10 Comics Too Big To Fail (That Did Anyway)
Lesson one when rebooting the Marvel Universe? Maybe don't.
It's easy to look at the world of comic books and find a series or two most people considered too big to fail. After all, there are thousands of comics published every year, and not all of them can go on to make huge amounts of money for the publishers. This includes DC and Marvel Comics.
Even the big guys stop publishing comics intended to run for a thousand issues, and it's often done shortly after they first hit the shelves. Fans drive the marketplace, and if the readers aren't buying books, there's no reason for a publisher to continue publishing them.
Modern comic books have been around, in one form or another, for nearly a century now, and in all that time, there are far more comics that went out of publication than there are that remain in print. Whether it's a series that has broken off from something like The X-Men or another popular title doesn't really matter — if it doesn't sell, or the fans aren't interested, that's it!
Because of this, publishers often approach a new series or story arc in a speculative way. Something they think can't fail because it's associated with popular characters, often does wind up failing. That leaves a lot of titles that were thought to be too big to fail, but that ended up failing anyway...
10. The Unbelievable Gwenpool
The Unbelievable Gwenpool first appeared on a variant cover of Deadpool's Secret Secret Wars, and despite not appearing anywhere in the comic, the character was a huge hit among fans. It wasn't long before she showed up again in a holiday special one-shot as a secondary character to Howard the Duck.
From there, she got her own series, The Unbelievable Gwenpool debuted in June 2016, and the fans loved her. The storylines were original, the character was funny, and the fourth-wall breaks were perfectly written. Sadly, they also foresaw the series' cancellation, as it only ran for a total of 26 issues, ending in April 2018.
The series had a dedicated fan base, so it was a surprising cancellation. While it may have been something the readers weren't expecting, Marvel didn't hesitate to order the series conclusion after less than two years of publication, and the reason is actually pretty simple.
The books may have had a lot of fans, but not enough to justify the expense of publishing the comics. Sales numbers were low, and Marvel axed the book alongside a bunch of others in early 2018. Seeing as the character remains popular among fans, it's likely she will reappear one day, but there's no telling when she'll land a series of her own again.
9. Maximum Carnage
The 1990s were all about crossovers for Spider-Man, and despite some highs and lows, most of them weren't awful. Fans enjoyed reading stories from different perspectives, that incorporated characters and elements from all over Spidey's world, which is why Maximum Carnage was such a highly anticipated project in 1993.
The series brought Carnage to the center of everything going on in Spider-Man's life at the time, and it capitalized on a villain many fans loved to hate. Previous Venom stories sold remarkably well, so it stood to reason that a crossover event starring Venom's offspring would perform as well in terms of sales.
There were a few problems with Maximum Carnage that didn't help it when the sales figures began to tabulate. For one thing, the 14 books in the series were written and illustrated by different people. This didn't help with the continuity of the story, seeing as everyone has a different approach to the characters, and the writers struggled to make it work.
That's not to say the creators weren't incredibly talented, but transitions in artwork and tone make the story, which is intended to flow from one book to the next, seem somewhat disjointed. The books didn't manage to meet expectations, and like the Clone Saga that would shortly follow, it was mostly a dud. It did inspire a video game, action figures, and an exhibition at Universal's Islands of Adventure in Florida though.
8. New Gods
Jack Kirby is a legend when it comes to comic books. He was one of the principal creators behind Marvel's most notable characters, having co-created Captain America, the Fantastic Four, the X-Men, and The Incredible Hulk. When Kirby created a character, he made up an entire world for them to play in.
Kirby went to work for DC after he felt he had been mistreated at Marvel, and with his arrival came the creation of Jack Kirby's Fourth World. His new universe-sized creation spawned several comic titles, with the New Gods standing as the best overall series.
Unfortunately, the books didn't sell well for DC. Kirby's high-minded series-spanning anthology didn't entice enough readers to throw down some cash and buy the books. Ultimately, New Gods only ran for 11 issues, which is shocking to think of these days.
