10 Comic Villains Who Were Right All Along
Their methods might be wrong, but these villains are actually right about something...
In big, dramatic villain monologues, it's uncommon to hear any genuinely sensible reasoning. Classic comic villains tend to use ridiculous arguments about how they want to take over the world, or just want to create chaos, in order to justify their delinquent deeds.
Even when superheroes are briefly the villain of a specific story, they quickly trade in their understandable rhetoric for barely decipherable posturing, seemingly picked from the same bad list of motivations their former opponents pulled from.
This is exactly why it's so interesting to find a villain whose motivations actually make sense. A surprising number of rogues have at least a basic argument that actually is right, and seeing them do the wrong things for the right reasons provides a much more thought-provoking character than merely someone who is evil 'just because'. It's also significantly more unnerving, because you find yourself relating to a person who is doing terrible, terrible things - which is exactly what you want when you're trying to create an engaging comic.
Varying from saving the planet to fighting corruption, it's hard to argue with these comic book villains (just so long as you can overlook the occasional homicide).
10. Ra's Al Ghul
It's often overlooked that, all fancy capes and evil plans aside, Ra's al Ghul is secretly all about saving the planet. Being eons old, the Head of the Demon has seen the catastrophic impact of humanity on the Earth, and believes the only way to prevent the planet getting destroyed by humans is to kill them.
Which is pretty evil, but also based on what is now real scientific fact. While this does lead to many attempts at destroying innocent people, Ra's isn't doing it for kicks, or even necessarily for his own benefit, as he is genuinely just carrying out the plans that he believes will ensure the Earth's survival - it's just that, unfortunately, these plans also... sorta... tend to also involve mass genocide.
Tragically, if Ra's where to only have gone fully into his love of science, he could have probably worked with various governments to try and find other methods to minimise humanity's ecological impact. As it is, he went down the assassin route, so he's pretty much locked into having to kill half the planet to save the world forever now.
9. Hela
With Hela's life story revolving around the fact that, due to a prophecy, Odin decided to exile her to Hel for eternity, it seems pretty fair of her to still be peeved about it.
Although trying to murder your lightning-wielding uncle and grandfather isn't the ideal way of sorting out family rivalries, the fact that Thor got told he would be King of the world from a young age, whereas Hela got stuffed into the underworld the minute she became an adult, seems like the kind of thing you would hold a grudge over.
Perhaps more importantly, it's shown time and time again that Hela doesn't hate Thor, but more wishes to both prove herself to Odin and to spite the man who ruined her life by taking Thor to the underworld. Despite this, she's repeatedly let him go, charmed by his sense of valour and honour - to the point that she has actually brought him back to life out of sympathy before.
She'd ensure an awkward family Thanksgiving, sure, but even Thor has had his share of fights with Odin, so it's hard to say Hela is evil for doing the same.
8. Poison Ivy
As much as Poison Ivy's human-hating, civilisation-destroying goals are definitely far fetched, it's undeniable that her whole 'humans are destroying the plants and planet' message is one that continues to be correct. With climate change steadily growing out of hand, and the Earth approaching the point of no return - as well as things like deforestation - it seems pretty fair that the woman who is half plant considers all this a gesture of war against nature.
And, although hardcore, if her actions make people take better care of the environment, it's hard to disagree with using intimidation tactics to make sure the world is saved. After all, if Pamela would drop the actual murder side of things, she'd essentially be a plant-protecting version of the Dark Knight - only one that is reminding people to not litter, instead of not stabbing people.
While it's not okay to kill people for not taking their green bins out, the threat of climate change would feel a lot more real if it came with the threat of getting punched in the face by Poison Ivy.
7. The Illuminati
A collection of Marvel's greatest superheroes, gathered in secret in order to join forces to help the world, The Illuminati have a pretty terrible track record as far as their comic history goes - especially Secret Wars, which saw the team arrange to destroy entire other universes without letting anyone else know. But then, what can you expect from a secret cult called The Illuminati, aside from bad ideas and worse actions?
Only, in a sentence that in any other context would be worrying, The Illuminati are actually right. Creating this crucial team in secret feels dishonest, but to have the X-Men, the Inhumans, and the Avengers openly working together would be a media nightmare, and would have only further complicated the matters the group had joined to try and fix.
Similarly, their attempt to destroy other universes in order to protect their own - while morally sketchy - is the exact same thing the majority of these other universes would have been attempting to do, meaning that this, too, is actually justifiable.
6. Magneto
Given he is occasionally responsible for some pretty awful deeds, it feels more than a little weird to say that Magneto is, on a lot of levels, right.
As much as Professor X's ideology of trying to help people understand and fix their prejudice towards mutants is more heroic, Magneto's argument that this will never fully happen does appear to hold weight, as it does seem despite the sacrifices and heroic actions of the X-Men, some people will always hold negative ideas about mutantkind.
