10 Problems With The Joker Nobody Wants To Admit

He's not even the best Batman villain...

The Joker
DC Comics

When a character's been around for long enough, and has been passed through multiple different writers, they start to get a little fuzzy round the edges. Sherlock Holmes has certain constants €“ the Ocam's razor approach to detective work, the arrogance, the vices, usually some sort of nod to a hat €- but there are also flaws with the character that have been there since Arthur Conan Doyle first put pen to paper with A Study in Scarlet, and have only been compounded with time, different writers, and popularity.

The same thing happens with any property that's suitably famous, old and written by multiple people. For instance, The Avengers aren't quite as perfect as everybody makes out. Even Batman has had his fair share of issues over the years, which tend to be swept under the rug. But spare a thought for the bad guys, too, since The Joker hasn't been quite as brilliant, cohesive and ingenious a villain since day one as people make out.

Sure, he's iconic. He's almost definitely the ideal foil for The Dark Knight. Plus he's a bad guy who stands up to different characterisations €“ to a degree, at least. He's a crazy person. Why wouldn't he act differently from day to day? That, too, might actually be an issue.

His whole shtick, his personality, his psychology, and all the pseudo-intellectual readings of the Clown Prince Of Crime that have reared their heads since the first fanboy decided there might be something up with Batman hanging around with young wards... all of those and more factor into the ten problems with The Joker nobody wants to admit.


10. What's With The Origin Story?

Joker Origin
DC Comics

Famously, The Joker is pitched as the opposite number to Batman. Where the Caped Crusader fights for order against injustice, the Joker is a criminal who spreads chaos; the Dark Knight lurks in the shadows, whilst his arch nemesis dresses in gaudily bright outfits for his theatrical escapades. Where Bruce Wayne has one of the most famous, well-defined and very rarely diverged-from origin stories in comic books (or, heck, in any form of media), the Clown Prince Of Crime's true beginnings have forever remained a mystery.

Sometimes that's a help, sometimes it's a hindrance, but it's definitely an issue at the core of the character that's rarely addressed. Alan Moore came closest to bringing a defining origin story to The Joker in his famous graphic novel with Brian Bolland, The Killing Joke, where it's implied he was a regular dude that happened to be cracked by €œone bad day€.

That's not been touched upon since, with his true background as vague as the mysterious Joker played by Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight film. It sort of makes out like he's some kind of elemental, mystical being, which is a little out of step with the gritty, ground-level sort of character that Batman is. Not every character needs an origin, but here it hinders the whole story.


9. He Is Wildly Inconsistent

Batman Joker Endgame
DC Comics

Now, part of what makes The Joker such a brilliant nemesis for Batman €“ and such an entertaining character for readers €“ is his unpredictability. The Dark Knight operates (at least partly) on gathering intelligence, knowing his enemy before he actual enters into combat with them, having already prepared for both their strengths and weaknesses. That doesn't really work with The Joker, since every time the two tangle it seems like he's completely reinvented himself.

One week he's a psychopathic mass murderer who will slaughter anybody who gets in his way; the next, he's all about pulling pranks and tricking Batman with one of those guns that shoots out a little flag reading €œbang!€. He's veered between immaculate clown in make up and suit to abattoir owner who wears his own severed face like a crusty mask over his tender flesh.

In Arkham Asylum, Grant Morrison makes the case for The Joker's €œhypersanity€. He realises he's insane, realises he's part of a cycle that sees him constantly being locked up, breaking out, and so on and so forth. It also suggests that the craziness of Gotham is part of what made The Joker so twisted, and each of his personalities is simply a reaction to that. So every morning he wakes up and starts from scratch, because Gotham has a tendency to change overnight (ie according to different writers/artists).

That makes things confusing, though, because sometimes he's a fun-loving rapscallion, and sometimes he's a mass murderer. Where are you meant to stand on him?


8. The Clown Thing Is Kinda Clichéd

The Joker Photograph
DC Comics

Scary clowns sell movie tickets. They sell books. They sell games. That's why you see them in everything from Stephen King's It to Twisted Metal Black to Northampton. It's a classic nightmarish image, a supposedly innocent and delightful image from childhood trips to the circus twisted into something evil.

A corruption of something juvenile into something all to adult and terrifying. That's why it's been used so often, to the point that it's a cliché. Which is why a creepy, murderous clown showed up in the most recent series of American Horror Story, a show which trades entirely on horror tropes.

