10 Times Comics Made Terrible Villains Great
These guys went from nobody to nightmare.
Creating supervillains can be a tricky business. Most superheroes have been fighting crime for decades and things can get stale if they’re just beating up the same few bad guys again and again. The pressure is always on for writers to come up with new and exciting adversaries to overcome, ones that match up to the hero’s classic rogues’ gallery.
Unfortunately, they don’t always hit the mark; for every Joker or Doctor Doom, there are invariably dozens of Killer Moths and Stilt-Men. Losers destined to be forgotten, unceremoniously slaughtered or doomed to the back of crowd shots for the rest of time.
However, some villains get lucky. Sometimes another writer will come along and see a spark of potential buried amongst the rubbish costumes and ridiculous super powers and give them a second chance. They’ll brush off the cobwebs and reinvent the character, taking a living punching bag and turning them into a true force to be reckoned with.
Here are ten of the worst villains who great writers rescued from the rubbish bin.
10. Maxie Zeus - Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earth
Maxie Zeus turned to a life of crime after his wife left him. While most men in his position would probably just buy a flashy car and start wearing double denim, Maxie instead slapped on a toga, declared himself to be the god Zeus and tried to take over Gotham’s underworld.
Unsurprisingly, he failed and Maxie and his amazing beard were left to rot in Arkham Asylum, destined to be forever remembered as a complete loser.
That would all change though when Maxie appeared in Grant Morrison’s phenomenal Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth.
Batman is trapped inside the madhouse and as he makes his way through the metaphorical (and possibly literal) Hell on Earth, he finds Maxie strapped to an electric chair. It’s a haunting scene, filled with religious imagery and brought to life by Dave McKean’s ethereal art. As the electricity cascades over him, Maxie Zeus genuinely seems like the god he imagines himself to be. He is equal parts benevolent and terrifying, even as he clings to a bucket of his own faeces.
Maxie Zeus doesn’t play a huge part in Arkham Asylum, but his appearance is sure to give him a starring role in your nightmares.
9. Arcade - Avengers Arena
For years, Arcade seemed like the punchline to a bad joke. This Marvel villain was a professional hitman who tried to assassinate heroes by building amusement-park themed deathtraps, specifically tailored to each target. These “Murderworlds” were a wildly impractical (and no-doubt expensive) method which killed less people than most actual theme parks.
That, combined with the questionable fashion sense of a white suit and polka dot bowtie, makes you wonder why anyone would ever hire this guy.
However, Arcade would become much deadlier in Avengers Arena by Dennis Hopeless. Inspired by a certain series of young adult novels, he kidnapped a group of teen heroes and forced them to fight to the death on his own private island.
Murderworld finally lived up to its name as numerous characters were killed off and even Arcade became a threat, using a mixture of technology and magic to give himself full control of the island and disintegrating Avengers Academy student Mettle.
Even though the surviving heroes managed to escape, Arcade managed to evade justice at the end of the series. However, he would get his comeuppance in the sequel Avengers Undercover, ending up strapped to the front of a stolen SHIELD Helicarrier.
8. The Orb - Original Sin
It takes a lot to go up against Ghost Rider; the biker from hell has fought literal demons and angels and still found a way to win. Drake Shannon had a special helmet that looked like an eye. He thought that would make him a match for Ghost Rider. He was wrong.
After being little more than a nuisance to Johnny Blaze, The Orb was eventually killed. To add insult to injury, it wasn’t even another hero or villain who did him in. He was shot by the henchmen of fellow D-Lister Plantman.
That was the last anyone saw of The Orb until a new version of appeared in Jason Aaron’s Ghost Rider run. Instead of a helmet, this unnamed character had an eye for a head and a habit of never shutting-up despite not having a mouth.
This new character was a creepy and darkly hilarious oddball who liked to take people’s eyes and “roll around naked on giant piles of them”. He even played a pivotal role in the crossover event Original Sin, revealing the darkest secrets of Marvel’s heroes and eventually becoming the new Watcher, albeit one who gets his kicks watching violent crimes.
7. Calendar Man - Batman: The Long Halloween
There’s no way around it, Calendar Man is ridiculous. Obsessed with calendars of all things, Julian Gregory Day (whose parents are the real villains here) has the incredibly restrictive modus operandi of only committing crimes that correspond to holidays. Initially wearing a different horrible costume for each day of the week, he eventually settled on one which was somehow worse than them all and started running around in a cape made of calendars.
Surprisingly, this misfit was redeemed by none other than Jeph Loeb. Before he started writing stories that are the equivalent of watching your house burn down, Loeb wrote the excellent Batman: The Long Halloween. In it, The Dark Knight is tracking a new criminal known as “The Holiday Killer” and goes to Arkham Asylum to consult the similarly-themed Calendar Man.
Day is portrayed as a sinister mastermind akin to Hannibal Lecter. He knows the killer’s real identity but won’t share it, leading Batman on a tense game of cat and mouse as he constantly taunts him with clues.
This version of the villain also made it into Batman: Arkham City as one of the game’s best Easter eggs, giving out different dialogue based on the date.
6. Doctor Destiny - The Sandman
Doctor Destiny is not the worst villain on this list. He was an early Justice League enemy and managed to give the team a fair run for their money. However, in an age where new bad guys would show up constantly, he didn’t stand out. He lacked any real motivation and his ability to control dreams was only used for some half-baked plan involving replacing superheroes and hoping no-one would notice.
