10 Disturbing Mysteries Superheroes Couldn't Solve
Not even the World's Greatest Detective can solve everything...
When a superhero comes across a mystery in a comic book, it usually becomes the focus of their adventure, and by the end of the book (or arc), that mystery is solved. That makes sense, and it's pretty much how storytelling works, but every so often, a mystery comes along that even Batman himself has trouble solving.
Granted, it's rare, and there's a good reason for that. Batman wouldn't be the World's Greatest Detective if he got stumped every other issue. Even though he's good at his job, he's dropped the ball on sleuthing a few things over the years, and he's not the only one.
Over in Marvel, Image, and numerous other universes, there are superheroes who have had to scratch their heads and admit there are just some mysteries that can't be solved by the end of a comic book. When it happens, the fans tend to speculate, but even the Internet can't answer everything.
There actually aren't all that many mysteries superheroes had trouble solving given the length of time their books have been out, but there are at least ten. The ones featured here are either the hardest ones to solve, or they remain a mystery because the writers and artists simply haven't given anyone the answer. At least not yet...
10. The Joker's True Identity
This is a big one, and it's the one most people think of when it comes to unsolved mysteries because the Joker's true identity has never been confirmed. There have been hints and various allusions over the years, and he's definitely been expanded on in television shows and films, but in the world of comics, it's far more confusing.
The Joker has been around since the beginning, having first appeared in Batman #1 in 1940. You would think his name might have been dropped sometime in the intervening eight decades, but it hasn't, and recently, his identity has gotten even stranger.
In 2016's DC Universe: Rebirth, the longtime publisher dropped a bomb in terms of the Joker, and the fans are still trying to get over it. The one-shot confirmed that there are, in fact, three different men who have the same identity as the Clown Prince of Crime in Gotham City!
The story didn't give the readers much more information than that, but Geoff Johns and Jason Fabok have confirmed that the forthcoming Batman: The Three Jokers will clear everything up. That being said, there's no indication it will clear up the true identity of the man who has plagued Batman for the better part of a century.
9. Who Is F.A.C.A.D.E.?
There's a character in the Marvel Universe named F.A.C.A.D.E., and nobody knows who he is. Whoever they are, they're outfitted with the Full Acclimation Combat and Defence Explo-skeleton armor, which gives them the ability to fire off bursts of energy derived from the wearer's bio-electricity, they can fly, and they have superhuman strength and durability.
F.A.C.A.D.E. was introduced in the early nineties with the mystery of who was in the armor, but the storyline hit a snag. F.A.C.A.D.E. is primarily associated with Spider-Man, and the intent was to slowly reveal his identity in a way similar to how Hobgoblin's was revealed.
The only problem was, the fans simply weren't interested in F.A.C.A.D.E. Not only that, but the Clone Saga was ramping up at the time, and there were more important things for our Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man to contend with. That's all well and good for Peter Parker, but what about the readers?
This was a long-held mystery without a payoff. The character was introduced in 1994, and here it is 26+ years later, and the world doesn't know who is in the F.A.C.A.D.E. armor. To be fair, hardly anyone truly cares, but it would be nice to revive this mystery, even in a simple aside, just to satisfy the fans and finally put this issue to rest.
8. What Was In Wanda Maximoff's Closet?
Wanda Maximoff, aka, the Scarlett Witch, is one of the most powerful mutants in the Marvel Universe, and for good reason. She has the ability to alter reality, though this often comes about when she's grief-stricken, or not thinking clearly. When the "House of M" crossover event concluded, she succumbed to partial amnesia, resulting from her reality-warping activities.
She's eventually found by Hawkeye, who finds her in a small European village, where she's living in a small apartment. She claimed she was sharing the apartment with her elderly Aunt Agatha, which was somewhat confusing, seeing as Maximoff's former mentor, Agatha Harkness, was very much deceased at the time.
Seeing her news as a bit baffling and disconcerting, Hawkeye attempted to investigate by seeing what was in Agatha's room. Being so small, the room was referred to by fans as her "closet."
When Hawkeye attempted to open the door, he was unable to do so, thanks to Wanda's reality-warping powers. There was nothing he could do, and the door to the closet remained closed. What, or who was inside, and why was Wanda prohibiting anyone from entering? This may be answered sometime in the future, but for now, it remains a mystery to Hawkeye and the readers.
7. What Happened At The Beginning Of Time?
This one's a bit of a mystery, but it's also a mega-taboo. There's a rule for the Oans and their Green Lantern Corps, and it's one that nobody is allowed to break. It is forbidden to travel to the beginning of time, and witness the creation of the universe.
This leaves the obvious question, what's at the beginning of the universe? The rule stems from a legend that indicates, nobody can truly witness the beginning of time, but there have been a few close calls, and some superheroes have almost witnessed the very moment of creation.
The beginning of time was nearly witnessed by Batman and John Stewart, as the pair pursued Chronos. When they were nearly there, Stewart mentioned how it was forbidden to witness, and all that could be seen was a gigantic hand known as the Hand of Creation. This was first seen in the comics back in Green Lantern #40.
In that issue, an Oan scientist named Krona witnessed the beginning of time, and the result of his actions was the creation of the Antimatter Universe. He was the only known being to witness the Hand of Creation at the Beginning of Time, which leaves the rest of the DC Universe in the dark as to what really happened.
6. What Is The Second Holiday's True Identity?
In the critically acclaimed Batman: The Long Halloween, the Dark Knight is on the hunt for a criminal who commits crimes on holidays, who is, of course, named, Holiday.
In the book, Holiday is a serial killer whose crimes set him apart as particularly dastardly. Nobody could ascertain his identity—not the Riddler, or the police. Of course, by the end of the book, Batman does what nobody else can, and deduces that Alberto Falcone, the son of Gotham City's crime boss, Carmine “The Roman” Falcone, is the villain.
