10 Comic Heroes You Weren't Supposed To Like
Alan Moore really didn't see the Rorschach fanboys coming.
Throughout the history of comic books, there has always been one recurring theme regardless of the era, or even the property. Whether Marvel or DC, Dark Horse or any other, comic books have generally always operated around the idea of good vs evil. A hero against a villain.
The likes of Captain America, the epitome of all that is good and right, and Superman, the embodiment of hope, perfectly capture this idea of the virtuous at one side of the spectrum, against the likes of Red Skull and Lex Luthor at the opposite side - however not all heroes are that cut and dry. There are certainly exceptions to this rule.
There are many heroes throughout the pages of comics that, although classed as heroes, were never designed to be liked. Some started life as villains, while others' loyalties were far more ambiguous, and some were certainly super heroes, just with wildly unlikeable personalities.
In some cases, in spite of such characters being created as far from virtuous, fans have ignored such intentions and found a way to love them anyway. This highlights how wonderfully interpretive comic books can be, as fans have even found ways to disagree with creators over the very characters they created.
10. Wolverine
Today, Wolverine can class himself among some of the most popular heroes Marvel have to offer, and is certainly one of the greatest X-Men of all time. Even before Hugh Jackman's historic portrayal of the character, Logan became incredibly popular thanks to his unique powers, and unblinking, badass attitude.
However, this certainly wasn't the case when he was introduced in 1974, neither was it the writers' intention. The character started life as a one off adversary of the Incredible Hulk, with the mutant brought in to track the Avenger for the Canadian government.
At the time, there was no intention of taking Wolverine's story any further beyond a mysterious superhuman working against the established character of the Hulk. Even after the writers decided that there was a story to be told, and brought the character into the X-Men, he did little to help his own cause, bringing tension to the team with his feelings for Jean Grey.
The character was almost dropped completely, but was ultimately saved when John Byrne took over the property in the late 1970's. Just several years later, thanks to the character's surge in popularity, Wolverine was given his own solo series, and went from strength to strength from there.
9. Black Widow
Since her introduction to the world of Marvel comics way back in 1964, it's possible that Natasha Romanoff has never been more popular than right now. With her solo movie set to be Marvel Studios' very next release, excitement and intrigue surrounding the character is greater than ever before, which is truly saying something.
Initially introduced as a Russian spy for the KGB, before soon defecting to the US and the Avengers, readers couldn't be certain about her loyalties or her true intentions. Naturally, this wasn't helped by her moniker and the details of her past.
After all, how likeable can a trained assassin be? She has a very chequered past, and Loki's sentiment from Avengers Assemble is as relevant for the comics as it was for the movies: can you wipe out that much red from your ledger?
Once Natasha solidified her role as an Avenger, surviving short lived collaborations with Spider-Man, Daredevil, and her own solo series that lasted just eight issues, she began to grow in popularity. Even with her less than virtuous past, and history of squaring up to some of Earth's Mightiest Heroes.
8. The Seven
With The Boys, Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson created something truly unique, as a comic book with very few genuinely likeable characters. The protagonists of the story, the titular team, are led by a violent, abusive murderer, trying to bring down a group of even worse people, the superheroes themselves.
The likes of Teenage Kix, Payback, and Maverikz are among the handful of superhero groups, and all are as bad as each other. Though the heroes are portrayed to the public as their saviours, the things they do behind the scenes would shock and disgust them.
However, despite these teams being made up of racists, homophobes, and sexists, by far the worst 'heroes' of all make up the Seven. The likes of Homelander, The Deep, and Jack from Jupiter are all of the above and more, committing genocide, abuse, and any other bad thing you can name, evidenced when they sexually assault Starlight as soon as she joined the team.
Garth Ennis has never been shy about his feelings surrounding superheroes. He hates them. The Boys was his way of fighting back against the genre, by taking the colourful, bright-eyed heroes that everybody loves, and turning them into the disgusting, hated villains of his story. This group are the only entry on this list that didn't eventually find popularity with the fans. Ennis wanted Homelander to be hated, and so he was - even if you love to hate him.
7. The Winter Soldier
When James Buchanan Barnes was initially introduced to Marvel comics way back in 1941, there was nothing to not like about him. The fifteen year old orphan rose through the army ranks to become Captain America's partner, and even gave his life for the cause, supposedly dying at the hands of Baron Zemo in 1945.
Many, many years later, in 2005, Bucky made his shocking return to the pages of the comics, only this time as the Winter Soldier, a perfect assassin who had been killing people for the Russians over the last several decades.
The new nemesis of Captain America was portrayed as a murderous villain, free of all memories, thoughts, and feelings that made Bucky who he was. The Winter Soldier was no longer Steve Rogers' friend, but fans simply couldn't separate the two, and fell in love with the assassin.
The character became so popular that he even went on to take the Captain America mantle from Steve Rogers, proving that even murderous, brainwashed assassins can be loved in the world of comic books. Natasha Romanoff isn't the only former killer that can get a pass from Marvel fans.
6. Lobo
Throughout comic history, there have been many characters that have found themselves fighting the good fight, or helping those around them, but only for their own personal gain or interests. If they weren't about to benefit personally from such good deeds, they wouldn't even think about getting involved.
Lobo, one of DC's most popular characters throughout the early 1990's, has carved himself a legacy as such an anti-hero, however this description is particularly flattering for the character. With the things he has done, Lobo shouldn't be described as anything other than a murderous villain.
