10 Times The Justice League Went Way Too Far
Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman's team haven't always gotten it right.
The Justice League, DC's premier team of heroes, has been forced to make tough decisions in their attempts to protect the world, and this is to be expected.
A superhero team facing devious and otherworldly threats is bound to encounter high stakes in their adventures, and consequently a lot of sacrifices are made to save lives and stop evil from reigning supreme.
Some of the best stories involving the League seek to analyze where the line that separates drastic action and outright cruelty is drawn. The team is composed of heroes with vastly different world views and methodologies and, as a result, many members have committed reprehensible acts in the name of justice.
If done well, these tales place the heroes in compromising situations that they simply cannot punch or blast through. It takes every ounce of their moral fiber and more to rise above their predicaments or they get consumed and end up embodying the very evil they normally stand against.
From animated incarnations to comic classics, this list covers notable instances where the Distinguished Competition's greatest crossed the line in their mission to protect the world and beyond.
10. Heroes In Crisis
2018's spiritual sequel to the mixed bag that is the Identity Crisis storyline matched its predecessor's divisiveness but is redeemed by incredible (if often too male gaze-focused) artwork from Clay Mann and interesting thematic content courtesy of Tom King.
Its initial exploration of mental health and disillusionment is commendable, but ultimately poorly handled, as its treatment of the League (especially Wally West) leaves a lot to be desired.
The story focuses on the events following the death of multiple heroes and reformed villains at the Sanctuary, a rehabilitation center for heroes dealing with mental health issues. Due to the nature of the crime scene, Booster Gold and Harley Quinn are the primary suspects and they each go about trying to solve the case despite opposition from various heroes.
The case is ultimately solved and in the process highlights how demented the Sanctuary really is. The League creates instances where the heroes at the center relive their trauma in the name of healing. It is a decision (in-story and out of it) that is in poor taste and only serves to further isolate souls that needed a tender approach to their recoveries.
9. Justice League: Gods And Monsters
One of two animated entries on this list, the alternate universe story of a crueler, less accountable Justice League highlights its heroes' desire to enforce order by any means necessary.
It is a version of the League that reminds audiences of the innate goodness needed to wield overwhelming power in a responsible manner, but also how that same goodness can be rediscovered through adversity.
The alternate versions of Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman are a far cry from their mainstream counterparts and this is highlighted in the tie-in miniseries that accompanies the movie. Viewers are treated (???) to disturbing moments from the Trinity, such as Batman drinking Harlequin's blood after stopping her killing spree and Superman mercy-killing a child Brainiac whose powers threatened to spiral out of control.
The main film is not devoid of spine-chilling moments like those found in the miniseries, but it better fleshes out the titular antiheroes. They are presented as beings who want to save the day, but their path to accomplishing this has more collateral damage along the way.
Fortunately, by the end of the film, the League disbands and its heroes take on a more introspective, heroic journey.
8. A Better World - Justice League
Speaking of animated Justice Leagues taking it too far, the DCAU's version of an out-of-control League is one of the most memorable arcs to come out of the beloved franchise.
The League still strives to maintain law and order on its Earth, but its warped sense of justice sees it undermines pre-existing institutions in the process.
A grieving League (suffering the loss of the Flash at the hands of President Lex Luthor) storms the White House and this leads to Lex's death at the hands of Superman. This more brutal team rebrands itself as the Justice Lords and takes over the world, limiting free speech and self-governance. They discover the main League's reality and seek to take over it the same way they did with their own.
This story is impactful for a number of reasons as it highlights how fallible these heroes really are and how that makes them a threat to the planet. It also sets the stage for the Cadmus storyline that sees the main League in a few instances veering very close to the authoritarian sensibilities embodied by the Justice Lords.
7. Throne Of Atlantis
The first entry where one League member puts their personal objectives above the team's, Throne of Atlantis explores Aquaman's character as he struggles to navigate the world as both a Leaguer and Atlantean royalty.
Following a naval exercise gone wrong, Atlantis, under the rule of Orm/Ocean Master, declares war on the surface world in retaliation.
Arthur is forced (for a brief time) to place his personal responsibilities over his obligations to the team and the consequences are dire despite the short timeframe in which they take place in. It does not help Arthur's case when it is revealed that the plans used by the Atlantean army to invade the surface world were developed by both him and his brother.
Furthermore, the undersea hero's complete lack of cooperation with his fellow Leaguers leads to their capture when they attempt to apprehend Orm and this only hastens the invasion of the surface.
Fortunately, Arthur ultimately stands by his team and stops his brother's plans, but the League's victory comes at the expense of their public perception - especially that of Aquaman's.
6. Crime Syndicate Of America
This alternative version of the iconic super-team is unique on this list as it is the only variation of the League that went far down the slippery slope of evil and abandoned all pretense of wanting to do good in the world.
The Crime Syndicate exists on Earth-3 in the greater DC multiverse, and is composed of villainous counterparts to the main Leaguers such as Ultraman, Owlman and Superwoman.
