10 Actors Who Gave Their Worst Performance In Star Wars

Even the brightest stars of their generation have struggled to make these Star Wars rocks float.

General Hux Star Wars Domhnall Gleeson
Lucasfilm

Spanning nine Skywalker Saga showings, a number of big-screen spin-offs, and a TV corner that appears to be gloriously expanding by the month, this galaxy far, far away has seen more than its fair share of instantly iconic or largely underrated turns over the years.

However, for every consistently mesmerising Ewan McGregor study of a leading light trying to navigate the path of a Jedi and the eventual downfall of an entire religion/Republic and fiery Carrie Fisher appearance reminding folks of the hope that still remains in the universe, there's sadly also been another Star Wars performance that left fans with "a bad feeling about this" very early on.

And what makes the following lacklustre inter-galactic displays so damn surprising is the fact that each and every name involved had all very much shown how strong they were with the acting Force in the lead-up to their Star Wars debut, or have excelled in a great many projects following on from their time in this space-aged series.

Yet, from deeply disappointing villainous arrivals, to recast icons that simply couldn't outshine what came before them, each of these stars definitely didn't experience their finest hours within George Lucas' brainchild.

10. Joel Edgerton

Star Wars Attack of the Clones Joel Edgerton
Lucasfilm

The news of Joel Edgerton unexpectedly returning to the Skywalker Saga in this year's Disney+ Obi-Wan Kenobi series was quite rightly met with some tentative optimism as the Australian sensation stepped back into his role of Uncle Owen Lars for the first time since 2005's Revenge of the Sith.

Not because of his displays in the galaxy far, far away up to that point, mind.

Before he went on to become one of the most respected thespians of his generation due to his captivating work in everything from 2011's Warrior to 2016's Loving, Edgerton gave about as bland and lifeless a performance as possible in his brief and unmemorable stint as Owen in both Episode II and III.

And while his wholly forgettable borderline cameos didn't exactly mark him out as a one to watch coming out of the Prequel Trilogy, largely due to being given next to nothing of note to do on-screen, Edgerton did at least brilliantly bluff his way into many a meeting early on in his career as he confessed to being a bigger part of the Skywalker story than he actually was before Attack of the Clones' release.


9. Gwendoline Christie

Star Wars The Last Jedi Captain Phasma
Lucasfilm

On the back of becoming something of a household name due to her commanding and deeply moving turn as Brienne of Tarth on HBO's world-conquering Game of Thrones series, the casting of Gwendoline Christie as one of The Force Awakens' secondary antagonists seemed like an inspired piece of work from J.J. Abrams and co.

However, instead of gifting the unquestionably gifted actor the chance to flex her performance muscles as she had done on the small-screen, Christie often found herself frustratingly hand-cuffed by either a lack of screen-time or painfully uninspired dialogue whenever she was afforded the chance to steal the spotlight.

What could have been a performance that utterly shook up the system, introducing a three-dimensional female big-screen baddie for the first time in the franchise's history, eventually wound up feeling like little more than a huge missed opportunity for all involved.

But with Christie herself seemingly being open to returning to the role that has been expanded and explored far more on the page than it was on screen, there may be hope in finally delivering on the promise of a character that fans clearly had an appetite for before her untimely end in The Last Jedi.


8. Hayden Christensen

Hayden Christensen Anakin Skywalker Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
Disney

Much like fellow returning Disney+ Obi-Wan Kenobi star Joel Edgerton, Hayden Christensen's highly-anticipated comeback to the galaxy far, far away this year gifted the star often buried underneath a stagnant script and routinely soulless scenes a chance to finally make good on the potential that was always present... even in those darker sandy days.

Long before he was being afforded the chance to fully let loose as Darth Vader against his old master or roll back the years with a glorious twinkle in his eye, Christensen became something of a scapegoat for the often derided Prequel flicks as a whole.