Now, when The Joker first appeared that wasn't quite so much a cliché. In fact, the whole Clown Prince Of Crime thing was a pretty smart gimmick for a villain as dark and moody as Batman was ever since the start, with The Joker offering a more colourful, less complicated and seemingly €œhappier€ counterpoint. Since then, though, he's become just another small part in a large tapestry of murderous creepy clowns throughout pop culture, which makes him a heck of a lot less special.

So what was once a unique and brilliant little shtick has since become...not.


7. He's A Total Rip Off

The Man Who Laughs
Universal

Of course, The Joker isn't quite as unique as that even suggests. Credit for the character's creation is disputed, with famous jerk-off Bob Kane and co-conspirator Jerry Robinson claiming most responsibility (whilst reluctantly admitting that Bill Finger made some significant writing contributions).

Even that seems pretty cheeky when you consider that the whole look of the character wasn't invented by Kane nor Robinson, but was lifted wholesale a photo of actor Conrad Veidt as Gwynplaine (a man with a disfigured face, giving him a perpetual grin) in the 1928 film The Man Who Laughs.

Well, technically it was a combination of that and a joker playing card provided by Robinson. Even Kane, who infamously keeps all credit for creating Batman to himself, which is total BS €“ admits that the character's roots are in that film. €œBill Finger had a book with a photograph of Conrad Veidt,€ he told an interviewer back in 1994, €œand showed it to me and said, 'Here's the Joker'.€

So there you go, straight from the horse's mouth. Even if it's a horse that frequently laughs. The iconic look of The Joker, which rarely changes too dramatically? Totally ripped off.


6. He Essentially Has Super Powers

Emperor Joker Comic
DC Comics

The reason that the lack of an origin story is a problem for The Joker is that it places him in rather a different position than the majority of Batman's rogues gallery. Whilst he does have some larger-than-life adversaries like Ra's al Ghul, Killer Croc, Clayface and Orca (shudder), the whole point of the character is that the majority of the villains he faces aren't any more powerful or €œmagical€ than he is.

Scarecrow has that funky gas, and The Penguin has a weird face, but they're still pretty much just human beings. Which is fair, too, since Batman is just a man €“ a highly trained man with a lot of resources, but still just a man. The one superhero in the DC Universe who doesn't actually have superpowers.

And yet his greatest enemy clearly does.

Now, in-universe The Joker is simply just a man, too. Albeit a totally insane one who too has a lot of resources (and a seemingly endless supply of henchman ready to throw their lives away for him at a moment's notice). But he's clearly in possession of some sort of superpowers, or else he wouldn't be able to get away with half of the schemes he's managed to pull of over the years.

No regular person could have the amount of foresight to successfully initiate all of his evil schemes, the ability to be in multiple places at once or else so quickly, the nigh-invulnerability that's kept him alive all this time. The Joker's no man.

You probably knew that though.


5. He Isn't Funny

Joker Killing Joke
DC Comics

Inconsistent though The Joker's various characterisations have been, they usually all fall back on a particular core thing that he wants: to make people laugh. Or, to make himself laugh. Or to make the usually stoic Batman laugh €“ that's the ultimate goal.

Anyway, what The Joker wants desperately, more than anything, is laughs. He's like a deranged Michael McIntyre. Perhaps a little less horrifying. And at least he's fictional. The Clown Prince Of Crime enjoys causing chaos, and trouble, but usually it's all in pursuit of one huge joke, a punchline that is sometimes not so literal...but sometimes is. But here's the rub: The Joker isn't funny. How often have you seen him crack an actual gag in a comic, film, TV or game appearance and actually chuckled? Probably never.

The dude just isn't funny. Perhaps that's why he had to give up the stand up comedy game (if The Killing Joke is to be believed) and get into crime instead. The other gig simply wasn't working out. Regardless, having a character whose whole shtick is based on him being at least semi-humorous and then not having him actually be able to make people laugh? That's bad.

That's what people in the industry call a €œDeadpool€.


4. He Isn't In Love With Batman

Joker Harley Quinn
DC Comics

So why exactly is The Joker so obsessed with Batman? If you throw out the mystical mumbo jumbo of how one cannot exist without the other, that they give each other purpose and all that malarkey, and instead focus on the actual explanations...well, usually writers just plump for the rote €œThe Joker is in love with Batman€.