When Magneto's plans are non-violent, then, they're quite difficult to not see as understandable, as things like moving to an island away from the people who want to kill you seems entirely reasonable.
In fact, Professor Xavier assists in doing this exact thing in the House of X series with the island of Krakoa, and their joined efforts genuinely appear to make life for mutants significantly better - all because Xavier was willing to accept that, on some levels, Magneto actually has some better ideas than him.
5. Villainy Inc.
In a rare case of genuinely relatable reasoning, the Golden Age team of Villainy Inc. was made up of a group of otherwise common crooks, who were kidnapped, taken to a strange island, and fitted with 'Venus Girdles' which leave them with absolutely no free will - and somehow weren't reformed by this process, much to the surprise of the Amazons who detained them.
As such, it's perhaps completely unsurprising that, after being freed from this Clockwork Orange-esque scenario, the villains become much, much worse. After all, they now know that the 'good guys' essentially use brain control on anyone they don't agree with - which makes the supposedly heroic Amazons seems distinctively evil.
It's pretty hard to blame someone for holding a grudge against the person who held them mind-controlled and against their will, meaning that all of the team's attempts to fight the Amazons after this are arguably justifiable, as Wonder Woman's warriors are basically committing war crimes on the sly.
4. Amanda Waller
Amanda Waller is perhaps the most unfairly hated character in DC, aside from perhaps Jason Todd, just before he was killed off by DC's fans.
Waller treats people like garbage, that much is undeniable. Even with the Suicide Squad - who would arguably work far better with her if she showed even an iota of care for them - she goes too far, treating the villains more like cattle than semi-kidnapped workers.
But it's not as though she does this for no reason. Waller is all about making the world a better place, and she'll do anything to get there; even enslave a bunch of DC villains and be ruthless to them so she never develops sympathy. It's not as though she enjoys this - she just knows what gets the best results the quickest, and it's certainly not letting a bunch of costumed criminals galavant around when they could be stopping dictators and taking on the dirty work regular superheroes wouldn't be caught dead with.
Amanda Waller is seldom nice, but there's no denying her heart's in the right place.
3. Virginia
After Vision's wife had killed Victor Mancha, The Grim Reaper, and Leon Kinsky, it seems reasonably fair to say she had started to inadvertently become one of the biggest villains of Tom King's 2018 Vision series.
But Virginia is also perhaps one of the best examples of how well-meaning terrible acts can be, as everything she does is in order to protect her family, who are repeatedly threatened by those who fear their robotic capabilities.
Her murder of the Reaper is accidental; her murder of Kinsky is only after he says he will kill all of her family; and her murder of Victor Mancha, most tragically, is because she knows Vision will kill him otherwise, and that if he does so the whole family will be seen as dangerous and shut down - whereas Virginia can claim to be a rogue agent.
This leads up to the single most heartbreaking scene in the entire series, where the android mother confesses all of her crimes in detail in order to keep her family safe. It's not quite The Taken, but in terms of seeing people take care of their families, it tugs at exactly the same heartstrings.
2. Ozymandias
When it's first revealed in Watchmen that Ozymandias' crazy plan to unite the world is to launch a fake alien invasion that will wipe out half of New York, it seems like the single most hog wild plan possible. The minute Adrian tells his fellow Watchmen, they all immediately tear it apart, calling him out for the destruction that his crimes will cause, with Veidt's arguments that this will still cause fewer deaths than the impending and ongoing wars falling on deaf ears.
But, as callous as this argument is, it's also completely correct. Not only does the 'alien attack' stop the Cold War, but it also ends all ongoing hostilities between nations, as the world comes together to prepare for an outside threat.
Similarly, his logic about why the other heroes shouldn't expose this conspiracy - namely, that this would undo any of the positive impact that these deaths resulted in - is also right, as all the Watchmen bar Rorschach willingly admit.
What Ozymandias does isn't okay in any way, but his logic - sick and twisted as it is - is also impeccable.
1. Colonel Jonas
As the villain of the Damage series, you'd expect that Colonel Jonas would be the archetypal 'evil government operative' figure. After all, Ethan is clearly unwillingly made into the monstrous Damage by her in the start, so she must be the bad guy...right?
Only, we find out Ethan agreed to become Damage, knowing that this would mean he'd have to be watched almost permanently to make sure he didn't run rampant. And so, Colonel Jonas is considered a villain for... not wanting a destructive grey Hulk rampaging around without some kind of guidance? As much as this is made out to be somehow evil of her, it seems pretty fair to want to know where the man who could total a city is at any given time.
Worse yet, issue #7 of Damage reveals that Jonas has been working with the Damage Project after an explosion put her husband in a coma and lost her an eye, which also means that she's entirely motivated by making sure that similar fates don't happen to other people - all of which is pretty hard to not consider an understandable motive.
Watch Next
MCU Quiz: Can You Name ALL The Marvel Villains Featured So Far?