10 Reasons Why The New 52 Did Not Work
DC's sprawling and flawed reboot unfortunately did not meet its lofty ambitions.
DC Comics is known for many things, chief among them its propensity to reboot once the brand's ongoing continuity becomes too complicated for fans both old and new to keep up with. The Post-Crisis and Rebirth eras are the most well-known reboots in the 21st century, and its these incarnations of various characters that are the most popular and most frequently adapted in non-comics media.
Enter, the New 52. Poised to replace the Post-Crisis (or Post-Infinite Crisis depending on who you ask) continuity, the companywide revamp was designed to streamline the DC Universe and retool it for the modern era. On paper, this sounded like a solid idea, but as the project dragged on, it was clear that it was doomed to fail.
To be fair, there were a few redeeming qualities about this endeavour. Ideas such as the Court of Owls, and giving Batgirl more agency, were indicative that the New 52 was not a complete failure. Unfortunately, the bad far outweighed the good, and its failings necessitated the Rebirth continuity do-over.
From iffy characterization and visual designs, to lacklustre crossover events and a rushed timeline, the New 52 should serve as a cautionary tale for comic book companies looking to try something new.
10. Strange And Unnecessary Character Redesigns
DC's heroes have striking costume designs that have endured over the last six to eight decades, and for good reason. From their use of primary colours, to simple yet creative visual cues, the outfits belonging to the likes of the Flash and Batman are etched deep within the psyches of many comics fans.
However, the 2011 revamp did not adhere to the "less is more" approach with its characters, and instead opted for costumes with complicated designs that oddly enough preceded the MCU's own strange aesthetic choices regarding its costumes.
Superman's seminal red and blue suit retained its colours, but went for an armoured approach that baffled many fans. Why would a character as durable as Kal-El need armour? Worse still, the "emo teen" appearance that Lobo sported for much of the New 52, completely missed the point of his appeal since his inception.
Other characters such as Barry Allen, Harley Quinn and Hawkman also sported poorly received designs as well, proving that some elements in DC do not require massive overhauls.
9. Cherry Picking What To Keep From Past Continuities Was A Failure
After 2006's Infinite Crisis and 2008's Blackest Night events, there were multiple directions that the DC universe was poised to follow that held a lot of promise. This is not to mention the exciting new direction that stories such as Batman Inc. and the Justice Society were taking before the universe started afresh in the early 2010s.
Unfortunately for the New 52, it made the grave error of discarding years of continuity (and hence stories) in order to start from scratch. But in a rather baffling move, it retained certain elements from the previous era that ended up feeling rather jarring when placed next to the newer stories and settings.
As seen with the Batman and Green Lantern titles, retaining certain parts of the pre-New 52 felt like a pandering move to readers that did not make sense, especially as far as the timespan is concerned (something that will be touched on in detail later).
DC's attempt to have it both ways is a prime example of how a non-committal approach to storytelling rarely, if ever, works out.
8. Intriguing New Ideas Were Quickly Abandoned
To be fair, the New 52 was not a complete disaster. Despite jettisoning great Pre-52 stories and drastic character overhauls, the company revamp had its fair share of potentially intriguing content, at first. For starters, DC revived the WildStorm imprint and developed stories under less popular genres such as Westerns, horror and war stories.
This undertaking offered long-time DC followers and newcomers a wealth of material to go through, as well as a nice alternative to the dominant superhero genre for those who wanted something else. Unfortunately, the publishing company's editorial board unsurprisingly but disappointingly cancelled most of these stories, and instead focused on its stalwart characters and teams.
This incensed many readers, especially those who welcomed the reprieve from multiple Batman and Superman stories and/or were fans of the above mentioned genres. Additionally, this wave of cancellation had the misfortune of seeing the already few PoC-led stories dwindle considerably.
7. Multiple Pre-Reboot Storylines Were Wasted
Following the companywide Blackest Night and Final Crisis events, DC had several stories that had significant promise. Teams such as the Justice Society and the Legion of Superheroes got new tales that reinvigorated their respective brands. In addition to this, DC stalwarts such as Swamp Thing and the Hawkpeople made their long-awaited returns.
Unfortunately, the New 52's arrival heralded the end of these stories in favour of, to put it mildly, divisive tales that lacked the verve and intrigue of their predecessors. This put off a lot of fans, since most of these offerings had not reached their narrative peaks, and starting afresh (or not seeing some of these characters until Rebirth) definitely did not make for an intriguing prospect.
As you will see in detail later on, the New 52 never truly felt lived in due to its brief timespan. This could have been easily countered by finding ways to integrate Pre-52 stories into the new timeline and DC would have had the best of both worlds, both literally and figuratively.
6. Legacy Characters And Teen Heroes Were Afterthoughts
It is fitting that the progenitors of the concept of a sidekick have some of comics' best teen and legacy heroes. Characters such as Dick Grayson, Wally West, Donna Troy and Kara Zor-El managed to step out of their mentors' shadows and become compelling and dynamic heroes in their own right.
