10 Underpowered Characters Who Defeated Major Heroes

Every villain has his day.

Superman Muhammad Ali
DC Comics

If there's one consistent trait superheroes possess that endears us to them, it's that they're not infallible. Comic heroes don't fight because they know they'll win - they do it because they know someone has to, and they're willing to put their life on the line to be that person, and to help others.

Even Superman - who by all means is stronger and better than regular humans in just about every way - is capable of being taken down by someone completely underpowered, given the right circumstances.

Without the very real chance that even the strongest heroes could be beat, there'd be literally zero stakes to the comics they're in, and as such, zero reason to actually pick the comics up and read them.

And there's only one solid way to make it appear as though said heroes could be defeated; namely, by having them get beat. Showing significantly weaker opponents taking the likes of Batman and Wonder Woman down proves that, even for the most powerful superheroes, any opponent can become a genuine threat - even if it's only temporarily.

10. Lex Luthor Vs. Superman

Lex Luthor
DC Comics

Superman #149 covers perhaps the single most unique concept in all of comics, wherein Lex Luthor researches and creates a cure for cancer just to kill Superman. It's... pretty intense.

With Lex clearly having no way to match the Man of Steel in any kind of actual fight, he instead pretends to reform, creating the cure for cancer as a ruse in order to convince everyone that his intentions are genuinely good. After gaining Superman's trust, Luthor convinces him to build him a space laboratory, where he can carry out his research in peace - research that, unbeknownst to Kent, is aimed at using Kryptonite to finally kill him.

And, somewhat surprisingly, his plan works, with the unaware Superman being killed by Lex's newest invention before he can react. For his crimes, Luthor is sent to the phantom zone, but not before getting in a couple final gloats about finally taking down his arch-rival.


9. Frank Pratt Vs. Batman

Batman Sgt. Branden
DC Comics

In Batman: Dark Victory, you'd be forgiven for ignoring pretty much everything but the intrigue of who the mysterious Hangman is - after all, that's the main plot of the series.

But there's also definitely something to be said about the fact that Batman gets a surprisingly decisive defeat from someone who isn't even his enemy. Frank Pratt - who had fought Batman due to his criminal past before - manages to accidentally confront Batman while on the run from the Hangman, who had confirmed Pratt as his newest victim.

In a panic, Frank shoots Batman, and hits him squarely in the chest - which doesn't kill him because of his bat-armor, but also knocks him clean out from the impact alone, meaning Pratt accidentally managed to beat the Bat.

Ironically, this fortunate pot shot serves to help Pratt in precisely zero ways, as he is summarily murdered by the time Batman is back up and ready to find him. The downside of wearing a spooky costume, really, is that people instinctively presume that you're out to beat them to dust - something that works to the Dark Knight's detriment in this case.


8. Muhammad Ali Vs. Superman

Superman Muhammad Ali
DC Comics

In a comic that is far, far more endearing than it has any right to be, Superman vs. Muhammad Ali shows that, for all his brawn, the Man of Steel could likely not face up to The Louisville Lip.

Although admittedly, this is entirely because Superman refuses to not fight fair against the boxer, and uses a light bulb replica of the red sun to weaken his powers, in order leave the two with sheerly their fighting skills remaining.

That said, Superman's fighting abilities - powers or no - should still be significantly above that of Ali's, as one of them fights people, and the other fights all-powerful alien fighting machines on the regular. Logically, Muhammad Ali should have had absolutely no chance versus Kent, but instead, it's made clear it's entirely the other way around, with Ali handily beating Superman across the ring.

The comic may be a little bias in making Ali the wittiest and strongest character in it - but then, the champ was these things, so it's pretty fair to do so.


7. Daredevil Vs. The Hulk

Daredevil The Hulk
Marvel Comics

While more a battle of wits than a battle of brawn, Daredevil shows that echolocation and a strong sense of hope can actually overpower the unimaginable strength of the Hulk - well, sometimes.

Upon seeing the big green giant wrecking New York one building at a time, Murdock changes into his superhero costume and confronts the Hulk, trying to convince him to calm down and leave the city before he destroys it.

Despite taking a mighty beatdown, Daredevil manages to eventually calm the creature down, by helping him realise that the man he is looking for - Bruce Banner - is actually his other form, and that the Hulk is actually just mad at himself.

It's likely to have disappointed anyone who expected a big fight between the pair, but still, any kind of victory against the Hulk counts as a win - and managing to calm him down in one of his rages might actually be more impressive than just beating him down.


6. Captain Boomerang Vs. The Flash

Captain Boomerang The Flash
DC Comics

When you're a supervillain with the ability to throw boomerangs well, set against a superhero who is the fastest man alive, you're going to have to get creative to even try and beat him.

As such, Captain Boomerang's efforts against The Flash can be only described as imaginative, as it's literally the only way he can get a shot in at the hero. Of these various attempts, the one that deserves the most recognition is unmistakably the time Boomerang makes his body into a Boomerang to use the Flash's ability to blow him away with a gust of air back at him. It's absolutely ridiculous, but that's exactly what makes it so decisively wonderful - as we see the surreal lengths that fighting The Flash requires.

