10 Genuine Lessons Batman V Superman Can Learn From Batman & Robin

Zack Snyder should pay attention to Joel Schumacher's misfire.

It's been very, very, very easy to bash Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice as its production brings dumb decision after inexplicably dumber decision, but at the very least there's no way it can match the unbridled horror of the worst Batman movie ever. Take your victories and all that. Now the superhero genre is Hollywood's biggest money spinner and Christopher Nolan has given the Caped Crusader a ground-up reinventing, Batman & Robin is a painful memory. Eighteen years on, its crimes against cinema are resolutely in the past, a haunting reminder of a time when a single movie could all but halt the entire notion of comic book adaptations. But don't let that distance hide just how abhorrent the film is. Anyone who claims it's a film whose cheese enables it to pass over into "so bad it's good" territory has clearly let time heal wounds; there's plenty to laugh at, sure, but each chortle at its ridiculousness is a soul-destroying one. And likewise, don't let the fact the superhero genre has come back fighting lull you into thinking nothing can be learned from Joel Schumacher's desecration of one of modern culture's greatest icons anymore. Another controversial Batman movie is set to hit in just over a year, and given a lot's riding on it (the entire DC Cinematic Universe soars or plummets based on Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice not only making money, but pleasing fans), maybe it's worth taking a look back to the last time Batman on screen really messed up. WARNING: There will be images from Batman & Robin present throughout. Proceed with caution.


10. Don€™t Have Characters Just For The Sake Of It

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Thanks to then-sixty years of history, Batman had a pretty impressive supporting cast in print. And you can bet Schumacher was keen to get as many as possible onto the big screen. On top of the already established Batman, Robin, Alfred and Gordon, the film added Batgirl, Poison Ivy, Mr. Freeze and Bane to the mix, which for a film in the pre-X-Men superhero genre was bursting the seams. What Batman & Robin did so wrong, however, was that it failed to justify these inclusions. Bane was thrown in because his defining Knightfall arc was still in the cultural memory, but the film showed none of the characters smarts by forcing him into the regular henchman mould, while Batgirl was there simply to get in a female audience. Adapting these characters in name only was pointless. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? Batman V Superman's ever-growing roster of characters has been well covered, with what started out as a Man Of Steel sequel becoming a Justice League film in everything except name thanks to addition of many of the team's roster. Given the showdown title, it all seems a bit much. However, because many of these appearances (Aquaman, Cyborg) are merely to introduce the characters to the audience ahead of their own standalone films, it's unlikely it'll be quite as pointless as a mute Bane.

9. Don€™t Plan A Sequel Ahead Of Time

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Batman was such a bankable box office smash that before Batman & Robin was released a sequel was already well into pre-production. Batman Triumphant would have seen the Dynamic Duo go up against Scarecrow and Harley Quinn, with the former's mind-altering drugs allowing a cameo from Jack Nicholson's Joker. Sounds alright, until you remember it was Schumacher who would have been behind the camera. Of course, Batman & Robin was such a stinker that any sequel plans were immediately culled, wasting all the time and effort put into Triumphant (which would have probably stank anyway). However, Warner Bros. never actually stopped trying to develop another Batman - they kept soldiering on until Nolan delivered Batman Begins. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? It already hasn't. The subtitle revealed that this was leading to something bigger, and now Warner Bros. have announced the release slate for the DC Cinematic Universe all the way up to 2020. To make it worse, those nine movies, ranging from the sure-fire Justice League to risky Cyborg all hinge on this one movie. Of course, Batman V Superman is operating in a different landscape, with superheroes now the biggest draw in blockbuster cinema, making planning ahead in this manner much less of a gamble. There's still a strong lesson to be taken from deeming an idea too potent to fail, however.

8. Address The Criticisms Of Earlier Movies

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Warner Bros. were never above making big creative changes to, in their eyes, improve Batman. When Tim Burton's overly-gothic Batman Returns (on which the director had total creative freedom) got a tepid box office and angered parents with its darker themes, the studio took the franchise in a totally different direction, bringing on Schumacher to make Batman Forever. Oddly enough, addressing complaints wasn't as forward in their minds after the garishly over-the-top Forever. Was Forever a better film needing less improvement than Returns? Of course not - it just had a better box office gross. Thus, many of the big mistakes Forever made (campy acting, day-glow Gotham and, worst of all, those Bat-nipples) were carried over to Batman & Robin, to inexplicably worse results. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? It actually seems like it. As Batman V Superman has progressed it seems key issues with Man Of Steel are going to be addressed. A less-than-expected box office for the reboot has no doubt motivated this rather than any creative impetus, but it's still reassuring. The thoughtless mass-destruction of Metropolis that so angered detractors looks set to be explored - it not only looks to be a backdrop to the Bruce Wayne/Lex Luthor side of the story, but also the source of a major public anti-Superman bent. And given Batman has to make it to the end credits alive, that major fan bug-bear of Supes getting out of problems by killing his enemies must be dealt with in some form too.

