Batman Vs Superman: 7 Essential Lex Luthor Details Eisenberg Must Channel

Or How Warner Bros Can Make Batman Vs Superman's Villain Not Completely Suck...

Last week's news that Jesse Eisenberg would be taking the role of Lex Luthor in Zack Snyder's 2016 release Batman vs. Superman was inevitably met with cries of lamentation across the web, along with the usual sprinkling of those hopeful that the strange casting might just work, in the same way it did with Nolan's Joker. To be sure, even with months of internet speculation and hundreds of names thrown into the ring including Joaquin Phoenix and Bryan Cranston, no one came close to predicting Eisenberg as a candidate for the villainous role. While it's certainly a strange choice, that doesn't necessarily mean the role or the movie is automatically doomed. To paraphrase Jon Stewart's reaction to Batfleck on The Daily Show, it's not like Eisenberg is now Luthor in all of your comic books, too - these characters have the ability to bounce back from a poor onscreen portrayal. Just ask Spider-man. Still, it'd be great to see Eisenberg pull a Heath ledger and nail the performance unexpectedly, and to do that he and the writers for Batman vs. Superman are going to have to pay a lot of attention to earlier models of Luthor. There are essential character elements that must be incorporated into this version of the character, most of which are traits and qualities explored in the comics that built a strong foundation for Luthor as Superman's greatest adversary. But previous big screen versions - those of Gene Hackman and Kevin Spacey - and television incarnations - including the animated character and Michael Rosenbaum's role on Smallville - should be considered as well in Snyder and Goyer's grand vision for Luthor. Each of these touched on different pieces of Lex to varying degrees of effectiveness, and it would be exciting to see Eisenberg replicate the best of these and bring to life those that have thus far gone overlooked. Eisenberg certainly has his work cut out for him, so let's hope he's up to the challenge - here are 7 already established details that he should pay attention to before tackling Lex Luthor.

7. Intelligence Beyond His Years

This is the obvious one: if Lex Luthor can point to anything as the source of his success and status, it's his vastly superior intellect. His brilliant mind leads him to discover Kryptonite, create Bizarro, and design a few versions of the LexCorp Battlesuit, and his mind, too, is mostly what keeps him from incarceration during these forays into illegality, and keeps him positioned as a favourite son of Metropolis. There's no doubt that Jesse Eisenberg can play a smart little griper. But it's the "little griper" part that is perhaps where Eisenberg seems most un-Luthorlike, because Lex isn't the complaining type - he can be fault-finding, sure, but he's probably figured out a way to solve the problem in the short span of time it would take him to whine about it. That brain never rests, and Eisenberg should remember that above all regardless of which version of Lex Luthor he brings to the screen. The "Beyond His Years" caveat is also necessary because Eisenberg is 30 (even if he looks younger) - he could be playing older in the movie (perhaps he will look older without those curly locks), but it's still hard to imagine him seeming anything but an upstart crow against the likes of Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill. If anyone in the DCU rivals the intelligence of Lex Luthor it's Bruce Wayne, and it's clear that Affleck's Wayne is going to have plenty of experience under his belt by the time the film takes place. Crucially, the schemes of young Luthor need to herald his arrival as one of the most powerful foes imaginable. Again, intellect is Luthor's most obvious trait, and there's as much pressure on the script as there is on Eisenberg to impress us with knowledge (or blind us with science).

6. Connections

Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor was a man recently freed from his constitutional obligations by a technicality, and so the public trust in him may have been at an all-time low during the events of Superman Returns. This idea certainly isn't unfounded, as there are many arcs in the comics that feature Lex's philanthropic façade cast into shadow - his knowledge of the Imperiex invasion marred his presidency when the public found out, his involvement with the Everyman Project forced him to stand trial for the umpteenth time, etc. etc. Obviously, though, these arcs will (or should, anyway) have little impact on the introduction of Luthor in the DC Cinematic Universe. Spacey's time as Luthor saw him lurking underground and aboard yachts with only his henchmen and Ms. Tessmacher to talk to, and it made for an utterly forgettable turn, as well as giving his sidekick all too much screen time. More importantly, though, it seemed at odds with the well-connected, friends-in-high-places magnate presented in 90% of Luthor appearances in the comics. Even Gene Hackman hardly left the company of Ned "Yes Mister Lew-thor" Beatty. As is the case with many entires here, Eisenberg is at the mercy of the Batman vs. Superman script. Not entirely, of course - it's still the job of the actor to carry all of this for the final leg of the relay - but Spacey's one-note Luthor was partially an effect of a weak script. If we're talking the first of multiple appearances by Eisenberg as this character, we need to see the dichotomous Lex that engages in shameless politicking and public laudation of the heroes of the Justice League - the daylight Lex - alongside the scheming, nefarious egomaniac who plots behind closed doors to defeat those same heroes - the Lex of the shadows.

