10 Times Superheroes Fought The WRONG Villain
Daredevil's most famous adversary was originally Spider-Man's...
The really funny part about having a shared superhero universe is that characters from other books can just... show up, unannounced. No one really bats an eye when Batman appears in Metropolis or when Spidey goes swinging with Daredevil. They're pals - what do you expect?
But if you want some real fun, you explore what happens when those superheroes run afoul of someone else's bad guy.
While if done wrong it can just seem out of place, if done right, it can make the universe feel all the more alive by giving these disparate characters their own dynamic between each other. It's always fun to see what happens when you take a hero and a villain who seem completely mismatched in terms of style, tone, and power level, and see how both parties adapt to the new challenge. And if you do it REALLY right, you can fundamentally redefine both characters forever.
These superheroes really had no business tangling with these villains, but that just makes it all the more fun. to watch.
10. Daredevil And Mysterio - Guardian Devil
If you want good old fashioned comic book weirdness mixed with eighties gen-x cynicism, look no further than the library of work by one Kevin Smith. And nowhere is this mix more starkly apparent, for good and for ill, than in his brief tenure on Daredevil. Specifically, when Daredevil took on Mysterio in the Guardian Devil storyline.
Frankly, any storyline involving Mysterio has no right to be anything other than wacky comic book goodness. In this story, Mysterio tricks a teenage girl, and by extension Daredevil, into thinking she's pregnant with the antichrist, due to being diagnosed with an inoperable brain tumor and wanting to go out by driving Daredevil mad.
After some insane and tragic shenanigans, including the murder of longtime love interest Karen Page, Daredevil finally runs Mysterio down and does the worst thing you can do to someone as obsessed with showmanship and appearances as he is: he riffs his scheme to pieces and berates him as unoriginal, pointing out how previous villains have done the exact same thing he did, and always unsuccessfully.
Realizing that he failed to break the Man Without Fear, and not wanting to go out via some brain tumor slowly killing him, Mysterio kills himself straight after.
9. Superman And Deathstroke - Superman #32
The DC universe has many killers for hire, but none of them are more effective - at least on Earth - than Deathstroke. Slade Wilson is so good at his job that, despite being a mostly normal squishy human, just with some bits and bobs added in, he has on multiple occasions felt confident enough in his abilities that he decided to go head to head with Superman.
This often has varying degrees of success, from the knock down drag out brawl in the New 52, to Superman drunkenly flicking Deathstroke with his finger and sending him skipping across the ocean in Superman: American Alien. There was also a confrontation between the pair in Deathstroke's own comic, where he used fake Kryptonite bullets to confuse the Man of Steel, but the best one for my money was during Superman Rebirth #32.
The interesting thing about this fight is that it is more of a battle of wills and wit than of fists, which are of course often the most interesting brawls that Supes gets into. When Slade sets an entire building on fire to lure Lois out, he holds her at gunpoint and gives Superman an ultimatum: kill him and save Lois, or watch her die. Superman, once he gets a chance to cool down, decides to not play Deathstroke's game and focus on putting out the blaze and save the other people trapped.
He later finds Lois alive and well in a safehouse, with a note left by Deathstroke stating that he never intended to harm her. Apparently this was all a test by Deathstroke's employers to see just how far Superman would go if push came to shove.
8. Justice League And Terminus - JLA/Avengers
One of the all time greatest comic book crossovers was - of course - JLA/Avengers, the epic maxi-series detailing the one (canonical) time when the DC and Marvel universes went head to head.
The story revolves around the DC villain Kronos striking a deal with the Grandmaster to decide whether or not Kronos gets to see the origin of all life (which would require destroying all life, which is why he can't just - ya know - HAVE it).
The story properly begins with an epic as hell use of in media res, where the Justice League are fighting the Marvel villain Terminus. Since he's something they'd never seen before, naturally they have a pretty hard time of it at first, but eventually they are able to wear the giant alien robot thing down. Which of course just leaves them with the question of the hour: what in 13 and 1/4 hells was that thing?
Fortunately, they don't have to wait long for an answer, as the story very quickly gets moving at top speed.
7. Blue Beetle And Giganta - Blue Beetle #19
One of the biggest hurdles for rebooting a hero with a new guy/girl is coming up with a brand new rogues gallery for them to fight.
The reboot of Blue Beetle actually managed to circumvent this problem by having the new villains be a constant presence in Jaime's life, and the lack of a memorable original rogues gallery in either his or his predecessor's arsenal was made up for by having those main villains hire or outsource other DC villains to do their dirty work.
In the 19th issue of the 2006 run of Blue Beetle, La Dama - Jaime's crime boss rival and loving aunt to one of his best friends - is attacked by Wonder Woman baddie Giganta.
As she chases La Dama through the streets, every trick Blue Beetle tries to bring her down bounces right off of her because he's trying to subdue her like she's a normal woman, when in actuality, being - well - gigantic, requires you to magically enhance your body so that it can handle the strain of being that large without collapsing into a pile of broken bones and screaming.
Only when he internalizes Peacemaker's lesson about the subtleties of the human body does he finally figure out how to use Giganta's size against her.
6. Batman And The Reverse Flash - The Flash: The Button
There are generally two heroes' rogues galleries that most heroes just would not last long against: Superman's and Flash's. Clark and Barry are two of the heaviest hitters the DC universe has to offer, so if someone can last even five minutes against them, it's safe to say most other heroes would be up the creek without a boat, much less a paddle.
