10 Messed Up Superman Storylines You Won't Believe Exist

Containing a lot more brain eating than your average comic.

Superman Comic
DC Comics

As the beloved and iconic all-American golden boy, many of Superman's comics are nothing short of wholesome. After all, there's something about seeing the Man of Steel overcome evil for the good and truth and justice that never quite gets old, no matter how many we see it on the inked page before us.

But this isn't to say that all of Supes' stories are all wholesome and pure. There's a fair share of weird, dark and bizarre plot lines with Superman, that detail just about every weird scenario you could ever imagine the superhero being in.

Because the fact that he is such a moral bastion means that Supes often gets the short straw in comics, as writers and artists know that putting him in dire and strange straights will fascinate an audience all the more for seeing how he deals with it - be his reaction good or bad. Containing everything from evil plants to a bloodthirsty gorilla, these stories remind us that with great power comes great potential to be put in weird storylines, whether you like it or not.

10. Luthor

Luthor Superman
DC Comics

Luthor is one of the best Superman comics you probably haven't read - but it's also, when you think about it, one of the wildest at the same time.

The series feels like it could be set in just about any of the various comics we've seen Superman and his biggest rival square off in when it starts. It quickly develops into something more complicated, however, as we see Luthor either create a robot woman, or otherwise replace a dying woman's entire internal system with robotic parts in order to create a new superhero ironically named Hope.

Luthor sets up Hope against Superman through the means of the Toyman, a villain who he purposefully manipulates behind the scenes. Lex has the man be held responsible for blowing up a children's daycare centre, after having convinced the criminal that his bomb would be used in a robbery instead.

When Hope goes to apprehend him, Lex has her drop the man from a great height, intending to kill him. As is generally the case when someone is dropped from a high place in Metropolis, Superman comes to save him, which results in Hope and Supes getting into a fight. To conclude his nefarious plans, Lex then explodes this robot woman so Superman will be blamed, despite the fact that it seemed like Lex was love with her.

Oh, and in case you were wondering - yes, it is heavily implied that he bones the robot lady. And no, this is not the first time he has boned a robot.


9. Superman/Doomsday: Hunter And Prey

Doomsday Bertron
DC Comics

Doomsday's introduction comic, The Death of Superman, is one of the most iconic Superman storylines to date, infamous for the dark plot containing the demise of the Man of Steel.

But as it turns out, this is not the darkest story containing Doomsday by a long shot. Enter the Hunter and Prey series, which details the frankly nightmarish details of Doomsday's creation. As it turns out, the rock-man was once an innocent baby, who was made the subject of cruel experiments by a scientist named Bertron. Bertron would send the infant out into the wilds of Krypton to have the child die at the hands of the dangerous creatures that lived there, only to gather its remains and then create it again, slowly evolving the creature to survive in the hostile environment.

However, this cloning process also provided Doomsday with the memories of his various deaths, driving him insane and making him hate all lifeforms. You almost can't blame him, given his childhood playschool basically taught him that everything about life is suffering.


8. What's So Funny About Truth, Justice, And The American Way? - Action Comics #775

Manchester Black The Elite
DC Comics

Actions Comics #775 begins with the bloody destruction of a colossal cyborg gorilla, and only proceeds to get weirder from there. The comic introduces the Elite, who are not in fact a wrestling team in the DC universe, but rather a group of superpowered individuals who are, for all intents and purposes, entirely lawless.

But they're portrayed by the Daily Planet's rival news company, The Star, as entirely heroic, as they take down largely terrorists and other criminal organisations. It's important to note however that The Star avoids talking about how badly they needlessly torture them, meaning they're beloved by the general public.

Superman often deals with threats to his physical safety, but it's a rare thing that we see him confront any challenges to his moral beliefs. To see this dealt out to the Man of Steel by a brit with a union jack flag and a purple hairdo is completely surreal, but also profoundly interesting - enough that the comic would be adapted into the animated film Superman vs. The Elite, anyway.


7. Superman: The Dark Side

Superman The Dark Side
DC Comics

Much of the character Superman is today is based upon his upbringing on Earth. The wholesome guidance of Ma and Pa Kent served young Clark well, and still very clearly influences his moral approach to being a superhero to this day.

This is exactly what makes Superman: The Dark Side so interesting, as it explores a universe in which the rocket ship that dropped Clark off on Earth instead landed on Apocalips, the home of Darkseid.

As you'd expect, Supes ends up notably less heroic in this series, as he's raised personally by the Dark God himself, taught to be totally merciless and entirely brutal. Though the Man of Steel manages to revert to his heroic ways by the end of the series, it's after he's single-handedly destroyed the planet of New Genesis - so it's too little too late for that world's entire population.


6. Kingdom Come

Superman Kingdom Come
DC Comics

Kingdom Come is a must-read for anyone who has a hankering for a good Elseworlds comic, as it covers a surprisingly believable scenario wherein Superman disappeared for many years, and the superhero community went on without him, albeit while disillusioned due to his departure.

It's a darker universe for each of our heroes. Wonder Woman has been exiled by the Amazonians, Batman has had his spine irreparably broken, and Shazam is being forcibly mind-controlled by Lex Luthor into being his subservient sidekick.