5. Strained Personal Relationships

It's important to note that Luthor's connections are largely hollow pacts formed only to further his personal goals and shore up his contingency plans - he may know everyone worth knowing, but that knowledge never manifests itself as any real emotion. This, like his intelligence and ego, is always true of Lex in every incarnation. Even in Elseworlds tales like "Red Son", Luthor values his work and his goals high above his relationships. This could be explored in many different ways, possibly even through past relationships with family members (more on that in a minute€) or connections to Smallville. More likely, though, is that we'll see Luthor closely associated with people who either aren't aware of his true nature or feel trapped inside his machinations. The latter is the case in "Red Son", if that can be used as an example again - Lex is paid a visit in his lab by his wife on their anniversary, who brings him a gift. He apologizes for not reciprocating, as he was busy that morning reading thirteen books, and when he returns to his work he asks her to leave the gift so his assistant can open it later. And she stays married to him! The point here is that whether they realize it or not, anyone in Lex Luthor's life is simply a chess piece, another element in the grand game for Lex to manipulate and use to his advantage. He rarely shows compassion toward anyone else, and when he does it is distinctly at odds with his character. Hand in hand with this characteristic, perhaps, is another element that we may just glimpse in Batman vs. Superman...

4. Past Tragedy

Man of Steel maybe went a little overboard with the Smallville-set scenes from Clark Kent's childhood. Some of these were done well, like the young Clark's frantic confusion upon discovering his x-ray vision during class, but a few too many conversations with Kevin Costner about being alone in the universe may have threatened to spoil these flashbacks, but it did open the door for future films to employ flashback as a storytelling technique. Tragic events of the past and Lex's way of dealing with them should be part of his character, whether shown explicitly in flashback or just alluded to in a word or a flicker of emotion from Eisenberg. In the 2003-04 series "Superman: Birthright", a lab fire during an experiment is the cause of both the death of Lex's parents and the loss of his hair. In a 2010 issue of Adventure Comics, Luthor's father dies of a heart attack - which we learn was caused by the young boy in order to capitalize on his father's insurance policy. "Arrogance" almost took this slot, but that character trait is best utilized as a mask for the pain Lex harbours from his past. Attention to this would make Eisenberg's portrayal a lot more humanized: we've already seen the actor play arrogant again and again, and only rarely does this mask slip to reveal something else behind it.

3. Moral Ambiguity

Moral ambiguity may seem at odds with the usual descriptors for a villain like Lex Luthor: there's no doubt that he's one bad guy, a major supervillain and possibly the most dangerous human threat to order and justice in the DCU - but this all didn't happen overnight. Part of what makes him so menacing throughout the Smallville run (as played by Michael Rosenbaum) is that Clark Kent can't easily discern whether he's a friend or a foe. We know he's a baddie because his name is Lex Luthor - but he operates behind the scenes so well that even Superman may be blind to this. His journey to the dark side could form a kind of origin story for Luthor, something that could be really interesting and a bold move by Batman vs. Superman. Henry Cavill's Superman has already enjoyed his origin tale in Man of Steel, and the decision to not redo the Batman origin story just yet is also as wise - Nolan's Batman Begins pretty much nailed that one. With Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman set in a supporting role, this film could instead spend time exploring what makes the villain tick. Rather than presenting him as the bad guy by just shaving his head and having him plot mischief, the writers could utilize Eisenberg in the way Smallville utilized Rosenbaum: namely, by having him walk a fine line between good and evil before forever slipping to one side.

2. His Hatred Of Superman

Gene Hackman was a serviceable Luthor in three Superman films, despite a few campy flaws, and his portrayal was superior to Kevin Spacey's later incarnation in almost every way. The one thing that Spacey had and Hackman mostly lacked, though, was a deep-rooted antipathy for the Man of Steel. Whether it comes from envy or jealousy or from something else, Luthor's disdain for the Last Son Of Krypton should not be overlooked in Batman vs. Superman. The motivations are important, and they are numerous throughout the comics and the animated versions of the character: in the Golden Age, Lex hated Superman simply because he accidentally caused his hair to burn off. Later, his inability to control or put a price on the Man Of Steel led to contempt and detestation. It would be more interesting for Eisenberg's Luthor to hate Superman simply for being an alien, for being proclaimed a hero and a saviour by the human citizens of the world while Lex himself plays second fiddle. This would fit with the exploration of "being human" in Man Of Steel, furthering Kal-El's quest to be counted as one of the people of Earth. Lex could see this super-powered being as the end of human achievement or as an obstacle in human evolution. Whatever motivation the writers ultimately give us, it will be up to Eisenberg to convey a multiplicity of roots for his unshakable hate.

1. Crime Of Passion

Superman himself admired the intellectual prowess and the determination of Lex Luthor in Action Comics #271 (1960), stating that the man "could have been a mighty force for good in the world, yet he chose to direct his great scientific brain into criminal channels." This sentence probably describes Luthor more fully than this entire article - whatever past tragedy he's endured, however many hollow relationships he maintains, and whatever hatred he holds for the Man of Steel, Luthor enjoys the thrill of outsmarting everyone else above all. Hackman's performance had this in spades: rather than brooding or just grinning at the prospect of a new plan to undo Superman, Hackman laughed, jumped around excitedly, and seemed genuinely thrilled with himself for being so darn smart. I can't see Eisenberg achieving this level of absurdity and being able to pull it off, but he really does need to have fun with the role. If he doesn't enjoy himself as Luthor, how is anyone else supposed to? This is not to say that Lex Luthor commits crime just for the hell of it - as we've said, his hatred of Superman is more motive than a villain like the Joker ever cared to express. But like the Joker, Lex Luthor relishes in every criminal moment. Even when he "loses" he still wins, either by escaping incarceration or planting puzzle pieces for a later scheme. Life is a game to Luthor, and it's a game he's very good at - Jesse Eisenberg would do well to remember that. What are your thoughts on the casting of Eisenberg? What other elements of the Luthor mythos would you like to see him bring to the screen? Let us know in the comments below!

Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.