8 Reasons Why Daredevil Is Marvel's Greatest Superhero
You thought Peter Parker had it tough? Think again.
Though it may appear otherwise, considering the limited exposure of the character in recent decades, Matthew Murdock is by far Marvel's greatest and most compelling creation.
He's a swashbuckler, a morally ambiguous vigilante, the protagonist of numerous courtroom dramas and a revolutionary hero that has formed the basis of countless tales both marvellous and thought-provoking. Indeed, there aren't many other costume-clad characters that can invoke such sentiments, even ones that have garnered a legendary reputation Murdock would struggle to eclipse.
But while that may have once been the case, Stan Lee and Bill Everett's creation is finally getting the recognition he's long deserved, experiencing a reinvigorated popularity as a result of Drew Goddard's sublime Netflix adaptation of their original source material. It may not have led to the character receiving the same iconic status of, say, Spider-Man or Captain America for instance, but as far as connoisseurs of all things comics are concerned, Daredevil is by far the most enthralling superhero on and off the page.
8. The Character's Had Some Of The Best Story-Arcs Ever
Born Again, The Devil in Cell Block D, Guardian Devil, The Murdock Papers - all are among the finest literary works in the medium. All transcend the usual tropes of the typical superhero comic book and in doing so, have elevated Matt Murdock, his allies, his enemies, and the world he inhabits to unparalleled story-telling heights.
The works of Frank Miller, Ann Nocenti, Brian Bendis, Ed Brubaker and Mark Waid epitomise the potential to be had within the superhero genre, as they demonstrate so eloquently through tales of deception, conflicts of morality, and through just plain ol' fashioned character-driven crime drama. What makes these tales so damn appealing however isn't just the intricate plots these authors are able to weave. No, what makes them so intriguing is that, at their core, they chronicle the events of a flawed, immensely relatable character.
While this element in itself isn't alien to the vast majority of comics fans familiar with the House of Ideas' library, there are countless stories to have featured the Man Without Fear that have rightly fostered a reputation for quality story-telling. There may be the occasional miss, but for the most part Daredevil has remained the go-to hero for thought-provoking drama.
7. ...As Well As The Brightest Creative Teams
Not to echo the previous entry too much, it must be said that no other hero has had as much talent grace its pages as Daredevil has.
The aforementioned creative tour-de-force of Frank Miller and Klaus Jenson redefined Matt Murdock, and heralded the start of Miller's long love-affair with creative story-telling. It was an affinity cut short by miscalculated sequels, unsavoury political statements and just plain odd characterisations of beloved cultural icons, but Miller's legacy and impact on the medium - one traced back to Daredevil - cannot be underestimated.
Indeed, Brian Bendis and Alex Maleev would take the threads that Miller weaved in the eighties and, in many ways, manage to surpass the seminal works the Born Again scribe once crafted. Over the course of 55 intoxicatingly good issues, Bendis and Maleev managed to create some of the most iconic imagery and storylines to be associated with the character in recent memory. These foundations were further innovated upon by Ed Brubaker (of Captain America fame) and Michael Lark, who again, managed to bring Matt down to his bleakest, only to then be brought back up by Mark Waid and Chris Samnee's trailblazing run on the character, returning him to his swashbuckling days of old. Even Charles Soule's recent run is redefining how we see the character, despite it flying somewhat beneath the radar.
With such a large variety of talent coming to the book, surely there must be something uniquely captivating about Matt Murdock? No other character could possibly warrant such attention, but here Murdock is, 50 years on from his debut, still bringing in audiences old and new thanks to the best in the biz showcasing remarkable respect for the character. It's phenomenal.
6. Matt Murdock Has Been Through Hell And Back
When you think of those characters who have managed to endure the most and triumphed against all odds, chances are the first figures that come to mind are either of the wall-crawling persuasion, or skull-clad ex-military types who execute copious amounts of bad guys in quests for revenge.
Despite the sombre demeanour, not many know of the trials and tribulations Matt Murdock has faced. Here is a man who has experienced his entire life being taken from him, time and again, by enemies he just can't seem to stop. Born Again depicted Murdock bloodied, bruised and exasperated. Karen Page had been ravaged by drug abuse, Nelson & Murdock had been ripped right underneath the attorney's feat, and his revered vigilante persona was shattered to pieces.
Of course, Murdock's meticulously crafted rise to revenge is equally as compelling as his original downfall was, but the story of torment and abuse doesn't just begin and end with Born Again. No, further stories would leave Murdock with innumerable broken relationships, his secret identity compromised, and - though not a narrative success by anyone's definition - even a newfound status as the self-anointed murderous king of Hell's Kitchen in Shadowland. Bit of a hectic life to live, is it not?
Daredevil is as much a courtroom drama as it is an enthralling chronicle of the underdog overcoming ridiculous odds to do the right thing. It's a tale best exemplified in Waid's run on the character, but no matter what comic book you pick up, you're guaranteed to experience emotive highs and lows. It really is character-driven story telling at its finest.
5. The Supporting Cast Are All Flawless
In may ways, Daredevil's supporting cast of journalists, super spies, lawyers and assassins actually end up outshining ol' hornhead himself.
Take Ben Urich for instance. Arguably the Daily Bugle's only hard-hitting investigative journalist, Urich was one of Matt Murdock's closest allies and confidants, and one of the few to know his true identity prior to the media frenzy that revealed it to the whole world. He's got a resume that would make Woodward and Bernstein jealous, and has served as one of the Daredevil mythos' brightest elements since he first debuted back in 1978.