The Syndicate conquered their world and eventually grew bored with the relative ease of global domination. As a result, they sought out other worlds in the multiverse and eventually came into conflict with the Justice League of Earth-1 and the Justice Society of Earth-2, but never ever fully defeating their heroic counterparts and their allies.
The Syndicate is composed of sadistic and completely reprehensible beings who will stop at nothing to conquer and annihilate any world they come across. They also lack the relative coordination and mutual trust of the League, with members constantly undermining one another and in some cases killing each other - a clear sign of their cruelty and selfishness.
5. Flashpoint
One of DC's most personal crisis crossovers/reboots, Flashpoint examines Barry Allen's (very understandable) desire to save and be reunited with his deceased mother, but his choice changes the world for the worse and places it on a path to annihilation.
In an attempt to stop Reverse Flash from killing his mother in the past, Flash unknowingly creates a reality where the Justice League does not exist, Captain Cold is Central City's greatest hero and Aquaman and Wonder Woman have waged a war against each other that decimated parts of Europe and threatens the world.
Barry, alongside Batman (Thomas Wayne) and Cyborg, attempt to stop the war and reset the timeline.
The Flash's wish to save his mother is by far more honorable than other instances on this list but the consequences are dire and threaten to tear the DC universe apart.
Fortunately, Barry resets the timeline again and it takes shape in the New 52 series of comics, but the comic is a reminder of how seemingly small changes can be devastating, especially in a universe as turbulent as DC's.
4. Identity Crisis
DC's first attempt at a wide scale super-powered murder mystery was a flawed but somewhat fascinating character study that ultimately failed to take its heroes and mystery in a direction that respected their lore as well as observe narrative coherency.
Following the death of Sue Dibny, Elongated Man's wife, the League and larger superhero community pulls out the stops to apprehend the killer.
The primary suspect in the investigation is Doctor Light, due to the fact that he assaulted Dibny in the past. To avoid this from happening again, various Leaguers opted to have the villain mindwiped by Zatanna and in the process mindwiped Batman as well, due to his objection of the act.
The real killer is eventually apprehended but the League is deeply divided due to the questionable ethics of having the Dark Knight's memory erased in such a manner. This also unfortunately paints the heroes in a negative light and presents them as selfish and unlikable characters - a far cry from their more grounded but endearing portrayal in more traditional stories.
3. Injustice
Injustice is one of DC's best tales in years, with its bold approach to worn out tropes winning over both new and old fans of the franchise.
This exploration of Superman's grief rolling over the world (and beyond) is a seminal example of what happens when absolute power is both compromised and unchecked.
After murdering the Joker for having killed Lois Lane, her unborn child and most of Metropolis, Superman and a few other Leaguers see it fit to take a more... proactive approach in global governance and policing.
Naturally, this totalitarian leap in logic on the Man of Steel's part is met with opposition from the world he wishes to protect and some of his old teammates, specifically Batman.
Superman's One Earth regime betrays the morals and ethos that the League was founded on, and during its devastating run commits atrocities that push the remaining Leaguers well beyond the moral event horizon in their severely unsound desire to uphold order across the globe.
2. Kingdom Come
The visually stunning and weighty tale of judgement and change in the DC universe, Kingdom Come explores a future where the old guard of the DC universe is pitted against a newer, more violent breed of antihero with (as always) the fate of the world on the balance.
It's a well-constructed commentary on the violent excess that defined nineties-era comics, and in many ways the definitive comic of the period too.
After the Joker is murdered by a new hero called Magog, Superman and some Leaguers resign due to being disillusioned by the overwhelming public support that the violent newbie is receiving. This sparks the rise of brutal heroes who dangerously come close to villainy, and after a particularly devastating battle, Superman returns and reforms the League.
Unfortunately, the new League's attempts to rehabilitate the newer heroes is unsuccessful and the League itself is more militant than it had ever once been. The intervention of Lex Luthor's own super team and the UN only serves to worsen the situation, pushing the older generation to their limits and resulting in massive loss of superhuman life.
Fortunately, Superman and his counterparts see the error of their ways before more lives are lost and the world returns to a more idealistic, but grounded age.
1. Tower Of Babel
Batman is well-known for his (sometimes ludicrous) pragmatism and mistrust of powerful forces in the League, and it is no surprise that he would develop contingencies against them. It's always stood to reason that his enemies would use these plans against his teammates, and this is what Mark Waid, Howard Porter and Steve Scott's Tower of Babel story explores in impressive detail.
Ra's al Ghul stole Batman's contingency plans and used them on the League to incapacitate them long enough to realize his plans of reducing the planet's population.
The plans are as horrifying as they are impressive, and highlight how meticulous (and dangerously paranoid) the Dark Knight is. Fortunately, Bruce and the rest of the League recover from their respective attacks in time to stop the villain's plot and save the world.
This story is unique in how it presents the League's actions in the aftermath and Batman's overall. The team is split over whether he was right or wrong in developing these plans in secret, and ultimately the Caped Crusader leaves the team.
The League's reactions and Batman's plans are somewhat understandable but they all miss the point of good communication and accountability, traits key in a team with powerful and sensitive dynamics such as theirs.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Justice League: Unlimited?