6 Wildest Batman Stories Never Published

From the Coulda Been Bat-astic to the Bat-$#!# Crazy.

If everyone in Hollywood seems to be working on a script, everyone in comics seems to have at least one Batman pitch. He may have the most varied interpretations of any character in comics, after all: sometimes he's goofy, sometimes he's gothy, sometimes he's a team player and sometimes a hag-ridden loner, sometimes he's written by Alan Moore and sometimes he's written by Kevin Smith. But no matter who he is, he's the highest-profile superhero who "could be you," who doesn't have the benefit of an alien upbringing or irradiated or otherwise altered cells, but just does what any average red-blooded citizen might do, if an average red-blooded citizen had a crimefighting obsession and virtually infinite money. That gets people writing the kind of fan-fiction that sometimes becomes a full-fledged pitch. And everyone wants to see him kick Superman's hinder next year. All kinds of ideas about Batman will never see print, sometimes for foolish reasons, sometimes for mundane ones and sometimes for really, really good ones. Follow us on a journey that begins with regret, and ends with profound relief.

6. €œJ€

Multi-talented comedian/actor Patton Oswalt made some waves in 2011 by releasing a couple of quirky pitches from a few years back. The one he had less confidence in, "J," seems to have been refused as "esoteric and pretentious," but it strikes us as the more compelling:
The Joker once again breaks out of Arkham Asylum, and Batman - along with the Justice League - tears apart Gotham to find him. And who feels the heat the worst when the League is cracking down hard? Gotham's criminals. And because Batman works his way up from minor street thug, higher and higher on the chain, it's the "C" list criminals who suffer first. Barely escaping a beatdown and capture, The Cluemaster (who I'm going to make a much younger, inexperienced criminal) gathers a literal "C"-list of other, frightened criminals - Crazyquilt, Crime Doctor, Calendar Man and Copperhead - to hunt the "J". What follows is a desperate night search through Gotham's underworld, during which our protagonist - The Cluemaster - sees firsthand the effects of crime (Calendar Man's failed, broken life; The Crime Doctor's past victims and wasted potential; Crazyquilt's petty "goals" and Copperhead's pointless savagery). It all comes to a head when they confront The Joker - who personifies every awful quality of his teammates. He stops them from killing "J" - they each have their reasons for wanting The Joker dead - and then leaves the "team". The last page shows him leaving one last clue for The Batman - the location of the loot he stole earlier that night. Like I said, maybe a little too esoteric. But I wanted to put Batman and the other big, colorful superheroes into the world of one of those low-stakes, early 70's noirs, like The Nickel Ride or Hustle.
Odds Of Being Good: 95%. Oswalt's existing comics work includes JLA: Welcome to the Working Week, which is packed to bursting with fun ideas. Odds Of Being Published Someday: 5%. Oswalt at least has some history with DC, but this project never got past the pitch stage.

5. Batman: Europa

And of course there were the artists: Giuseppe Camuncoli providing layouts for all four issues, Lee painting over issue #1, Camuncoli finishing #2 and Diego Latorre and Jock doing #3 and #4 respectively. At least, that was the plan. Originally announced and solicited in 2004, it was re-announced in 2011 with considerable fanfare (including a cover feature on Diamond Previews), but neither came to anything more than some intriguing plot summaries and all four covers. Odds Of Being Good:90%. The talent involved is considerable, and most are well known for other projects. "Batman teams up with the Joker" isn't all that original a hook, but the added dimensions of a virus slowing him down and a European setting rendered by European natives is still interesting. Odds Of Being Published: 30%. Lee himself may be the holdup, and if the basic layouts are completed, then this project got a lot further than the others on this list.

4, Kingdom Of The Mad

There may be no musician who jumped into comics more successfully than Gerard Way. His Umbrella Academy won several awards and was optioned by Universal, and while he's hardly a full-timer, he's kept his hand in, most recently in Edge of Spider-Verse and Vertigo Quarterly. DC greenlit "Kingdom of the Mad" for its Vertigo line. Way never made the plot of the series clear, but he tweeted some intriguing sketches and character notes...
only eats rats... Thinks he's a bat... The inside of the cape has a massive drawing of a magical kingdom that he made up, like his version of Heaven. He has ESP, can turn into a bat, and can see into the future, but only he knows about these powers.

€œI€™m Mr. Freeze! I like to dress up as my dead wife in armor I sculpted out of scrap-metal from her car accident!€ pic.twitter.com/xNnluYpeXU

€” goth claudia (@gerardway) June 2, 2013
Odds Of Being Good:70%. Some of the ideas here seem almost too oddball, but if there's one mythos that can take a little gothic experimentation, it's Batman's. Odds Of Being Published:20%. DC has shown interest, and if Way's career ever slows down, he might have the freedom or even the need to flesh this project out. DC is definitely about as friendly to alternate worlds as it's ever been.

3. Batman, Prince Of Denmark

Steve Englehart has his bona fides as a Bat-writer, and he came up with a fascinating concept: turn Hamlet into Batman. The two do have some intriguing features in common: a fixation on murdered parents, a background of wealth and privilege which they never fully enjoy but employ in their dark missions, a tendency to talk out loud to themselves, a poor track record with romance and emotional availability. So it's kind of amazing that Englehart's pitch didn't turn out more engaging. The biggest surprise is that in his version, the Joker-like Jester is actually a benevolent agent, guiding Hamlet to his ultimate destiny.

Alone in a deserted turret of the castle, Hamlet calls himself a coward and berates himself. The Jester comes and talks with him, advising him to take his adoption of a false persona a step farther. If he, Hamlet, can't make himself act, why not "become" a man dedicated to action? "They'll still know who I am," complains Hamlet. Then why not wear a mask? Something designed to show those who encounter you that you're no one to be trifled with? Something to strike fear in their hearts! At that moment, a bat flies through the turret window. And so is born€the idea for the Bat-man.

