10 Unbelievable Retcons That Changed Comics For The Better

Wolverine's claws weren't always as cool as you think they are...

Wolverine Claws X-Men 2
20th Century Fox

Every time something changes in comic books, there will always be a tsunami of outcry. “Worst. Thing. Ever.” has become the cattle call for any sort of change to the status quo, even when there’s very little status quo to be had. This happens with reboots, shifts in directions and, the most common ticket to ride the hate-train: the dreaded retcon!

Retcons are a marvellously weird thing in long term storytelling. In a film, the surprise reveal that the guy killed in the cold opener is still alive to betray the hero in the third act is a now-standard plot device. No one ever decries that twist as having betrayed the spirit of the first five minutes of the film. But in a TV show or a comic book, it becomes the point of contention that causes waves of hate, ire, or even just plain annoyance.

However, there have been retcons that have done good. The principle seems to be after the flood of complaints recede, and time is allowed to pass, these retcons are either accepted en masse, or there is legitimately positive feedback in the wake of the initial shock surrounding the change. The following, however, are undoubtedly the best to have graced the medium.

10. Darth Vader Knew About Luke Skywalker

Star Wars Darth Vader 6 luke son
Marvel Comics

Losing the Expanded Universe of Star Wars is still a touchy subject for many fans of its massive history. In essence, Marvel's new line of Star Wars comics were a reboot that cleared all the history except for the films and the television shows.

However, the publisher had a huge hit with the Darth Vader title. If you couldn’t tell by the title, it follows Darth Vader in between A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back, and it truly is a glorious read and a welcome addition to the Star Wars canon.

One of the most iconic moments is in Star Wars: Darth Vader #6 when Boba Fett tells Darth Vader that he discovered the name of the pilot that blew up the first Death Star. Skywalker. After Boba Fett leaves, Darth Vader tries to contain his rage but flashes of his past, with the death of Padme and his children in his mind, mean he’s unable to contain the power of the Force and cracks the glass in his office.

The grandness of the moment adds a depth to all interactions between the Emperor after that, including a unique level to the “revelation” when Emperor Palpatine tells him of his son, as both sides know that Vader already knows by that point.


9. Hal Jordan Was Possessed By Parallax

Green Lantern v2 49 crazy hal jordan emerald twilight
DC Comics

There has to be one controversial choice and here it is. The set up for the story is that Coast City, Hal’s home, is destroyed with all seven million inhabitants killed. Hal goes a bit insane (understandably) and recreates the entire city as a projection from his ring, including his girlfriend and parents.

The Guardians, the leaders of the Green Lanterns, are not happy about this, and bring him back to Oa to reprimand him for using the ring in such a way. That goes over about as well as a Baby Ruth in a pool, and Hal, in his anger, starts and wins a war against the Green Lantern Corps, now calling himself Parallax.

After the event where he tries to rewrite time, Hal sacrifices himself to save the solar system in the mid-nineties. All this was because DC wanted to end the Silver Age versions of their characters to put all new, all different characters in.

Things were fine until 2004, when DC Comics decided that they wanted to bring back Hal Jordan as a Green Lantern with the Green Lantern: Rebirth series. It was then that Geoff Johns retconned the whole Parallax fiasco to be Hal Jordan being possessed by a giant space-bug comprised of yellow fear energy.

It also explained the reason that Green Lanterns couldn’t affect yellow objects for a bit, but, more importantly, It reinvented the whole of the GL mythos with multiple Corps, an emotional spectrum and stories that would become instant classics for years to follow!


8. Quicksilver And Scarlet Witch Are Magneto's Children

Giant-Sized Avengers 1 quicksilver scarlet witch whizzer
Marvel Comics/Rich Buckler

Magneto is the father of Pietro and Wanda Maximoff. It is an ingrained truth that has existed for the past 40 years. It was never really stated explicitly until the Vision & Scarlet Witch series, but since the mid-seventies, they have been Magneto's children.

Magneto’s wife, Magda, had fled to the Wundagore Mountains after her husband had developed strange powers. She gives birth to her twins but abandons them days later. The midwife attempts to give the kids to Robert Frank, the costumed speedster Whizzer, after his own wife and child die during birth, but he ran off so they were given to the Maximoff family in a local village. It has been a staple of their characters for so long that even in 2014, when that was revamped yet again so that the High Evolutionary gave them their powers and they were just born of dirt-farming peasants, it was met with a huge fan backlash.