Not only is this moment permanently hilarious, but it's also a pretty good look into how such an underpowered villain has anywhere near a chance of taking on The Flash; i.e, by elaborate and bizarre evil schemes.


5. Mantis Vs. Thor

Mantis Thor
Marvel Comics

With Thor being a God of Thunder with super-strength and all the powers his role provides him, you'd expect he'd fare against Mantis pretty handily.

While Mantis is seriously talented at martial arts, her feature in the MCU had many people see her as somewhat underpowered. This is also not helped by the fact that her only actual superpower is the ability to sense the emotions of others - which is a pretty questionable superpower, given many of us can sense other people's emotion, by the magical power of looking at their expression.

But this doesn't stop Mantis handing Thor a sweet beatdown in Avengers #114, where she and Swordsman take on the entirety of the Avengers before joining them. For all his might, Thor is taken down in one nerve punch to the neck.

To add insult to injury, this isn't actually the only time Mantis takes Thor down, as within ten issues of this she is in another fight with the God of Thunder, and yet again beats him in a single punch - although this time he doesn't fall unconscious, so maybe it can be considered an improvement.


4. Harley Quinn Vs. Wonder Woman

Harley Quinn Wonder Woman
DC Comics

Given Wonder Woman is one of three superheroes considered the main and more powerful in the DC universe - that of Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman - it's understandable that Harley Quinn's chances against her don't seem all that strong.

Yet Harley changes the game, using her ingenuity, her smarts, and the significant advantage that is knockout gas to take her down and steal her costume. It's admittedly not much in terms of a fight, but given that many of Wonder Woman's long-time enemies have never managed to knock her unconscious, it can definitely be considered a win on Quinn's end.

Hilariously, Quinn likely doesn't even consider what she has done a victory against the Amazonian, as she only knocked Wonder Woman out in order to take her costume and 'help her out' by being Wonder Woman for a day.

While it's not going to win any awards for most exciting fight in comics, Harley Quinn taking down Wonder Woman proves that even people without superpowers have a decent chance against heroes given the right field advantage.


3. Joker Vs. Superman

Injustice Superman Kills Joker Batman
DC Comics

With Superman being pretty much invulnerable to attack from most supervillains - the Joker included - doing any kind of harm to him requires a little thinking outside of the box.

In Injustice, Joker manages just this, by lacing the inside of his evil submarine lair with fear toxin laced kryptonite, which made the Man of Steel hallucinate that Doomsday was attacking him, when in actuality it was Lois Lane, who an unaware Superman flew into space. If this didn't seem cruel enough, the Joker also rigged up a bomb in Metropolis to her heart rate, which would explode upon her death.

And thus, in one fell swoop, Joker gets Superman to kill Lois, their unborn child, and blow up half of Metropolis, which isn't bad for a day's evil work.

Superman does try and even things out by killing the Joker in suitably dramatic fashion, but unfortunately Joker cares unimaginably little about his own mortality, meaning - especially with the hero vs. hero carnage that takes place after - that Injustice marks the Joker's biggest victory over the Man of Steel.


2. Deacon Blackfire Vs. Batman

Batman Deacon Blackfire
DC Comics

Proving that charisma should be a legitimate superpower, Deacon Blackfire - despite a seeming total lack of not only superpowers, or even any real fighting abilities - takes down Batman handily.

For the majority of his first appearance in DC - in Batman: The Cult - the hero is decisively beaten by him, with Blackfire brainwashing him to make him do his bidding, which includes making the Dark Knight break his one rule and kill a man. It's as impressive as it is surprising, and really works well in terms of reminding us that Batman is human, and could be taken down by any of the enemies that he goes against.

Batman does clearly have the physical advantage, as when the two actually fight, it's an incredibly one-sided contest. But in terms of managing to force Batman to carry out his will, Deacon clearly also managed to beat the Bat down for a good while.


1. Punisher Vs. All The X-Men

Punisher Nukes the X-Men
Marvel Comics

While it's undeniable that the Punisher is capable of some pretty intense feats, it's also safe to say that he is just a little less powerful than the entirety of the X-Men combined - and by a little, we do mean entirely and without a shadow of a doubt.

However, this doesn't stop Punisher from doing exactly what the Punisher Kills the Marvel Universe title suggests, and successfully taking out the far more powerful faction - with some slight help in the form of a nuke plundered from Dr. Doom's lair.

Punisher invited both Magneto and Professor X's sides of the mutant team to a meeting, with both parties convinced that the other had invited them. Just as they realised something was amiss, Punisher set his plan in motion, and blew the entire team sky-high - with the exception of Wolverine, who he killed in person later.

While it's hardly surprising that the Punisher proved to be very good at killing, taking out the entire of the X-Men in one fell swoop is no easy task, especially for a man without any kind of superpowers.


How Big A Fan Of The Punisher Are You?

The Punisher cover art
Marvel Comics

1. Who Was The Punisher's Nemesis In Jason Aaron's Punisher Max (2010 - 2011)?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.