So along came the infamous crossover between The Flash and Batman and prelude to Doomsday Clock: The Button. Where the greatest enemy of The Flash - The Reverse Flash - comes to tangle with Batman.
For story reasons we don't have time to get into, The Reverse Flash ends up in the Batcave, because when you're as fast as The Flash and without the handicap of silly things like "morals", you can kinda just go wherever you want.
While Barry does contribute to this fight as well, Batman spends a pretty long time taking Reverse Flash all on his lonesome, just barely surviving the fight with the evil speedster, but managing to get the drop on him more than once because - well - this IS Batman on his home turf, of course he has a trick or two up his sleeve for this.
5. Ms. Marvel And Shocker - Ms. Marvel #35
During the time of this issue, Ms. Marvel had quite enough to worry about, having fallen out with her idol Carol Danvers and trying to keep her personal relationships - particularly with her childhood friend Bruno - from completely falling apart. The last thing she needs is a C-List Spidey villain muscling in on her turf.
So anyway, Shocker shows up.
Now, Shocker may be easy pickings against someone with the advantages of Spider-Man, but Kamala does not have those advantages, so while she does hold her own against the villain, to the point where he's mainly played for laughs, those shockwave gauntlets are no joke, and Kamala gets knocked around pretty heavily throughout the issue.
The fight comes to a draw when Bruno whisks her away via wormhole tech, leaving a very confused Shocker standing in the street alone like a dope, most likely wondering why he even bothered getting out of bed that morning.
The fight is entertaining not just because of how our heroine uses her powers in a combat situation she is at a disadvantage against, but also because of how this fight only exacerbates her frustrations with the entire world.
4. Batgirl And Livewire - Batman: The Animated Series
One of the best things about the final season of Batman: The Animated Series was all of the crossover episodes with Superman: The Animated Series, best showcased with the episode Girls Night Out.
In this episode, Livewire breaks out of a prison convoy taking her through Gotham to prison, so while she's in town, she decides to shack up with Poison Ivy and Harley, who are now living together for reasons they weren't allowed to explicitly state back then.
Thankfully the solo Batgirl gets some much needed help from Supergirl, and the two take on the three villainesses.
It all ends in an awesome fight in the zoo where the three baddies are hiding out in, where Batgirl manages to actually take down Livewire - someone who can manage to fight Superman to a standstill - on her own. Granted she has some help from Supergirl wrecking the place during her fight, which gives her a nice supply of water to toss Livewire into to finish the job, but hey, it's still her victory.
3. Captain America And Prometheus - JLA/Avengers
Frankly this whole list could be filled to the brim with fights from this classic crossover to end all crossovers, but in terms of heroes fighting the wrong villain for their book, there were none more satisfying than when Cap handily took down Prometheus.
Prometheus' whole gimmick is that he has a helmet which can predict the movements of his opponents and feed him strategies, so when he steps up to take on the first Avenger, he's pretty confident that he has the old man beat.
Yeah he uh, doesn't even get to put a scratch on Cap.
Cap meanwhile takes him out in just a few panels, commenting that he took on the worst of the Nazis, so Prometheus' dinky little helmet doesn't impress him. He then moves on, leaving Prometheus in a broken heap.
Yeah, that's for Lian Harper, you goofy looking scum-smear.
2. Superman And Darkseid - Superman: The Animated Series
Superman had taken on Darkseid before in the comics, but even when he did it was always established that Darkseid was a New Gods villain. But arguably the most important instance of the two godlike super beings going head to head was when Darkseid made his breakout appearance in the two-parter Apokalips Now in Superman: The Animated Series.
The reason this is here above the other instances before it is because for an entire generation of kids who would grow up into comic nerds or even writers themselves, it cemented Darkseid as a Superman villain, instead of a New Gods villain. It's why Darkseid keeps appearing in later Superman books when the other New Gods are nowhere to be seen, sometimes for years at a time. And it all started with this blockbuster story of Superman's first encounter with the most evil being in the DC universe.
Superman doesn't even really fight him at first, Darkseid immediately overwhelms him with his Omega Beam and presents his broken body to Metropolis. Only for the Jack Kirby inspired Officer Turpin to stand up to him, at the cost of his own life.
For an entire generation who had never up to then even heard of Darkseid, this was about as good a first impression of a villain as you can get.
1. Daredevil And The Kingpin - Daredevil #169-172
With the other entries on this list, while superheroes may fight other villains from other books, once the story is done, those villains will return to their rightful book and return the universe to the status quo. Giganta is still a Wonder Woman villain, Mysterio is still a Spidey villain, and even Darkseid still has the occasional pedantic comic nerd to remind people of where he originated.
But the Kingpin, who debuted as a Spider-Man villain? Yeah, no, that dude is a Daredevil villain.
Frank Miller needed a recognizable mobster villain that no one else was using for his newest story idea, so he pulled the Kingpin out of retirement. It's in this story - Gang War - that the Kingpin goes from a riff on Bond villains to the hyper intelligent, intimidating gangster we know him as today. All culminating, of course, in the first proper brawl between him and Daredevil.
There was just something about their interactions that clicked better than he ever did with Spider-Man. This could have something to do with Kingpin actually BEING a character this time around instead of a pastiche of spy movie villains, to the point where Miller was the one who gave Kingpin a proper name - Wilson Fisk. But more than that, their personalities and differing worldviews just meshed way better than with previous heroes the Kingpin took on.
It may have been the wrong villain at the time, but it soon became a full on adoption of Wilson Fisk into the world of Daredevil.
Watch Next
The Ultimate Daredevil Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Man Without Fear?