10 Wild Versions Of Spider-Man That Could Actually Work On Film
You get a big delight in every bite of Spider-Man fruit pies!
Spider-Man: No Way Home hits theaters in just a few months, and speculation continues as to whether Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield may fight alongside Tom Holland in the MCU's wildest crossover yet.
Even if the rumors turn out to be bogus, however, Spidey fans still have a menagerie of Spider-Men to look forward to in the coming years. Between Marvel’s new What If...? series on Disney+, at least two upcoming Spider-Verse films, and even proposals for a Spider-Verse TV series, the stage is set to bring any number of Spidey variants to life on big and small screens alike.
With literally dozens of Wall-crawlers featured in the comics, there’s no telling what Marvel and Sony may have in store. Both studios are clearly willing to stretch their limits for the sake of fan service, with the MCU even going as far as to bring back J.K. Simmons after the previous film series glossed over his character with a text message, and Sony's Spider-Verse giving a number of lesser-known Spideys their big-screen debut.
In a world where Spider-Fans can watch Nic Cage join forces with a cartoon pig, there’s no reason to think these next ten Web-slingers couldn’t get their own shot at stardom.
10. Spider-Ma'am
Maybelle Parker might be the most wholesome, maternal figure throughout Marvel's extensive canon. So maternal, in fact, that Marvel's attempt to recast our friendly neighborhood auntie as a badass remains centered largely on her love for Peter Parker.
When the Parker of Earth-3123 leaves his lunch at home on the way to the same field trip that would have otherwise given him his powers, his aunt makes a mad dash through traffic to bring it to him. She gets bitten by a spider and, despite attributing her sudden powers to the new vitamin tonic she's been taking, conveniently still settles on a spider-themed costume as she arms herself with a weaponized pastry decorator and sets out to save a candy store from the nefarious Leap-Frog.
In recent years, Spider-Ma'am received proper web shooters after letting Peter in on her secret identity. Still every bit the surrogate mother she's always been, she soon began fostering a team of former supervillains after they were turned into babies by Doc Ock's Spider-Army.
Having originated in the first volume of Marvel's What If comics, Spider-Ma'am could easily feature on the Disney+ series. But don't rule out the big screen. Anything can happen in Sony's Spider-Verse, and even their current Aunt May has the tech she'd need to start her own web-slinging career if ever called to do so.
As for the MCU, Marisa Tomei and Sally Field have both expressed desires to stretch their limits and try on less saccharine characters. The films' growing multiverse could make way for the perfect opportunity to grant that wish.
9. Patton Parnel
Man-Spider would be an easy entry on this list, but Marvel already considered a similar plot for their What If...? series and decided that Peter's transformation into a real spider was too horrific for their target demo. As such, those familiar with Patton Parnel's appearance in Edge of Spider-Verse may wonder what he's doing on this list.
Not only does Parnel take on the features of a humanoid spider, he then goes on a sadistic cannibal killing spree that claims the lives of his abusive Uncle Ted, several neighborhood pets, and an innocent little boy. He then implants girl-next-door Sara Jane with tiny egg sacs that hatch beneath her flesh and presumably kill her.
To make matters worse, he's actually set up as a budding sociopath well before his transformation. Prior to his spider bite, we see him torturing animals, peeping through Sara Jane's window, and daydreaming about the deaths of his classmates.
So how could such a dark character make it onto the big screen? Surprisingly, like most of the characters on this list, Parnel's best fit would be in Sony's family-friendly Spider-Verse.
While the darker elements of Parnel's character would need some sugar-coating, the planned expansion of the Spider-Verse makes it all too likely that the Spidey Squad will eventually come face to face with some less heroic versions of themselves.
With a few admittedly major adjustments to his character (such as emphasizing the fact that he suffered his spider bites while liberating lab animals), Parnel could be recast as a more sympathetic and possibly even redeemable secondary villain.
8. Spider-Punk
The Anarchic Spider-Man, Hobart Brown, may strike the more cynical reader as a lazy attempt to rein in fringe consumers by creating the most edgelord Marvel hero ever. Spider-Punk's hobbies include wailing on electric guitar, referring to himself as a "radioactive suicide machine," and totally not selling out. And because low-hanging fruit is the best fruit, he does all of this while leading a revolution against an elected leader with plans to "make America great again."
Despite Marvel's attempt to ruin any possible story immersion with the most thinly veiled political references imaginable, Hobie's improved in the comics since his debut.
Both his character and his universe have been expanded and given some much-needed depth, yet he still hasn't made much of a mark on other media. In fact, some audiences for his most notable animated appearance on Disney XD's Ultimate Spider-Man might be entirely unaware of his origin as an American freedom fighter, as the series gave him a Cockney accent in apparent tribute to his origin as a prototype design for Spider-UK.
Whether cast as a British punk or an American rebel, Hobart Brown's offbeat design would make him a shoe-in for Sony's Spider-Verse. Perhaps the best use of the character, however, would be on Disney+.
Not only could a rock-oriented episode of What If...? pair Hobie with Captain Anarchy and the punk Hulk seen in the Edge of Spider-Geddon comics, the series could introduce some other crazy takes on classic heroes that the comic didn't have time to give us—such as the briefly mentioned "M.C. Strange."
7. Spider-Kid
Uncle Ben's sage advice on responsibility has become such a deeply rooted part of Spidey canon that numerous comics have made a running joke out of having the line cut off halfway through (this also happens in Into the Spider-Verse). But what if Uncle Ben had been less supportive? What if he'd said the words, but failed to live them?
That's the version of reality that poor Charlie Parker was born into, suffering so much abuse at the hands of Uncle Ben that it drove him to leave home as a mere child and abandon his birth name, Peter.
The comics introduce us to Charlie not long before he's recruited for a Spidey crossover by Ashley Barton, also known as Spider-Bitch in the Old Man Logan timeline. Despite living alone at 13, she finds him in an apartment that not many working Manhattanites could afford. That's because he gets his money robbing drug dealers, specifically those who try to pass themselves off as high schoolers to hook younger prey. He's a compelling character, essentially doing the right things for the wrong reasons.
Charlie's abuse history and degenerate lifestyle might be a bit serious for the Spider-Verse, and the MCU has yet to really deal with Uncle Ben at all, but Disney+ could still deliver a version of this Spider-Kid by simply asking: What if Peter Parker didn't have Aunt May?
6. Aracnido Jr.
Created by Marvel's Mexican writer Enrique Puig, this Spidey's real name remains unknown. He debuted in the same Spider-Verse issue as Spider-Punk, yet received far less attention in the proper crossovers thereafter.
What we do know is that rather than losing a beloved uncle, this Spidey lost his father, a luchador who went by the stage name Arácnido. Much like Daredevil, Arácnido Jr. receives his powers at some point prior to his father's death at the hands of gangsters. The mob pays off Daddy Arácnido's wrestling partner Escorpión to stand idly by while a competitor fatally injures him in the ring, and Junior dons the Spidey suit to seek revenge.
With Sony's Spider-Verse already opening the doors for more racial inclusivity among its big-screen web-slingers, Arácnido Jr. should be a prime candidate for inclusion. It's not that his culture is any less under-represented than a number of others, but at least Web-slingers such as the Indian Pavitr Prabhakar have been given some depth in the comics. Since his debut, Arácnido remains under-utilized in virtually all mediums.
Not only would Junior add even more diversity to Sony's Spider-Verse than already provided by Miles and Peni, he'd do so in a refreshing way. New York is as much a character in Spider-Man's comics and movies as the Wall-crawler himself. It would be an interesting twist to see the Big Apple recast as Mexico City, with a hero who loves his capital every bit as much as Peter loves Queens.
5. Spider-Monkey
Peter Porker's far from the only non-human Spidey on Marvel's roster. Featured in the Marvel Apes comics alongside such heroes as Iron Mandrill and the Mighty Thorangutan, Spider-Monkey also has his own one-shot and a role in the Marvel Apes/Marvel Zombies crossover. This means that he could pretty effectively fit into either the Spider-Verse or the What If...? series, especially if the showrunners at What If...? decide to start doing their own crossovers within the series.
Spider-Monkey did eventually make it into one of the mainstream comic crossovers, and the results were fatal. Following an all-out assault by the Inheritors, Spider-Monkey's death followed those of other powerful Web-heads including Cosmic Spider-Man and the Great Spider-Wolf of the Lycansphere.
Sony's Spider-Verse could easily give him the same treatment, providing his character arc some extra gravity and allowing him to stand apart from the cartoonish Spider-Ham (although their team-up would still allow for no shortage of zany antics in the interim).
Of course, Spider-Monkey doesn't have to die to be taken seriously. If Disney+ were to faithfully adapt the initial Marvel Apes run, the result would be more than a mere series of lame monkey puns.
In the comics, Spider-Monkey is among one of several Ape-vengers who follow Captain America's orders to brutally murder any villain deemed unworthy of rehabilitation, a surprisingly dark twist in a seemingly frivolous series. Despite seeming like a fairly straightforward parody character, his unquestioning alacrity for murder makes this Spider-Simian one of the most tonally versatile characters on this list.
4. Spider-Girl
Spider-Girl is a common name in the Marvel multiverse, and Penelope Parker doesn't initially seem to have the same draws as other versions of the hero. Unlike Mayday Parker (an alternate Peter's daughter), she has no relation to the man we typically know as Spider-Man. She also lacks the diversity appeal and deep storyline associated with Anya Corazon, better known as Araña. And at a mere 11 years old, she won't be drawing the same crowds as the cleavage-encumbered Betty Brant.
So what does Penelope have to offer? Well, first, she's about the most adorable human character to ever grace the pages of a Marvel comic. Created by Katie Cook (best known for her work on IDW's My Little Pony comics), Penelope's youth sets her apart from other Web-slingers. There's something painfully real about watching her cry her little eyes out when she first learns that her dreams of normalcy have been killed by a spider bite, yet simultaneously humorous as she vents her frustration that she couldn't have been bitten by a radioactive unicorn instead.
That said, Penelope Parker still boasts all the same character traits that make up Spider-Man's core identity. She's precocious, she's pure of heart, and she answers the call to duty with a balance of grim determination and self-effacing humor.
While Penelope could administer Sony's Spider-Verse with an almost excessive dose of concentrated cuteness, she could also be a role model for girls her own age by showing them what it looks like to embrace their struggles and make the most of them no matter how much it hurts.
3. Golden Sponge Cakes Spider-Man
Forget the shawarma, it's time for Marvel and Sony to serve us up some fruit pies.
Appearing primarily in Hostess ads, this version of Spider-Man doles out justice tempered with mercy, typically by distracting his opponents with delicious snacks. And not just Twinkies, as the above moniker implies. He also has a fondness for cupcakes and fruit pies, which even mainstream Spider-Man comics have alluded to on occasion.
Unfortunately, hailing from a world where evil can be overcome by sugar has its drawbacks. This version of Spider-Man has never truly had to win a fight, leading to his surprise murder at the hands of life force vampire Morlun after Spidey's trusted Twinkies failed to stop the supervillain in his tracks as they've so often done before.
Despite the sheer lunacy of everything above, it's actually the same flaw which led to Spidey's death that could ultimately justify his revival on the big screen. Into the Spider-Verse already cracked wise about Spidey's history as a marketing tool, and it's easy to assume that any inclusion in future outings would be relegated to a short cameo and a cheap joke. However, hailing from a universe where bank vaults are full of cupcakes and differences can be sorted out with enough cream filling, Hostess Spidey is arguably the most hopeful version of a character already beloved for his optimism. Perhaps he's useless in most real fights, but he could become a pivotal cheerleader for the Spider-Verse heroes at their lowest.
In the age of product placement, there's no Spidey better suited to take point in the typical third-act rallying cry.
2. Spiders-Man
Assuming the What If...? producers were to stick with the anti-horror sentiments currently preventing them from embracing such ideas as Man-Spider or Patton Parnel, Spiders-Man could offer Disney+ the homerun they need to justify a story involving real spiders. There's no ghastly transformation here, just a bunch of cute spiders piling on top of each other inside a costume. It's practically just a slightly more disturbing take on the "three kids in a trench coat" gag.
Spiders-Man, like many Spider-Men on this list, was created for the Spider-Geddon crossover event. His origin in the Vault of Spiders tie-in explains that his universe's Peter Parker fell into a pit of experimental spiders who essentially devoured him and absorbed his consciousness as the new foundation for their hive mind. They now suffer something of an identity crisis, believing themselves to be the real Peter Parker despite also theorizing that the real Peter likely died that day. This belief in Peter's apparent death ultimately causes a grief-ridden Spiders-Man ultimately to cut ties with Gwen Stacy when she discusses plans to turn "Peter" back to normal.
Despite his dark origins, Spiders-Man still provokes some twisted laughs here and there with frequent casual references to his hunger for human flesh. He may gross out his fellow Web-slingers, but he does so with just enough self-awareness to allow for some meta-humor if Sony ever wanted to include him in their Spider-Verse.
With many characters showing up to that universe already fully developed, Sony could neatly avoid the more disturbing elements of his origin while still enjoying the sheer novelty of a Spider-Man who does whatever ten thousand spiders can.
1. Spider-Cop
Spider-Cop's three-panel appearance in Spider-Geddon serves as little more than setup and payoff for a joke aimed at PS4 Spider-Man fans. While it's easy to imagine him making a brief leap to the big screen, it'd likely only happen as a brief cameo in Sony's Spider-Verse, and only for the sheer amusement of seeing Spider-Man with a fake moustache. A longer appearance would require much more depth and backstory than the comics have bothered to give him.
Surprisingly, however, that's where he becomes one of the few Web-slingers on this list suited for an appearance in the more grounded MCU. His origin would merely need to borrow from another police-oriented Wall-crawler, The Spider.
Appearing in the same Vault of Spiders issue as Spiders-Man, the black-suited Spider is a pistol-wielding George Stacy who seems (although it's never stated outright) to be fighting in honor of a deceased Gwen. In the comics, Spider-Gwen is the one to bring both Spider-Cop and The Spider into the Superior Spider-Army, but the potential for her interactions with an alternate version of her father is never fully explored. Into the Spider-Verse could adapt this story faithfully while also plumbing its emotional depths in a new way.
As for the MCU? Well, if No Way Home really does throw former big-screen Spideys into the mix, then the MCU can begin providing them some closure on the losses they suffered in their own films.
While Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man seemingly overcame Gwen's loss over the length of a single montage, her father's death haunted him throughout much of his second outing. Getting the chance to speak with George Stacy one last time, even if not technically the "real" George Stacy, could provide his character some much-needed closure.