10 Horror Movies That Keep Tricking Viewers

These films really pulled the wool over our eyes.

Identity movie
Columbia Pictures

Horror films are often designed, not just to scare but to mislead, especially when it comes to whodunits and slashers. If there's a great mystery to be solved or a deranged killer to be unmasked, there's bound to be a decent amount of misdirection to keep the guessing game going as long as possible.

However, some movies refuse to settle for just one red herring and instead throw in a whole gaggle of them. Now, these sorts of rug-pulls don't always lead to a twist, and sometimes ploys like these are there simply to subvert expectations.

For example, a character may be set up as an unstoppable hero, only to be the first person to pop their clogs. A specific plot point can be repeatedly teased, just to make it more shocking when the story veers in a different direction. When a certain character behaves like an imbecile, it's unexpected when they end up saving the day.

When the audience falls for these ruses, they should be more on their toes to ensure they don't get tricked again. Having said that, there's no doubt the entries on this list fooled everybody time and time again.

10. Bodies Bodies Bodies

Bodies Bodies Bodies
A24

In Halina Reijn's satyrical whodunit, a group of vapid Gen-Z friends decide to party in an opulent mansion during hurricane season. When the wi-fi and lights go off, they play a murder-in-the-dark game to pass the time.

However, the murder game gets a bit too literal when one partygoer, David, winds up dead, his neck slashed with a sword. Believing there's a wolf in the fold, it isn't long before everyone is at each others' throats, leading to further bloodshed. When Bee and Sophie are all who remain, there's no doubt one of them is the initial culprit.

Or maybe not. 

When it comes to slashers, there tends to be one simple rule: somebody must be the killer. Despite that, Bodies Bodies Bodies flips the script, revealing that David slashed his throat by accident, meaning the massacre that followed was for nothing.

Since this trope goes hand-in-hand with the genre, it's impossible not to accuse every character, especially when everyone behaves suspiciously and acts hostile to one another. Although it's annoying to watch the group accuse the innocent, viewers will feel ashamed when they realise they were doing the same thing.


9. Final Destination 5

Final Destination 5
Warner Bros.

Each Final Destination instalment revolves around a group who managed to cheat death, only for the Grim Reaper to get wind of this and attempt to eliminate the survivors one-by-one, often by orchestrating an elaborate chain of events.

Although these chains of events usually start small, they quickly snowball into something disastrous, lethal, and super-gross. As a result, it's difficult to tell how victims will be snuffed out.

With that said, Final Destination 5 goes out of its way to ensure the ensemble meet a grisly end in the most unexpected way possible. When one character receives acupuncture, it looks like his demise will involve needles. Instead, he's killed when a statue squashes his head. Another character has eye laser surgery when the machine malfunctions, causing the laser to incinerate her face. How does she die? By falling out of a window.

However, the most blindsiding moment occurs during the climax, where Sam and Molly board a plane, triumphant they'd cheated death yet again. Suddenly, these lovebirds notice a scuffle breaking out amongst the passengers, which is revealed to be the main characters from the original movie.

Yep, that means Final Destination 5 was a secret prequel the whole time. And since the remaining passengers perished in Final Destination during the scene in question, it's soon apparent that Sam and Molly are doomed.

Well played, Death.


8. Oxygen

Oxygen Melanie Laurent
Netflix

In this sci-fi thriller, a woman awakens in a cryogenic chamber with no idea of who she is, why she's there, or how to get out. She has an AI to assist her, but it's programmed not to answer certain questions, making her current situation all the more cryptic. Worst of all, her pod is set to run out of air in two hours or less.

Since nothing is known about this woman at first, every piece of information feels like a curveball. When she starts to float, it becomes clear she's in space. After contacting the tech's manufacturer, she discovers her chamber was meant to be destroyed years ago. When she calls her home, a mysterious woman answers, informing her that her husband is dead. But when she learns her husband might be alive, our heroine has no idea what to believe anymore. 

Just when it seems like a juicy detail is disclosed, it's completely contradicted five minutes later. As such, it feels like our amnesiac protagonist is further away from learning the truth than when her predicament started.