It's a concept that has long been in the background, but was brought to the fore with the recent Death Of The Family storyline where the Caped Crusader freaked out his nemesis by calling him €œdarling€; itself a call back to The Dark Knight Returns, where he came out of a coma after seeing his love return and uttering the same name. Now that motivation is either wrong-headed, offensive, or somewhere in between the two.

On the latter point, it's sort of perpetuating the idea of homosexuality as a dangerous fringe form of sexuality that lunatics and perverts indulge in. The former is just bad writing. The Joker is in love with Batman? Then the writers who depict him as such have a very shaky grasp on what love is, and you almost certainly shouldn't date them.

Harley Quinn's dangerous romantic obsession with The Joker makes a certain kind of twisted sense. The Joker being in love with Batman €“ on the basis of how he treats Batman - doesn't follow any kind of logic. Even a crazy person's.


3. He's Clearly Mentally Ill (And The Ethical Implications Of That)

Joker Scars Dark Knight
Warner Bros.

Speaking of which, it's all fairly agreed upon that The Joker is insane, right? The guy clearly has mental issues. That's why he has never faced the death penalty, and why he always gets imprisoned in the Arkham Asylum For The Criminally Insane rather than a regular jail.

The law protects people with mental health issues from being €œpunished€ in the same way as someone whose criminal intentions were more clear, and made with a more level head. It's not really fair to punish somebody who isn't of sound mind, because (arguably) they aren't really responsible for their actions.

The incarceration of The Joker certainly matches up with the way criminals with mental illnesses should be treated (to a degree), but what about the rest of the time? Is it not kind of messed up that Batman so gleefully indulges in beating the crap out of the clown, for having a personal vendetta against him, that he blames The Joker for every one of his actions? If you take The Killing Joke origin, he becomes even more tragic.

The Joker has done bad things, but it's because the guys insane. He probably deserves some sympathy. Or at least not repeatedly ending up in the hospital.


2. He Isn't Even The Best Bat Villain

Ras Al Ghul
DC Comics

One of Batman's greatest strengths, rather ironically, is his rogues gallery. He really is a character who's made by his villains, a hero who is defined by those he fights against. It just so happens that he has a particularly brilliant set of villains, from Mr Freeze to Victor Zsaz to Bane and all points in between (well, nearly all points) (not Orca) (shudder).

With the stunning diversity and vast cornucopia of brilliant ideas which populate Batman's seemingly endless roster of adversaries, it seems almost lazy to rely on The Joker all the time. Especially when he proves to be one of the more inflexible villains who nonetheless is an almost constant.

He's inconsistent, but he always tends to return to the one point. He's almost always deployed as Batman's €œgreatest enemy€, and often referred to as such by the Dark Knight himself. But The Joker is...kind of boring. You know he's never going to get killed off, because he's The Joker.

He's never going to change all that much, because he's The Joker. His plans will always come to naught, because he's The Joker. Not a whole lot of room for drama in there, save for the time he killed a Robin and crippled a Batgirl. Both of those turned out to be temporary. The guy doesn't have much of a lasting effect on anything.

But Ra's Al Ghul... now there's a villain.


1. Batman And The Joker Aren't The Same

Batman Joker
Warner Bros.

There are certain €œtheories€ people like to recite like they know everything about the Caped Crusader. Batman isn't the mask, Bruce Wayne is! Hanging out with kids totally isn't weird, he's just pining for his own lost youth! Of course nobody knows his secret identity, he floods the internet with disinformation!

The reason he and The Joker are perpetually engaged in a seemingly endless battle is because they are one and the same, equal and opposite numbers who cannot exist without each other, both borderline insane and equally committed to their causes. Except that's totally wrong. They aren't the same at all.

Any similarities are a stretch, and again play into the idea that the pair are intrinsically entwined on some sort of cosmic level, like it's fate or something. Which, regardless of how you think of the world, doesn't really gel properly with the Batman who thinks ill of criminals for being a €œsuperstitious, cowardly lot€.

Batman and The Joker aren't the same. Not by a long shot.

If they were, it would suggest the former could so easily tip over into being the latter, and vice versa, which are things that will never happen. Maybe not a problem with The Joker himself. Maybe none of these are. Maybe the real problem is the way that we read, watch, and thing about the character. Or maybe he is just a mess of contradictions and half-baked theories.

Why so serious, eh?

Do you agree with this article? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/