8 Smartest Decisions In Marvel Villain History

Is Doctor Doom the best? Yes. Yes he is.

Masters Of Evil
Marvel Comics

Although most once tended to hold the opinion that DC outmatched their rivals Marvel in the villain department, the company's resurgent presence over the last two decades has brought parity between both publishers. The House of Ideas has a dependable cast of devilish evil-doers to play with, and they're just as good as those at DC.

Naturally, given the Marvel universe has been going for close to sixty years now, it makes sense that their villains have also bested their heroic counterparts on more than one occasion. Sometimes, however, their smartest decision actually ends up revolving around their decision to use their gifts for good, which also happens to be a more common occurrence at Marvel than at DC.

It may even be fair to say that Marvel actually possesses the lion's share of incredibly smart villains. There's Doctor Doom, The Maker (an evil alternate version of Mister Fantastic), and on a somewhat less cosmic scale you have the likes of Wilson Fisk and Doctor Octopus, both of whom have managed the occasional - and devastating - victory over their closest adversaries.

And, just as it was with DC, there's just something about seeing a villain finally outwit their opponent that's so much more satisfying than the inverse scenario. The stakes are raised, and so is the pressure to deliver. Here are the best occasions where Marvel's bad guys came good on their scheming.


8. Loki Reenacts Men In Black - War Of The Realms

Loki Kills Laufey War of the Realms
Marvel Comics/Russell Dauterman/Matt Wilson

Loki Laufeyson is the God of Mischief, tricks and deception, and with thousands of years spent on Earth and the wider cosmos it only makes sense that he's proven victorious every now and then. Rarely ever against his brother Thor, but still - the Asgardian is considered a master warrior for good reason.

Out of the many centuries he's spent scheming and deceiving however, his best moment potentially came during the most recent one. Jason Aaron's stint on Thor built to a major conflict in War of the Realms, and it saw Loki - ever the trickster - deceiving both the forces of Asgard and Svartalfheim to achieve his own goals.

Be that as it may, it wasn't made clear until the most recent event where Loki's allegiances truly lied. Tricking his Frost Giant father Laufey into thinking he was ready to join his side, the God of Mischief reveals his true intentions to stand against him and gets himself eaten for his troubles. Only, he was basically doing his best impression of Agent K's battle against the Bug in Men in Black, as he plans a newer, messier kind of attack from within.

Daredevil, the newly anointed guardian of the Bifrost, sees Loki inside his father's stomach and throws Hofund into the giant's mouth. Thor's adopted sibling then uses the weapon to cut his way out and finally settle his differences with his dad, cementing that - even in death - there's no outwitting Asgard's favourite trickster.


7. Magneto Strips Wolverine's Adamantium - Fatal Attractions

X-Men Magneto Wolverine
Marvel Comics

Depending on how you look at it, this moment from 1993's Fatal Attractions was either the smartest thing Magneto's ever done or potentially the dumbest. Either way, there's no denying it isn't found wanting for iconicity.

Magneto is a cruel tyrant most of the time, but he was at his most ruthless in this particular tale, which was actually released to celebrate the X-Men's thirtieth anniversary. Needless to say, Wolverine has probably seen better birthdays, with Fatal Attractions also marking the occasion Magneto finally uses his powers to wrest Logan's adamantium from his own skeleton, through his skin, and out of his body completely.

It's rendered in excruciating detail by artist Andy Kubert, but the consequences don't stop there. Magneto's act of torture is emotionally motivated, based on the fact Wolverine nearly killed him moments earlier, but it unintentionally hands him a pyrrhic victory. He renders one of the X-Men destructible, and when Professor X lashes out in retaliation and mentally destroys him, also succeeds in bringing his old adversary down to his level.

Sure, it might be slightly disingenuous to call that a clever move given how it ended for him, but he does basically win... right?

Look, it was either this or the whole Xorn thing from New X-Men. Magneto's a crafty character regardless.


