7 Wildly Different Iterations Of The Punisher

From the weird to the wonderful...

The state a hero leaves the villain in speaks volumes for their character. Spider-Man will generally tie up the bad guys in a mass of pubescent symbolism and a post-it note. Aquaman leaves them without their dignity. The Punisher, though? The Punisher has them Eskimo kiss an Uzi and puts so many holes in their faces they end up looking like Seal just got attacked by a pack of seals. His name isn€™t €˜Non-threatening Foot Massage Man€™. It€™s the Punisher. Frank Castle is a force of nature and if he sets his sights on you then you are not long for this world. Reflective of his black and white vision of morality, Castle isn€™t a complex man. He€™s a product of and an answer to crime. The bogeyman for boogeymen. Beginning as a foil for Spider-Man and slowly developing into the merciless vigilante that we all know and love, Frank Castle is of a different breed. He doesn€™t guide villains through the proverbial revolving door of the justice system. He smokes them faster than a hipster with a pack of menthols. Is the Punisher insane or is he the sanest man alive? That€™s for you to decide. Here are some of the best (and worst) versions of the most dangerous man in the Marvel Universe...

7. Mangaverse

Let€™s play a game of word association with the Punisher. Merciless. Dark. Cold. Kinky. Murderer. Wait, what? The Marvel Mangaverse was an interesting endeavour; cash in on the anime and manga boom of the early 2000€™s by creating an €˜East meet West€™ universe featuring the Marvel characters. Naturally, each portrayal boasted a healthy dose of Eastern stereotypes but the Punisher€™s was the only one to incorporate a healthy dose of BDSM. Dubbed €˜Tokyo€™s Kinkiest Superhero€™, this female version of the Punisher is a high school principal by day and vigilante geisha by night. Armed with a whip and spanking paddle, Sosumi Brown terrorizes Yakuza and Oni alike by sullying them into submission. Trading firearms for feathers and claymores for canes, the Mangaverse Punisher playfully digs at the perceived sexual deviancy of our Eastern brethren. Hits; Though in no way as iconic as the haunting skull that Frank dons as he doles out his interpretation of vengeance, the design of Sosumi Brown as a geisha with skull-inspired face paint is eye-catching. Sosumi appears almost ethereal, reminiscent of a yurei (Japanese ghost). Until she starts spanking Korean gangsters, that is. The Oni€™s method of attack is basically Bulbasaur€™s Razor Leaf. Sosumi€™s parents were killed in a €˜freak pogo stick accident€™. Yes, you read that correctly. Misses; Frank Castle doesn€™t use a safe word.

6. Purgatory

In the immortal words of the Spice Girls; €˜too much of something is bad enough€™. There was a point in the 90€™s when the Punisher had no less than four monthly comics on the shelves. When his popularity eventually began to wane, editorial decided that something needed to be done in order to boost sales and a radical change was permitted. Frank was made to turn his gun on himself, only to be resurrected as a demon hunting angel. This is not the last time the Punisher is given a supernatural twist, however it€™s widely regarded as a low-point in the characters history and was ignored by the next scribe (the incomparable Garth Ennis) entirely. Yes, Frank is a bogeyman for criminals, but not in the literal sense; his stories (mostly) incorporate a degree of realism, even if he is using a steamroller to turn Wolverine into a hairy, Canadian crepe. Giving him a facial tattoo as embarrassing as Mike Tyson€™s (please don€™t hurt me) and a pair of magical, phallic guns that are less badass and more demon-dong does the character and the reader no favours. The Punisher is the embodiment of vengeance but on a human level. Incorporating a biblical element dissolves the raw, guttural appeal of the character. Frank may be a Catholic, but there is nothing holy about him. He knows that when his futile war inevitably reaches its bloody conclusion, he will not be reunited with his family. He€™ll have to look up to see them from his own solitary circle of hell. Fact. Hits; Not even. Misses; It turns out that Frank Castle€™s guardian angel was chasing skirt on the day Frank€™s family were viciously gunned down. Which makes sense, because heaven would be all about the bumping of uglies. The Punisher would not commit suicide. He€™s not that emotional. Frank would keep chasing down scum until his knees grind to dust and his heart farts out one last, thunderous beat.