But Hamlet still doesn't do anything. "To be the Bat, or not to be€"

Problem is, that destiny is nothing if not predictable: Hamlet's tale sticks pretty close to the play before veering away just in time to avoid any killing that could be said to be by Hamlet's own hand. (Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are fine!) At which point he becomes Batman and swears to bring his uncle and anyone who supports him to justice! And, um, that's the end.

Odds Of Being Good:35%. Nothing about actually bringing his uncle to justice, or how the most effective way for a prince to fight crime might be to, you know, become king? Englehart is a fine writer and it's possible he could rework this a bit. Plus, working from Shakespeare isn't a bad place to start. It's just that pitch itself is really puzzling. Odds Of Being Published:30%. Some mashup of Batman and Hamlet does seem like the sort of thing DC will publish eventually, though whether it'll be based on this pitch or even involve Englehart is uncertain.

2. Samaritan X

Back when J. Michael Straczynski was getting high-profile assignments on Superman and Wonder Woman, he started work on this original graphic novel, best described as ER meets Gotham.
Samaritan X is as impressive outside as it is inside: a twenty-story gleaming glass and steel tower with two landing platforms on the roof, bullet-proof glass three inches thick, a staff of the best and the brightest in a variety of disciplines, and every high-tech, cutting-edge medical, scientific and diagnostic tool ever created, all in service to an area of specialization, and a clientele, that is utterly unique. In a world where super-powered individuals fight a never-ending battle against evil, Samaritan X is where those wounded on either side of that struggle come to be treated and saved. Within its walls the essential human drama of life and death is made even more intense by its application to those whom the world calls heroes or villains, the celebrated and the vilified, the nearly immortal and the previously invulnerable. When an eternally young character suddenly begins aging€when Metamorpho discovers that he can no longer control his chemical reactions and is a danger to himself and others€when Supergirl needs a life-saving operation but her skin cannot be pierced by any known science€when a female hero is about to have her first child, and fears that the strength of her contractions in birth could kill her normal son€when Cyborg discovers that his life-sustaining cybernetic implants are failing€when a hero with fiery powers discovers he can no longer turn it off and may have to live the rest of his life never touching another human being, even his own children€when a hero is wounded in battle and brought to the hospital for treatment only to be pursued there by his enemy, who is determined to finish what he started regardless of who gets caught in the middle€when a hero on the edge of collapse suffers a psychotic break€when young men and women from all over the world discover for the first time that they have powers and don€™t know how to handle them..when those or a million other things go wrong with people strong enough to tear apart whole cities with their bare hands...their best hope for survival is Samaritan X.
Odds Of Being Good: 35%. The pitch sounds amazing, really. A superhero medical drama is a natural and under-explored idea. The only problem is Stracynski-- his work on Superman and Wonder Woman was distinctly underwhelming, a far cry from his glory days on Babylon 5. Even his earlier Spider-Man work was largely mixed. Odds Of Being Published:8%. We haven't heard any reason this couldn't be revived in some way-- but that's just it: we haven't heard anything about it at all, and JMS is a busy guy. He's been headlining his own studio since 2012, and aside from Before Watchmen, his DC Comics work has sharply tapered off.

1. Holy Terror, Batman!

(Not to be confused with Batman: Holy Terror, a 1991 story by Alan Brennert and Norm Breyfogle.) How do you solve a problem like Frank Miller? His early work-- Daredevil, Batman: Year One, Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Martha Washington, Ronin and others-- is resonant and powerful, a proud part of comics history. Even somewhat later pieces like Sin City and 300 were entertaining in a rock-em-sock-em, pulpy way. But even as Netflix's Daredevil and Batman v. Superman bring some of his old ideas to the screen, Miller has gone back to those old ideas with diminishing returns, putting style so far over substance that it's practically become the substance, if not abstract expressionism. 300 and The Dark Knight Returns got sequels that are better off ignored, and later this year, Dark Knight Returns will be getting another, with the worrying subtitle "The Master Race." That subtitle leads us to the other problem with Miller: he was always a little right of center, but has become so politically inflexible that it's colored some of his work in retrospect. There's nothing wrong, necessarily, with making Islamic terrorists your villains: they're certainly despicable enough. There's something considerably more wrong with writing a superhero story that is simply anti-Islam, conflating 1.2 billion people with the actions of Al-Qaeda or ISIS, reducing all Muslims to faceless Chitauri and making an outright cartoon of the war on terror. But that's exactly what Miller did, and in his early drafts, he was going to use Batman to do it. Odds Of Being Good:Incalculably Small.Odds Of Being Published... Actually, this story barely qualifies as unpublished-- a version of it did see print as Holy Terror, and it's pretty clear that the main protagonists are Miller's Batman and Catwoman with the serial numbers filed off (especially if you've read Miller's All-Star Batman and Robin, where they act similarly). Even so, it's easy to imagine how much worse this would have been if marketed as an official Batman story by one of superhero comics' biggest stars, or even as part of Batman's canon.
Though DC Comics was not interested in publishing the result, Miller presented the decision to turn Holy Terror into a non-Batman story as his, not DC's. If that's true, then it is the only thing about this project that shows any kind of restraint. He also said the book was "guaranteed to offend just about everybody." Mission accomplished. What are your favorite comics, Batman-related or otherwise, that never reached issue #1 and therefore, technically, do not exist? Ponder the philosophical implications of that, then let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Batman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

T Campbell has written quite a few online comics series and selected work for Marvel, Archie and Tokyopop. His longest-running works are Fans, Penny and Aggie-- and his current project with co-writer Phil Kahn, Guilded Age.