6. The Symbiote Rediscovers Its Good Side - Venom

Venom Guardians of the Galaxy Captain Marvel Rocket
Marvel Comics

Whenever it comes to Venom a delineation must be made. There's the symbiote, an alien also known as a Klyntar whose actual name is Venom, and their hosts; Eddie Brock, Flash Thompson, and so on. In this case, a crash course in the symbiote's history is also called for.

For most of the character's existence Venom has been considered evil, and also one of Spider-Man's greatest villains. But while it's true that the symbiote started out as a corrupting force in the comics, one originally written as the source behind a given host's nasty leanings, newer retcons have confirmed that the opposite is basically true.

The clue's in the name. Symbiotes have a symbiotic relationship with their host, and both beings feed into each other. Venom was only evil because it was spurned by Peter Parker and later tapped into Eddie Brock's own hate for the symbiote's former host. So, when it finally realised its true nature during Rick Remender's series when bonded to Flash - and encouraged him to go seek out the truth behind its origins - the results were fairly mind-blowing.

Further retcons by Brian Bendis, Donny Cates, Ryan Stegman and others have turned Venom into a noble anti-hero with good intentions. The smartest decision of all, though, was having the symbiote getting back in touch with its origins, and making everyone reappraise what Venom really stood for in the process.


5. Norman Osborn Assembles The Avengers - Dark Avengers

Norman Osborn
Marvel Comics

Like Venom, Norman Osborn is most famously known to fans as one of Spider-Man's greatest villains. However, recent years have seen the character expand his horizons past the friendly neighbourhood web-slinger, to the point where he's even gone toe-to-toe with Earth's Mightiest Heroes themselves, the Avengers.

It was actually during this point in time where Osborn concocted what has to be his most successful scheme yet. Utilising the paranoia brought on by the superhero Civil War, the Skrull Secret Invasion and Tony Stark's own conflicted position at S.H.I.E.L.D., Osborn managed to utilise his own political standing to outmuscle the former Avenger and replace him at S.H.I.E.L.D., which he renamed H.A.M.M.E.R. for added effect.

While the head of his new defence organisation, Osborn fashions his own team of Avengers, recruited from the various rogues galleries of the Marvel universe. He leads them as the Iron Patriot, a monument to American jingoism that depicts a cruel distortion of Tony Stark's legacy. Joining his ranks are Daken, the self-proclaimed 'Dark Wolverine'; Mac Gargan's Venom as Spider-Man; and Bullseye, who takes on the role of a new Hawkeye.

Osborn's own Dark Reign would last for several years, until it eventually came undone during a botched invasion of Asgard. Still, as far as villainous reigns of terror go, Normie's was definitely one of the most successful in Marvel history.


4. Thanos Acquires The Infinity Gauntlet - Infinity Gauntlet

Infinity Gauntlet Thanos Snap
Marvel Comics

Referring to Thanos' scheme to acquire the Infinity Gems as intelligent is probably a gross misreading of Jim Starlin and George Perez's Infinity Gauntlet, given the Mad Titan was primarily motivated by his own lust, but it's still the case the villain came closer than anyone to destroying the entire universe - or at least just half of it.

The Infinity Gauntlet is a seminal entry in the Marvel canon for several reasons, not least because it marked what was, at the time, the biggest crossover in Marvel history. It was typically ambitious, and managed to transform Thanos from being just another Darkseid clone into something truly formidable - an intergalactic monster who, for a period of time, actually succeeded in killing all of Marvel's heroes.

Ignoring for a second how the Mad Titan found himself manipulated by Mephisto, the events leading up to the terrifying snap reiterates the character's ingenuity. He fakes his own death when confronted by the Silver Surfer - a being more powerful than Thanos before he acquires the Gauntlet - and then spends time researching the Gems as a means to win Death's affections.

The tyrant is a pioneer in that sense, and while his bid to make Death love him ultimately fails, there's no denying the actual act of fashioning the Gauntlet was especially clever.


