10 Times DC Went Too Far
DC comics are supposed to be the happy hopeful ones, right? Well, someone tell them that.
The appeal of DC's heroes is exactly the opposite of Marvel's. While Marvel had heroes you could look out the window and see swinging through the New York skyline, DC created heroes that were meant to be ideals to strive toward. We could never be Superman, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try anyway.
Sure would be nice if the writers and higher ups at DC remembered this from time to time!
Because dark and gritty comics are all the rage (or so they keep telling us), DC keeps feeling the need to push the boundaries of what they can get away with in these stories and with these characters, both of which (by the way), were originally intended for children.
The reason for this is obvious. Comic book companies, even the big two, are in a constant battle to keep their books in the black, so they need to ensure that you come back for the next issue. A tale as old as the industry itself.
But there are just some lines that you don't cross if you want to stay respectable or considered basically decent people. These are the times DC thought it could straddle those lines, and ended up accidentally pole vaulting right over them - much to the disappointment of their readers.
10. The Death Of Jason Todd - A Death In The Family
Despite its fame, this one sits at the bottom because DC is not the only one at fault here. Fans famously despised the post-crisis version of Jason Todd, so when A Death In The Family was announced, DC provided a call in poll about what fans felt should be done about Jason Todd. The voting was unanimous: kill em'.
And so DC proceeded to do exactly that, and the death pretty much overshadows everything else about the story. I mean, in this same story, Joker gets appointed in a position within the Iranian government. Remember that? Of course you don't, because just a few issues later he's taking a crowbar to Jason Todd until the kid is reduced to putty.
What makes the scene so utterly haunting is that you see every second of it. Each swing of that crowbar is given two panels, one to show the wind-up, the other to show the impact. And while you never see the actual damage, you really don't need to because of that.
It was the first time DC had killed someone in such a visceral fashion. But it was far from the last.
9. Maxwell Lord Murders Blue Beetle - Countdown To Infinite Crisis
The life of Ted Kord is one of the most fascinating in comic history, not just of DC. After being adopted into the DC universe during Crisis on Infinite Earths, Ted hung around, helping out where he could. Sure he wasn't as smart as Batman, but he was definitely more approachable and better with people.
And then they killed him.
And they didn't just kill him. Oh no, they had Maxwell Lord pull one of the most confusing heel turns into villainy comics readers are likely to see, and then had him blow Ted's brains out, the next panel hyper focusing on his mangled death mask staring off into space as blood oozes from his skull.
Countdown to Infinite Crisis really is a good story, but killing off Ted Kord, and doing so in such a gratuitously brutal way, was just stepping over the line.
This is definitely not the last we'll be seeing of the Infinite Crisis event on this list. But Ted Kord's death was about as perfect a sign of what readers were in for.
8. Superman And Wonder Woman Have (Literally) Earth Shattering Sex - The Dark Knight Strikes Again
What even WAS The Dark Knight Strikes Again? Can anyone who was actually alive when it came out explain? Because as someone who just got done reading it (and currently trying to talk myself out of tearing out my eyeballs because of it) I am utterly stumped.
There are so many points where this book goes too far, that I barely knew where to begin. Then I got to the part where Superman and Wonder Woman kill a LOT of people just from having sex, and my path was suddenly clear.
I'll spare you the context behind this because I don't want to give it the honor of describing it, but basically, Superman and Wonder Woman finally decide to bone. And the resulting sex causes earthquakes and tsunamis around the entire planet, likely killing hundreds - if not thousands of people. And all for one stupid pun Wondie makes at the end. The artwork definitely doesn't help, the once clever caricature-style art of TDKR just looking sloppy here in the sequel, and it only has the effect of making both Supes and Wonder Woman far uglier than their past stories would suggest.
Like the rest of TDKSA, it was just a poorly thought out, poor taste scene that looked ugly and just made you feel uncomfortable after reading it.
7. Alexandra DeWitt Gets Fridged - Green Lantern #54
A moment so heinous that it's still being referenced today, the death of Kyle Rayner's girlfriend Alexandra is one of the most infamous acts of brutality in DC canon.
After the deaths of the other Green Lanterns at the hands of a psychotic Hal Jordan, Kyle Rayner is recruited as the one and only remaining Green Lantern. This soft reboot of the franchise left a lot of fans irrationally angry in a way that I don't have the patience to get into today. But the series would get flak from a completely different front when Major Force brutally murdered Kyle's girlfriend and stuffed her body in a refrigerator for pure shock value, and to just give motivation to Kyle.
This vexed writer and all around awesome person Gail Simone so badly, that she coined the phrase "women in refrigerators" and listed every single time a woman was violated, harmed, murdered or de-powered just to give a man motivation in either Marvel or DC's comics.
The death of Alex was just so pointless besides giving Kyle something to be sad about. And to this day, the writers of that issue have not heard the end of it, thanks to the trope being immortalized by the shorthand "fridging".
6. Lian Harper's Death - Cry For Justice
If there is anything that DC and Marvel have in common, one similarity is that they choose the stupidest stuff to stay permanent. Every poignant death is reversed due to popularity, no loss is ever truly permanent, and whenever the world changes drastically, it will always shift back into place.
Unless your name is Roy Harper. Then you are the DC universe's punching bag and are never allowed nice things.
It was hard to pick just one of the many injustices heaped upon poor Roy Harper throughout DC history, but the worst offense of all was the casual murder of his daughter Lian.
