10 Kindhearted Comic Book Characters With Superbly Nuanced Flaws

10. Moira MacTaggert
Moira MacTaggert is an incredibly likable character. Her combination of cheerfulness and intelligence is contagious, and maybe that's part of what created her greatest flaw. Her son Kevin, a.k.a. Proteus. In her younger days, Moira was forced into a marriage with a cruel man who she didn't love, and after her husband raped her, she had Kevin, who eventually developed a mutation which broke down his body, forcing him to need others' bodies to survive. Moira developed a chamber in which Kevin could survive until a solution could be found, but after spending years in the chamber, Kevin went insane. Talk about having a skeleton in your closet, and then having to face itultimately in the form of your ex-husband who physically attacked you, no less. Proteus provided an astonishing conflict for Moira. Regardless of Moira's motivations, her actions in regards to Kevin blur the lines of what was under her control. Finding out about Proteus was a bombshell if I ever read one, and this was in an older X-Men story no less, where bombshells happened almost as much as Professor X getting angry for no reason.
9. James Gordon
James Gordon is another character for whom I hold a great deal of respect. He's honest, assertive, all about common sense, and believes in justice and law through and through. Gordon always tries to do his best, but sometimes, unbeknownst to all but his closest associates, his job gets the better of him. His affair with Sarah Essen didn't help things either. Gordon has dealt with numerous issues (is that a pun?) over the course of his career, including his strained relationships with both Harvey Dent and Batman, hoping with all his very real heart that they can both return from their respective darknesses. These elements have created many dimensions in Gordon's life. It gives his personal life a great deal of complexity, the everyday humanity and painand the time that passes within familybehind the strength.
8. Selina Kyle
Selina Kyle is a lot of fun, what with her Catwoman persona and all. But what really makes her cool is what's churning in those eyes behind the mask. Selina has a lot of pain in her life, from how she had to live before becoming Catwoman, to the truth of her ancestry, to the many shades of moral ambiguity she feels she must navigate to achieve her goals. Selina doesn't always enjoy what she's doing, but she always knows exactly what she wants and doesn't let anything stand in her way. And that's the pointit's all about what she FEELS she must do, and to take the most direct paths possible. Because of her reactions to how her life has played out, she reacts as a mature, three-dimensional adult in extraordinary ways both grand and subtle, especially for the world of comics. In many stories she's even portrayed as more stable than Bruce Wayne. She has enough layers to be. Minus the questionable one-liners of course.
7. Flash Thompson
Flash Thompson has gone through a journey that I highly doubt anyone could have predicted when he first appeared alongside Peter Parker in Amazing Fantasy #15. Arguably going through as much evolution as Peter, Flash has gone from the class bully to Spider-Man's biggest fan to a troubled, close friendship with Peter Parker (waitthere's life AFTER high school?!) to a soldier who loses both of his legs to the current Venom. And over that time, we've continued to learn more than we ever thought possible about the truth behind the jock. Flash's father was an abusive alcoholic. Abusive alcoholics come a dime a dozen in comics, but how it's been used to develop Flash has been tremendous. Flash's personal insecurities, pain, and issues with responsibility (a great foil for Peter Parker in so many ways) have led him to not only bully Peter, but to cheat on at least one girlfriend and even become an alcoholic himself. Flash also worries about hiding the truth in all its forms from both Betty Brant and Peter Parker while currently dealing with his own willpower and responsibility in trying to contain the Venom symbiote. Yet throughout all these things, we know that Flash has a good heart, and this allows us to remember that his flaws are just being human. It takes the Spider-Man stories, as well as Flash's own, to tremendous new places.
6. Matt Murdock
Matt Murdock is a very good guy. He's all about helping people in court and on the streets, and has a great sense of humor, despite all the sadness within him. But old Matt is very human. He makes mistakes all the time, despiteand maybe because ofhis heightened senses. For one thing, he can be short with those around him despite his years of training in eloquent rhetoric. From his long history of failed relationships (and it is long, although to his credit, some of it is Bullseye's fault) to his penchant for the irreverent, Matt has a tendency to let his emotions get the better of him, whether in cutting out the friends and family who care about him the most or thinking a baby is the Antichrist. Yet no matter what happens to him, Matt always bounces back, even from being locked inside underwater taxis, and when someone needs his help, he's almost always there.