Deeply forced and uncomfortable sexual tension with Natalie Portman's Padmé Amidala, hit-and-miss bursts of petulant rage, and a lack of any real presence for an entity known as one of the most respected Jedi in the galaxy later down the road were issues all heightened by that aforementioned dreadful dialogue throughout.

And it's not as though Christensen is an entirely untalented performer either, with his gripping work in 2001's Life as a House, 2003's Shattered Glass, and the already noted Obi-Wan series all highlighting the talent that was largely stifled in his Episode II and III showings.


7. Terence Stamp

Terence Stamp Star Wars
LucasFilm

Sticking with wholly disappointing Prequel performances, and to an actor whose misery whilst shooting the panned trilogy was very much evident throughout his lacklustre appearance in The Phantom Menace.

After being convinced to appear opposite such esteemed talent as the aforementioned Natalie Portman, Superman's General Zod himself Terence Stamp decided to step into the galaxy far, far away. However, upon finally making his way half-way around the world to shoot his scene opposite the Léon: The Professional star, Stamp was completely taken aback by the reveal of his scene partner being little more than "a bit of paper on the wall."

What followed was a turn that very much reflected Stamp's feeling of the entire experience being "just boring", with his Supreme Chancellor Valorum being about as remarkable as the entirely dreary locale that was digitally forged around him throughout his political exchanges with Queen Amidala.


6. Paul Bettany

Solo A Star Wars Story Dryden Vos
Lucasfilm

Recruiting the routine scene-stealer that is Paul Bettany to the inter-galactic ranks for Disney's attempts to spin-off the galaxy's favourite smuggler felt like a bit of a no-brainer heading into Solo: A Star Wars Story.

Sadly though, instead of offering up another deliciously compelling showing like the Brit had throughout his run as Vision in the MCU and Stephen Maturin in 2003's Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, Bettany turned in a rather timid and limp portrayal of supposed big bad Dryden Vos.

Droning and aimlessly meandering during much of his screen-time, the scarred figure doesn't so much as terrify as he does nullify any glimmer of genuine threat a scene involving him has to offer. And his eventual conquering at the hands of Emilia Clarke's Qi'ra felt like a mercy more than anything else.

Bettany could've definitely brought something fresh to the Star Wars sphere, but stepping into the shoes of a moustache twiddling antagonist like Vos, only to dial back on the explosions and menace was something of a misstep for both Disney's casting department and the actor himself.


5. Natalie Portman

Natalie Portman Padme Star Wars
Lucasfilm

As her ridiculously consistent back catalogue showcases, Natalie Portman is arguably one of the most diverse and absorbing actors of her time, picking up Academy Awards acclaim for her work in 2011's Black Swan, alongside further nods for the likes of 2005's Closer and 2016's Jackie.

And that's all without mentioning the project that first thrust her into the spotlight way back when, with her stunning work in 1994 as Mathilda Lando in Léon: The Professional putting Portman on the radar of just about every director worth their salt.

Sure enough, when it came time to cast the mother of Luke and Leia, Padmé Amidala, for his long-awaited Prequel Trilogy, George Lucas was all too happy to bring the up-and-coming sensation aboard his space opera epic.

Yet, instead of capitalising on the young star's unquestionable chops, Lucas largely restricted Portman's Amidala to little more than a bland tag-along in her Phantom Menace debut before further relegating her to the part of love-sick puppy in the subsequent Episodes.

In fact, things got so bad for Portman in the wake of the release of said early noughties entries that she'd later confess to New York Magazine, "...everyone thought I was a horrible actress. I was in the biggest-grossing movie of the decade, and no director wanted to work with me."


4. Brian Blessed

star wars Boss Nass Laugh
Disney

Jar Jar Binks wasn't the only gungan to rub fans up the wrong way heading out of that already noted Episode I misfire.

