10 Shocking Cover Ups Marvel Comics Wants You To Forget
Marvel is not here to make friends, but if they are, they're incredibly bad at it.
Marvel has been operating as a large part of the cultural zeitgeist for over eighty years.
In that time, like any company worth writing about, they've seen astronomical heights and deeply depressing lows. Some of these are well-documented and oft-retold. After all, they are the company with the highest selling single issue of a comic of all time, with 1991's X-Men #1 selling over 8 million copies. On the other end of the spectrum, who could forget the time they declared bankruptcy only five years later?
However, not everything in their history is as well known as these huge events. Marvel have so mant skeletons in their closet that they've started to spill out into the room, and it's very difficult to sweep a skeleton under the rug.
With that in mind, here are some of the strangest, silliest, and most shocking times Marvel have metaphorically driven over their neighbour's dog and pretended it was just a speed bump. Whether it's exploiting a legal loophole, hiding a massive creative failure, or even erasing an artist's entire legacy from the history books, it seems there is no low Marvel won't stoop to in the name of the brand.
10. Jack Kirby Created Everything
When we think of the people who shaped Marvel, it is natural for Stan Lee to pop into our heads. Although he was an undeniable force in building the company's public image and cultural significance, he too often gets credit for actually creating their most famous superheroes. In truth, that credit should be aimed more towards a true unsung hero: Lee's collaborator, Jack Kirby.
You just need to look at their careers side-by-side: Jack Kirby created tons of characters both before and after working with Stan Lee, including the iconic Captain America. But Lee had never created a superhero until he worked with Kirby, and after they stopped collaborating he never went on to create a truly memorable character again (unless you count Stripperella, which you really shouldn't). Kirby's fingerprints are even all over Spider-Man, one of Lee's few characters he 'allegedly' had no hand in creating at all.
Kirby is now championed by other struggling comics creators, seen as somewhat of a martyr for the community. When Mark Waid and Mike Wieringo made a Fantastic Four comic in which the team met God, they made sure to make the Almighty look and act exactly like Kirby.
Image Comics, a company created by writers and artists who were sick of Marvel's "work-for-hire" contracts, originally planned to have "Jack Kirby presents" at the start of all of their comics. This was in protest to Marvel writing "Stan Lee presents" before each title, even if Lee had no involvement with that title.
9. The Spider-Man Deal
Unless you've been living under a rock with no Wi-Fi, you'll no doubt be aware of the recent big scare that all Spider-Fans had. Sony and Disney announced that their deal to share the movie rights to Spider-Man had fallen through, and that we wouldn't be seeing any more of Tom Holland's Peter Parker in the MCU. This was, of course, all patched up in a matter of weeks, with thanks to Holland himself making a drunken phonecall to the powers-that-be and imploring them to think of the fans.
It was very interesting to see how the public reacted to this news when it was first revealed. It seemed that everyone was siding with Disney and Marvel, claiming that Sony were simply being greedy by refusing to give them a bigger slice of the movie profits. The truth is, however, that Marvel were already making much more money than Sony from Spider-Man, and really had no need for that larger share.
See, while Sony gained the majority of profits from the films, Marvel still got 100% of money made from all Spider-Man merchandise. And while a movie would come along every two or three years and make a big splash, Spidey merch makes upwards of one billion dollars every single year. This amount just increases even more whenever a Spider-Man movie is released.
So, while we were all rooting for Marvel, they were quietly profiting even more off the free publicity from the entire controversy.
8. Holding Hulk Hogan Hostage
This all began when a wrestler going by the name of Terry Boulder appeared on a chat show with Lou Ferigno, television's Incredible Hulk. When Terry realised that he was bigger and more muscular than the actor playing one of the strongest creatures on the planet, he decided to flex on him by incorporating it in to his new wrestling name. And thus, Hulk Hogan was born.
As this new Hulk gained popularity in the WWF, Marvel came looking for a slice of the action. As the owners of the Hulk trademark, they were able to reach an agreement. Marvel would own the rights to the Hulk Hogan name, and would licence it to WWF for a fee.
That's right: any time Hogan appeared in the ring, or any time a 'Hulkamania' bandana was sold, Marvel were getting a cut of the profit. By owning the name, the comics company also technically owned the 'character' of Hulk Hogan, and could do anything they wanted with him. Bizarrely, Marvel did not take much advantage of this, only ever occasionally drawing Hogan into the background of a scene, simply because they could.