7. It Needs To Feel Real (Within Its Own World)

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Batman movies don't need to be realistic. Sure, it worked for Nolan's trilogy, but there's no rule that a film with a billionaire whacking on a cape to fight crime needs to garner comparisons to Heat. Tim Burton's films were both dripping in a heightened gothic style that allowed them to feature both down-and-dirty action scenes and the Penguin riding a giant rubber duck with ease. Schumacher's film's tossed the broad sensibilities of that out, introducing a neon brightness that made Gotham feel like a city-spanning nightclub. But even ignoring the contrast between movies, the Gotham presented in Batman & Robin just didn't feel real within its own film. There was a total disconnect from the wider shots of Gotham and Bruce Wayne's socialising, which was only accentuated by sets so dripping with perceived style (Ivy's lair and anything touched by Freeze) that it was impossible to take any of it seriously. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? Man Of Steel messed up in this regard. It spent a lot of time aping Nolan's realism, which jarred heavily when it descended into city-smashing action. Half of Metropolis was decimated, but what stopped people from being able to overlook it like in The Avengers was that it didn't fit the serious tone that had been built up. There is hope Batman V Superman can correct this earlier issue, however. Snyder has always been competent at building consistent worlds - just look at Watchmen - so as long as he's decided to change things up a bit, there's every chance Dawn Of Justice could feel genuinely real.

6. Cast For The Character, Not The Marketing

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Was George Clooney the wrong person to play Batman? It's difficult to give a measured answer given how crap his entry was, but he was definitely far from the best choice to wear the rubber suit. From a financial perspective, however, he was a perfect fit; getting the break-out star of ER was a great box office gimmick (or at least looked to be). Batman & Robin's casting is all over the shop, motivated from the most uncreative place possible. Look at the at-the-time massive Uma Thurman and Arnold Schwarzenegger. She kinda fit Poison Ivy, but the once-and-future-and-past Terminator was nothing more than a lazily-picked name to whack on the marketing. Ever since the sixties TV series, stunt-casting Batman villains was commonplace, but Batman & Robin showed its serious downside. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? Ben Affleck all-but proves Batman V Superman isn't just casting to please the fans - the fan anger at the appointment of the star of Gigli/director of Argo as Batman has only just died down. Maybe be it's all a master marketing trick, but most likely Zack Snyder chased the best man for the job. Of course, there's other casting that it's less clear on. Jesse Eisenberg has surely been picked as Lex Luthor on the back of The Social Network, but is that because of what he can bring to the role or what his name promises when slapped on the poster? The same goes for Jason Momoa as Aquaman - is he there because he's the best fit for the Marine Marvel or because he brings in the Game Of Thrones audience?

5. Treat The Wider DC Pantheon Seriously

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: The opening of Batman & Robin is one of the worst sequences in cinema. After a run of dutch-angled shots of the pair's rubber suits - crotch and all - to the sound of rejected Terminator sound effects, the Batmobile rises and Robin quips he wants one because "chicks dig the car," to which Batman remarks, "This is why Superman works alone." Ha? It sets up very early on that the film has no aspirations to present anything novel, but the Superman joke in particular is a pretty low-blow, showing a real contempt for the wider scale of the source material. It's endemic of the state of superhero cinema at the time (and the film's approach to its own source), but that doesn't make it any easier to excuse. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? When Batman & Robin was made, the simple notion that anyone outside of the World's Finest could support their own movie was a joke (and even Superman was a shaky prospect). Now, in a post-Guardians Of The Galaxy world where Iron Man is the biggest hero on the planet, embracing that wider continuity is not only beneficial, but necessary. And, with all those extra characters actually popping up in Batman V Superman (and the more joke-prone heroes like Aquaman drawing from their grittier representations) it's looking like things are being taken very seriously this time. If the rumours of joke-less movies are true, maybe too seriously.