Very much blessed with an unrivalled set of pipes that can almost guarantee a genuine sense of authority and dominance for whichever character he is tasked with bringing to life, Brian Blessed could unfortunately do little to establish the brash Boss Nass as another legitimate force of nature.

Again weighed down by such verbal drivel as "Mesa no carrrrrrin' about the Naboo. The Naboo think they are so smarty," Blessed was facing an uphill battle here from the get-go.

And even with Blessed appearing to have the time of his life roaring and shaking his gums throughout his vocal and physical performance as the cartoonish gungan leader, the portrayal was largely mocked and criticised due to its hammy nature and digital effects that haven't aged as well as George Lucas would've liked.


3. Samuel L. Jackson

Mace Windu
Disney

Another piece of recruitment that looked like the stuff of Star Wars fans' dreams heading into a hit-and-miss Prequel era, bringing the baddest muthaf***a in the galaxy into the Jedi fold felt like a match made in heaven for a time.

Only, instead of having Samuel L. Jackson lend his undeniable charisma to the sort of maverick variation of Jedi seen in Liam Neeson's Qui-Gon Jinn, George Lucas thought it best to stuff the Pulp Fiction icon into the soulless Master that was Mace Windu for his entire stint in space.

Now sure, Jackson did get to add some swagger to the mix on the battlefield, sporting his one-of-a-kind purple lightsaber as he took down Jango Fett and making one of the all-time top entrances in the saga's history beforehand with his "this party's over" utterance on Geonosis in Attack of the Clones.

But outside of those few highlights, Jackson was as under-utilised as he's ever been throughout his prolific career during much of his Episode I-III screen-time, spending more moments rumbling on about prophecies and politics than he does proving precisely why Windu was classed as the greatest champion of the Jedi Order.


2. Forest Whitaker

Rogue One A Star Wars Story Saw Gerrera Forest Whitaker
Lucasfilm

Another one-time underwhelming Star Wars performer who looks set for a second stab at the space-opera sphere, Forest Whitaker's return to the Rebellion in this year's Andor could finally gift fans with a live-action version of Saw Gerrara that doesn't spend most of his screen-time babbling on like a lunatic and sounding like an inter-galactic chainsmoker.

Whitaker would prove in his animated showings in the role in both the Jedi: Fallen Order video game and Rebels series that he holds the ability to grip an audience and make fans truly believe why so many were quick to commit to the passionate Gerrera's extreme Partisans cause over the years.

But Rogue One most definitely sits as one of the few misses in a simply stacked career, making you wonder how the same person who picked up an Oscar for The Last King of Scotland could produce such a lacklustre and tonally all over the place performance as the one fans were exposed to during an otherwise stellar Star Wars Story.

And with Andor star Stellan Skarsgard already noting how he's shot some "juicy scenes" with the returning Saw actor, here's hoping Whitaker can entirely redeem himself in the Disney+ series.


1. Domhnall Gleeson

star wars hux
Lucasfilm

For all of the things J.J. Abrams appeared to get absolutely bang on in his reintroducing of the galaxy far, far away back in 2015, there was one particular character that often felt like he'd stumbled into the wrong universe out of the gates.

Brought to life by a clearly game Domhnall Gleeson, The First Order's General Hux is neither unsettling nor the sort of villainous presence you simply love to hate. He's just sort of there. And Gleeson provides audiences with more reasons to cringe and fast forward the action than the sort of undeniable feeling of fear seen in the likes of Peter Cushing's Grand Moff Tarkin and Ben Mendelsohn's Director Krennic.

From jarringly screaming his way through First Order rallies, to painfully unfunny attempts at comedy in his exchanges with Poe Dameron, the otherwise consistently excellent Gleeson isn't half-assing his way through the Sequels by any means. He just appears to be lacking any real direction or guidance in the part, often bringing weird slapstick beats and melodramatic explosions into being in his own surreal corner of the Trilogy.

And the less said about that baffling decision to switch sides late in The Rise of Skywalker day the better, too.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!