10 Comics Where You Couldn’t Help But Root For The Villain
You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy... who you also kinda root for.
When you read a comic book, who do you find yourself rooting for? It's almost always the guy in the cape, right? With the cool gadgets and one-liners? Batman; Superman; Spider-Man; The Avengers; after all, they have their names on a bunch of books for a reason, surely?
Well, it's not always that simple. As Dexter, Breaking Bad, the Punisher and countless others have proven across decades of TV, cinema and comic books, audiences love to hate a good bad guy.
Whether it's a deliberate choice on the writer's part, complete accident, or one just happens to go for the underdog, some audiences can't help but find themselves relating to the villain of the piece. We now live in a society where Joaquin Phoenix won an Oscar for his performance as the Joker - people just can't get enough of a good baddie.
Here we run through ten comic books where we found ourselves rooting for the villain of the piece - either through design, accident or pure sympathy. Not that we condone any of the acts of villainy portrayed herein... but sometimes, well, it is fun to watch.
And let's face it, those heroic types could do with taking down a peg or two.
10. The Joker - Batman: White Knight
What if the Joker, but sane? So posits Sean Murphy's White Knight. Set in an alternate universe where the Batman has finally gone off the deep end, losing the support of Gotham, the Bat-family and the GCPD, an unlikely contender rises to face this public enemy. Yes, the Joker, with the help of an experimental new medical treatment to cure his madness.
Released from Arkham, the once Clown Prince of Crime re-invents himself as a politician, campaigning against the brutality of the Batman and drawing public attention to the collateral damage in his never-ending war against crime. And you know what, he's kind of right.
That readers find themselves rooting for the Joker and Harley is kind of the point, but Murphy works in the grey areas - with a Batman who isn't really irredeemable, and a Joker who isn't truly good (or... is he?) In White Knight, Murphy achieves a Joker who readers can root for in his plot against the Batman - all without bashing us over the head with the fact that we Live In A Society.
9. Wesley Gibson - Wanted
When cubicle rat Wesley Gibson is recruited to join an underground society of supervillains known as the Fraternity, his life changes forever. He enters a world where the supervillains won, erasing superheroes from existence, remaining only as a faint fantasy-like memory. Gibson takes on his late (?) father's mantle, becoming The Killer... essentially every teenage loser's dream.
With the help of fellow supervillain the Fox, Wesley quickly rises through the ranks of the Fraternity, learning to love and enjoy committing acts of violence, raiding alternate universes and acting as personal bodyguard to an actual mad scientist.
Yet, in spite of Wesley's immature, edgelord frat-boy behaviour, one can't help but go along with it, cheering Wesley on in his exploits. Like so much else of Mark Millar's Millarworld, Wanted is sheer power fantasy... and that's okay sometimes. Ironically, the movie 'adaptation', which dulled down many of the book's rougher edges and supervillain vibes fell flat on its face - precisely because it made Wesley a more traditional hero type.
8. The Punisher - Punisher Kills The Marvel Universe
The Punisher is not a hero. An ex-military serial killer with a guns and skull fetish, Frank Castle is a straight-up monster. No matter how one feels about vigilante justice, the Punisher is not a hero. And yet, that hasn't stopped readers (for better or far worse) from latching onto the character, giving him a popularity to rival many a caped hero.
No writer has toed the line between anti-hero and villain like Garth Ennis. In Punisher Kills the Marvel Universe, we saw what happens when Frank Castle truly lets loose on the capes.
In an alternate universe where the X-Men were (indirectly) responsible for the death of his family, Frank blamed all superheroes, and set out on a bloody campaign to kill each and every one of them. And you know what? In spite of Frank cutting swathes through the Marvel Universe's most popular heroes, we kind of rooted for the guy, perversely excited to see what he'd do next. Not bad, for not a hero.
7. Negan - The Walking Dead
In issue #100 of The Walking Dead, an iconic new villain swaggered onto the scene, wielding a baseball bat wrapped in razor wire and swearing up a storm. Brutally slaughtering a beloved character in front of his friends and family, it was the book's most shocking moment, and one which forever changed the collective fate of Rick Grimes and his fellow survivors.
One would think that there would be no going back from that. And yet, the foul-mouthed, bloodthirsty Negan proved so popular with fans (and the writer) that he just kept on going, long after the culmination of Robert Kirkman's All Out War storyline. In fact, Negan became such a fan favourite that he became one of the lucky few to survive all the way to the end.
His silly redemption arc be damned (can anyone really come back from after what he did to Glenn?), the simple fact is that this perfectly loathsome villain was just too fun to hate.
6. The Riddler - The Last Riddler Story
Not content with bringing us some of the greatest Batman stories of all time on the small-screen, Batman: The Animated Series also did pretty well on the comic book page too. For example - The Last Riddler Story, (see Batman Adventures #10); one of the best, most thoughtful Riddler stories of all time.