When Hogan jumped ship to WCW, a rival wrestling league, he changed his name to Hollywood Hogan in order to avoid paying Marvel for existing. Eventually, in 2009, he finally gave in and bought his name back. This was unfortunately followed by a string of controversies that ended his career, just as he finally held the rights to his own likeness.
7. Welcome To Marville
As seen in the final pages of recent series The History of the Marvel Universe, Marvel superheroes have always had one simple mission statement: "with great power there must always come great responsibility." If only those behind the scenes followed the same rules.
Back in 2002, then-president of Marvel Bill Jemas made a bet with writer Peter David that he could write a comic more popular than David's Captain Marvel reboot. Because apparently, even though he was president of the entire company, Jemas still had time to write one of the weirdest, dullest and most nonsensical comics ever made.
The result was Marville, an attempt to satirise superheroes and, oddly enough, the AOL-Time-Warner company. It was an impenetrable read, that needed an extra page just to explain all the industry in-jokes it contained. The thing was, knowing the backstory behind every joke somehow made them even less funny.
After a wholly unsuccessful two issues, Marville moved away from comedy and started to focus on "the origin and the meaning of life." Jemas's ideas on this subject were, frankly, incomprehensible. After six issues that sold almost no issues, the series finally ended, with Jemas proudly announcing:
“Marville has been a story that would never have been published if I didn’t happen to have this here job as President of Marvel.”
Jemas did not keep his job as president for much longer, and Marvel (as well as anyone who read the thing) has since been happily pretending that Marville never existed in the first place.
6. Adapting The Ancient One Is A No-Win Scenario
When Marvel Studios decided to adapt Doctor Strange for the big screen, they ran into a bit of a problem. One of the most important characters in the character's origin story is The Ancient One, a Tibetan monk and, honestly, a bit of an Asian stereotype.
One of the film's writers, C. Robert Cargill, explained that trying to write this character into a Hollywood movie was "Marvel's Kobayashi Maru," a purposely unwinnable training exercise from Star Trek lore. Aside from wanting to avoid writing any stereotypical caricatures, there was also the fact that one of Marvel Studio's largest markets is that of China. And it just so happens that a large amount of Chinese people refuse to acknowledge Tibet as an independent region.
"Every single decision that involves the Ancient One is a bad one... it all comes down on which way you're willing to lose. The Ancient One was a racist stereotype who comes from a region of the world that is in a very weird political place. He originates from Tibet, so if you acknowledge that Tibet is a place and that he's Tibetan, you risk alienating one billion people who think that that's bulls**t and risk the Chinese government going, 'Hey, you know one of the biggest film-watching countries in the world? We're not going to show your movie because you decided to get political.'"
Instead, they opted to cater towards neither China nor Tibet, and cast Tilda Swinton, catering towards... fans of Wes Anderson movies, we guess?
5. Stan Lee Is Sued By Stan Lee
Although Stan Lee may not have been the genius superhero creator that many remember him as, there is no denying that he was a super savvy businessman who knew how to publicise and market the Marvel brand. With the rise of the internet in the late nineties, he applied this business know-how to found a start-up company called Stan Lee Media, which would focus on creating new superhero media for the web.
When the company began to lose money fast during the dot com meltdown of the early 2000s, Lee himself decided to leave and focus on his new venture, POW! Entertainment. You would think that the departure of Stan Lee himself would spell the end of Stan Lee Media, but the shareholders did not think the same way.
As a company bearing the name Stan Lee, they decided that they must be partial owners of everything the real Stan Lee had ever created, and began to sue just about anyone they could in an attempt to cash in on that name. What followed was a series of ridiculous and frivolous lawsuits, spanning over 15 years, with Stan Lee Media going up against Marvel, Disney and even Stan Lee himself. Can you imagine the confusion of going up in court against a company that beared your name, but was in no way connected to you?
4. Howard The Duck Is A Clone
Like Jack Kirby before him, Steve Gerber is no stranger to contract disputes with Marvel, as well as other powerful companies. When his satirical character Howard the Duck was unveiled in 1973, he was immediately scrutinised by Disney for bearing a more than striking resemblance to Donald Duck. This didn't stop him from becoming a huge hit with comic book fans, leading to him being the title character in the first ever cinematic Marvel movie in 1986.
