superman came to Earth, and rather a tragic superhero sequel to Groundhog Day - which admittedly still sounds pretty cool.
9. Kick-Ass 3
Kick-Ass 3 had somehow the most perfect ending, and the most inadvertently heart-breaking one at the same time. This is because it closes with Mindy McCready escaping both family and police pursuit, in order to travel the globe and kill crooks and criminals across the world - presumably for the rest of her life.
While this is all suitably delightful, it totally ignores the biggest tragedy of the entire series, which is the way in which Mindy is totally unable to live a normal life.
It's badass seeing her beat endless bad guys down, but this doesn't take away from the fact that she's a child with literally zero people taking care of her, facing down all of the world's grossest baddies.
Sure, she's a hyper capable kid - but that doesn't mean she should have to live a life of solitude and suffering, just because she's good at murder.
8. Secret Empire
After restoring Steve Rogers to all of his non-villainous glory, the end of Secret Empire is largely a happy one - or at least it seems that way, because all the heroes who had died tragically in the issues running up until it are now brought back, safe and sound.
While everyone should be grateful that the creepy Hydra version of Captain America was finally stopped, this isn't to suggest that this ending is as happy as it would initially appear.
It's seemingly waved over that, although the Cosmic Cube changed many things back to normal, it didn't change the desolation that had taken place over the course of the comic - meaning that while the heroes are fine, a good portion of civilisation is essentially in tatters.
The gravity of this is best seen in a panel on the second to last page of the comic, which shows that Las Vegas appears to have been destroyed - so even in a best-case scenario, the entire 600,000 odd people who lived and worked there have now had their entire lives ruined.
7. The Boys
Reading through The Boys' ending and seeing Hughie get his well-deserved happy moment is equal parts delightful and tragic, as it's clear that - although the ending is happy for him - it's still taking place in what is set to be a jolly old dystopia.
Because, as the series rightly suggests, killing off the Seven and the various superhero groups around them isn't the same as fixing the entire broken system that created the Seven in the first place.
While we end on the note of Voight failing to create another successful superhero brand, this isn't to say that they never will, as it's quite clear that the company's intentions are to continually throw ideas at the wall until one of them sticks.
It's a huge relief that our protagonist gets a happy ending, but knowing that the problems that The Boys fought so hard to try and fix are going to come back exactly as strong - and without our team of vigilantes to stop them - is a sobering thought for an otherwise cheerful ending.
6. Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
The ending of Batman: The Dark Knight Returns is pretty much the perfect way to end the comic, containing the ultimate surprise: that Batman is significantly less dead than it appeared, and is training the next generation to take over after he is gone.
But, when you look at it from the perspective of Batman, it's really quite sad.
Although Bruce Wayne was never going to quit being a superhero entirely, futures where he does still enjoy the comforts of his non-Dark Knight life seem like way happier endings for him, as living in a dank dark cave for the rest of your life doesn't sound like a comfortable retirement.
It's clear that Bruce actively wants this hermit lifestyle, but it's been shown time and time again that the Caped Crusader can be a bit of a masochist when it comes to his own wellbeing. And after so many years of giving his heart, blood, and soul for Gotham, it seems only fair that he gets at least some creature comforts in his final years - which he could still have had while commanding his sidekick army.
5. Avengers & X-Men: AXIS
Avengers & X-Men: AXIS is a particularly dramatic story, featuring an event that results in the Marvel cast having their morality flipped, so villains turn to heroes and vice versa. All this drama in mind, you'd think that the comic's ending - where this change was swapped back - would account for a pretty happy ending.
You'd almost be right.
But there is one key problem, in that not every character was reverted back. Iron Man, Havok and Sabretooth all avoided the reinversion spell, which would result in an evil Avenger, Havok joining the X-Men as a hidden time bomb, and Sabretooth optionally placing himself in jail despite now having genuinely heroic intentions.
Even those who were reinverted weren't all cheery stories, as Red Skull's would see the Nazi take control of his own body again, instead of Professor X, who was once more forced to be a passenger in the mind of a madman Everyone else was fine though, so... hooray?