Worse of all, the concept of being a superhero has been commercialised, with restaurant chains using famous superhero costumes for their servers, and with many 'hero' vigilantes being more interested in beating someone down than any kind of justice.

The series has a mercifully light and hopeful ending, but it's one that comes at the cost of Shazam's life and thousands more, which leaves it kind of mixed in tone.


5. Batman/Superman #16

Superman Comic
DC Comics

You'd think that Superman and everyone bearing his logo facing an assassination attempt wouldn't make for that sad of a plot line - after all, someone literally tries to kill the Man of Steel every other Wednesday, and he generally reacts to it with all the emotion of someone realising they left pickles on their burger.

However, the 2013 Batman/Superman storyline is a little different, as a regular man named Chuck gets caught up in the crossfire of this murder attempt, as at the time he is dressed up like Superman in order to entertain children in the kid's ward of a hospital. As he is wearing the iconic logo, Chuck is also shot, and dies of his wounds then and there.

Seeing Supes discover this news - and seeing Chuck bravely hide his wound to the kids he was cheering up, instead stepping out of the room to die so as to not upset them - is legitimately tearjerking, especially as it focuses on such an ordinary, and yet such a heroic, figure.


4. For The Man Who Has Everything (Superman Annual 11)

Superman For The Man Who Has Everything
DC Comics

When you look at older Superman comics, it's hard to figure out what storylines are messed up, because pretty much every issue has one moment of profound weirdness.

This said, the eleventh ever Superman annual - titled 'For The Man WHo Has Everything', which was written by Alan Moore - still manages to be head and shoulders above the rest, because it's wall to wall wildness.

The story starts with Superman going about his ordinary life on Krypton, which immediately shows something is off, because the issue takes place in the main DC universe, where the planet is famously destroyed. We quickly learn that Superman is hallucinating this due to a bioweapon named the Black Mercy that has attached itself to him, and that Wonder Woman and Batman are furiously trying to rescue him from its clutches.

Superman frees himself, but the weapon then attaches to Batman, who dreams a life where his parents didn't die. Both return to the real world, but both are left undeniably scarred by memories of alternate lives that seem completely real to them.


3. Injustice

Injustice Solomon Grundy Superman
DC Comics

Once upon a time, anyone looking for an alternate universe story where Superman becomes an outright villain would have to satiate themselves with the likes of Superman: Red Son and Superman: The Dark Side - which are both good comics, but also fairly short comics.

Then Injustice came out, and suddenly if you wanted your fix of jerk Superman, you could now get it weekly. The Man of Steel becoming a murdering dictator is vaguely justified, in the sense that the Joker does set up a scheme where Supes ends up accidentally murdering his wife and unborn child, and naturally this upsets him a little.

But the former hero officially goes past the point of understandable reactions when he begins to systematically murder seemingly every villain that has ever existed, including those such as Solomon Grundy, who are more disturbed than evil. Just to change the minds of anyone who still thinks he might be good, Supes then gets up to all sorts of awful antics, such as getting Victor Zsasz to kill Alfred, and to tweet out Batman's secret identity to force him to go into hiding.

When he's a hero, there are few heroes better than Superman - but when he's a villain, there are few antagonists worse.


2. Superman: The Black Ring

Gorilla Grodd The Black Ring
DC Comics

Superman: The Black Ring is a comic that was destined to be entirely messed up because of its premise. The story takes place just after the events of Blackest Night, showing Lex after his ordeal being an Orange Lantern. Combine Luthor becoming even more power-hungry with him being sent into a series of hallucinations by Mister Mind, and you're all set for a series of weird dream scenarios that are straight out of your worst fever dreams.

But Lex's weird fantasies aren't even the weirdest thing about all of this. Despite the series focusing around him, it's actually Gorilla Grodd who takes the cake for the most unsettling entity in the comic. A brain-guzzling, head eating monster, this version of the evolved anthropoid spends the majority of his time dancing between a comic relief character and a terrifying villain.

This proves absolutely terrifying, as Monsieur Mallah's cousin goes from messing around with a comically large spoon, to cutting Luthor's head off with said spoon, in the literal blink of an eye.


1. Superman: At Earth's End

Superman: At Earth's End
DC Comics

When you see the cover of Superman: At Earth's End, you immediately know several things about the series. Witnessing a ripped, white-haired version of Superman holding four gatling guns that are twice the size of him, you can predict a good portion of the antics of the series in front of you.

But not all of it, because good god, the human mind was not made to come up with stuff like this comic. Superman spends the entire comic looking like a buff Santa, and by the fifth page of this muscled merry maker ripping cyborgs to shreds, you will either despise the series with every ounce of your being, or be undeniably fascinated by it.

It's something that has to be seen to be believed, but here are some brief footnotes; there's a kid's motorcycle gang whose parents are being kept by robots to breed, and also Hitler shows up.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: Who Said It - Batman Or Superman?

Superman New 52 Ceremonial Armor
DC Comics

1. "We Both Looked Into The Abyss, But When It Looked Back At Us, You Blinked."

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.