8 Comics That Would Sell More If The Lead Character Was Replaced

Does the world really need Captain Britain any more?

Sometimes, even the greatest of heroes just need a fresh perspective. As times and trends change, some characters can feel outdated, or the writers may just run out of quality ideas. When a comic book character becomes as stale as last week's bagels, there are a few tried and true options to breathe some life back into book sales. Often, a reboot works. Just hit the reset button, tweak the origin, and give the whole thing a good spring cleaning. Green Arrow's reboot allowed Ollie Queen to be his own man and not just a Bruce Wayne knockoff. John Byrne successfully pulled it off with Superman. Occasionally this is done on a major scale, as was the case with Marvel's Ultimates (more of a second world than a strict reboot) and DC's New 52. When something different for the title is in order, it may be necessary to keep with the current continuity, but replace the primary character. History has shown that this can be pulled off successfully as well. Having Bucky Barnes and Sam Wilson become Captain America brought a nice twist to the star spangled hero. The new female Thor boosted sales over her male predecessor. DC crime fighters Flash, Green Lantern and Batman have been replaced more than once. It's not that these four-color protagonists are inherently bad, mind you, but to increase marketability it's time to put some new blood beneath the tights.

8. Black Panther

This nice thing about Black Panther is that his character's story is designed to be handed down over generations. The name of Black Panther is a ceremonial title that is given to the chief of the Panther tribe in the fictional African nation of Wakanda. Wakandan native T'Challa first earned the mantle of the Black Panther after his father died and T'Challa defeated the champions of the various national tribes. Being the Black Panther not only endowed T'Challa with the monarchy of his country, but also control of his country's vibranium supply and enhanced physical abilities (courtesy of a Panther god). As mighty as T'Challa's reign has been, he's been running the show since 1966. In that time, he's been an avenger, married to Storm, part of the Civil War, and has even helped Daredevil to defend Hell's Kitchen. It's not crazy to imagine that somebody would be ready to step up and challenge T'Challa for the title. Wakanda is a very progressive nation, and the mantle of the Panther isn't limited to just men. T'Challa's sister Shuri has been the Panther while he was indisposed. Ideally, a new member of the tribe would be put in a situation to pass the trials of the Panther. If this new Panther took on a less ethnocentric approach to foreign policy than his predecessor, he could become a bigger player in the grand scheme and likely spark new interest in the title.

7. Aqua Man

Poor Aqua Man. He's actually a very powerful character, yet he has historically been given the snub when compared to his Justice League counterparts. Despite popular belief, his abilities extend well beyond "go talk to some fish". First off, he doesn't just talk to fish, he controls sea life (and people) with his will. That means schools of sharks or walls of tsunami-causing whales are at his command. He rules the 70% of earth that land-dwellers cannot effectively invade. He is super strong (enough to throw a car like a football), super fast, and wields a trident that can make Darkseid bleed like a stuck pig. He is not only a member, but the founder of the Justice League. With such an impressive resume, comic fans still feel tepid about the ruler of Atlantis. DC attempted to reboot his origin in 1989 and even took a crack at replacing and rebooting him in 2006. It's time for Aquaman, born Orin and known as Arthur Curry, to pass the Trident on to the next monarch. The cinematic version of Aquaman that will be performed by Jason Momoa looks to be a more intriguing take on the character. He's darker, more serious-looking, and quite frankly, looks more like an aqua...man. Lest you think a simple makeover would do the trick for the sea-dweller, this has been done before as well. He's had new outfits, new haircuts, a new beard and a new hand. Sadly, DC needs a new king or queen; someone who connects with modern readers and makes the ocean a fun place for fans to go again.

6. Captain Marvel (Shazam)

Shazam, also known as Captain Marvel, is an insanely powerful character in the DC Universe. His abilities are the sum of powers from the most powerful Greek gods. This makes Shazam's talents comparable to Superman's. Sadly, Shazam is, well...kind of corny. The character has been around since 1940 and still feels that way a bit. His alter ego is a 12 year-old boy named Billy Batson (also very 1940s-sounding). Billy was granted his powers from a wizard named Shazam. When Billy speaks the wizard's name, a bolt of magic lightning transforms him into Captain Marvel, the Earth's mightiest mortal. It's not hard to see where the problem is. DC already has Superman. Shazam comes off as an unnecessary, sillier clone. What's fortunate about a hero like Shazam, as compared to one like Superman, is that Shazam was given his powers through magical means. That means those very same powers could be endowed to someone else. Let Billy Batson grow up and grow tired of the responsibilities of Shazam. Let the next Shazam not have a name as cheesy as Shazam. That's not to say he or she would need to be darker than Batman at a Cure concert, but a more mature person with the powers of six gods would fit the modern landscape of comics. Oh, this person would also change up the costume. The hooded cape may have worked for Robin, but it's not doing much for ol' Shazam.

5. Captain Britain

Brian Braddock has a couple of strikes against him. He was essentially created to be the English Captain America, and he's a little like Marvel's Shazam. His powers are magical in nature and were originally given to him by a wizard. Cap Britain has had a tough go at it. His character has been through costume changes, revamps, and ended up having his powers tied to his emotional state. If Braddock is feeling a bit emo, he won't have as much gas in the battle tank. He's also a "brilliant scientist with a Ph.D.", just like a hundred other superheroes. What Captain Britain lacks is a certain "it factor" that makes him stand out and connect with readers. His solo book was canceled. A few incarnations of his team, Excalibur, have come and gone. He was kind of a member of an Avengers sub-group for awhile, but that went away too. In a modern culture saturated with superheroes, there just isn't a lot of space at the table for Captain Britain. Another British upstart like Brian Falsworth (Union Jack) could step into the role and give the character a shot in the arm, with a new attitude and maybe a new, subtle outfit.

