10 Overhyped Comic Books That Were Incredibly Mediocre

Unfortunately, these much anticipated stories were nothing to write home about.

Old Man Logan
Marvel Comics

The long-running nature of comic books means that, after a while, some of the ongoing storylines may lose some of their lustre and even relevance. Repeating tired tropes, bringing back dead characters and/or returning the world(s) to their original status quos can push away readers and risk having the stories cancelled.

This is why, every now and then a publishing company will announce a comic and tout it as "the next big thing" and use ominous taglines such as 'everything will change" to describe the upcoming cataclysmic events. Some of these stories (such as Secret Invasion or Final Crisis) will live up to their lofty expectations and significantly alter their respective universes, but others simply end up being duds.

The reasons behind their failures vary, but there is no denying that the reputations of the characters involved and their stories are tarnished with little chance of recovery. These comics feel like unwilling components in a cynical hype machine to justify the relevance of the publishing companies but end up sinking the companies even further down into oblivion.

From wide-scale murder mysteries to company reboots and alternative future tales, these comics showed that flashy advertising and tie-ins do not make up for a weak story and baffling characterization.

10. Identity Crisis

Identity Crisis 1280 720
DC Comics / Michael Turner

In the last 2 years alone, DC has gone through two different crises and is about to go through a third one. Despite this overreliance on crossover stories, their crisis events have been well-crafted and entertaining for the most part.

Unfortunately, this cannot be said for 2004's Identity Crisis, a widespread murder mystery that was unbelievably tone deaf and left a bad taste in most readers' mouths after they finished it. Following the death of the Elongated Man's wife, Sue Dibny, the Justice League sets out to find the killer (heavily suspected to be supervillain Dr. Light) before they can strike again.

In the process, the team learns uncomfortable truths about how far its members would go to protect themselves and their loved ones. The story is rife with inconsistencies in the characterization of various heroes and paints the normally united team in a disturbing and disjointed light.

In addition to the above, the story's core component and its resolution were both underwhelming and sexist, showing that the creative team were unable of crafting a murder mystery that respected the characters involved.


9. Civil War

Marvel Comics Civil War
Marvel Comics

Seeing heroes clash is conceptually interesting due to the prospect of knowing who is more powerful and/or skilled. Furthermore, the ideological differences and situations that force these heroes into conflict are even more compelling. Unfortunately, Marvel's grand event missed the mark in delivering a satisfying hero vs. hero showdown despite its potentially profound themes.

Civil War may have given us moments such as Spider-Man revealing his identity to the world and the iconic Captain America/Iron Man fight , but at the same time the heroes involved were woefully out-of-character and unlikable.

Following a tragedy involving rookie superheroes and villains, the nation calls for increased accountability in the superhuman community. This culminated in the Superhero Registration Act, a document whose content tore the Avengers and most superhero teams apart.

Acts such as Tony Stark employing supervillains to hunt down his former comrades and Reed Richards' construction of an extra-dimensional prison for said heroes were not only despicable, but also robbed the story of its moral complexity. Ultimately, the story's impact is undercut by a shakily defined Act and an underwhelming resolution.


8. Heroes In Crisis

DC Heroes in Crisis
DC Comics

Before its release, Heroes In Crisis seemed promising due to its proposed exploration of the mental health of various superheroes in addition to the main murder mystery. Sadly, the comic series handled these themes in an unconvincing and insensitive manner, and its treatment of Wally West in particular left a lot to be desired.

The story introduces the Sanctuary, a secret rehabilitation center that caters to the needs of superheroes and reformed supervillains. Following a mass shooting that claims the lives of characters such as Wally West and Poison Ivy, the League investigates the heinous act with Booster Gold and Harley Quinn as its main suspects.

As the mystery unfolds, two things become clear. One, the existence of the Sanctuary is unsettling for the superhuman community. Two, Wally West's involvement in the massacre is more convoluted and disturbing than initially expected.

The mental health element of the story amounts to nothing and seemed to serve more as a selling point rather than a tasteful exploration of its characters' various psyches. This is seen in Wally's treatment, an act that strives to mine his trauma for shock value more than anything else.


7. Old Man Logan

old man logan
Marvel Comics

Old Man Logan is an intriguing exploration of a dystopic Marvel universe as well as an older, more world-weary Wolverine. That said, some of its narrative elements were terribly misguided in hindsight.

Majority of the heroes in this timeline are dead and the rest are under the mercy of a cabal of supervillains (such as Red Skull, Kingpin and a villainous Hulk) who took over after wiping most of this Earth's superheroic community. An older Logan lives with his family in Hulk-controlled territory and due to the pressures of the former powerhouse's family, sets out on a cross-country journey with Hawkeye.

The artwork by Steve McNiven suitably captures the bleak and gory world the characters inhabit, but the generic story itself paints them in an awful light. It is bleak to a fault, and while this is the point of dystopic stories it quickly gets exhausting to immerse yourself into.

Characters such as the Hulk and She-Hulk are extremely off-putting, and Logan's pacifism feels undercooked and its inciting incident is both inexplicable and infuriating. All in all, the story has some intriguing aspects but was a whole frustratingly executed.


6. The New 52 As A Whole

New 52 Textless
DC Comics

For every Post-Crisis era or Rebirth era in DC, we get the New 52; easily the most disappointing initiative DC has undertaken in the modern age of comics.

The decision to take away 10 or so years from the histories of most DC characters is fascinating on paper, but the younger heroes, villains and supporting characters were not as compelling as their older counterparts and felt like second-rate parodies of themselves.

Characters such as Superman and Starfire became unlikable in an attempt to make them more flawed, and most heroes' costume designs made for uncomfortable sights due to their overdesigned, tactical armor-like nature. The continuity was all over the place as well. For starters, Batman had multiple Robins and a ten-year old son with Talia despite being a hero for only a few years.