4. Batman: Master Of The Future
As the lone sequel of Gotham By Gaslight, it's hard to say that Batman: Master of the Future is anything but a lovable and cheerful romp through Victorian England, complete with badass fencing scenes and a giant steam-powered robot. However, despite its charming ending - where love interest Julie Madison tells Bruce she knows is secret identity, and loves him all the more for it - it's not entirely the superhero equivalent of Pride and Prejudice.
Because, importantly, this version of Batman is pretty much fated to die horribly. The time of shark repellant and elaborate but useful gadgets are far, far in the future, and although the steampunk-esque gizmos he uses are inventive, they won't allow him the same upper hand against villains who are clearly using the cutting edge of technology.
Perhaps more importantly, when you remember that some pretty awful diseases were still around in Victorian England and the slums Batman patrols, there's a pretty good chance the Dark Knight dies tragically of scarlet fever or whooping cough not long after his 'happy ending'.
3. The Superior Spider-Man
When you read a comic that features Otto Octavius taking over Peter Parker's body to be Spider-Man, you don't expect to actually feel proud of the villain by the end.
However, there was still the issue of Otto's one irredeemable action - that of taking over Parker's body, and leaving him a backseat driver in his own consciousness. In a move perfect for the end of Otto's character arc, the end of the 'Goblin Nation' storyline sees him put aside his considerable ego, and give Peter back his body in order for him to save Otto's love interest Anne Marie.
While you'd presume this isn't a happy ending because Otto dies, this isn't the case - as it's clear that he went willingly and happily to allow Peter his body back - and because, let's be honest, nobody except Uncle Ben dies for good in the Spider-Man series.
What is sad, however, is the fact that this suggests, had the bowl-cut bad boy had the right motivation or support, he could have become someone genuinely good - and now that opportunity is unlikely to ever happen again.
2. The Walking Dead
After countless trials and ordeals, endless life-threatening scenarios, and moments where it genuinely appeared humanity would be wiped out by zombie hordes, seeing Carl Grimes get his happy ending at the closing of the series is nothing short of heartwarming.
What is significantly less heartwarming, though, is the implication throughout the end of the series that the world may be overcome by the zombie threat once more. While Rick and his various allies managed to wrench back civilisation from the zombie hordes and restrain them, the end of the series is set far enough in the future that people are beginning to underestimate the danger they pose - and it'd only take one rogue zombie for things to go terribly wrong.
Although we get what we want from the ending of the Walking Dead - namely, a happy ending for Carl, who we've watched almost continually suffer over the 193 issues of the comic - it's made clear that this peaceful life could revert back to being overrun by zombies pretty dang fast.
1. Batman: Heart Of Hush
Heart of Hush brings us what looks like a classic good ending; with the bad guy beat, the heroes happy, and karma served out like an all-you-can-eat buffet. Seeing Catwoman and Batman escape defeat Hush and declare their love for each other seems like one of those feel-good endings that really just can't be beat.
Only it definitely can, as there's a fair amount that's worrying about the ending of Heart of Hush. Firstly, the comic is a tie-in with the Batman R.I.P event, with the two happening at the same time - meaning this saccharine ending totally ignores the fact that the Black Glove society are still gunning for the Dark Knight.
Similarly, while it's a karmic justice to see all of Hush's money be stolen by Selina, it's hardly going to prevent him from still doing crime. The fact that there's still a highly unstable surgeon roaming around Gotham's streets means it’s quite difficult to consider this a happy ending, as while the heroes escaped unscathed, you know somebody’s getting their face sliced off by Hush the very same night.
While it's a karmic justice to see all of Hush's money be stolen through various methods by Selina, this isn't going to prevent him from doing crime. The fact that there's still a highly unstable talented surgeon roaming around Gotham's streets means it’s quite difficult to call it a definitely happy ending, as while the heroes escaped unscathed you know somebody’s getting their face sliced off by Hush the very same night.
Similarly, Catwoman and Batman’s heartfelt declarations of love are kind of ruined by the fact that their relationship would be retconned soon after, and only be properly reinstated this year - a whopping century after Heart of Hush.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Titans?