7 Scariest Batman Moments Ever

Batman is many things. He's a superhero; a vigilante; an avenger; a detective; a master of disguise. But perhaps Batman's greatest role is as a symbol to Gotham City; a symbol of hope and justice to its citizens but a symbol of dread and fear to its teeming criminal element. Batman is indeed a fearful presence. But he€™s arguably nothing compared to the characters that said presence attracts. Batman€™s rogues gallery is filled with creepy individuals. And don€™t forget the creepy locations. And when you really think about it, Bats can be pretty creepy too when he wants to be. Over the course of Batman€™s illustrious career in print there have been more than a few scary moments. After all, While other supes face off against the power mad and the global domination driven, Batman prefers to focus his attention on the deranged and the criminally psychotic. And if there€™s one thing you can trust the deranged and the criminally psychotic to deliver it€™s scary moments. This piece aims to chronicle seven such moments; the ones that made us reel in repulsion or gasp in worried surprise, reluctant to turn the page. So hold on to your Bat-nuts and let€™s dive in.

7. Batman Year One: Batman Comes To Dinner

I know most of you probably weren't expecting the hero to have much of a presence on a scary Batman moments list. This is in part due to the fact that the character of Batman has always attracted "a better class of criminal" who are generally either quite menacing, escaped mental patients, just flat out morbid, or most likely a combination of the three. However we must never forget (and never will thanks to the Nolan films) that Batman is a character who himself uses fear tactics to combat his enemies. Of all of my favorite "Batman scaring the crap out of someone" moments, one scene in Frank Miller's Batman: Year One will always resonate with me. During a lavish dinner with all of Gotham's most corrupt citizens, Batman blows up a whole side of the house, kills the lights, and is lit by only a small flambé fire. The Dark Knight's shadowy face will always be emblazoned in my mind thanks to the beautiful artwork of David Mazzucchelli in this panel. The faces of the dinner patrons are also rendered in a such a way as to show how truly frightened they are. Then you have some of Frank Miller's finest writing of his career: Ladies. Gentleman. You have eaten well. You have eaten Gotham's wealth. It's Spirit. Your feast is nearly over. From this moment on-- None of you are safe. (Frank Miller) Then The Bat-Man closes the lid on the flambé leaving everyone in somber terror. If anyone wants to know how scary Batman can be, look no further than Batman: Year One.

6. Any Time Bruce Wayne Hallucinates About His Dead Parents

It's always creepy to see your dead parents lurking around your house am I right? For Bruce Wayne/Batman unfortunately, this practically happens every Tuesday. Whether our hero is drugged by Scarecrow's fear toxin, drinking spiked water from a fountain belonging to The Court of Owls, or has just had too many long nights without sleep, the late Thomas and Martha Wayne always seem to haunt his waking nightmares. You can't really blame the guy of course, seeing that he watched them murdered before his 9 year old eyes. Though it may be cheating a little, my favorite dead Bat-parent situation occurs in the Arkham Asylum video game. At least it was written by God-like comic and TV writer Paul Dini so cut me some slack. In the game at one point, Batman gets drugged and enters the Asylums morgue. In front of him are 3 body bags; all of them shaking slightly from whatever is inside. You then have to make Batman open each of the bags in order to move on in the game. Sorry Bruce! But I had to do it! Inside of course are Thomas, Martha, and finally the Scarecrow in that order. Batman's parents look like zombies and they even taunt our hero for not being able to save them. Worst... Guilt trip... Ever!

5. A Death in the Family: The Last Flight of a Robin

To put it bluntly, The second Robin (Jason Todd) gets beaten practically to death by the Joker with a crowbar. Covered in blood and tattered tights, Robin then gets blown up by a bomb. This is one of the most defining moments in the history of Batman in comics. It is also quite disturbing and extremely brutal. The scenes of Robin being beaten while the Joker laughs and cracks jokes has been seen time and again in flashbacks and memories ever since. Possibly the darkest part of this sordid tale is the now legendary fact that in 1988, Batman fans actually voted for this to happen by calling a special phone number. Fans becoming literary murderers pulled us all into the reality that where the death of Robin is concerned, we are no better than those that Batman has always tried to stop. Kinda cool in a scary way wouldn't you say?

4. Batman #663: The Clown At Midnight

Found in the story arc of Batman and Son by Grant Morrison, The Clown At Midnight tells the haunting tale of the Joker's disturbing rebirth as "The Harlequin of Hate" after being shot in the face by a Batman impersonator. The terror of this story line is driven into your brain like a rusty iron rod as the events unfold in beautiful prose rather than speech bubbles. The words of Grant Morrison have never been so pretty or sadistic as this. The piece could even be defined as a morbid poem formed by the Joker's twisted mind. The basic plot of the story is that the Joker is planning to reincarnate himself into the world with his newest personality and look. To start with though, he plans on killing all of his henchmen (Harley Quinn included) through the use of toxin in red and black flowers. Batman of course deals with the Joker in usual fashion, but the new Joker is ultimately born regardless. The scariest moments of this story are largely thanks to the genius bordering on madness of John Van Fleet's art. The best way I can describe it is as some form of digital/pencilled/painted photoshopped perfection. Technically referred to as mixed-media art, to see it yourself is really the only way to fully grasp it. The Joker's new look consists of a mad scientist butcher coat type outfit, with a stitched permanent grin be carves himself, and choppy hair. Evil has never been so clearly defined. The classic Stephen King quote is still clearly true: "nobody likes a clown at midnight."