Although Oxygen is riveting from beginning to end, the avalanche of misdirection and twists is sure to keep anyone befuddled long after it's over.


7. The Midnight Meat Train

The Midnight Meat Train Vinnie Jones
Lionsgate

It's no surprise The Midnight Meat Train is messed up considering it's from the mind of Clive Barker, best known for creating Hellraiser. However, this WTF gorefest is more twisted than anyone could expect, since it changes genre every half-hour or so.

The story kicks off with rising photographer Leon (Bradley Cooper) stumbling upon a creepy man on the subway named Mahogany (Vinnie Jones). When Leon follows him, he learns Mahogany is mutilating victims for undisclosed reasons.

As Leon investigates further, he discovers Mahogany's murder spree has been going on for over a century. Just when it feels like the story couldn't get stranger, the climax goes balls-to-the-wall bonkers.

After Leon leaves the killer mortally wounded, he learns Mahogany was chosen by a cabal to protect humanity. Every night, Mahogany travels to a hidden civilisation underground that's populated by reptilian creatures, and feeds them fresh meat to stop them invading the surface world. After Mahogany dies, Leon is forced to take his place to ensure the creatures remain satiated.

Even though The Midnight Meat Train starts as a grounded detective drama, it quickly descends into a full-scale slasher, then a supernatural horror, before suddenly turning into a Lovecraftian nightmare. The story at the end has so little resemblance to how it started, it doesn't even feel like the same movie by the time the credits roll.


6. Coherence

Coherence Movie
Ugly Duckling Films

It goes without saying, any story exploring quantum decoherence is going to be tricky to follow. 

James Ward Byrkit's metaphysical drama starts simple enough, with a bunch of friends getting together for a dinner party. But when a passing comet triggers an anomaly in the multiverse (as they do), the ensemble begins to question all of reality. 

Looking outside, they spot a duplicate of their house, suggesting their universe has merged with another. After they see their exact doubles through the window, it further implies two dimensions have fused into one, and when the group theorise at least one doppelgänger has infiltrated the house, it becomes impossible to tell if everyone is who they say they are.

Despite the zany premise, Coherence's sci-fi elements are understated, which helps maintain the mystery. On first viewing, it's hard to tell whether universes are collapsing into one another or there's a more rational explanation. But even when it's apparent what's really going on, Coherence still keeps everyone guessing, and every time it seems like the characters are wrapping their head around the situation, another piece of the puzzle pops up, challenging everything they thought they knew. 

Even on repeated viewings, this cerebral mind-bender is sure to leave anyone scratching their head.


5. Feast

Feast 2005
Dimension Films

Rather than saving the most gobsmacking moments for the finale, some horrors switch it up by dropping their biggest bombshell in the opening. Which brings us to 2006's Feast. 

Considering the story revolves around a bunch of pub patrons being terrorised by monsters, this horror-comedy sounds as generic as they come. Luckily, Feast is anything but.

When a badass literally named Hero appears in the first ten minutes and starts calling the shots, it's evident he's meant to be the protagonist. That's why it's a surprise when this so-called saviour gets his head chewed off 90 seconds later.

However, that's not the only time Feast goes against convention. Even though children tend to make it out alive in a creature feature, a kid here suffers the grisliest death. Later, when a character called Heroine takes control of the situation, it looks like she might lead everyone out to safety... before she's abruptly killed.

When Tuffy the waitress becomes too traumatised to fight, she seems like a lost cause. But during the climax, a title card appears, showing Tuffy's name being rewritten as Heroine 2, highlighting she's become the new protagonist.

Since Feast constantly sets up tropes only to discard them, it's impossible to tell what's going to happen next.


4. Triangle

Triangle Film
UK Film Council

Back in 2009, Christopher Smith helmed a trippy time-travel thriller called Triangle.

Due to stress in her personal life, single mom Jessica is looking forward to having a relaxing boat trip with her friends. When the vessel capsizes, though, the group is forced to seek refuge on an ocean liner. 

To their surprise, there's nobody on the ship, save for a mysterious sack-headed maniac. When Jessica discovers the area is affected by a space-time anomaly, things go from bad to nightmarish in the blink of an eye.