3. Wilson Fisk Runs For Mayor - Daredevil

Wilson Fisk Mayor
Marvel Comics

Wilson Fisk is one of the most diabolical antagonists in Marvel's library, and potentially even its greatest. He's been a villain both to Spider-Man and the Punisher, but it's Daredevil with whom he appears to be locked in battle with the most.

The Man Without Fear revitalised his rivalry with the Kingpin of Crime during Frank Miller's stint on the character in the 1980s, at which point Fisk managed to bring the hero to the brink during Born Again. While that campaign of terror alone could go down as one of the smartest campaigns in Marvel's history, it's a more recent development that was probably Fisk's most ingenious.

After Fisk ratted out Daredevil's secret identity to the press, and also after the Man Without Fear managed to put that revelation back in the bottle with the help of the Purple Children, he decided to run for Mayor of New York City. Doing so would grant him new powers, even more influence, and a means of vexing his greatest rival through official channels.

Fisk has now confessed that he wields less power as Mayor than he did as Kingpin, but don't underestimate what he got up to while Mayor. He outlawed vigilantes in New York, undermined Murdock's efforts to make it possible for heroes to testify in court without disclosing their own identity, and is now even more untouchable than he ever was before.


2. Dock Ock Pulls A Freaky Friday - Superior Spider-Man

Superior Spider Man
Marvel Comics/J. Scott Campbell

In another case of a given character's smartest move also being one that made them a hero (sort of), Doctor Octopus' initially evil decision to take control of Peter Parker's body is one of Marvel's most fascinating.

Dan Slott's Spider-Man was the very definition of a mixed bag, but it really came into its own with this particular thread. It's gruesome to begin with, as Ock manages to trap Peter Parker's mind in his own, failing body, but it ends on a note where Peter begs Octavius to honour his legacy. Then, in a barrage of memories, the long-time Spidey villain resolves to use his newfound body for good, as a new, superior Spider-Man.

The most interesting thing about this scheme is that not only does Ock win, in that he successfully swaps his body with Peter, but also that he manages to keep winning too. Ge gets a better spidey-suit, and takes to fighting crime in a markedly more ruthless fashion than Parker ever did when he was the web-slinger.

He might not prove that he genuinely was a 'Superior Spider-Man' by the time Peter regained control, but it was impressive while it lasted all the same.


1. Doom Is Rabum Alal - Avengers

Doctor Doom Rabum Alal
Marvel Comics

Jonathan Hickman's Avengers was brilliant start to finish, but one of the best things about it actually drew upon what the writer did on the Fantastic Four years earlier.

Hickman is a long-term strategist; concepts introduced early on in his stories rarely ever peter out as a run nears his end, and the Avengers were no different. Early on, during New Avengers, Hickman introduced the threat that would govern the remainder of his time on the comic - multiversal incursions. Alternate Earths and realities threatened to destroy the Earth and it was up to the Illuminati to save the day - but at great cost.

They toiled for years, destroying other realities so that their world could live. Along the way they encountered the Black Swans, cosmic beings beholden to the will of Rabum Alal. The big reveal? Doom is Alal, and he's been using the Swans as his soldiers in a multiversal conflict against the Beyonders, a group of beings who existed outside of the omniverse and threatened to destroy all the perceived realities in Marvel continuity.

Doom uses the Swans to destroy each universe's Molecule Man, and in doing so goes on to confront the Beyonders themselves. The battle results in the demise of thousands of different worlds, leaving only a select few. Successful, Doom then goes on to fashion Battleworld, a mishmash of the remaining realities which he ruled via the help of Stephen Strange, the only other Earthly figure to discover Doom's master plan.

Victor's creation of Battleworld typified the character's tyrannical inclinations, but he also saved all of existence with a plan years in the making. Moves don't get much smarter, and if anything were to back up Doom's status as Marvel's greatest villain, that would be it.


Watch Next


The ULTIMATE Marvel 80th Anniversary Quiz

All New All Different Marvel
Marvel Comics

1. Before It Rebranded As Marvel, What Was The Company Originally Known As?

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.