However, when Gerber saw the amount of money that the company was making from his creation, he became dissatisfied with his standard "work-for-hire" contract. Even though he had developed a smash hit, he was still only paid by the page and didn't own the rights to Howard. When they started to allow other writers to work on the character, Gerber became so frustrated that he quit Marvel altogether.
He teamed up with Jack Kirby to create Destroyer Duck for Eclipse Comics. This duck's main storyline involved him trying to save his friend, a duck known as "the Little Guy", who had been held hostage and exploited by a thoughtless giant conglomeration called “Godcorp”. It was later revealed that the Little Guy was actually a clone of the original Howard, named Leonard the Duck. Then, in a crossover with Savage Dragon, it was revealed that Leonard was actually the original Howard, and the Howard in the Marvel comics was the clone.
It was essentially a very complicated but very effective middle finger to Gerber's former employers.
3. The Reign Of The America Men
Rob Liefeld is no stranger to controversy within the comics community. As one of the rabble-rousing troublemakers who shook up the entire industry when he came up with the idea for Image Comics, he commands respect from all struggling creatives. However, he has been involved in enough scandals and troubles that his name can also send a shiver down the spine of those same creatives.
When Liefeld, alongside Jeph Loeb, was commissioned to revamp Captain America for Marvel Comics, the results were terrible. Marvel cancelled the series, acting as if it had never happened.
Liefeld and Loeb still had untold Captain America stories that they had been planning, so they decided to continue these stories with a different hero: Fighting American. Fighting American was a Cap clone created by Cap's actual creators, Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, back when Marvel had put them in a very similar situation over forty years prior.
However, even this didn't work, as Simon and Kirby's widow Roz demanded too much money for Fighting American's rights. So, Liefeld went ahead and created a clone of both Captain America and Fighting American named Agent America. Now with three characters in comics who all looked and acted almost exactly the same, the ensuing legal shenanigans were messy to say the least.
2. Ike Perlmutter, The CEO In The Shadows
Ike Perlmutter, the former CEO and current chairman of Marvel Entertainment, is a mysterious man. So much so, that until recently, the last known photograph of him available to the public was one taken in the 1980s. However, the hack that leaked Sony's emails a few years ago ended up revealing quite a lot about the shadowy figure.
If there is one criticism that the Marvel Cinematic Universe often (and fairly) receives, it's a lack of diversity in its leading characters. Until Black Panther and Captain Marvel were given their own solo films, every protagonist the studio had ever produced was another white man. These two films went on to become two of the highest grossing non-team-up movies in the series, proving that the audience was hungry for them. If Perlmutter hadn't been asked by Disney and Kevin Feige to step away from Marvel's film division, this would very likely never have happened.
Perlmutter simply believed that female superheroes were not profitable, and wrote an email citing films like Elektra, Catwoman and Supergirl as proof of his theory. He also had some choice words about non-white actors playing superheroes, allegedly stating that nobody would notice if they recast Terrence Howard's War Machine with Don Cheadle, as all black people "look the same".
It's no coincidence that movies like Captain Marvel, Black Panther, and Black Widow began development almost immediately after Perlmutter stood down.
1. Marvel Superheroes Are Not Legally Human
The X-Men have historically had a rough time of it. Although they have the mutant gene in their DNA, for decades they have been trying to prove that they are still human beings and deserve to be treated with the same rights as everyone else. They have served as a metaphorical stand-in for countless minority groups who have suffered the same discrimination. At the very least, their creators would never denounce their humanity, especially not to simply make a quick buck. Right?
Wrong! Very, very wrong.
When Marvel went into business with ToyBiz in the early nineties, they collaborated on a line of X-Men action figures. However, because dolls were taxed higher than other toys, Marvel decided to try and exploit a legal loophole. The definition of a 'doll' was a toy modeled on a human person, so Marvel simply declared that the X-Men were not human people. Therefore, any model of an X-Man was not technically a doll, and they saved themselves a nice lump of cash in tax.
Marvel went further, denouncing the humanity of their non-mutant heroes too. Eventually, the Fantastic Four, Spider-Man, and all of his villains were considered legally non-human.
When word of this got out, both fans and comics creators themselves felt betrayed that Marvel would so easily dismiss the humanity of the characters they loved. Marvel attempted to calm this by claiming they believed their heroes to be MORE than human, not less than, and ended up sounding like a business-savvy Magneto.
Watch Next
Marvel Quiz: Can You Name These Obscure Avengers?