However, originally, Robert Frank was there with a real purpose. Instead of running off because his own wife and child died in a separate incident, the twins were his! In Giant-Size Avengers #1, the story is told to Wanda, as the Whizzer lay dying in Avengers Mansion. His wife, the Golden Age hero Miss America, gave birth on Wundagore Mountain, but died days after giving birth to his twins and fled in grief at the loss of his wife. This was the status quo for a couple of years until the addition of Magneto tied Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver much closer to the extremely popular X-Men book.


7. Daredevil Was Trained By Stick

Stick Trains Daredevil
Marvel Comics

The Hand, the Chaste and Stick are all fixtures of the Daredevil mythos. How else could a blind 15-year-old learn how to do all the kick-ass things that Daredevil can? Simply put, he taught himself. In the original Daredevil #1, there was no Stick and no grand design outside of a couple of panels of young Matt Murdock training himself to fight.

It wasn't until Frank Miller’s Daredevil: The Man Without Fear that those fantastical ninja elements were incorporated into the character's backstory. Matt was struggling in his life due to his altered senses, and Stick came into the picture not necessarily to help him but to train him as a weapon to fight against the Hand.

Granted, Man Without Fear was never meant to be anything more than a potential movie script that happened to become one of the defining bibles in Daredevil’s history, so there’s still some general tweaking of the new backstory that happens every so often to fit whatever story is being told, but there's a reason the origin has stuck for as long as it has.


6. Wolverine's Claws Are A Part Of His Mutation

Hunt For Wolverine 1
Marvel Comics

Len Wein did not want Wolverine to be a mutated wolverine who was made human-like by the High Evolutionary. That is a bombshell many people like putting on Top 10 Things You Didn’t Know or random tidbit lists but it’s just not true. Roy Thomas just wanted a character who was Canadian and short, with the temperament of a wolverine. So Len Wein wrote a human to be that way, with super-strength, agility, and retractable claws - although the claws weren’t shown retracting until his addition to the X-Men lineup.

The retcon is that originally the now-iconic claws were supposed to be in his gloves! His mutation was just the speed and strength, though fighting Hulk could easily imply he had the healing factor from the get-go. Think about every story that has come about because of the claws being fused with his skeleton, and you will understand why this changed comics for the better. That is... until Wolverine became an overused character that stole the spotlight from everyone, which is also an ironic twist since editorial wanted to drop Wolverine from the X-books, only for John Byrne to stand up for his fellow Canadian.

Now this also led to the retcon of his claws actually being part of his mutation after the adamantium was stripped from his body, but that is a change that doesn't need to be on this list.


5. Bucky Barnes Never Died

Winter Soldier Winter Kills
Marvel Comics

After a Captain America retcon that will definitely come up later, Bucky Barnes was deemed dead in the same secret drone explosion that froze Steve Rogers in the Arctic Circle, and - for the better part of fifty years - that was the rule.

In the same way that Uncle Ben or the Waynes are dead to begin with, that was the case for James Buchanan Barnes. That is until Ed Brubaker flipped the script in 2005.

A new secret history was given to Bucky. Now, after the explosion, Captain America's sidekick was found by a Russian submarine and taken to become their top assassin with a cool bionic arm. This led to not only a bit of a retcon for most of the espionage/war heroes, such as Black Widow, for instance, but it did a lot more than that too. It gave fans the phenomenal Winter Soldier storyline and the star-spangled awesome that was the Death of Captain America, where Bucky became the man under the mask for a time.


4. Swamp Thing's Anatomy Lesson

Scary Comics Joe Hill Swamp Thing anatomy lesson v2 21
DC Comics/Steve Bissette

Swamp Thing was a run of the mill monster-man at the beginning. Alec Holland was caught in an explosion, and as this is comics, he was transformed into a thing made from swamp plants. The book was well-received for a time until it got cancelled for one reason or another.

That is until 1982 and the Wes Craven Swamp Thing movie was greenlit. A second volume was launched to a warm reception, all about Alec needing to stop an evil child who may be the Anti-Christ. Yet, despite this obviously brilliant premise, dipping sales meant the book was destined to succumb to cancellation too.

In steps Alan Moore, a name you know you can trust about retconning previously established history, and things get intense.