If Bats figured out who the bad guy was, you might be wondering, why is he mentioned in an article about mysteries superheroes couldn't solve? Well, it's simple: there was more than one Holiday! This is revealed at the end of the book when Two-Face casually mentioned that there were actually two people acting as Holiday.
When Batman hears this, he dismisses it as a lie or a trick from his nemesis, but he may not be completely convinced that Two-Face was lying to him. In the final scene, Two-Face's wife, Gilda, is suggested to be the guilty party, but it's never clarified or confirmed.
5. What Happened To Number Five?
In The Umbrella Academy, a group of children who were spontaneously born around the world at the same time were collected and assembled into a team of superheroes. Eventually, the children get a bit older, and things go to hell, which served to disenfranchise everyone from one another.
One of the kids, who was only ever named "Number Five," had the ability to travel through time, but he had some difficulty getting the math just right. At one point, he simply disappears, and nobody on the team was aware of what actually happened to him. It was a mystery nobody could solve.
Granted, it was revealed to the reader that Number Five traveled to the future, where he found a post-apocalyptic landscape where everyone on Earth was dead. He lived in this world until he reached old-age, as he was unable to work the math just right so he could return to a time before the end of the world.
Eventually, he returned to the present, but through some time travel shenanigans, he is returned in his adolescent body, but with the mind of an octogenarian. Despite being solved, the entire time he was gone, nobody on the team could crack the mystery of what happened to Number Five.
4. Why Can't Doctor Strange Heal His Hands?
We all know that Doctor Steven Strange wound up being the Master of the Mystic Arts at the end of a long hunt for a way to heal his hands. Ultimately, he never did heal them, but he was able to go on to become the Sorcerer Supreme of Earth, so it wasn't all bad.
If you're a typical reader, you might be wondering, if he's so powerful, and has the ability to travel to other dimensions, project massive amounts of energy, and go toe-to-toe with the Hulk, why can't he repair his hands? He's been shown to heal others, but for some reason, his own injury remains unhealed.
To be fair, there have been a few instances throughout his tenure in the Marvel Universe where he has healed his hands. In one, he takes a spell from a demon and heals them so he can save a life. Of course, it doesn't last, and there was a price to pay.
In the forthcoming Doctor Strange: Surgeon Supreme, he's supposed to heal once more, but it's not expected to last. After all, his infirmity is part of what makes him who he is, but it doesn't stand up to logic that he hasn't figured out a way to permanently heal his hands after all these years.
3. Hooded Justice's Real Name And Identity
The Watchmen comics have been expanded on in recent years with Before Watchmen, Watchmen (the HBO series), and the Watchmen live-action film. Despite these additions, the original maxi-series by Alan Moore remains one of the greatest examples of adult-themed comic book storytelling ever written, and it's full of innuendo and mystery.
There was one mystery in particular that a certain superhero was never able to figure out. The original Night Owl, otherwise known as Hollis Mason, was never able to uncover the true identity of Hooded Justice. This was a bit of a bother to him, as Hooded Justice was the very first person to put on a mask and beat the crap out of criminals.
Night Owl didn't know who he was, and neither did any of the other members of the Minutemen, though there was some speculation Mason wrote about in his book. His autobiography, "Under The Hood," offered up the possibility that Hooded Justice's real identity was that of Rolf Müller.
He could have been right, or he could have been way off. Because Moore will never expand on this, nobody will know the truth. In the television series Watchmen, he's clearly depicted as Will Reeves, a former police officer, but the actual comics identity of the character will likely always remain a mystery.
2. What Happened That Started The Apocalypse In The Walking Dead?
Robert Kirkman's The Walking Dead is likely one of the most popular independent books Image published since its inception. It didn't hurt that AMC launched a massive television franchise based on the books, but needless to say, TWD has a lot of fans.
Now, nobody is saying there are superheroes in The Walking Dead comics, but it's hard to argue that Rick Grimes isn't a hero. Sure, he regularly kills people and has done some nasty things to survive, but he would have continued being a good cop had the apocalypse been put off for a century or two.
Speaking of the apocalypse, does anyone know how it started? That's one of the things that's never revealed in the books, and despite the brief mentions in the television show, it remains a complete mystery. Nobody knows if there is a virus infecting them or what's caused the dead to rise.
It's also unclear as to when and where it began. Did it start in one place, or did the dead all over the world spontaneously rise and begin chomping on the living? It's a mystery that will never be solved, seeing as the comics have concluded without answering this one basic question: how did the apocalypse begin?
1. Why Exactly Does Kryptonite Hurt Kryptonians?
Kryptonite was first introduced in 1943 on the Superman radio show for a rather unique reason. The actor who gave voice to the Man of Steel wanted to take a vacation, but the show must go on, so they were left with a strange choice.
They introduced Kryptonite as a way of making Superman sick. For the weeklong vacation, another actor moaned and made distressing sounds to pretend Superman was there but wasn't doing too well. It was then introduced in 1949's Superman #61 in a non-green variety with the standard green rock appearing in 1951's Action Comics #161.
It's clear that Kryptonite hurts Superman, but does anyone actually know why this is the case? Why would a rock from his homeworld cause him immeasurable pain, and deprive him of his superpowers? After all, wouldn't a Kryptonian have evolved on Krypton, and be immune to the planet's ill effects?
There have been numerous theories put forth about this over the years, and while they are all pretty good, the comics haven't confirmed anything. Kryptonite remains more of a reverse deus ex machina or a MacGuffin meant to drive the story in one way or another, and for whatever reason, it's never really been explained.
DC Quiz: Can You Name That Superman Villain?