Those who were fans of the Titans in the nineties know Lian as the most adorable little girl on the face of the planet. Those who became fans in the 2000s know her as the kid who was killed in a single panel during an abysmal event comic called Cry For Justice. And it isn't just the death that irked fans so badly, it was just how casual they were about killing her. You get one little panel of the heroes reacting to the death, then it is never brought up or acknowledged again in the comic.
It was nothing short of shock tactics done poorly, and the fact that it took DC nearly a decade to realize that this wasn't a hill worth dying on is frankly atrocious.
5. Wally West Murders Everyone - Heroes In Crisis
Tom King's run on Batman had already ruffled some feathers, but they pale in comparison to the ire raised by his event comic, Heroes In Crisis - a story about a murder mystery taking place around a therapeutic sanctuary for traumatized superheroes. Long story short, the killer is revealed to be Wally West, who had just been returned to the DC Universe after spending years in limbo.
He used the VR therapy machines at the sanctuary to frame Booster Gold AND Harley Quinn simultaneously for the murders, including his own (which was really himself from five days in the future - it's complicated). So while the heroes go on a wild goose chase figuring out which of the two really did it, he could get off scot free.
Wally had many reasons for doing this, all of them complicated and we don't really have time to dig into it all. But not five years after bringing back this beloved character, does DC decide to pull something this gruesome on him. Nothing short of shameful.
4. Black Adam Rips A Man In Half - 52
52 is rightly regarded as one of the absolute best DC stories ever written in the last few decades. An incredibly interesting story of the DC universe dealing with the fallout of Infinite Crisis, exploring the new multiverse of 52 parallel universes that spawned from the event, the series pulled together a number of creators and put the spotlight on lesser-known characters like the Question, who rose up to occupy the void left behind by DC's Trinity.
However, in this otherwise hopeful story of heroes coming together, there are also moments of gratuitous brutality. And, well, you read the title to this entry, and there's not a lot of room for interpretation there. Black Adam, once the previous wielder of the magic of the wizard Shazam, has since become the ruler of the nation of Kahndaq.
Naturally, he isn't the nicest guy when it comes to people breaking his rules. As demonstrated when Black Adam decides to pay the Kahndaq embassy in New York a visit to say hi to the locals, grease some palms with ambassadors, and maybe try some of that New York pizza he's never had time in between slug fights with Captain Marvel to taste.
Oh, and rip poor, poor Terra-man in two. He also does that.
3. Joker Slices His Face Off - Detective Comics #1
Scott Snyder's run on Batman and Tony S. Daniels' run on Detective Comics were both highlights of the New 52, but there were definitely times when they both could crank up the dark for no apparent reason.
The most famous example of this from Snyder and Daniels' tenure is from the lead up to the otherwise excellent Death of the Family storyline. Specifically Detective Comics #1, where The Joker allows Batman to capture him and send him to Arkham, where he then gets in contact with the villain Dollmaker. Why? Because he wanted Dollmaker to slice his face off!
If you're waiting for why he does this, you're gonna be waiting here for a while.
Oh sure he gives some kind of rambling explanation when he returns in Death Of The Family about how it's symbolic of how low he's truly sunk. But Batman Endgame did the same thing and it had about zero face slicing (on the contrary, he brainwashed the Justice League to attack Bruce, which was amazing).
There's just no reason as to why this was the best course of action to symbolize this new depth of depravity for the Joker besides Daniels wanting something grotesque to end his debut issue on. At least he had the good sense to ascribe this act to the Joker, whose actions don't really need to make sense.
2. Superboy Prime Kills Pantha - Infinite Crisis
Infinite Crisis is one of the most divisive event comics that DC has ever published. And most of this centres around whether or not it's hypocritical in its condemnation of grim dark storytelling. On one hand, the lashing that this story gives the DC heroes (and by proxy, DC as a company) for letting what was once filled with hope and optimism get so dour and grim and gory is well deserved and satisfying to watch.
On the other hand, Superboy Prime punches Pantha's head off.
Granted that's not all that he accomplishes in this scene, but it's definitely the most shocking and visceral of all the acts of brutality that Superboy Prime commits while fighting the Titans. Not only was it just a dumb way to kill a character that turned out to have a MUCH larger following than writer Geoff Johns anticipated, but it's so indulgently gory that it undoes - even if just a little - the very critique it set out to make about the DC universe at the time.
1. Doctor Light Rapes Sue Dibny - Identity Crisis
Gore is one thing. Gore can be entertaining as hell. If you're writing horror, it's almost expected, and sometimes it's the only death fitting of certain characters. While the other entries on this list may have pushed the envelope a bit in terms of taste or respect for the audience, this plot point in Identity Crisis actively angers DC's readers, and this author personally.
Identity Crisis up until this reveal was a legitimately fun closed door murder mystery. But when it revealed that Doctor Light had brutally raped Sue Dibny (whose equally brutal death set off this whole story to begin with) and that was what drove the league to wipe his and Batman's minds, all that was left was utter contempt for the whole thing.
It's not just the fact that Doctor Light raped her - though that definitely doesn't help at all. It's the fact that this story took so sensitive a topic, that is guaranteed to put a lot of readers on edge to begin with, and just used it to drive the plot. This, combined with Sue Dibny being so horribly murdered at the beginning, shows two things: that the writers of this story saw Sue less as a character and more of a punching bag to motivate the heroes, and that they see sexual assault not as a sensitive topic that requires respect and a careful hand, but as a cheap way to make their story appear more "adult" and "gritty".
It is, in no uncertain terms, the most egregious example of DC going too far.
Watch Next
DC Comics Quiz: How Well Do You Know The DC Universe?