10 Best Acting Performances By Musicians

They can sing, dance, play guitar - but can they act?

david bowie man from earth
British Lion Films

For most of us, all can hope for in life is to be OK at one thing. We can hone our skills with every hour we’re given, but 99% are destined for the also-rans scrap heap, goggling bitterly at the overachievers. So when you come across individuals who are brilliant at two things, it doesn't sit well.

But rather than grinding your teeth with resentment at these high flying hyphenates, try a sunnier outlook, and celebrate that rare breed – the successful musician who can also turn in a blinding performance in a film or TV show.

Now, success on the stage does not necessarily equate to the same on the screen, and many’s the talented, charismatic musician whose attempted career leap has fallen flat (sorry, Crossroads fans - Britney will not be featuring in this list). But let’s not focus on failure and folly. Instead, let’s praise those multitalented individuals, of whom we’re not even jealous!

(With apologies to the Fresh Prince and Marky Mark, this list eschews those who have abandoned their singing careers in favour of acting, focussing only on individuals who still derive a living from music. Wahlberg, if you feel like reuniting the Funky Bunch, we’ll reconsider).

10. Meat Loaf - Fight Club

Meat Loaf Fight Club
20th Century Fox

He would do anything for love – but he won't talk about Fight Club. The doughy Canadian balladeer turns in a performance both hilarious and heartfelt in David Fincher's ode to a lost generation, while never attempting to steal the show or throw his (not inconsiderable) weight around.

His name is Robert Paulson, and he is a cancer survivor and former steroid abuser who, as a result of his illness, has grown a pair of full on breasts. As one of the first characters to share a scene with The Narrator, the Bat Out Of Hell singer has an important role to fulfil – as a once manly man who has developed feminine features, he is an early encapsulation of the crisis of masculinity that makes up much of Fight Club's subtext. Fincher is an exacting and calculating director; he wouldn't cast Meat Loaf just for the novelty or shock value, and the singer does a great job with the surreal material.

This was far from the start of Loaf's acting career, having previously appeared in The Rocky Horror Picture Show and Wayne's World, among others. But as far as character work goes, he turns in as measured and mature a performance as you could expect from any longtime character actor.


9. Tom Waits - Down By Law

down by law tom waites
Universal Pictures

Tom Waits the person is an intelligent, sensitive, socially conscious middle aged man who keeps himself to himself. Tom Waits the singer is a hell raising bawler and brawler who spins yarns about hobos and hoodlums, while also penning some of the all time greatest ballads. Tom Waits the actor is somewhere in between. Over the years he's chalked up a not-insignificant resume of bizarre, Tom Waits-esque characters, normally dispensing wry quips and the occasional nugget of wisdom. And his particular skill set has never been put to better use than in Jim Jarmusch's Down By Law.

Opening on the ramshackle sounds of Waits' Jockey Full Of Bourbon, Down By Law is a shaggy tale of three escaped convicts, played by Waits, John Lurie, and Roberto Benigni. In typical Jarmusch fashion, they stroll around, shoot the breeze, and don't do a lot else, plot wise. Like a lot of his work, Waits carries much of the film through sheer force of personality; he's not tasked with a particularly large palette of emotions, but with his overwhelming charisma, he's endlessly watchable.

And this, really, is the strength of hiring a non-actor: rather than watching someone step into yet another role, with which they may lack a significant connection, you have a bespoke performance from one of the all time great rock stars, who brings to the part his own baggage, his own tropes and expectations. To watch anyone else in the role would likely come across as corny.


8. Jennifer Lopez - Out Of Sight

Jennifer Lopez Out Of Sight
Universal Pictures

There's no use sugarcoating it – Jennifer Lopez has been involved in some bad films. Monster In Law was a critical flop, and Gigli was just... weird (proper weird). Indeed, J-Lo's acting career is often used as something of a punchline, and if you take a look at her filmography, you can kind of see why. The exception? Stephen Soderbergh's Out Of Sight.

Taking on a challenge as a fiery U.S Marshal, Lopez is tasked with creating a believably hard nosed persona, while keeping the tone cool and frothy in fitting with the Elmore Leonard source material. In parts tough and playful, Lopez excels as Karen Sisco – she's given a complex character and a lot of screen time to fill, and she's more than a match for the task. Most importantly, though, she works tremendously well with co-star George Clooney, in one of his smoothest roles as glib (i.e George Clooney-esque) bank robber Jack Foley. It is the chemistry between the two leads that makes the film so memorable – the scene in which they're crammed inside a car boot together is pretty much the first clip you'd show to actors to define “spark”.