Fed up of being constantly outwitted by Batman, the Riddler is about ready to throw in the towel. Persuaded by his goons to try out one last heist, Nygma goes after a set of rare jewels, employing all of his usual modus operandi (writing riddles in the sky et al). Batman, of course, foils the Riddler but only by chance, not having solved his riddle at all.
A win for the Riddler, even if he does wind up back in Arkham by the end of it all. The reader too, can't help but feel happy for the poor guy, finally getting one over on that know-it-all Bat.
5. The Capes - The Boys
Rooting for the comic's bad guys, but for the wrong reasons. One or two honorable exceptions aside, the superheroes of Garth Ennis's The Boys are a loathsome lot; cowardly, perverted, stupid at best, downright evil at their worst. Bad eggs, one and all. And yet, our 'heroes' - Billy Butcher, Wee Hughie and The Boys - are hardly any better.
Indeed, Billy Butcher as written is a vile specimen - a violent, murderous, sexist pig who is in no way better than the heroes he hunts. That he turns out to be the series' ultimate bad guy is no surprise (and a classic Garth Ennis move), but for much of the book we're supposed to find his antics amusing, in a juvenile sort of way. And yet, no. Their super-powered enemies are presented as being so pathetic that we can't help but root for them against the brutal, violent bullying of the Boys.
4. Jason And Leatherface - Jason Vs Leatherface
The comic book Jason vs Leatherface did exactly what it said on the tin - bringing together slasher icons Jason Voorhees (Friday the 13th) and Leatherface (the Texas Chainsaw Massacre) for the mother (sorry Jason) of all showdowns. What readers couldn't have predicted, however, was how sympathetic the book would be to its two dimwitted monsters. Bonding over their inability to speak and their love of murdering teenagers, the two became good friends, and so a bromance was born.
Sadly, Leatherface's idiotic, chittering family quickly caused ructions between the pair, forcing Leatherface to choose blood over buds. In the final issue, the pair fought, bringing about the titular battle - Leatherface's chainsaw against Jason's machete.
In spite of their combined bodycount and crimes against humanity, one couldn't help but feel for the pair. Who would have thought that a comic book called Jason vs Leatherface could have turned out to be the bittersweet bromance of the century? Not us, but here we are.
3. Mean Machine - Judge Dredd: The Three Amigos
The Judge Dredd Megazine story The Three Amigos teamed Dredd up with his two greatest enemies - Judge Death and the cybernetically enhanced Mean Machine Angel.
Future fascist Dredd never has made it easy for his fans to root for him, and his treatment of Mean in this book once again had readers questioning their loyalties. Promising to release Mean and his family from imprisonment should he help take down a minor Cursed Earth dictator (named, ahem, Clinton Box), Dredd enlisted his enemy's aid.
In spite of his few brain cells and severe anger management issues, Mean proved a surprisingly faithful ally. Indeed, he ultimately wound up saving Mega City One from nuclear annihilation and backed up Dredd in the face of Death's betrayal. And what did Mean Machine and the Angel gang get for their trouble? Dumped in an inhospitable patch of land, then subsequently arrested and locked up again.
2. Suicide Squad
Can't help rooting for them, or actively encouraged? You decide. DC's Suicide Squad takes in a rotating roster of scum and villainy, from expert assassin Deadshot to the Joker's squeeze herself, Harley Quinn (plus Aussie Captain Boomerang).
Assembled by none-too-clean-herself handler Amanda Waller, this gang of supervillains and criminals are sent in to handle the jobs the Justice League won't touch, with complete deniability. Yes, like some kind of... Suicide Squad.
With the team channeled into committing acts of good (albeit via remote controlled explosive) we're granted a deeper insight than usual into their psychology and inner workings. You know, more than you'd generally get than when Batman is there, punching their lights out. The constant shadiness of Amanda Waller also tends to make them seem more sympathetic by comparison. One always takes the supervillain over the bureaucrat.
This all makes them easier to swing for than most supervillain teams, even if it is by design.
1. Evil Ernie
An undead, all-powerful psychotic killer whose amassed powers could destroy the world, Evil Ernie is the epitome of early nineties antihero. Think The Mask (the proper comic book one, not the watered down Jim Carrey version), but with ambition and scale. This is a guy who once stole the US's nuclear arsenal and blew up the world, with the help of his very own zombie army.
Created by Brian Pulido and Steven Hughes in 1991, Evil Ernie has been through various incarnations, from the now-defunct Eternity Comics all the way through to his current home at Dynamite Entertainment. Though Evil Ernie's home and origins story may fluctuate, one thing remains consistent - his evil. The word is right there in his name.
But no matter what mayhem and violence he might inflict upon the world, Evil Ernie remains an absolute hoot, and a comic book villain we truly can't help but love.
You’ll Never Get 100% On This Joker Quiz!