New Gods may not have sold well when it was first published, but the concepts and characters from Jack Kirby's Fourth World have been used as a basis for much of the DC Cosmic Universe. Darkseid is easily one of Superman's greatest foes, and the various elements of Kirby's universe can be seen in most DC Comics still published today... not to mention, DC is releasing a New Gods film based on Kirby's work in the near future.
7. Before Watchmen
Years ago, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons created something special with their 12-issue maxi-series, Watchmen. The Hugo Award-winning books have long been considered masterpieces of the medium, and years went by before anyone had the courage to adapt them in any way. In 2009, Zack Snyder's film adaptation was released, and it opened up a floodgate.
The movie wasn't a blockbuster success, but it did well enough to raise a few eyebrows at DC. In 2012, the publisher released a prequel series based on Moore's Watchmen universe, but without any collaboration from Moore or Gibbons whatsoever. That's not surprising, as Moore is well-known for his dislike of how his work is perceived and adapted, and in particular with how DC treated him following Watchmen's publication, but the publisher pushed forward anyway.
Unfortunately, things didn't go according to plan. Despite the massive fan-following The Watchmen had, DC pulled the plug prematurely on the series due to low sales figures. A planned Epilogue one-shot was scrapped, and the entire run concluded with 37 issues.
6. DC's All-Star Series
Looking back at the All-Star series from DC, it's hard to believe they ever came to an end. All-Star Superman is now considered to be one of the Man of Steel's greatest storylines, and even though it had the advantage of being written by Grant Morrison with pencils by Frank Quietly, the other All-Star books weren't far behind.
The idea behind the All-Stars imprint was to give some of the industry's greatest creators a chance to do whatever they wanted with DC's greatest characters. Morrison's work with Superman obviously did remarkably well in this context, and even though it sold well, All-Star Batman & Robin, the Boy Wonder didn't meet the high standard even with Frank Miller and Jim Lee on as creators.
The books were gritty and well-written but much different than Superman's books. It sold well throughout its run but came to an end in 2008. All-Star Batgirl was announced with Geoff Johns set to write, but the book never materialized. The same happened to All-Star Wonder Woman. That was set to be Adam Hughes' story all about the world's most famous Amazon, but it never came to fruition.
The last book to never see the light of day was All-Star Green Lantern, which would have focused on John Stewart, with Brian Azzarello on to write. Unfortunately, the success of All-Star Superman just couldn't be duplicated, and the whole concept of All-Star... anything, just fizzled out as DC canceled the imprint.
5. Clone Saga
For fans of Spider-Man, looking back at the Clone Saga brings up feelings of resentment and disgust. The Clone Saga is one of the most reviled crossovers in Spider-Man history, but hindsight is 20:20, and before it debuted, the storyline was expected to bust sales records and reinvigorate interest in everyone's Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man.
Between 1994 and 1996, the Clone Sage dominated every Spider-Man book in print, and while it has since become the most controversial and divisive storyline among fans, it started out well. At first, it appeared as if it would deliver on everything Marvel was promising.
The Clone Saga was originally going to last for a single year, and during that first 12 months, Spidey's books sold like crazy. The fans enjoyed the story, which was arguably written well, as it tied back to the original Clone Saga from the 1970s, which introduced the first clone of Spider-Man.
The problem arose when Marvel looked at its sales figures. A crossover that was intended to last a year was pushed to an additional 14 months, and the writers struggled to make sense of the whole thing. What came out of the House of Ideas was perverted and extended beyond its original intent, and it flopped as a result.
4. Loki
Loki was presented as a trickster and mostly annoying throughout his early career in Marvel Comics, but the character got something of a facelift thanks to the MCU. Tom Hiddleston managed to play Loki so well, his charm and ability to woo the audience made his comic book counterpart change in a number of ways.
This newfound love for the character launched several changes, including turning Loki into a kid and giving him an eponymous series in 2019. Marvel Comics launched Loki after an April 2019 announcement, but after only publishing five issues, the publisher canceled the book.