5. Frankencastle

I wholeheartedly believe that if the writer of this storyline, Rick Remender, were to play a game of word association with Frankencastle, he would immediately say €˜Tequilas€™. Plural. This is a crazy, supernatural version of the Punisher done right. Set during the Dark Reign days of the Marvel Universe when Norman Osborn and his weird-ass hair was top cop, Norman had basically had enough of Frank€™s s**t and sent Wolverine€™s son, Daken, to give him a stern talking-to. And by that, I mean slice Frank into nine or ten different pieces. Naturally, Frank is reanimated by the unassuming Legion of Monsters (featuring a werewolf named Jack Russel and a giant, green Man Thing) into Frankencastle. A Japanese society known as The Hunter of Monsters Special Force and their leader, Hellsgaard, the Captain of Science, are trying to destroy the Legion and their subterranean hideaway filled with terrified creatures. At first, Frank decides that it is not his fight, however when a monster that previously offered him some food is killed at his doorstep, Frankencastle steps in. Because that burrito smelt good, dammit. Now that is how Frank would meet his end and subsequently be resurrected for the second time because, you know, comics. He€™d go out in tsunami of savagery, not a bubble-bath of €˜blah€™. Remender orchestrated a drastic change in the character without altering the core of what makes the Punisher tick. Plus, he had Frankencastle ride into battle against an army of cybernetic samurai monster-hunters on the back of a dragon with a god-damn Gatling gun attached to its head. You know what that is? That€™s metal. Hits; The Road Runner/Wile E. Coyote-esque showdown between Daken and Frankencastle. When two opponents can take a lot of damage, the potential for violence is deliciously high. €˜I hold three PHD€™s in partying with your mothers€™ Gorgeous Tony Moore art. There is a f**king DRAGON with a GATTLING GUN on its head!

4. Marvel Noir

The Marvel Noir concept was two great tastes that taste great together. Stellar Marvel characters and noir grittier than a sand sandwich, hardboiled like the egg of whatever lays coconuts. Yum. The Punisher fits snug in a noir setting, especially when he finds no shortage of high profile targets during an era of enforcers. It€™s pre-WWII Manhattan and mobster Dutch Schultz is feeling the pinch from rivals Capone and Luciano, prosecutor Thomas Dewey and some guy with a skull mask (see what they did there?) taking out his guys. Might this killer of killers also be the son of one Frank Castelione Sr., WWI veteran who once refused to pay Schultz protection money? Frank Tieri creates a Punisher with a little less restraint and pits him against Shultz€™s hitmen, noir versions of Castelione€™s rogue€™s gallery, Barracuda, Jigsaw and the Russian. The fact that I said three men was a rogue€™s gallery tells you everything you need to know about the character. The fact that one of those men has gigantic knockers is hilarious. There are some twists and turns along the way that offer a nice diversion from formula and the art complements the mood. It€™s a realistic tale with the added factor of historic events to give it another layer of intrigue. What would the Punisher do if he came to form when the bad guys hid in plain sight? He€™d peel back the caps of every gangster he could find, like some type of hat-stealing gremlin. Hits: The mask is a pants-wetting level of intimidating. Frank appears to be death incarnate. Frank Sr. taking out Nazi€™s and fighting the freakish Russian on a train, only to castrate him with a grenade down the pants. What does a deadly, Russian soldier do when he gets castrated and nearly blown up? He gets angry. And boobs. Also boobs.

3. Greg Rucka€™s Punisher

You know what€™s more badass than a guy who wears a shirt with a skull on it while he shoots criminals in the face? A guy with a f**king beard who wears a shirt with a skull on it while he shoots criminals in the face. The most recent of the Punisher solo series set in the regular Marvel Universe, writer Greg Rucka adopts a €˜less is more€™ approach to the character. In a clear case of showing versus telling, Rucka avoids using internal dialogue for the Punisher. This results in a Punisher story where the title character rarely speaks and although that may seem off-putting, it€™s a fresh dynamic. Although Frank in no way attempts to justify why he does what he does, taking away the insight into his mind forces the reader to scrutinize his methods. He is truly a man of action. So you€™ve got this stoic, silent, deadly, broccoli fart of a vigilante who has a beautifully drawn, brutal hand-to-hand battle with the vicious, animalistic version of the Vulture. The Punisher barely wins with his eye and, in a display of vulnerability, needs time to recover. And then it happens. Without warning, without provocation, it happens. Beard. When a wedding of two marines results in a massacre, the sole survivor, bride Rachel Cole finds herself fighting for revenge alongside the Punisher, who has subsequently turned the €˜badass€™ dial up to eleven with his new, Snake Plissken look (complete with an eye bandage). This sets up a curious relationship in which the Punisher tests whether or not Cole is truly capable of committing to the mission. Rucka also answers a question that has plagued many readers; what happens when the Avengers try to take in Frank Castle? When Frank is framed for a grisly bloodbath, Captain America turns his attention towards him and decides he cannot be ignored. Seeing how heroes react differently to Frank€™s black/white disposition makes for an interesting read as each Avenger is granted an individual confrontation with Castle. The Punisher is a character who challenges the reader; why wouldn€™t he challenge the characters he comes into contact with? Hits Beard. Thor, of all the Avengers, takes the diplomatic approach with Frank Castle. Instead of bringing the hammer down, he opted to offer the Punisher a drink instead, seeing within him a fellow warrior. It€™s a nice change of pace; unexpected, yet completely in character. The journey of Rachel Cole is both heartbreaking and satisfying. Seriously, the f**king beard.