The biggest retcon that changed it all was that Alec Holland did die in the explosion. The Swamp Thing was animated vegetation that thought it was a man, which ended up being the first of many key changes to come. There were actually dozens of Swamp Things throughout the ages, combining all previous appearances into continuity, and introducing the Parliament of Trees and the Green, the grand force that connected all plant life. That by itself has become a giant addition to DC continuity, but Moore didn’t stop there.

With this new direction, there were no limits to where it could go - everyone needs to read the Alan Moore run on this and see just how far the swamp hole goes.


3. Alfred Was Always There

Batman v1 16 Alfred Arrives
DC Comics/Bob Kane

Alfred Pennyworth first appeared in Batman #16 as a bumbling, fat valet who came to work for Bruce Wayne after a deathbed promise from his father, Jarvis, and merely stumbled into the discovery of the Bat-cave.

With modern eyes, this character hurts on so many levels. His dim-witted nature despite being part of British Intelligence was only the tip of the iceberg with every "Mawster Bruce" they wrote for him. Luckily, Alfred would be changed to fit more in line with the actor from the 1943 Batman serial, with a lean frame and a moustache that would become his iconic look. Gone too, was his bumbling demeanour.

Then Crisis on Infinite Earths happened and the continuity shifted so that Alfred Pennyworth was always the valet for the Wayne family and, upon their death, became Bruce’s guardian.

Needless to say, this change was one of the best things to happen to the Bat-mythos. It gave Bruce a strong role model for him to be able to lean on and instil in the moral compass that would make Bruce the hero he would later become.


2. Captain America Was Frozen

Avengers v1 4 Captain America Thawed
Marvel Comics/Jack Kirby

The Marvel Universe has revolved around the fact that Captain America was frozen towards the end of World War II. His time with the Avengers, his solo series, the epic of Civil War where he stands against the government, that other time he quit being Captain America by standing against the government - everything hinged on his idealism as it stood at the end of World War II, when there was a clear answer of who the bad guys were and why they needed to be stopped.

Except, that wasn't always the case.

Long ago, after World War II ended, Timely Comics still published Captain America adventures, except now he was a schoolteacher with a young girl sidekick, Golden Girl. It did not do so well. But then came a new 'threat' to the foreground of the American mindset. Communism! So Timely got Stan Lee and John Romita Sr. to create tales trying to capture the same spark as the Nazi-punching days, with Golden Girl out as his sidekick and Bucky back in, but it wasn't successful.

But then the sixties swung around and the Marvel Age had taken root. This time Lee and Kirby came up with a means to bring Captain America back, and bypass the awkward Commie-smashing years. Cap was actually frozen in ice and Bucky was dead by the end of WW2. That Cap running around punching Commies? Oh that was just an obsessed fanboy who decided to try and be the character for a while - a premise that would eventually inform one of the best stories from Ed Brubaker's run on the character.


1. The DC Multiverse

the flash 123 Flash of Two Worlds
DC Comics/Carmine Infantino

The DC Multiverse is the single greatest retcon that changed comics for the better.

The Silver Age of Comics brought about a total reboot to the known works of DC, beginning with a new Flash, Barry Allen, in Showcase #4 in 1956. That success brought about Silver Age versions of older established characters like Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman, but they weren’t the same as their Golden Age counterparts. In fact, in Barry Allen’s case, the Golden Age Flash, Jay Garrick, was just a comic book character. All that changed in Flash #123, Flash Of Two Worlds!

Flash of Two Worlds introduced the concept that the Jay Garrick wasn’t just a fictional comic character, but was in fact an active hero on a parallel Earth, dubbed creatively Earth-2. This comic became a massive success and suddenly yearly crossovers between the Justice League of America and the Justice Society of Earth-2 became the norm. This exploded out into other universes, such as Earth-3 with the villainous Ultraman and the Crime Syndicate of America, or Earth-X, where the Quality Comics characters would stay battling in a world where Nazis won World War II.

The Elseworlds that came out of it, the legacy heroes that became so integral to the universes and even the Crisis events that would alter the Multiverse, even erasing it so Hypertime is a thing at one point, and so much more have shaped the DC Comics, and comic history as a whole that is the greatest retcon that has changed comics for the better!

Watch Next...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

A.J. Carey is a child of pop culture, learning to read on comic books and raised like any true '90s child on films way above his age range and network television!