Such a discrepancy was reflective of the New 52's failed attempt to take countless years of history and condense them into a relatively short timeframe. Fortunately, DC Rebirth was able to set things for the most part.


5. Fear Itself

Fear Itself Captain America Mjolnir
Marvel Comics

The 2011 crossover event follows the machinations of the Serpent, an Asgardian fear god whose schemes to claim the throne of Asgard spelt disaster for Earth. Despite focusing on the diabolical deity and the trio of Thor, Captain America and Iron Man, the event was a muddled tale with a questionable plot structure, lackluster writing and inconsequential nature.

Following the settlement of Asgard on Earth after the Siege storyline, Red Skull's daughter Sin recovers Skadi's Hammer, a relic that transformed her into the Serpent's Herald. This sets off a chain of events that imperils both Earth and Asgard and pushes the heroes of the former to their limits.

Despite featuring fan-pleasing moments such as Captain America wielding Mjolnir, the Serpent destroying Cap's shield, and Iron Man creating Uru-infused weaponry, the main story is poorly paced from the onset. Its buildup was poorly done, meaning that the rest of the story did not flow as instead and this served to work against the far-reaching nature of the story.

That said, the event's tie-ins made for entertaining reads, even if they undercut the impact of the main story in some instances.


4. A Death In The Family

A death in the family
DC Comics

It is not everyday that readers actively choose the fate of a character via a phone call, but this was the case with A Death in the Family, one of a handful of Batman stories that ushered in the Dark Age of comics.

Centering the story on the unlikable Robin (Jason Todd) was ingratiating for readers back in 1988, but having the readers kill him off was essentially an admission by the staff at DC that they were incapable of redeeming Todd or making him more palatable for readers.

Up until the titular death, the story's tone is all over the place and ranges from silly and Silver-Age esque, to disturbing and grim (see Joker's torture of Jason Todd). Speaking of the Clown Prince of Crime, his tenure as...Iran's ambassador to the UN is a poor attempt at humour and arguably Islamophobic.

Equating Iranians (and the Arab world in general) to the Joker was incredibly misguided and served no purpose in the narrative. All in all, one of Batman's most iconic stories is a messy attempt at adding stakes in the Batman mythos and elevating Joker's threat level.


3. Ultimatum

Ultimatum Marvel
Marvel Comics

The Ultimate Marvel (Ultimate Comics) imprint that ran from 2000 to 2015 was a mixed bag, to say the least. The modern reimagining of classic Marvel characters and teams was criticized for its edgy take on superheroes and its dated attempts at this left a sour taste in readers' mouths.

For every Ultimate Spider-Man tale that was at least palatable, there was an Ultimate Captain America acting nationalistic, incestuous siblings, and an unsettling amount of cannibalism. Suffice to say, Marvel's attempt to streamline their universe was a mess.

This is best reflected in Ultimatum, the 2009 storyline that saw Magneto seeking revenge on Earth for the deaths of Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver. His plans go horribly well, and in the chaos heroes such as Thor, the Wasp, Cyclops, Professor X and Doctor Strange all die, in addition to countless lives around the globe.

As much as the storyline helped differentiate the Ultimate universe from the main one, the gory deaths (especially Wasp and Blob's) were disgusting to see and felt like they were included to add shock value to the story more than anything else. The Ultimate universe powered on for a few more years after the event but it never fully recovered after the ghastly crossover event.


2. All Star Batman And Robin, The Boy Wonder

All-Star Batman And Robin Frank Miller
DC Comics/Jim Lee

If you were to read this comic and expect a grand, emotionally stirring epic in the vein of All Star Superman, you would be in for a rude awakening. Frank Miller's retelling of Robin's origin as completely butchered the likes of Batman, Robin and other DC characters and is an example of the writer's jaded sensibilities not always working in a world of heroes.

The art by Jim Lee is reliably well-crafted and is often considered to be the saving grace of the comic. Beyond that, readers are... treated to a cruel and sadistic Dark Knight who insists to a young, grief-stricken Robin that he addresses him as the "Goddamn Batman". Not only is the line unintentionally hilarious, it blatantly ignores the character's capacity for warmth and empathy.

In addition to that, the treatment of a young Dick Grayson is disturbing to say the least and strips Batman of whatever shreds of humanity he has left. His fellow heroes (especially Green Lantern) are seen as ineffectual and only serve to reinforce Batman's unstoppable persona.

That said, Batman and Robin's takedown of Green Lantern is hilarious and almost feels like a mockery of the zany Silver Age of Comics.


1. Spider-Man: One More Day

Spider-Man One More Day
Marvel Comics

Following the game-changing events of Civil War, Spider-Man fans were curious to see where Marvel would take the beloved icon following the reveal of his secret identity to the world. One More Day explores this new change to the status quo in initially interesting fashion, before going off the rails with its second half and conclusion.

After Aunt May is shot by a sniper and hospitalized, a desperate Peter turns to the likes of Doctor Strange, the High Evolutionary and even Doctor Doom for assistance. When none of them offer the help Peter needs, the demonic Mephisto offers to save May's life at the expense of the hero's marriage to Mary Jane Watson.

While the story may be slightly lauded for emphasizing how Spider-Man's life is defined by sacrifice and protecting his loved ones from his heroic identity, the story's Deus Ex Machina resolution feels like a cheap and cynical attempt at returning the hero back to the status quo.

Removing his marriage to Mary Jane negates any chance at growth for Peter and involving Mephisto in the ordeal removes his agency as a character. Ultimately, Peter Parker's past and future were disrespected in a story afraid to look at both periods as a whole for the hero.


Watch Next


Contributor

David Ng'ethe hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.