10 Great Movie Ideas Let Down By Their Budget

Sometimes, you have to speculate to accumulate...

Gemini Man
Paramount Pictures

A movie can live or die by its budget and that is why so much strategy goes into deciding how much dollar a certain idea will be allocated by a studio.

If it seems like your concept is a little risky and doesn't look as though it will be the mega commercial hit that most producers crave, the chances are you're going to be given less of a financial push than say a typical MCU film.

At the end of the day, films are investments. If your project doesn't recoup its budget and then some, it can only be seen as a failure. Yet, sometimes an idea can be let down by a lack of funding, which could aid the scripts desperate need for top class CGI or perhaps a higher calibre of cast.

Equally, an inflated budget can weigh down a once untainted idea and cause the filmmakers involved to convolute the potential of what could have been.

More money can mean more problems, but at the same time - without enough of it - some of the most original films to ever be conceived would never have made it to our screens.

10. Dog Soldiers

Dog Soldiers H 600x338
Kismet Entertainment Group

When Dog Soldiers howled its way into existence in 2002, it did so to little fanfare.

The story of a routine military exercise gone horrifically wrong - pitting a group of British soldiers up against some gangly werewolves - didn't exactly rip up the British box office upon its release, earning just £5 million from a reported £2.3 million budget.

Despite the cast trying their damnedest to have you believe the threat these hairy beasts posed was sincere, the sight of a man clearly running around in a werewolf suit and painfully obvious rubber organs being torn out of bodies, made sure that this film would never punch above its weight.

It's a shame, as with a little more investment - both on-screen and off it - this film had the potential to be the kind of creepy, slasher/monster flick that could have horrified audiences around the world.

Jason Statham and Simon Pegg were both attached to roles at some point, which tells you all you need to know about what they thought of the script. With a little more money used on putting together a stronger cast, tightening up the visuals and promoting the film overseas, Dog Soldiers could have seriously moved the needle.


9. Gemini Man

Gemini Man Will Smith
Paramount Pictures

When a film's selling point is its willingness to de-age one of the top actors on the planet, by god you have to deliver on that effect.

Gemini Man - with its $150 million budget - did not.

Instead of creating visuals worthy of claiming Academy awards, the usually outstanding Weta Digital (responsible for The Lord of the Rings and Avatar's epic visuals) dropped the ball catastrophically and produced a younger Will Smith that look more like a video game cut-scene character than a digitally realised human being.

With the money clearly not being pumped into the visuals, that must have meant that other aspects of the film were tended to with the sizeable finances.

Nope. The script felt taped together, the settings were drab and the cinematography felt messy. So, all arrows pointed to an overpaid cast and poor marketing strategy.

Will Smith and Clive Owen's paychecks alone would not have been cheap and the promotion of the film didn't skimp on the cash either, as posters, TV spots and trailers were slapped on anything Paramount could get their hands on.

If we actually got a surprising film that didn't spend a huge chunk of its budget on spoiling the majority of the major plot points and lining the pockets of its feature players, we could have got a genuinely interesting identity thriller with spectacular visuals.

Instead we got a stuttering blip of a movie with effects that already feel outdated.


8. John Carter

John Carter Taylor Kitsch
Disney

Don't ever believe that Disney are untouchable in the forging of profitable franchises. Sometimes it goes 'John Carter wrong'.

Based on A Princess of Mars - the first of the Barsoom series of books by Edgar Rice Burroughs - the film saw John Carter, an American Civil War soldier who has been transported to Mars, trying to help the beings on the planet to get along.

The visual effects and cinematography on show in the finished article were impressive to say the least, it's just a shame that the same couldn't be said for the performance of the titular character.

Taylor Kitsch, not exactly a box office superstar at the time, didn't add much other than the occasional smoulder to the role and we were also subjected to a hammy villain in Mark Strong and a wasted all-star ensemble.

The story itself wasn't awful and the potential was there to push on with more outings, the problem was that this first showing of Disney's newest big name prospect didn't really do much to separate it from any sci-fi/fantasy film we'd seen before.

In offering up a paint by numbers movie - with no major draw - the films mammoth $306 million budget looked to have stifled any hope of pushing the boat out. Instead, Disney relied on safe storytelling and the hope that the fantastic visuals could get audiences through the cinema doors, thus making a new star in Kitsch.