Of course, an entry focussing on Murdock's best pals wouldn't be complete without mentioning Foggy Nelson. 'Foggy Bear' encapsulates the warmth of Nelson & Murdock perfectly, and as the comedic foil to Murdock's stoic hero, he accomplishes in grounding Daredevil wonderfully. Not that he's all laughs and no business however. After all, Foggy has taken Matt to task over all sorts of issues in the past, and in these heated, often emotively charged moments, the human element of the comic series is best represented.
Though not exactly limited to Daredevil and Hell's Kitchen alone, Matt's friendships with Peter Parker, Luke Cage, Danny Rand, Stephen Strange and more have all cemented the influence and significance the character has on New York and the Marvel Universe as a whole. For a hero so synonymous with humanity's darkest traits, Daredevil certainly keeps a fantastic company of friends. But he also surrounds himself with some morally questionable characters too. In many ways these juxtaposing personalities are even more enthralling to witness than the amiable relationships Murdock actually does possess. Frank Castle in particular signifies vigilantism in the extreme, and while both he and Daredevil are undoubtedly fighting for the same cause, the Punisher's lethality often puts him in direct confrontation with Murdock's commitment to a more righteous style of crimefighting.
It's perhaps the most interesting of all Murdock's relationships, and to see it come to life on screen is an opportunity no comic fan should turn down.
4. The Netflix Show Is The Best Live-Action Superhero Adaptation Ever
To put it bluntly, Netflix's Daredevil makes every other superhero TV show look cheap, tacky and mediocre. Even if we may have a fondness for the unfortunately cancelled Constantine - a show that had one of the best comic book casts of all time - it still doesn't come close to what Netflix achieved with Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and Punisher (don't ask about the other one).
The show's success is of course owed to the multitude of creative talents placed firmly at its helm, but Daredevil itself is a property intrinsically linked with quality and nuance - it's a hard thing to mess up. Sure, the 2003 film may not have given the hero the portrayal he deserved, but its supposed status as being 'one of the worst' comic book films of all time is sorely inaccurate, especially when its Director's Cut retained many admirable aspects long associated with its source material.
The point is that a bad character will ultimately be given a bad show, as opposed to an inherently well written character who will most likely be given a good one. Arrow may serve as an exception to this rule, but Netflix's show wouldn't have been such a hit if the character's literature was of poor quality.
3. The Courtroom Dynamic Is Complex And Creative
Out of all the occupations in the legal profession, none have been more represented in the media than the lawyer. Give or take a few police procedurals of course. Perry Mason, Atticus Finch, Ally McBeal, Vinny Gambini and to a lesser extent Jeff Winger have all come to embody the noble defence attorney in popular culture, but Matt Murdock is a different kind of special.
Ignoring the very on the nose irony of a blind lawyer personifying the oft-espoused belief that 'justice is itself blind,' Murdock's relation to the law is one especially intriguing. On one hand, Matt, as a representative of Nelson & Murdock, puts his faith in the law and adheres to it when it comes to trial. On the other, Daredevil subverts it in order to achieve justice, showcasing the reality that the legal system isn't nearly as black and white as the paper it's printed on.
In order to achieve justice one must often challenge the law - something Daredevil does on a daily basis. You don't have to dig deeper beneath the surface to find the best of this dynamic however. More often than not the cases that Matt takes on embody the very best of pop-culture's courtroom dramas, and when they happen to intersect with Murdock's life under the cowl, the stories only get more absorbing.
2. The Character Has Limits
Despite the red spandex, superhuman abilities and outlandish villains, Daredevil actually offers a very human portrayal of the Marvel Universe as we know it. Again, this is something that has been synonymous with Marvel for decades, but in their quest to create relatable characters, their heroes can and often do fail.
No Marvel hero has become more accustomed to this sense of defeat than Daredevil himself, but in his darkest moments humanity is really best embodied. He may be superhuman, but the character is not impervious to the mental strains of daily life, nor its physical constraints either - ignoring his heightened agility of course.
Moral ambiguity is enshrined in the Daredevil mythos - in many ways it is its hallmark. Seeing how Matt grapples with these obscure themes grounds the series in a gritty ambience other comic book heroes fail to really emulate, and this is best encompassed when Daredevil does get hit, or when he's shown struggling. It shows that whilst he may be one of Marvel's most accomplished fighters, he isn't exactly invulnerable. Rather, it's his vulnerability that makes the character so great.
1. Witty Swashbuckler Or Sombre Vigilante, Daredevil Is Always Fantastic
As with most heroes of the medium, Daredevil's evolution has spanned a great many personalities, costumes and even locales. He's been the 'Kingpin' of Hell's Kitchen and has served as one of San Francisco's foremost crime-fighters, all complete with varying tones to suit respective creative teams' artistic visions.
More often than not these fall into either one of two categories: the daring swashbuckler or the sombre vigilante; but whilst these may sound like two distinct, independent takes on the character, the overlap between them - though not entirely frequent - makes perfect sense. It's not exactly a large juxtaposition, after all. Matt, like many of us, has experienced both good times and bad. Though he may fluctuate between tones, character progression is still central to his story - none of it feels anomalous or even contradictory to previous tales told. The confident and upbeat devil of Waid and Samnee's run is the same one Miller pioneered in the eighties - he just had to find the key to his happiness.
Matt Murdock is without doubt Marvel's foremost literary property. Though others have come close, no other hero in their library best channels the publisher's creativity than Daredevil. He has the personality, the look, and the drama - the only thing missing is mainstream recognition of those qualities.
The Ultimate Daredevil Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Man Without Fear?