10 Movies That Are Just Way Too Long

Why... won't... you... end...

A common complaint about modern movies is that they're getting longer. But while it may certainly feel that way when sitting through the latest Hollywood explosion fest, it isn't exactly true. Yes, many big releases clock in at over two hours long, but that's nothing new. In fact, the average film length has actually decreased (marginally) in recent years. And yet this remains a prominent complaint. You could argue it's because people are using the films they watched in their youth as a barometer (kids films have always been traditionally shorter) but the truth is more depressing; films are simply feeling longer. The sort of films that would push three hours used to be massive epics that needed that time just to get the majesty of their story across. Nowadays it's cynically produced movies based on a toy with the depth of a paddling pool. It's now deemed strange if a blockbuster movie clocks in at less than two hours; the old type of movies rarely get made and traditionally shorter pulpy movies have taken their place in terms of length. But in this inflation the content issue hasn't been accounted for, with shorter stories stretched to breaking point. Today we're going to look at ten movies that would have been infinitely better if they came in a good bit shorter and try and think how exactly a bit more editing could have improved them.

10. Les Misérables

Running Time: 158 minutes A film about the French Revolution has some justification in having a pretty epic length, but Les Misérables has only a fleeting reference to the full movement. If anything, it's a prequel, dealing with the unsuccessful June Rebellion rather than anything really historically impactful. Thus what we're left with is a fictional period piece. A very good fictional period piece that is evidently well thought out in terms of its themes, but all the same, it's still made up. That's not an inherent issue - The Godfather is made up - but in the case of Tom Hooper's adaptation of the musical based on Victor Hugo's gigantic book it stands out as an ordeal, long because it simply is. The play is 175 minutes with an interval, meaning that the film is pretty much exactly the same length, a prospect that makes your arse ache just thinking about it. Another issue that serves to highlight the bloated length is the attempts at creating a sense of epicness. The musical achieves this by its very nature, but on screen, where big casts and large sets are the bread and butter, we get more visual tricks - obnoxious close-ups and clearly CGI crane shots - that wear awfully quickly. What could be cut? All the songs that have been written for the screen for a start. After that it would have to be anything with Sacha Baron Cohen and Helena Bonham Carter, obviously.

9. King Kong

Running Time: 187 minutes You could almost watch the original King Kong through twice in the time it takes to slog through Peter Jackson's 2005 remake. And when the only source for that film is the original that is not something to be proud of. Obviously there's some things that need to be added to make a version of the story of a giant ape and his tragic trip to the big city work for modern audiences. The characters need to be more than just crudely drawn archetypes and more narrative motivation is demanded; why would you bring an ape to New York. There's even some nice additions that would please serious fans - the scene with Kong throwing the crew off a log into a pit of beetles is the realisation of a sequence cut from the original. But that's something the 1976 remake tried and semi-successfully did at an apparently spry 134 minutes. Jackson's film has so much padding and so little restraint that the only thing that keeps you watching is the promise of the Empire State Building finale. What could be cut? So, so much. Taking an hour to get to the island is ridiculous, and the amount of extended action sequences that serve only to give Jack Black something to do in the second act push things too far. Also the Central Park scene, which not only stretches physics, but also acts just to tease the audience shouldn't have seen the light of day.

8. Transformers

Running Time: 144 minutes Transformers is a dumb idea. Not quite as dumb as turtles who mutated into giant ninjas, but it's up there with other series treated with sincerity thanks to nostalgia hiding their stupidity. However, while it's dumb, it also has the potential to be fun. It is robots that turn into cars after all. The films ultimatley fail at this in a lot of ways, with the high levels of product placement almost seeming like they've forgotten this is an advert already, but what seals its reputation is the length. A dumb ninety minute Transformers would be infinitely preferable to a dumb hundred-and-forty minute Transformers. Not only would it be less pain, some of the more obnoxious elements would be less prolonged. We're not saying it would be great, but it would be certainly more palatable. The first film, Transformers, is actually the shortest of the lot (each film got slightly longer than its predecessor), but not only does it suffer in the same way, it set the precedent of bloated movies. What could be cut? In any Bay-inflected state, Transformers is a lost cause, but essentially if all the awkward humour and the obsession with the female form wasn't included then not only would there be a lot less to hate, it may be, to some degree, bearable.

7. The Equalizer

Running Time: 131 minutes Films based on TV shows are always a tricky proposition. Not only requiring a story that works at two, three or four times the usual length of an episode, there needs to be a suitably justified reason (beyond "we want money") to have it make the transition from the small screen. The new high watermark is 21 Jump Street, which serves as both a remake and sequel of the Johnny Depp-starring eighties comedy, although as evidenced by The Equalizer, it's not going to be topped anytime soon. The Denzel Washington actioner serves as an origin-story/reboot of the eighties TV series of the same name, seeing a well meaning do-gooder with a wide-ranging set of skills violently help out people who otherwise couldn't have help. Compared to some films on this list, 131 minutes may not seen like that much of a cinematic crime, but for a film whose plot summary is the entire basic story it's a slog. Despite an iffy back-catalogue, Antoine Fuqua brings a film with some nice visual style and semi-well-thought out characters. But to get to that stuff there's emotional build-up to suffer through that really doesn't make you care any more. What could be cut? It has narrative importance, but actually adds very little to the film given the amount of time put on it, so we'd see the Chloë Grace Moretz as a prostitute thread reduced or totally done-away with.