John Carter went on to earn just $284.1 million at the box office, not even recouping Disney's sizeable influx of cash into the project.

File this one under missed opportunities.


7. The Predator

The Predator New Trailer
Fox

Though absolutely nobody was expecting a film on par with the Arnold Schwarzenegger led alien battle of one-upmanship we got in the original Predator, 2018's The Predator looked to be heading back to that same world of rated R suspense filled gore that made the first film so iconic.

Shane Black - an original Predator cast member - was on board to direct (so it may even be funny, right?) and the project had been given double the budget of the last entry in the series (going from Predators $40 million to $88 million) yet with that money came the unpredictable beast of ambition.

Instead of focusing on what made the original story so compelling - a single alien hunting down some of our planet's deadliest inhabitants - Black and Co opted to cram the story full of unnecessary jokes, plot points and some dreadful CGI.

Whenever the film threatened to become interesting and characters were forced to think on their feet to survive, they were met by either the poorly rendered Preda-dogs or another needless ploy to set up a bigger universe.

With a smaller nest of money to draw from, this film could have utilised the brilliant cast and decent plot of a predator being forced to join sides with the humans in order to do away with a bigger, badder Predator. Yet, instead we got a film that attempted to be bigger than it needed to be.

This is what happens when more money opens a few too many doors.


6. Life

Life Jake Gyllenhaal
Columbia Pictures

Admittedly, 2017's Life isn't an awful film, it just didn't exactly do anything of note for the sci-fi genre.

The reason? Well, the budget of $62 million for a rated R film is quite high for a start and with that comes a certain level of expectation to boot.

So, instead of ensuring his film had a creative and innovative narrative that could really entrance an audience, Daniel Espinosa chose to focus on creating a reality aboard his fantasy space shuttle.

Suspended by wires for the majority of their time on set, the actors would feel as though they were suspended in a zero gravity environment that would be found on a space shuttle. This would involve a hefty investment in rigging said set with the equipment to achieve the visual effect and the cost of cutting out the wires in post wouldn't have been cheap either.

Add to that the detailed visual rendering of the small devilish entity, Calvin, and you can see where the majority of this generous investment could be found.

Yes, the effect of suspending in mid-air and Calvin (the foreign body) were admirable to behold, but was all that really worth sacrificing the bones of what could have been an intimate low-budget character study of what happens when you are forced to survive or perish? Just $100 million worldwide at the box office, suggests not.


5. Doom

Doom Dwayne The Rock Johnson
Universal Pictures

In the mid 90's, fresh off the back of the success of Doom II, Universal eventually decided to put their time and money into a Doom movie that would adapt a few elements from the third game in the franchise.

A hefty $60 million was handed over to the production team, so fans were excited to see the creatures they had grown up fighting come to life.

Arnold Schwarzenegger and Vin Diesel were both offered a role in the feature, only to turn it down - not a good first sign for the film's prospects.

Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson would finally sign on the dotted line and joined Karl Urban and Rosamund Pike to form a cast of decent ability, yet there was still no one with the clout of Diesel or Arnie attached. Still, at least the game's monsters would keep us interested, right?

When it was released in 2005, all that terror and fear that the original gaming experience provoked was replaced by groans when the aliens were seen for the first time. Word travelled fast and it became quickly apparent that next to no one wanted to watch a badly executed version of a beloved video game, evidenced in the film's $55.9 million return.

It's a lot to ask of a rated R film that already had a decent amount of money behind it, but with a couple extra million in the bank Universal could have attached a bigger star or really gone to town on the visuals - bearing in mind this was the same year as Peter Jackson's King Kong.


4. 12 Strong

12 Strong Chris Hemsworth Michael Pena
Warner Bros.

Anything that had Thor himself, Chris Hemsworth, attached to it post Thor: Ragnarok should have been printing dollar bills, right?

When he had been attached to a project about the real life recount of a group of soldiers who were sent to Afghanistan immediately after the September 11th attacks in 2001, fans felt that this could set Hemsworth up as a mature dramatic actor and were keen to see how he would get on in the flick.