3. Batman #13: The New 52 Joker

After so many years, I never thought the Joker would really benefit much from the whole DC New 52 initiative. I was severely wrong. I clearly didn't put enough faith in the writing of such wonderful authors as Tony S. Daniel or Scott Snyder. I'm not sure why I didn't either because neither of them have ever really let me down before. In Daniel's Detective Comics #1, we are first introduced to a character named Dollmaker who in the end of the issue is asked by the Joker to remove his face for him. We see the horrible result in a huge full page image of the Joker's fully removed face hanging on the wall. Then for a year the Joker vanished... But now he's back! In the most recent issue of Batman (#13) The Clown Prince of Crime has returned to Gotham in a truly frightening way. Not since the first time I saw Heath Ledger in Joker makeup have I been so truly uncomfortable and scared by the classic character. Basically in Batman #13, the Joker kills the lights to police headquarters, and then proceeds to start killing cops in the pitch darkness. The villain is only seen in shadow or out of the corner of your eye which is always more frightening than seeing the monster right away. He isn't just there for cop killing either. He wants back his locked away evidence room prize: his removed face! Not only is the Joker back to his killing ways, but he is also back to his iconic style of announcing his murders will happen at a certain time. Not only that, but he's putting a new spin on his old favorites by calling back to his first murders that date back to the original 1st issue of Batman in 1940. We don't fully know what is in store with this new Joker, but 2 things are certain: The Joker is out for the blood of the entire Bat-Family for one thing. And now he has one Hell of a new skin mask stretched over his damaged face!

2. The Killing Joke: Everything The Joker Does

In 1988, Alan Moore and Brian Bolland single handedly made one of the greatest contributions to Batman comics since Alfred: They created The Killing Joke. Not only did this one-shot revolutionize the way the character of the Joker has been portrayed ever since, but it also began the transformation of Barbara Gordon from Batgirl to Oracle. That transformation tragically begins in The Killing Joke with one of the most terrifying comic book scenes of all time. The doorbell rings at Jim Gordon's home, Barbara answers it, and standing behind the door in the shadows of night is the Joker. He is dressed as a Hawaiian tourist with a camera around his neck and a gun in his hand. He then proceeds to shoot Barbara Gordon through the spine, paralyzing her until only recently in the New 52 comics. As if that weren't enough, he then strips off all of her clothing so that he can take nude photographs of her. Later on Joker uses all of this to try and prove that anyone can go mad like him if they go through just one very bad day. He does this by (you guessed it) stripping down Commissioner Gordon so he is naked, takes him to an abandoned amusement park filled with freaks, and makes him look at the photos of his naked daughter as she bleeds out on the floor. The events of The Killing Joke are so disturbing and frightening that this comic is still viewed almost universally as the best Joker story of all time. I find it hard to disagree with those fine folks... But it isn't the scariest! Bwwaa ha ha!

1. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earth The winner is without a doubt Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On Serious Earth. And not just a singular moment from this groundbreaking 1989 graphic novel by Grant Morrison, but the entire book as a whole. If you see this as me cheating by picking a whole story as a scary moment, then you are a fool who has clearly never experienced this macabre window into madness and fear. Created in a surrealist manner with strong pathological tones as well as sexual conflicts and even architecture, Arkham Asylum creates a Batman world that needs to be seen to be believed. If you have never read it yourself, or it has been a long time since you entered that serious house, it is time to remedy either of those psychoses. By far the scariest Batman moments in comics appear behind the walls of Grant Morrison's Arkham Asylum. This is in large part due to the absolutely shocking and almost impossible artwork of Dave McKean. Batman takes on the image of a giant charcoal wraith with haunting angles and a wispy cape. The Joker (always the flip side of Batman's coin) appears as a neon splash of insanity and clown makeup. Never has the Joker looked so manic, horrifying, and beautiful all at once. Then you have the flashback sequences of Amadeus Arkham tending to his bug-filled mouthed mother and losing his mind to the point of wearing a wedding dress complete with straight razor. The final piece of this terror puzzle is the stunning lettering job done by Gaspar Saladino. Giving all the characters different fonts when they speak was nothing short of genius. The Joker in particular with his blood red splashed dialogue gave the character the perfect "voice" that has resonated with readers ever since. At the time this practice of fonts to fit the character was being pioneered. Now it shows up almost everywhere you look. And comics I feel are all the better for it. Arkham Asylum exists in it's own strange world by itself. From the Joker telling Batman he's sharpening pencils so he can poke out a young girl's eyes, to a tragic Two-Face who can't even decide not to urinate on himself due to new treatments involving tarot cards and a six sided die, fear lives around every corner. Even Clayface comes off as a horror in this book and that is saying something in my opinion. Arkham Asylum has it all my friends. Once again I must insist that you commit yourself to this graphic novel madhouse at once! That does it for my list of terrors. I do hope you enjoyed it. But now for a question: What scares you in the Batman world? Do you have what it takes to plunge into the horrors that lurk in Gotham? Comment below... If you dare...


In this post: 
Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

By day, Don is the manager of an after-school program for 4th-8th graders... When night falls, he can be found writing primarily about Batman right here on What Culture! When not consumed by The Dark Knight, Don writes poetry, short stories, and screenplays. No matter how much he intrigues you though, Don is "off the market in love" with his girlfriend Mary. He also likes macaroni and cheese a lot. And bacon...