4. Moon Knight

Moon Knight is another classic example of a character who comes off like an Ersatz version of another successful hero. Rich guy, no superpowers, uses his vast wealth to amass an arsenal of gadgetry while wearing a cape and fighting crime at night, has a teenage sidekick...sounds familiar. Marc Spector differs from Bruce Wayne in a few ways however. He is a former U.S. Marine. He is a little unstable mentally. He considers himself the earthly avatar of the Egyptian god Khonshu. The most important difference is that Moon Knight isn't selling comic books and merchandise hand over fist, the way Batman is. A little emotional turmoil, as seen with The Punisher, is intriguing. Moon Knight's multiple personalities and polarizing personality doesn't come across quite as charming. In 2014, Moon Knight was brought back in the Marvel NOW publications. If history sets any precedent, this new Moon Knight title will suffer the same fate as its predecessors. It's sad, really, because he has a lot going for him. He is a damaged, dark and serious character. He has weaknesses and flaws. He takes risks and is utterly dedicated to his cause. It's admirable...it just isn't selling books. Moon Knight doesn't necessarily need to change gender or race as some others have, but costume and story reboots haven't done the trick. It's time to up the risk and try a new night stalker.

3. Iron Fist

Iron Fist was created in 1974 by Roy Thomas and Gil Kane. This was a time when more traditional martial arts movies were cool. Bruce Lee was cool. Even through the 80's that was all pretty cool. In 2015, Danny Rand (Iron Fist) still feels, well...a bit 1970s. This is evidenced by the fact that Rand's power, granted to him by plunging his hands into the molten heart of a dragon, is brought out by channeling his "chi". None of it really rings true with modern comic book heroism. When you consider that Iron Fist tends to hang out with cool characters like Luke Cage, Jessica Jones and Daredevil, Iron Fist is in desperate need of a creative overhaul. Danny Rand has been through a lot. An engagement, a false pregnancy with his girlfriend, a death-like stasis. Perhaps Rand decides to focus more on his personal life after discovering a young, aspiring MMA fighter in New York City (MMA is way more zeitgeist in 2015) who is worthy to be the next Iron Fist. Rand could mentor this diamond-in-the-rough and eventually let him off his chain to fight crime in the Big Apple. It's got to be better than yet another attempt to rekindle "Heroes for Hire".

2. Silver Surfer

Like many other struggling characters, Silver Surfer is being given another shot as part of the Marvel NOW revamps. It might work, but history suggests that the surfer's independent titles have a pretty short shelf life. Unless Marvel is content with keeping the silver one relegated to supporting roles, something needs to be done to bring more appeal to the former herald of Galactus. Norrin Radd has been the Silver Surfer since his creation in 1966. Galactus, the world eater, imbued Radd with the "power cosmic" so that Radd could be his herald. The surfer eventually broke away from his master and teamed up with the likes of the Fantastic Four, Hulk, and the Sub-Mariner. Over the years he's been a little good, a little bad. His loyalties have wavered here and there and he has battle enemies both foreign and domestic. What he hasn't done is consistently keep a comic title afloat. The real risk with creating a new Silver Surfer is that Marvel would attempt to reach a younger demographic and create a cosmically-powered, neophyte street kid called "The Silver Skater". It's good to get with the times, but that's certainly not the way. While ethnocentrism is a hindrance for Aqua-Man, it might help to have an earth-based Silver Surfer who ventures out into the universe to do battle, but ultimately keeps home his or her priority.

1. Spawn

Spawn was created by legendary comic writer/artist Todd McFarlane and debuted in 1992. Almost 25 years, one bad movie, and a few costume changes later, Spawn is still the flagship character of Image Comics. For much of Spawn's history, he was the alter ego of Al Simmons. Simmons was turned into Spawn when he sold his soul to the demon Malebolgia. Much like Marvel's Venom, Spawn's costume is a living symbiote. When Simmons shot himself in the head, the symbiote was linked to a fellow named Jim Downing. Simmons bonded with a powerful female symbiote suit and became "Omega Spawn". As Omega Spawn, Simmons becomes the ruler of Hell. Downing has done some impressive work as Spawn and his powers are arguably greater than those of Simmons during his tenure. It also makes sense that the change to Downing was made. After all, every lesser move was made first. The costume was changed. The powers were changed. Finally, the folks at Image crossed to the final frontier and changed the man in the costume. It did exactly what it should: Brought new life too the character and put the original Spawn in a position to do something new with his character. The reason Spawn is number 1 on this list is because he is the only example of a comic whose lead character was already replaced...and can now be changed back. Jim Downing doesn't need to leave the Spawn Universe. After all, Bucky Barnes, Steve Rogers and Sam Wilson are still in the Marvel Universe and they have all been Captain America. Downing can certainly serve his purpose, but Al Simmons is Spawn and he should be Spawn...at least, until the book needs another change.

Contributor
Contributor

George is a life-long fan of genre, wrestling and guitars. He is an actor, writer, CrossFit trainer and former WWE storyline writer. He currently works as talent development for PWX wrestling and resides in the birthplace of the zombie movie, Pittsburgh, PA.