The news of the cancellation came in the letter column, titled "Mischief Mail," when one reader asked if the series would feature the gender-fluid character, the Goddess of the Moon. In his reply, the series artist, Daniel Kibblesmith, wrote the following:
"Unfortunately, as we're now closing up shop on this nook of the House of Ideas, it seems that a proper return of the Goddess is not in the cards for us — for now. The Moon never wanes for long."
With those words, Loki's solo series was finished, and a seemingly untouchable title was canceled. Marvel didn't provide a reason, and while the five-issue run managed to complete a story arc, it was intended to be an ongoing series.
3. The Incredible Hulk
The Incredible Hulk is easily one of Marvel's greatest superheroes, and his comics have sold well for decades. Why then did Marvel cancel the series so soon after it was published? If you didn't know, that's what happened with the first Incredible Hulk series, and fans are still scratching their heads asking why.
It's hard to imagine a time when the Hulk wasn't one of the best-known characters in the Marvel Universe, but when his series debuted, he was brand spanking new. Still, the books gained an audience, and it was looking like the Hulk might be around for a while.
As it happens, the first Incredible Hulk series only ran for a whopping six issues. That's all it got before Marvel had enough and pulled the plug. The Hulk didn't exactly go away, he just didn't have his own series any longer, and it would be some time before he would.
He showed up in the Avengers, and two years after The Incredible Hulk's cancellation, he started appearing in Tales to Astonish. As his popularity picked up, Marvel decided it was time to give the green guy another chance with a new series launch in 1968, though it started with issue #102, which picked up following the events in Tales to Astonish.
2. Heroes Reborn
Back in the early 1990s, a group of writers and artists left Marvel Comics en masse due to their disagreement with the publisher's views on creator's rights. That group of eight included Todd McFarlane, Erik Larsen, Marc Silvestri, Jim Valentino, Whilce Portacio, Chris Claremont, Jim Lee, and Rob Liefeld.
They were titans in the industry, and they left the House of Ideas to found Image Comics. Their departure dealt a heavy blow to Marvel, and the industry has since adapted to acknowledge the publishing power of Image, which now rivals that of DC and Marvel, though with less quantity in the marketplace.
To try and recover some of the lost quality the departure cost Marvel, the company offered Jim Lee and Rob Liefeld the opportunity to jump back into the Marvel Universe via Heroes Reborn, a one-year multi-title story arc, which was outsourced to Marvel's former employees' studios at Image Comics. With their return came the cancellation of Marvel's longest-running series', followed by an immediate relaunch.
There was a lot of buzz and fanfare supporting Heroes Reborn, and it seemed like a surefire hit. Problems arose creatively, and the series ultimately failed when Jim Lee refused to illustrate another issue when Marvel offered the option to continue Heroes Reborn indefinitely. The resulting fanfare died down, and despite an initial upsurge in sales figures, Heroes Reborn died out, and the sequel series, Heroes Return, lacked the involvement of Liefeld and Lee.
1. The Fantastic Four
The Fantastic Four have been around since Marvel set foot in the Silver Age of Comics, and because the books were incredibly popular, they never went out of print. For 50+ years, fans could read stories featuring the Human Torch, Mister Fantastic, the Invisible Woman, and the Thing without any worry that Marvel would stop publishing them.
Then, in 2014, Marvel did the unthinkable and stopped publishing the Fantastic Four. On the surface, it didn't make any sense, as the issues were selling well enough, and the fans weren't overtly complaining about anything, which begs the question, why did Marvel kill off one of its most beloved series?
The reason Marvel axed the series was all about the characters' film rights, and a general disagreement with FOX. Back when Marvel Comics was facing bankruptcy, it sold the film rights to some of its most popular characters, and FOX nabbed the FF. When a new movie adaptation of the Fantastic Four was set to debut in 2015, Marvel called it quits on the comic series. The company didn't want to promote the film in any way, and to ensure it didn't, the FF had to go.
Technically, the FF didn't fail in the traditional sense, but it did end, and that was a big deal at the time. The FF was the foundation of the Marvel Universe, having been created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby so long ago. It wasn't thought possible that Marvel would kill the series, but they did... for three whole years.
Watch Next
The Ultimate Marvel Comics Quiz