On a first watch, it's pretty blatant who the killer is, making the inevitable unmasking pretty anticlimactic. But once Jess finds herself caught in a timeloop, Triangle becomes so unpredictable, it's surprisingly hard to follow.

When Jessica sees different versions of her friends, she needs to figure out which of them are from the past, present, or future, knowing her actions can create or destroy specific timelines. Sometimes, Jessica does the opposite of her past self, suggesting she can change the timeline. Other times, her actions seem locked into place, indicating her destiny is predetermined.

By the time all's said and done, it becomes painfully obvious the audience was looking at Triangle's overarching narrative from the wrong angle.


3. Identity

Identity Movie
Columbia Pictures

Loosely inspired by Agatha Christie's And Then They Were None, Identity begins with 11 strangers forced to stay in an isolated motel during a storm. When residents wind up with knives in the chest and baseball bats rammed down the throat, the survivors realise there's a killer amongst them.

While this is going on, there's a parallel story surrounding psychiatrist Dr. Malick and mentally ill murderer Malcolm Rivers. Initially, it's hard to tell how the two plots are connected, though over time it's revealed the events in the motel are a fantasy concocted by Malcolm. According to Malick, at least one of the identities harbours malicious intent, compelling Malcolm to kill when consumed by that personality. If that identity is quashed, he should be free of his bloodlust forever.

Even though this is a big bombshell, it's far from the last. When the killer in the motel is exposed, it's a total shocker, especially since there were several clues hinting at the person's true identity (no pun intended).

Just as it looks like everything is wrapping up, another epiphany is thrown in at the eleventh hour, with this twist retconning the story so spectacularly that a rewatch is necessary to appreciate it.


2. One Cut Of The Dead

One Cut Of The Dead
Enbu Seminar

One Cut of the Dead tossed convention to the wind the instant it started. When a zombie descends upon a blood-spattered woman within the first frame, this Japanese indie looks like a run-of-the-mill zombie flick. However, it's revealed immediately after that the pair are acting in a movie called True Fear. Furious about the performers lack of talent, the director arranges a blood ritual to awaken the dead, hoping the danger of being eaten for real will elevate the cast's acting skills.

Even though the first third of One Cut of the Dead is entertaining, it's let down by some amateur moments as the actors are hammy and regularly move in a staged manner, and the camera at times doesn't focus on the action, making it hard to follow what's going on.

During the second act, it's revealed all the events up until this point took place within a fictional film, meaning One Cut of the Dead is a film within a film within a film. And that's not all.

For the final act, One Cut of the Dead re-enacts the True Fear movie again, this time from behind the scenes, highlighting that every error was intentional. For example, the reason why the camera didn't focus on pivotal moments was because something went wrong or somebody missed their cue, and the actors move awkwardly to keep the stage crew out of sight or to set up an elaborate special effect.

Seeing how much effort was put into these deliberate mistakes should make viewers feel bad, since they erroneously believed they were unintentional blunders.


1. Frailty

Frailty Bill Paxton
Lionsgate

Though the late Bill Paxton had a tremendous acting career, his directorial debut proved he was also a gifted filmmaker. Frailty may not have been a big hit at the box office, but it's easy to see why it developed a cult following.

This nerve-shredding thriller opens with the disturbed Fenton Meiks recounting his childhood to an FBI agent, divulging how his father believed he was chosen by an angel to destroy demons. Thinking he couldn't accomplish God's work alone, Dad Meiks tasked his sons, Fenton and Adam, to slaughter regular folk, under the impression they were demons in disguise. Though Fenton thought his father was mentally ill, Adam was certain they were on the side of literal angels. After refusing to take part in his father's evil crusade, Fenton realised he had to take measures into his own hands before the situation escalated.

Even though Frailty is over 20 years old, it would be criminal to spoil the jaw-dropping ending. However, one thing that can be said is that this underrated gem never stops being shocking. Although the story is terrific and the performances are top-notch, it's the numerous revelations in the third act that leave the biggest impression.


Watch Next


In this post: 
identity
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows