15 Greatest Joker Comics Of All Time

The clown prince's best.

Joker Rebirth
DC Comics

Over 75 years, The Joker has shown that his main appeal lies in his flexibility. What other comic book villain is more shapeable, more reinvent-able? You can do almost anything with The Clown Prince Of Crime and he’ll still be recognizably himself.

Make him a prankster, a killer, a cross-dresser, an anarchist, or a junkie. Make him insane, supersane, or just differently sane. He’s that great embodiment of the Shapeshifter archetype. His form is being formless, and he can bewilder the hero (and the reader) at every turn.

Even so, you can only stretch Joker’s putty-like characteristics so far before he comes apart. How many pranks can he pull without losing his edge? How sadistic can he get before he stops making us laugh? (And Joker should make us laugh, albeit with discomfort.) How many tattoos can he sport until his trademark elegance is cancelled out? 

With that in mind, there are some Joker comics in which he excels more than others, and singling them out is thus even more valuable. In every case, the creators put forth their own take on The Mogul of Mountebanks while staying true to the spirit of the character.

Now there may be some surprises on this list - perhaps even some upheavals - but it's all in the anarchic spirit of the character...

15. The Return Of The Joker

Return of the Joker
DC Comics

To be frank, “A Death in the Family" is over-rated and undeserving of the highest praise. There’s a certain torture porn vibe around The Joker beating Robin to death (especially just months after he paralyzed and assaulted Barbara Gordon) that just doesn’t do it for me.

It always felt like less of an organic character development and more of an editorial intervention to boost sales. Probably because that's precisely what it was.

In contract, this little two-parter from Marv Wolfman and Jim Aparo represents a story that’s very much a response to Joker’s dark turn at the end of the ‘80s. These comics are about him trying to “find the joke again” after his brutal attacks on sidekicks. 

It’s as if The Joker himself, suffering from gunshot wounds and doubt, rejects the empty and violent direction he’d been taken. And it's a brilliant arc.


14. The Man Who Laughs

Batman The Man Who Laughs Page 10
DC Comics

This sounds like faint praise, but this comic is admirable in its restraint. It’s a tight and self-contained reimagining of Joker’s first killing spree back in 1940 and Joker’s victims have rarely looked so grotesque. (Those bodies he experimented on and left to rot are the worst.)

Batman’s victory is a small one in the end - it's merely his first defeat of Joker, and we know that he can only look forward to a lifetime’s worth of conflicts. 

With how grandiose their feuds would become, it’s cool to see their first struggle played out as a rooftop argument (followed by a swift pummelling obviously). 

This comic is a small victory in its own way; a remake that works as well as the original. 


13. Batman And Robin Must Die!

Batman and Robin Reborn Frank Quitely
DC Comics

“A Robin who even brings his own crowbar to the party? You might be the funniest one yet.” In a satisfying twist, Joker finds himself locked in a room with a crowbar-wielding Damian Wayne - the Robin who has no qualms with assassination - and things only get more unhinged from there.

Frazer Irving’s art is gorgeous in a clammy way - Joker’s thick greasy hair, his pink eyes streaming makeup, his jagged black fingernails. And the jaw-dropping scene with Joker and Damian feels like the payoff end of a revenge flick, and again shows how “A Death in the Family” works best as a jumping off point for other stories. 


12. Death Of The Family

batman the joker death of the family face cut off
DC Comics

The stakes of this claustrophobic horror story are deeply personal: just picture your loved ones in danger. “Death of the Family” sees Joker hitting very close to home. It has Joker as a jilted lover and a home wrecker who invades the tranquility of the Batcave and destroys the trust built up by Bruce among his family.

And props have to go to the New 52 team for so successfully overhauling Joker’s look, with the mechanic’s coverall and the terrifying impact of Joker’s detached face. That has become one of the most haunting and already most recaptured moments in the Joker lexicon.

Some claim the ending is uneventful compared to the plot’s horrifying anticipation. To me, the comedown conclusion is fitting with the story’s primally emotional stakes.


11. The Sound Of One Hand Clapping

Sound of One Hand Clapping
DC Comics

This hidden gem serves as a pleasantly untraditional window onto the Clown Prince. 

In a conversation between Joker and Superman, it is concluded that Joker is the more boring of the two. Every comprehensive “Greatest Ever” list should include a detracting voice, and this is a sharp indictment of The Joker as a character.

Joker seems totally unprepared for any audience other than his safely grim Batman. Superman laughs at one of his jokes, and he doesn’t even know how to process it. As it turns out, when you pay attention to Joker like Superman would, he comes off unformed, uninspired, and uncertain. 


10. Joker

Joker Comic.jpg
DC Comics

There’s some confusion about how much Heath Ledger’s crusty turn as an off-his-meds Joker inspired the creative team behind the “Joker” graphic novel, or vice versa. 

But regardless of the spark’s origin, this 2008 book catches the same rejuvenating lightning as its onscreen counterpart. This Joker is a tough-talking, bird-flipping, pill-popping killer, robber, and rapist. Disgustingly real blood runs through this guy’s veins.

In the eyes of the comic’s lowlife protagonist, Jonny Frost, Joker seems an unstoppable conquering force. This is The Joker as Scarface, but without “The World Is Yours.” In its place, “Sin Will Find You Out.” 


9. Zero Year: Secret City

The Red Hood Gang
DC Comics

Is this take on Joker’s origin better than Alan Moore’s? Well, maybe.

This time around, The Red Hood is vicious from the start. It might be a rebellious approach, but it makes sense with Scott Snyder’s vision of Joker as an elemental force of cruel nothingness. He always was an ambassador for the abyss, and he always will be.

Maybe you think his look is a bit strange, with that pill shaped hood and exposed mouth, but isn’t it just completely, perfectly unnerving? 

It’s wacky and showcases that iconic grin, and it also puts to rest any actual questions as to whether this Red Hood does or doesn’t go on to become The Joker. This version might as well already be wearing the same purple suit.


8. Gotham Central: Soft Targets

Soft Targets
DC Comics

This one comes off like how the people behind HBO’s The Wire would interpret Heath Ledger’s chaotic schemes from The Dark Knight. For most of the story Joker is an infuriating offstage force, sniping Gotham’s public figures and civilians, and whipping up municipal panic.

It's an atypical career move by the Clown Prince, given that he's usually a lot closer to the action (preferring to see the emotional reactions first hand as currency), but there's definitely something of The Dark Knight's version of the character in here too. That Gotham Central was never as appreciated as it deserved to be 

Artist Michael Lark’s Joker looks like the Jack Nicholson movie clown stepped off the silver screen and his knowing expressions are plain unsettling. He also beats a guy to death with a phone book, which is just too much to take. 


7. The Joker

Batman The Joker's Death
DC

Not even the first appearance of Batman himself can match the elemental power of The Joker’s 1940 debut. Bob Kane’s art still carries the shock of the immediate 75 years later. And it seems The Joker was an expert of media manipulation from the very beginning, spitefully announcing his first crimes over the radio.

It’s extra fun reading this one now with the knowledge that he was supposed to die at the end, accidentally stabbed in the heart by himself and collapsing with delightful disbelief. 

He only survived by the grace of an editor who commissioned a last-minute panel of Joker recovering in an ambulance. Otherwise, this could have been the first and last Joker comic.


6. The Laughing Fish!

Batman Laughing Fish
DC Comics

Since the beginning, The Joker’s best plots have used media to target the masses. In 1940 Joker intoned his dark deeds to a tuned-in radio public, Jack Nicholson’s Joker hijacked the TV news, and Heath Ledger’s Joker stirred up citywide chaos with a camcorder. 

But really, what medium could be more perfectly suited to spread Joker’s face around than mass marketed fish?

This is bar none the best scheme Joker’s ever hatched: poisoning Gotham’s fish supply with Joker toxin and trying to copyright the grinning results. The creative team behind this 1978 effort is legendary for a reason: Steve Englehart’s scripts nail Joker’s peculiar humor, and Marshall Rogers is one of the best visual storytellers in the business.


5. The Dark Knight Returns: Hunt The Dark Knight

Batman Joker Smile.jpg
DC Comics

The most thoroughly individualized Joker of all time can be found in the icky center of this excessive ‘80s update. Frank Miller tweaked the look and feel of the character in ways that add up to a very probable older Joker - the white suit, the tall but heavy build, the taut yet wrinkled skin, the tiny puckered mouth. It's arguably an even more unsettling look than normal.

And this Joker just comes out and calls Batman “darling” and “my sweet” in the midst of knife play. He’s straight up perverse. 

Crucially, Miller also gives the character a great death, with Joker twisting his own spine into oblivion. That feels pretty definitive.


4. Endgame

batman endgame joker fight stab
DC Comics

After some disappointed readers called the climax of “Death of the Family” toothless compared to the buildup, “Endgame” definitely delivered.

The story starts off with a Jokerized Justice League attack, trucks on with Joker cutting off Alfred’s hand, and halts with a brutal battle to the death between Joker and Batman. Greg Capullo’s fight scene would make the most grizzled Frank Miller disciple drool and wince.

How great is it also that Joker here unleashes a climactic parade straight out of Tim Burton's first Batman movie, except this time he’s riding a giant grinning dinosaur. As memorable images go, it's pretty damn good.


3. The Killing Joke

The Killing Joke
DC Comics

Look, “The Killing Joke" is great and everyone knows it, but it’s not the best Joker comic no matter how you spin it. That doesn't mean it's any less important, of course.

"The Killing Joke" reads similarly to Alan Moore’s other masterwork “Watchmen” - literary, poetic, symbolic, self-reflexive and structured. And in a way, this kind of story just can’t be Joker’s greatest, no matter how memorable the moments or how chilling the crimes.

Joker is most effective as a character when his madness bleeds a bit into the nature of the comic itself. (For the best example, see Number 1 on this list.) The storytelling techniques of “The Killing Joke” work against the warped madness of the character. This feels like putting Joker in a cage, albeit a beautifully and solidly constructed one.


2. Mad Love

harley quinn mad love
DC Comics

There are plenty of obvious reasons to hate The Joker. For one, he’s a fully functioning homicidal artist. But this masterpiece from the creators of “Batman: The Animated Series” convinces you to hate him for something a bit more domestic: he’s a terrible boyfriend.

Through Harley Quinn’s transformation from malleable pop psychologist to supervillain moll, all a result of Joker’s game playing, we see very different shades of Joker’s evil than we’re used to. We realize he’s manipulative, fickle, and unglamorous in his obsessions. 

We see an unpleasant caricature of the abusive boyfriend. Come for the storytelling genius of the creative team, stay for the emotional fish-whacks to the gut.


1. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earth

Arkham Asylum Serious House JOker.jpg
DC Comics

Read this comic and let your mind melt a little. Look into Joker’s bloody searing eyes. Open your mouth and let the roaches fall out. Dave McKean’s art holds atmosphere that can’t be found anywhere else in comics, making his interpretation of Joker feel like a singularity. And dig those high heels.

This is a graphic novel by creators who absolutely let Joker lead the way. They stepped into his world and changed their approach. 

Grant Morrison’s Joker incorporates the best of the character’s many voices through history - the perversity of Frank Miller, the dark humor of Steve Englehart, the sinister drive of the Robinson/Finger/Kane original. You may as well surrender and consume the whole thing in one feverish reading, because Joker’s running the place.


Which do you think are the greatest Joker comic books of all time? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
Batman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Nathan Hastings hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.