John Dee was just another face in a villainous crowd until he was reinvented in Neil Gaiman’s masterpiece The Sandman. The series retconned his powers as being derived from a stolen artefact belonging to Morpheus, the personification of dreams, and that by trying to stop him using it, the Justice League had accidentally made him unable to dream.
This drove Dee mad and caused him to start wasting away until he looked inhuman, skin stretched so thinly across his face he no-longer needed a skull mask to look nightmarish. In a chilling story, he took an entire restaurant hostage and submitted them to a series of horrific tortures, before ordering them to kill each other.
Perhaps even worse, the story ended with Doctor Destiny getting exactly what he wanted, his ability to dream restored.
5. Black Hand - Blackest Night
Black Hand was a weird mishmash of ideas. Instead of having any sort of hand-related powers, he was a scientist who got his name from being the black sheep of the Hand family. He also believed that all old sayings were true for some reason and would let that shape his plans.
Despite professing to be “the criminal who cannot fail”, Black Hand’s plan to steal Green Lantern’s power failed when Hal exploited his weakness to being punched in the face. He would go on to top this by quitting villainy to open an adult theatre, then having a breakdown and going back to villainy only to have his hand turned to coal by The Spectre.
The only way for Green Lantern writer Geoff Johns to fix the character was to completely rewrite him. Black Hand became a death-obsessed nutjob and serial murderer who slept in an open grave.
As part of the Blackest Night event, he killed himself and came back as head of the Black Lanterns. Leading an army of superpowered zombies, he attacked DC’s heroes with their lost loved ones and summoned the dark god Nekron, who nearly wiped out all life on the planet.
4. Boomerang - Superior Foes Of Spider-Man
This guy, right? A disgraced baseball pitcher, Fred Myers decided to use his incredible aim to become a second-rate Bullseye specialising in an obsolete weapon. While he’s mostly known for being a Spider-Man villain, Bullseye in his first appearance was hilariously mismatched against the Hulk.
For years Boomerang was the definitive D-list villain, a joke character used as a punching bag by half the Marvel universe whose biggest accomplishment was standing in the same group shot as bigger villains.
Unlike most of this list, Boomerang didn’t become a criminal genius or deadly assassin. Instead, he became the lead character in Nick Spencer’s Superior Foes of Spider-Man. This criminally underrated series was a hilarious look at the lives of a group of white-collar criminals as they get involved in the biggest heist of their careers.
Boomerang and the rest of his Sinister Six (which only had five members) will never be on the same level as the Green Goblin or Doctor Doom but that’s what makes them so incredibly likable. They’re underdogs trying to make something of themselves in a world that sees them as nothing more than jokes.
3. The Scorpion - Marvel Knights Spider-Man
Scorpion should have been one of Spider-Man’s biggest foes. With a personal vendetta against both Peter and J. Jonah Jameson, plus powers of superhuman strength and resilience that even Spidey struggled to contend with, it seemed like Mac Gargan was set to reach the same heights as other classic villains of the era like Electro and Sandman.
Unfortunately, Scorpion fell foul to every villain’s kryptonite, diminishing returns. With each subsequent appearance, he was defeated that little bit easier and his character devolved further and further until his defining characteristic was how depressed he was at always being beaten by Spider-Man.
The character got a much-needed boost though in Mark Millar’s Marvel Knights Spider-Man by replacing Eddie Brock as Venom. The symbiote itself had also suffered a huge drop in credibility, to the point where it could be scared off with just a lighter, but Millar’s skilful combination of the two characters sent them right back to the A-list.
This Venom was a brutal monster, replacing Brock’s anti-heroic tendencies with a habit of eating his opponents alive. As one of Norman Osborn’s right hand men, he served on both the Thunderbolts and the Dark Avengers before being finally taken down.
2. Catman - Villains United
If there’s one thing Batman absolutely needed it was another silly gimmick villain. To make matters worse, Thomas Blake didn’t even come up with his own silly gimmick, he just nicked Catwoman’s. Then again, maybe that’s a good start for someone aiming to be a master thief.
Regardless, getting on the bad side of both Gotham’s top hero and one of its top villains is never a good idea, and Catman soon found himself caged. Worse still, the character then became a laughing stock, portrayed as a fat incompetent slob who heroes were embarrassed to have in their rogues’ gallery.
Despite seemingly being eaten by a gorilla (you’d be surprised how often it happens), Catman showed up again in Gail Simone’s Villains United. Realising what a loser he had become, Blake decided to get back in touch with his roots by living with a pack of lions. He managed to not get eaten, even after becoming pure beefcake, and joined up with a bunch of fellow no-name villains to form the Secret Six.
The quirky supervillain team then got their own incredible series and Catman got plenty of moments to shine, even managing to fight Batman himself to a standstill.
1. Deadshot - Suicide Squad
DC’s coolest assassin may be a surprising addition to this list, but Deadshot had a long road to get to where he is today.
The character dates back all the way to 1950 where he was involved in a weird plot to replace Batman whilst dressed in a top hat and tails like he’d just come back from the opera via the Old West.
In later appearances, he would adopt his classic red outfit and silver facemask but still struggled to live up to his own hype. For someone whose whole deal is never missing, his targets always seemed suspiciously lacking in bullet holes.
Deadshot wouldn’t live up to his potential until the 1980s when he became part of John Ostrander’s Suicide Squad. The book finally made him earn his reputation as a master assassin and fleshed out his character to become a stone-cold killer who would happily take on dangerous missions, not caring if he lived or died.
Deadshot was the breakout character of the series, earning himself a spin-off book that explored his tragic origins and has been one of DC’s most popular villains ever since.