The impact of her Out Of Sight performance may have been mitigated by roles past and future, as well as the tabloids' continual fascination with Jenny From The Block, but here, Lopez clearly shows that she's got it. Perhaps the biggest compliment, or to be unkind surprise, is that at no point does she dine out on her fame during this film.

She fully inhabits the role, and contributes towards Out Of Sight being one of the premium post-Tarantino '90s thrillers.


7. Justin Timberlake - The Social Network

Justin Timberlake In The Social Network
Sony

Everybody likes Justin Timberlake. He can sing, he can dance, he can tell jokes, provided someone else has written them down for him. He is a true old fashioned entertainer, a man of many talents, and from the impression we get, a very nice chap. Which is odd, because he's a whole lot better at playing horrid folks.

The Social Network is a true story of our times, and perhaps the most intriguing performance is Timberlake's, as Napster founder Sean Parker. While Jesse Eisenberg's Mark Zuckerberg is all twitches and tics, righteous anger as a bubbling undercurrent, Timberlake plays Parker as !*$% of the walk, the bright shining star of the internet revolution, the man who holds the keys to the kingdom that many of us haven't even discovered yet. Timberlake relishes playing against type; he's affable as ever, but he dials up the smarm. He's a phony, a coattail rider – an all round bad egg. He gets the lion's share of the memorable quotes – it's not just down to his fame that he takes up a great deal of the trailer.

Handsome, funny, talented, charismatic – evidently Timberlake is a man who, if he wants, can pretty much coast through life. But he should look for challenges like this more often, because it's clear he's able to rise to them.


6. Eminem - 8 Mile

8 Mile
Universal Picture

OK, so granted – it’s not the most imaginitive casting in the world. A rags-to-riches white rapper who rose through the battle scene playing a rags-to-prospective riches white battle rapper. But for Eminem’s big screen debut, it makes perfect sense, and it’s not like you’d want to see him playing King Louis XIV (except that you would because that would be the greatest film of all time).

So it’s unsurprising that he does such a good job as James “B” Rabbit, hard grinding Detroit MC, but that doesn’t take anything away from his performance. Channelling, one would imagine, much of the anger and resentment he felt as an up and coming performing trying to break into a less than welcoming culture, Mathers is the epitome of the plucky underdog, caring for his daughter, living in a trailer, and battling Pimp My Ride host Xzibit at the steel mill they both work at.

A film that could so easily have been just awful, 8 Mile succeeds primarily due to the casting of a musician; the potential cringe factor of having, say, Edward Norton letting us know that Papa Doc went to Cranbrook (that’s a private school) is overwhelming. But as a star-making vehicle for (at the time) the world’s most popular rapper, it works perfectly, a 21st century Rocky with added disses.


5. Jennifer Hudson - Dreamgirls

dreamgirls jennifer hudson
Paramount

Often in film, there's nothing more powerful than an unknown quantity. In America, Jennifer Hudson was perhaps known as a contestant on American Idol; elsewhere, she wasn't known at all. Flash forward to 2008, and she's an Oscar winning actress, and a major recording artist. Stroke of luck, or a just reward for a great talent?

Well, mostly the former. It's not often such a perfect role falls into a performer's lap. In Motown quasi-biopic Dreamgirls, Hudson plays Effie, the golden voiced sole singer who just can't catch that big break. Having come seventh in a TV talent show, one could suggest that Hudson knows a little about artistic disappointments and the like. But there's no doubt this is one opportunity she grabbed ahold of with both hands. Upstaging Eddie Murphy – perhaps the biggest star of the '80s – and Beyonce – perhaps the biggest star of the '00s – on your first try? That's worth the Oscar alone.

Most impressively for Hudson, the role served as a double breakthrough – the Academy Award lead to a sequence of varyingly successful film roles (including a slightly surprising part as Winnie Mandela), and the sheer vocal bravura gave her singing career a real kickstart. It is likely to remain the barometer by which debut acting jobs are judged for some time to come.


4. David Bowie - Everything

david bowie man who fell to earth
British Lion Films

David Bowie is David Bowie in The Man Who Fell To Earth. He’s David Bowie as Nikolai Tesla in The Prestige; David Bowie as a prisoner of war in Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence; and, bizarrely, David Bowie as Pontius Pilate in the otherwise deadly serious Last Temptation Of Christ.He does his Bowie voice and his Bowie mannerisms, and it takes you out of the film every time and it’s always fantastic.