The Last Czarnian, a title he earned by wiping out the rest of his otherwise peaceful race, is a cold hearted bounty hunter, happy to kill for whoever offers him the most money. The name Lobo actually translates to 'he who devours your entrails and thoroughly enjoys it'. How is it possible that a character like this could possibly find himself with such a loyal fanbase?
Lobo certainly didn't connect with fans straight away, as his debut in the 1980's was followed by a decade of obscurity. It wasn't until the 90's that fans fell in love with this particular genocidal maniac.
5. Loki
In 1949, when the villainous Loki made his comic book debut, there wasn't a heroic bone in his body. The overshadowed brother of Thor, trickster, and God of Mischief was a tyrannical supervillain, terrorising the people of both Asgard and Earth, among other worlds.
Yet somehow, despite there being absolutely no intention for the character to be liked, Loki has become incredibly popular with fans over the years. He has gone from nemesis of the Avengers to having several solo runs to his name, compelling audiences both on the page and on the screen.
While Tom Hiddleston's captivating performances throughout the Marvel Cinematic Universe may have gone a long way towards this popularity, it isn't the sole reason behind this change, since his comics debut as a villain Loki has evolved into a far more complex character than a straight forward villain.
With more of a fluid moral compass, passing easily and often between good and bad, and several different versions of the character, Loki is one of the most unique and compelling characters in Marvel's locker. Whether as his male, female, or kid version, Loki is far more popular than ever could have been expected in 1949.
4. Booster Gold
Some characters on this list were supposed to be disliked because of either their past, their questionable methods, or the fact that they were initially introduced as straight up villains. Booster Gold however, was certainly a hero, and had no skeletons in his closet, he was just a bit of a d*ck.
Michael Jon Carter was a wonderfully gifted athlete from 25th century Gotham, who was disgraced after purposefully throwing football games so he and his father could bet against him and win big. He decided to find a way to travel to the 20th century, becoming a superhero in the process.
Even with something as noble as this, the character found a way to make it selfish. He only became a superhero so he could live comfortably, and even after achieving his goal, he milked it for all it was worth. The money, the fame, and the glory was truly why Carter became Booster Gold.
The hero's new found fame went to his head, and he continued to be a self-obsessed, shameless self-promoter and show off, even after joining the Justice League. Supposedly no one likes a show off, but this super hero eventually found a way into the hearts of fans despite his less than ideal personality.
3. Damian Wayne
Batman has always been one of DC comics' greatest creations, and has undeniably stood the test of time. He has stayed as popular as he has ever been since he first came to life in 1939, however he hasn't always had the best of luck with his sidekicks.
Damian Wayne has a complicated heritage to say the least, as the test tube child of Bruce Wayne and Talia al Ghul, and suffered something of a conflicting personality because of it. While he wanted to help Batman, there was possibly too much of his mother and grandfather in his blood.
When he was first introduced as Batman's son, much like Booster Gold, Damian's personality prevented him from being likeable. He was spoiled, arrogant, and violent, and immediately looked to take Tim Drake's place as Robin by his dad's side. He also broke Batman's no killing rule almost immediately.
Damian's personality wasn't the only reason fans couldn't take to the character when he was first introduced, he was actually sent to Batman by Talia al Ghul as little more than a distraction. Despite all this however, the fifth Robin somehow still managed to eventually carve himself a legacy as one of the most popular characters introduced by DC in recent memory.
2. Rorschach
In 2009, Alan Moore brought Watchmen to the world, in what almost instantly became a classic story of the genre. It was lauded by fans and critics alike, and was completely unique in its depiction of what a worst case scenario, real life superhero world would look like.
Though there was not one particular character that could be described as the 'main' character, with the likes of Nite Owl, The Comedian, and Doctor Manhattan, among others, Rorschach was possibly the most important character. The story was told through his perspective, but his impact on the story went even deeper.
Rorschach was intended to be the epitome of a superhero gone wrong, as a violent thug having no problem killing those he deemed guilty, and having absolutely no one to answer to. The character was intended to highlight the fact that having a 'superhero' in your neighbourhood would end in catastrophe.
However, to creator Alan Moore's chagrin, fans almost entirely missed the point of the character, and he became wildly popular from the very beginning. Though he was never supposed to be liked, his no nonsense attitude and complex development resonated with fans in such a way that Moore never saw coming.
1. Deadpool
The comic book industry has always been very incestuous, with many characters being born from inspiration taken from others. Flash and Quicksilver, Aquaman and Namor, Thanos and Darkseid, are all incredibly similar characters across both Marvel and DC, and may well have taken inspiration from one another.
One such character that was most certainly born out of this kind of inspiration was Deadpool. Created as something of Marvel's version of Deathstroke, Deadpool was never intended to be popular. The mask wearing mercenary was even named Wade Wilson to mimic DC's Slade Wilson, and was hired to kill Cable and the New Mutants.
This was far before Ryan Reynolds' affiliation with the character, and before his loveable, quippy personality shone through in later comics. Wade Wilson was intended to be little more than a rip off of a successful DC character, as the creators leaned into the initial similarities between the two.
Yet the fans couldn't get enough of the hired killer, and before too long Deadpool had his own solo series, and began to evolve into the wonderful personality we all know and love. There aren't many characters that could kill the entire Marvel universe, twice, and stay this popular.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Really Know Deadpool?