2. Welcome Back Frank

The Purgatory storyline was appropriately named, as that is where The Punisher found himself immediately after it had ended. But then Garth Ennis was all like €˜Fuck that€™ and got the Punisher to punch a polar bear in the face. The era of Ennis begins with a celebratory return to form that results in Frank throwing a dude off the Empire State, because no one parties like the Punisher parties. From the first page, Ennis force- feeds the reader with a stupid amount of entertainment and my only complaint is that I€™m already fat enough. Speaking of having your own gravitational pull, this is the run to read if you want to see Frank suffocate the Russian with a morbidly obese man named Mr Bumpo. €˜How long has it been, Mr Bumpo?€™ €˜About twenty minutes, sir.€™ €˜... We€™ll give it another ten.€™ €˜Okeydokey€™ Ennis added his trademark sense of dark humour to juxtapose the seriousness of the character and capitalize on the often absurd nature of the Marvel Universe. The culmination of the sidesplittingly funny and the literal splitting of sides created a dynamic that brought the Punisher back to the forefront of reader€™s minds. Not only is it humorous, but it also has a lot of heart. As well as lower intestine, stomach and many other internal organs. Every character, from minor to major, live and breathe harder than that creep who always calls when you€™re home alone. The Punisher is granted a supporting cast to bounce off, something a silent character such as himself needs. Ennis has a particular disposition towards the spandex crowd and this run is shows exception; each of the heroes featured have a paradoxical nature. Especially Wolverine, who is portrayed as a stumpy, rabid berserker, like Joe Pesci in need of a Snickers. I hope you don€™t have diabetes, because this version of the Punisher is truly a treat. And if you just said, €˜Pfft, treats are for pussies, give me some f**king bourbon€™, then you€™re gonna love what comes next. Hits: You know when you drop your phone and then try to catch it with your foot and end up kicking it halfway across the room? Frank€™s phone is a limbless Mob boss named Ma Gnucci. Nobody does facial expressions like Steve Dillon. The Punisher€™s response to a concussed and confused Spider-Man who has been used as a human shield against a surgically enhanced Russian? €˜We had a team-up. You were great.€™

1. Max

It€™s a testament to a writers ability when they can create stellar stories containing a character who constantly murders criminals, while still managing to keep it somewhat €˜safe€™ for readers under eighteen. But when the writer is given no boundaries and can have Frank interrogate a sex trafficker by keeping him alive with drugs while stringing his intestines around tree branches, everything is just that little bit sweeter. The violence knows no bounds, the content is extremely adult and characters are allowed to swear like a sailor with Tourette€™s. Welcome to the MAX line. This is a world in which the colourful heroes who resemble an eight years olds vomit after eating an entire pack of Skittles are non-existent. The Punisher has been active for the last 30 years and has killed over 2, 000 people. He€™s a force of nature. Think of the most badass grandpa in the world; this Frank is that badass grandpa€™s badass grandpa. Garth Ennis is a military brat and it€™s with this version of character that his knowledge of military history is truly allowed to shine. The CIA, KGB, SIS, SAS and IRA are just some of the organizations featured and the plots utilize aspects of the Cold War, as well as corporate fraud, sexual slavery and the War on Terror. The grey world of politics slams up against the black and white finality of Frank and the result is glorious. And violent. Oh, so violent. In a series where the Punisher is almost an antagonist, the villains need to have just as much dick as they do dastardly. Wait, that didn€™t sound right. Ennis creates some of the most vile, venomous assholes to ever grace the page of a comic book and the satisfaction that you get when Frank eventually gets his hands on them is so intense that you need a cigarette once it€™s over. Special attention should be paid to the almighty Barracuda, a man who may even rival the Punisher in toughness. Jason Aaron picked up where Garth left off and had this version of Frank pit himself against the MAX editions of Bullseye, Elektra and the Kingpin, the latter managing to break Frank down as far as a broken man can go. This is Frank Castle in his purest form. A cold, calculating force who eats, sleeps and breathes his mission. He€™s the Punisher. He punishes. Hits: There are so many hits with the MAX version of the Punisher that you WILL be a beaten and bloody pulp by the end of it. And you€™ll beg for more. Pervert.

In this post: 
The Punisher
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

When I was a kid, I used to think the moon followed our car everywhere.