The same can be said about teams such as the Teen Titans, Young Justice and the Legion of Superheroes, who all had captivating adventures and devoted fanbases. Despite these storied histories and earned legacies, the New 52 did not hesitate to gut a crucial section of DC and replace it with something far less enjoyable.
It turns out that Dan DiDio harbours a strong dislike of teen heroes and legacy characters, and this manifested in the way their stories felt like afterthoughts. To add insult to injury, beloved figures such as Wally West, Aqualad and Tim Drake had lacklustre replacements or were completely missing in the rebooted timeline.
5. It Did Not Handle Crossover Events Very Well
After Crisis on Infinite Earths, DC became well known for its crossover events. Identity Crisis aside, most DC events were well-received and had actual long-lasting impact on the wider universe.
Unfortunately, the 2010s were not so kind to the franchise as far as its grander stories were concerned. It did not help that these crossover events were editorially mandated, regardless of whether or not they made sense within the continuity itself.
This meant various stories would stop dead in their tracks to accommodate whatever cosmic foe(s) threatened the universe or multiverse. Far from the narrative heights and thrills of Zero Hour and Final Crisis, events such as Trinity War and especially Convergence were damp squibs that could not justify their existence nor bring meaningful change to the DC universe.
It is fitting that the New 52's events were disappointing messes, since its inciting incident - Flashpoint - never truly felt like it was meant to serve as a Crisis-level saga. This set the stage for haphazard crossovers that lacked the weight of their predecessors.
4. Several Stories Felt Like Throwbacks To The Excess Of The 90s
The 1990s was a dark time for the comics industry, and this was primarily marked by poor sales and the development of characters who felt like the very embodiment of teenage angst come to life, so to speak.
While characters such as Deadpool and Cable transcended their origins, their peers did not fare as well and eventually fell out of favour with most readers.
That's why it is all the more baffling that the New 52 saw it prudent to harken back to an era marked by oversized guns, numerous pouches and "grit". In addition to this, this time also embraced these embarrassing visual cues,
DC sourced the services of noted 90s authors and writers such as Rob Liefeld, Ethan van Sciver and Scott Lobdell, and their work reflected their heyday in the worst way possible. While this is not an attack on the above creatives, their sensibilities are best suited for smaller-scale/fringe stories and not flagship characters.
3. Poor Planning And Treatment Of Writers
More than a decade after the New 52 was launched, it has become clear that DC's editorial board more than dropped the ball when it came to the handling of the endeavour. In addition to cancelling intriguing stories and authorizing confusing continuity changes, the overseeing entity mistreated its creatives and held them to its poorly thought-out schemes.
Writers such as Gail Simone, George Perez and Greg Rucka were victims of poor editorial oversight, and their stories were gutted in favour of a slopshod approach that predictably saw diminishing returns as far as creative output and sales went.
Haden Blackman's run on Batwoman was a notable victim of this interference, as the DC head honchos forbade the titular character and her love interest Maggie Sawyer from tying the knot. This decision enraged countless fans and cut short one of the company's most creative tenures at that time.
Just like its cinematic side a few years later, DC struggled with executive oversight that ignored genuine creativity in favour of its own misguided machinations.
2. Questionable Characterization
By now, it is clear that the Post-Crisis era offered the definitive interpretations of many heroes and villains for many fans, and any change made to their personalities would be met with hesitation at the very least. Now, this is not to say that such a revamp is incapable of working, but its execution needs to be spot on and justified.
Some of the Prime-Earth residents received changes to their personalities that were so drastic, they felt like brand new characters, and not in a good way. Heroes such as Martian Manhunter, Wonder Woman and Superman were far cries from their more well-known selves, and as a result were more abrasive, hot-tempered and generally unlikeable.
Unfortunately, poor characterization was felt far strongly with DC's heroines and other female characters. In addition to being oversexualized, characters such as Catwoman, and especially Starfire, felt less like three-dimensional characters and more like props that set the stage for male-dominated stories.
1. A Drastically Compressed Timeline
DC's Post-Crisis era played out across 25 years or so, and while the in-universe timeline did not match up with the real world, it at least felt like a fair amount of time had passed since the debuts of the Justice League's members, villains and fellow heroes in different teams. This allowed for their stories to progress organically across the years and for the seamless introduction of new characters and concepts.
True to form, the New 52 saw its predecessor's approach and did the exact opposite. Instead of having superhero careers play out across 10-15 years, the New 52 played out across a laughably small five-year window. This meant that the vast majority of heroes, villains, teams and organizations debuted around the same time and went through important milestones in half a decade or so.
This becomes even more absurd when you consider that the characters are, for the most, part younger than usual. This means that, for instance, Batman not only had a shortened career, but unsettlingly went through multiple Robins and Batgirls within that period.