5. Most Of The Green Lanterns I've Read About
Most of the Green Lanterns I know, especially the human ones, have origins that would make you think they could never be Green Lanterns. Hal Jordan was the overconfident ne'er-do-well. John Stewart was all too jaded about the harsh realities of the world and the consequences of irresponsibility. Kyle Rayner felt a great deal of collateral from his distant parents. Simon Baz stole cars. Guy Gardner dabbled in a little of all of the above. And yet they were all given the honor of becoming Green Lanterns. Even with what tuns out to be their truly great willpower, each of their personalities affected the success of their endeavors. It's not often you can be a good person and be in a position to destroy the universe, but many of them have been in positions to do just that. Some of them were even killed in the process, yet nevertheless survived to deal with the aftermath of their actions. And this seems to be a common thing within the Corps, since many of the Green Lanterns from other worlds also have personalities that bring about just as many shades of green.
4. Mr. Freeze
You probably knew this one was coming. Mr. Freeze is one of the most sympathetic villains in the history of comics (at least since his portrayal in Batman: The Animated Series anyway). He is completely devoted to his wife, and ever since the latter contracted a very rare illness, Mr. Freeze has stopped at nothing to save her. With his signature cold demeanor that manifests itself both physically and emotionally, yet also comes from a very warm place somewhere inside of him, Mr. Freeze gives off an incredible understated bittersweet presence in almost every panel he occupies. He doesn't have to yell and scream to create drama (although his freeze gun is certainly appealing), and that's why Mr. Freeze will undeniably remain one of the most well-respected, if not immediately popular, comic book villains out there.
3. Oliver Queen
Oliver Queen just can't seem to stop himself, or beating himself up about it. He occupies the body of an adult, but like many actual adults, Oliver constantly questions just how much of an adult he really is. For all the good he does for strangers, Oliver is the butterfingers of morality. If he were a compass, he would be all over the place. Whether he's double-crossing Dinah, double-crossing his best friends, double-crossing his oldest son, or double-crossing everyone else like with that incident with Prometheus, he just can't seem to listen to his own logic. He tries. He really does. But at the end of the day, much like his father, he's the most human a human can be, except he also gets the chance to moonlight as a superhero. Every day for him is truly another chanceafter he reprimands himself. He was also able to use a Green Lantern ring too. Just saying.
2. Jean Grey
Thanks to both the Phoenix and the magic of comic book drama, it's hard to say what Jean has done and what she hasn't done, but one thing is for certaineven if Jean Grey wasn't physically part of the Dark Phoenix Saga, she has enough layers to give her the Number Two spot on this list. Jean has been through a great deal in her time, from learning everything about Madelyne Pryor to all of those issues with kids from other timelines, but Jean Grey almost in fact transcends this list, because as she has put it, part of her has always been the Phoenix. She lives with more maturity and responsibility than most of the characters in the Marvel Universe, and with more memories churning within her than most people in any universe could bear. Through it all, she has always proven her mettle, again and again, from leading Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters to standing up to Onslaught's temptations to even coming to the rescue of Emma Frost (several times). Her past self is even the leader of the past X-Men team in the present! And then there's her relationship with Scott, and all they've been through. Speaking of which...
1. Scott Summers
Yep. Cyclops. Almost always casually dismissed as the boring boy scout of the Marvel Universe, Scott Summers is my favorite example of a good character dealing with very real flaws at different times that gradually develop from his personality and experiences. In the early days of X-Men comics, Scott was one of the first characters to really admonish himself constantly, yet keep his doubts to himself to be able to lead the team, which created a distance between himself and those who could have been his friends, and was made even worse by his mutation. Cyclops always had to be the bigger person to do what was right. Scott's fears very much influenced his relationship with Jean Grey, and with all they've been through, readers can always feel the truth of time between them, even across the scores of writers and artists who have handled them. But Scott's misgivings in his life have ever-increasingly led him to do questionable things. There's his tendency to go off by himself whenever something bad happens. There was his affair with Emma Frost. Then he killed Professor Xwell, at least until we'll inevitably find out it was a robotand STILL took responsibility. Kind of. Now, convinced that hostility against and apathy toward mutants is worse than ever, especially from those in power, Scott has been leading a force of mutants for mutant rights in ways the current X-Men disagree with, even his past self. Scott unapologetically protects mutants from being persecuted, whether by the institutions of law or education, while the other (and past) X-Men try to convince Cyclops of how "wrong" he is. For better or for worse, Cyclops is done trying to convince the world that they need mutants, instead showing them they mutants are a fact that "normal" people are just going to have to live with. It's truly radical stuff done very well. Cyclops is much more true to Malcolm X's still-misunderstood memory than Magneto supposedly ever was. With the giant X on Scott's face, the X-Men story has never had more nuanced meaning in its hyperbole. There's nothing like average over-the-top comic book conflict, but there's also nothing like watching more nuanced flaws play out in kinder hearts, whose motivations and conflicts can tread truly complex paths all their own when given the opportunity. What about you? What are some great comic book character layers you enjoy?