Think of this as a career retrospective. It may be unfair to refrain from singling out any particular David Bowie role, but it seems just as unfair not to discuss them all. For truly the man was a titan of the cinema, making up what he lacked in classical training with utter devotion, winning charisma, and every ounce of oddness you would expect from the erstwhile-Thin White Duke. He could be charming – see The Snowman – or comically sinister – see career-defining role Jareth in Labyrinth – but he was always Bowie, larger than life and evidently having a whale of a time.

Look, maybe Bowie’s thespian skills are low on anyone’s list of reasons they miss him. But seeing Bowie pop up on screen was like being visited by a benevolent alien, who wasn’t super great at acting, but had a real good go of it every single time. And you can’t say that about many of today’s stars.


3. Katey Sagal - Sons Of Anarchy

Sons Of Anarchy Katey Sagal 3
FX

As the excellent documentary 20 Feet From Stardom ably demonstrates, being a backing singer can be pretty thankless work. Beginning her career singing for Bob Dylan and Bette Midler, 8 Simple Rules and Futurama star Katey Sagal had to wait almost two decades before releasing her first album.

She had to wait a little longer than that to be considered one of TV's best actresses, but in Sons Of Anarchy, she came across one of those once in a lifetime roles that unheralded thespians seem to be finding on television dramas these days. As motorcycle gang matriarch Gemma, Sagal is tasked with finding pathos and profundity in a show that can often degenerate into schlock and silliness, and the vast majority of the time she is highly successful. Like many a popular cable drama, Sons Of Anarchy focusses primarily on angry white men, but Sagal takes great joy in playing an even angrier (equally white) woman. Consumed by frustration, anger, power lust, and a contrasting desire to see her son safe and well, Gemma Teller is one of the series' more complex and compelling characters, and until Sons reaches its cartoonish nadir, there's always something to empathise with.

Much has been said, as it should, about the lack of roles for women “of a certain age” on TV and in movies, and Sons goes to lengths to demonstrate why this is so silly. In a show all about vicious, Harley Davidson-bound brutes, the most intimidating character of all is often a 50 year old woman with extensively manicured nails.


2. Ice Cube - Boyz N The Hood

Ice Cube Boyz From The Hood
Columbia Pictures

He may be more well known these days for his money-grabbing run as a family friendly angry dad, but in his screen debut, O'shea “Ice Cube” Jackson turned in a performance of such genuine intensity, anger, and power that, decades later, he's hardly recognisable as the same actor.

Starring as Doughboy opposite the oft-underrated Cuba Gooding jr, Cube gives the film its edge of legitimacy. No sense of a cash grab is to be seen here – he's fully invested, eager for white America to witness the strength of street knowledge. Again, perhaps, the role of a tearaway teen on the dangerous streets of Compton is not the biggest test for the performer (though given Cube's diploma in architecture, who can say), but the NWA leader quickly proves himself to be an adept actor with charisma to boot, and there's little denying he steals the show from Gooding jr's milquetoast lead character.

In later years Cube found a surprising knack for comedy, perhaps best displayed in 21 Jump Street, and the relatively versatile actor has worked steadily in film since the late '80s, but he's never bettered Boyz N The Hood. One might surmise that the project was somewhat emotionally draining, or that he just felt like taking it easy in his secondary career. But when you have a debut performance of this calibre, maybe there just isn't much point trying to top it.


1. Bjork - Dancer In The Dark

Dancer in the Dark
Fine Line Features

Miserabalist and provocateur Lars Von Trier is a director who knows how to push buttons. Over the course of his celebrated career he has butted heads with many high profile names, perhaps never more so than with Icelandic critical darling Bjork. Like any good renegade cop, though, his methods may be unorthodox – but damn, do they get results!

A celebrated singer songwriter, Bjork had barely acted a lick before appearing in Von Trier’s tragedy. But rather than this making her a liability, her rawness and total lack of Hollywood sheen is a large part of what sells the film. Bjork’s presence is always somewhat otherworldly, and her ethereal quality is utilised magnificently in this tale of misplaced trust and cruelty. Playing a near-blind factory worker, she exudes both naivety and a worldweary melancholy. You just want someone to swoop her up and take her away from this wretched town.

Only, this is a Von Trier film, and without giving the game away, that’s not how the Danish auteur’s films tend to end.Set to a magnificent soundtrack that veers from start to grandiose (performed by Bjork herself), Dancer In The Dark is certainly not a warm hearted tale for all the family to enjoy. It is, however, an experience, a unique one at that, with a truly extraordinary performance at its heart.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)