4. Care About The Comics

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: You'd think a Batman movie in the nineties would take the character's relatively recent turn into the grit following The Dark Knight Returns as inspiration, exploring this new layer Frank Miller had added to both character and the wider comic medium. You'd be wrong - although Joel Schumacher would often describe himself as a Bat-fan, Batman & Robin was really calling back to the TV show from the '60s, only with none of the knowingness Adam West brought to it, actively disregarding the print source. Of course, Christopher Nolan was also pretty loose in how he adapted classic comic elements, but throughout The Dark Knight Trilogy there was still a sense of reverence to the graphic novel origins that just wasn't there for the Clooney movie. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? In the wake of source-disregarding duds like Catwoman, Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer and X-Men: The Last Stand, as well as the success of Marvel's geek-out Cinematic Universe, comic reverence is an even more potent drive in superhero cinema than it was twenty years ago. So it'd be highly unlikely for the new movie to completely eschew the graphic novels. Man Of Steel messed a lot with the culturally known Superman origin, but most of its changes did admittedly come from various comic sources. Likewise, Batman V Superman looks like it'll be borrowing liberally from The Dark Knight Returns and various runs of DC's New 52, which, when coupled with Snyder's affinity for the material, should mean the characters in the film are fitting adaptations.

3. Respect What Came Before

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: There's a fan theory that both of Joel Schumacher's Batman flicks are actually movies in the Tim Burton world; cheap family films made once Michael Keaton's Bruce Wayne reveals all about his alter ego. This not only shows just how extreme the distaste with Batman Forever and Batman & Robin is, but also how out of sync with the earlier movies they are - they bear so little resemblance to the movies that kicked it all off. But the disrespect doesn't end there - even though Schumacher had Adam West's take in his cross-hairs, he totally misread the TV show, missing all the tongue-in-cheek humour. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? This applies to Batman V Superman on two levels. Firstly, as it's building on it, the film needs to at least acknowledge Man Of Steel. The Superman reboot under-performed in all corners, and with an almost three year gap between it and the sequel-cum-franchise expansion it'd be easy to treat Dawn Of Justice as a soft reboot. Which, while good for the movie, would be a big mistake for the DC Cinematic Universe going forward, betraying a make-it-up-as-you-go attitude. The other is more contextual, but no less important. The Dark Knight Trilogy brought Batman to a hitherto unprecedented level of popularity (which given his ever-present history is really saying something). With Dawn Of Justice coming only four years after The Dark Knight Rises, there's the risk of seeming like a cynical money-grab, or otherwise treading over old ground. Thankfully, a much older, and thus different Bruce Wayne, has the potential to avoid that.

2. Deal With The Negative Hype Before It's Too Late

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: Batman & Robin was one of the first films to be killed by the internet. Rather than waiting for new films to arrive and having their say with their money, fans could look into the development process and mouth off about anything like didn't like. Site likes Ain't It Cool News were quick to crucify Batman & Robin, criticising the film at length in the months leading up to release (although much of the ire did embarrassingly come from Joel Schumacher's sexual orientation). Of course, the world wide web was still in its infancy, with Hollywood not yet fully understanding how impactful it could be and thus Warner didn't think much of it until it was too late. The film came out and thanks to the internet it became quickly apparent it was a dud. Welcome to the new age of fan-based movie-making. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? In case you haven't noticed, there's been some scepticism over whether Batman V Superman will be any good. It may not be as all pervasive as it was with Batman & Robin, but as the whole blockbuster genre is heavily internet-obsessed, throwing out teaser after trailer after pointless news story to keep fans engaged, the sizeable distaste isn't great given how dangerous bad word-of-mouth can be (just look at The Amazing Spider-Man 2 or Green Lantern). Warner Bros. need to do something drastic to side-step this. That promised trailer needs to be something really special.

1. Don't Be Trying To Sell Something Else

The Mistake Batman And Robin Made: To call Batman & Robin a movie is a disservice to quote unquote movies such as Birdemic and The Room. Those three feature-length exercises may all deservedly be labelled as some of the worst films of all time, but at least the latter two were made with a vague sense of cinematic purpose. Joel Schumacher's second Batman exercise existed to sell toys, pure and simple, with no case for anything else. At least Michael Bay had the decency to throw in racial stereotypes and military fetishism to jazz up the Transformers films. Will Dawn Of Justice Learn The Lesson? Obviously with its darker tone Batman V Superman isn't aimed directly at toy-buying-age children, but one of its key production points is still to sell something else; more movies. Ever since Marvel started their Cinematic Universe, with each new movie doubling as a tease for later adventures, every studio with a superhero property has been trying to replicate it. Sony failed miserably with Spider-Man, forgetting they needed an interesting grounding to throw all the sequel set-up on, to the point they've just given up and joined the genre leaders. Interesting, Man Of Steel, for its many, many faults, was at least happy to tell its own story, with any hints at universe-building snuck so deep in the background only super-fans have a hope of picking up on them. But Warner Bros. really risk repeated Sony's error on the sequel by chucking in so much that's only there to enable the other nine movies coming afterwards. They really should just chill it on the overt universe building. Chill. Geddit? Are there any other lessons from earlier Batman movies Dawn Of Justice can learn from? Share your picks down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.