With a fairly low budget of $35 million, many were expecting this story to be more focused on the people involved in the emotional and mental aftermath of such a catastrophic moment in history, rather than a retreading of the typical war in Afghanistan film.

Instead we got the latter and it looked as though that budget nudged director Nicolai Fuglsig into creating a plodding 130 minute slog that spent more time firing rocket launchers at his characters than actually trying to understand them.

The film didn't bomb by any means - earning $70.8 million - but it could have added another new dimension to Hemsworth and the war genre in general had it invested more cash into marketing a film that had some depth and meaning, rather than clearly injecting that money into extravagant set-pieces in the hope it could wrangle in some adrenaline junkies.


3. It: Chapter 2

Bill Skarsgard It Pennywise
Warner Bros.

In the horror flick of 2017, Stephen King's terrifying clown, Pennywise, returned to the screen in It, after 27 years away - which is eery if you know anything of the clown's origin story.

With a worldwide box office take of $700 million from a $35 million budget, you had to believe a sequel would be inevitable and it wasn't long before It: Chapter Two was on the cards.

What made the first in the series so fantastic was its titular character and the group of ragtag young heroes going toe to toe, with the latter trying to stay alive long enough to tell the tale. Even though the first film wasn't a short movie by any standards - clocking in at 135 minutes - it managed to get everything it needed to inside that runtime without feeling bloated.

The same can't be said for Chapter Two, as the film found itself trying to do too much with its improved $79 million to play with.

Between stuffing the older and younger versions of the gang into needless detours and the fact that it seemed crafted purely for scares and not to further the narrative set up in its predecessor, Chapter Two fell victim to having too much money for its own good and the unnecessary 169 minute runtime is testament to that.

If the sequel had stuck to the roots of what captivated audiences the first time round - that team's chemistry in dealing with the maniacal Pennywise - perhaps this clammered for follow up could have earned similar critical success.


2. Hellboy

Hellboy David Harbour
Lionsgate

Guillermo del Toro had been begging to get behind the wheel of another Hellboy movie since 2008's Hellboy II: The Golden Army and had been sprinkling bread crumbs of a potential follow up for years.

That all came to a devastating end in 2017 when Del Toro admitted to Twitter that any hope of Hellboy 3 was gone, as no company was willing to invest the $120 million needed to fund his vision for a sensational blow-off for the Demon.

Then, just as fans the world over had given up on the idea of Hellboy ever returning to their screens, Lionsgate announced that Neil Marshall would be directing David Harbour as the titular anti-hero. Only this iteration would require just $50 million to finance.

We'd finally be seeing the return of a beloved character and the studio didn't have to break the bank to do so.

Win-win?

Sadly, it was pretty clear from the get go that the effects were not up to standard for a film of this calibre in 2019 and Ian McShane's disastrously animated body - upon being turned into a spirit towards the end of the movie - was memed for all the wrong reasons.

A poorly presented story, lacking enough depth or character development to paper over the cheap effects meant that Hellboy earned a putrid $44.6 million worldwide.

What could have been Guillermo...


1. The Dark Tower

The Dark Tower Idris Elba Tom Taylor
Columbia

The Dark Tower - Stephen King's eight book epic book series following Roland Deschain, the 'gunslinger', on his quest to find The Dark Tower - found itself in developmental hell for years, with everyone from J.J. Abrams to Ron Howard attached to direct the fantasy adventure.

After a near ten year wait for the movie to finally find a home, Nikolaj Arcel was brought in to direct the Sony Pictures project, with Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey cast as Roland and the Man in Black, respectively.

The project had cast two stars at the peak of their powers, but in attempting to cram the density and richness of King's world into an unfathomable 95 minute runtime, the film instead opted to use Sony's riskless $66 million budget to create a dull, kid friendly film.

If the studio had invested anywhere near the amount of say a Lord of the Rings ($281 million over three films) and taken more time to bleed out a series that possessed enough visceral brilliance and devout fans to stick around for the duration of the story's arc, it would have at least been better than this poor attempt to throw a project with a bit of money at the wall in the hope it stuck.

The film was panned and now a TV series is in the works. Here's hoping fans finally get the faithful visual realisation of the story they fell in love with all those years ago.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Gemini Man
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!