6. Casino

Running Time: 178 minutes You can't watch Casino without drawing some pretty strong comparisons to Goodfellas. Aside from all the Martin Scorcese tricks you expect from his decade spanning epics (extensive voice-overs, long steadicam shots, Robert De Niro), the story of the rise and fall of gangster-led Vegas is narratively rather similar to that of Henry Hill's experience with the mob on the other side of the country. You're tricked into finding the clearly illegal lifestyle alluring before seeing everything crumble in a horrible explosion of violence and emotions, with the one semi-good guy just about getting away. Obviously, being a Scorcese film, Casino is a good movie. It's entertaining and enlightening, with Joe Pesci once again perfecting psychopathic gangster. But there's a distinct familiarity to it that makes its length much more noticeable; it's an extra half an hour longer than Goodfellas, yet doesn't really do anything to justify it. Heck, even The Godfather came in at 175 minutes. What could be cut? There's plenty of episodic vignettes that wouldn't be missed, but really just a more sprightly sense of pace would make Casino an immediately more arresting film.

5. Harry Potter And The Chamber Of Secrets

Running Time: 160 minutes The Harry Potter movies are long. The shortest is The Deathly Hallows: Part 2, which despite only adapting a small sliver of the final book still comes in at 130 minutes. That in and of itself isn't too much of a problem; there's a strong plot running through the seven books/eight films, with lots of little clues dropped throughout the earlier installments that pay off in the later chapters, and all that is alongside the more conventional coming-of-age drama. But watching the series through, seeing the tone and visual style completely change, it's obvious that this wasn't at the forefront of the producers minds, evidenced by the way the books were adapted. The Chamber Of Secrets, widely regarded as the weakest in the series, is the longest, despite coming from the second-shortest book. A faithful adaptation is all well and good, but when it leads to a film longer than another based on a book three times its length (The Order Of The Phoenix) you get the feeling a better editor was needed. What could be cut? From a whole series standpoint, a lot. What's most important in The Chamber Of Secrets to the overarching plot is Tom Riddle's Diary and Lucius Malfoy. Beyond that everything else is take it or leave it; if they'd known how much of a short shrift he'd would get later on do you think Dobby would have been so focal?

4. Django Unchained

Running Time: 180 minutes Django Unchained is one of those films that people proclaim as too long before they've even seen it. Coming in at three hours, this looked an exploitive and glorified B-movie, overblown in a way we're all too accustomed to by Quentin Tarantino. It' was an odd criticism after such success with a similar revenge fantasy Inglourious Basterds, but there's nothing like pre-release denouncing of Oscar hopefuls. Now, Django is too long, there's no way around it. It takes almost an hour for the big villain to even get mentioned and entire sequences early on feel completely superfluous, but there's enough smarts in the script and brilliance in the performances (particularly Leonardo DiCaprio as a detestable slave owner) to forgive the dragged out elements. What stops it sitting alongside Basterds is that despite being half an hour longer there's less going on; there's no major subplots, with the film sticking religiously to its central plot. The real problem with Django is that it kills off the two most interesting characters within seconds of each other, leaving us with a rather uninteresting lead for its final twenty minutes. What could be cut? Going for the low-hanging fruit, Tarantino's cringe-worthy cameo, but beyond that a general refinement of the story, getting to Candyland quicker and less umming-and-ahhing after the plan goes awry would make something great.

3. Funny People

Running Time: 153 minutes If you're going to be making a big claim about a film in its title, you better be ready to deliver on it. People don't call a movie The Greatest Story Ever Told or The NeverEnding Story unless they're ready to deliver. Funny People is one of the worst offenders. Judd Apatow's look at the lives of stand-ups when off the stage may be about funny people, but it is the furthest thing from making us laugh. There's the odd chuckle, but for the most part the jokes (and boy are there a lot of attempts) fall flat. Obviously the film is trying to aim for an air of sincerity (it's about the cost of fame and opens with the lead discovering he has leukemia) but at the end of the day this is clearly meant to be a comedy and fails, mainly due to it being over two-and-a-half hours long. Apatow-brand comedies have a tendency to come in on the longer side of things. Comedy may be a genre that lends itself to shorter movies, but his consistently come in at over two hours out of a lack of any sense of restraint. While this sounds like more bang for your buck, there's still the same amount of humour as a ninety minute outing, with the added length coming from forced emotion. Funny People is the worst example of this. What could be cut? Any of the myriad of subplots could, although if we're being really harsh the entire stuff with Eric Bana which only serves to distract from what you feel the film should be about.

2. Avatar

Running Time: 161 minutes Avatar is the highest grossing film of all time, making more money than people even thought possible. It was obviously helped by the 3D surcharge (it was a time when the gimmick was viewed as an essential part of the viewing experience), but you wonder if it could have been even bigger had it had a less mammoth run time; a shorter film equals more potential showings through the day. That is, of course, not why we think Avatar is too long. That stems from the fact its simplistic story padded out with pretty visuals. From the first twenty minutes the major plot beats are obvious, making the roundabout way James Cameron gets to them a chore. For many the sights of Pandora and its alien denizens was enough to make it worth it, but for us it made what could have been a great film into an OK one. There are two extended cuts that make the film even longer and add nothing to the effect; the added scenes are just more "ooh, isn't Pandora pretty" moments. What could be cut? A lot, particularly from the second act. From when Jake first meets the Na'vi to the destruction of Home Tree the film is rather aimless, dragged out just to give the sense of passing time. Getting to the explosive final act quicker would have curbed a lot of the eventual criticism.

1. The Hobbit

Running Time: 330 minutes (and counting) We all know the ridiculousness of having The Hobbit, a slim tome a fraction of the size of any one of The Lord Of The Rings books, turned into a trilogy. But while it's easy to harp on about Tauriel and all those damn appendices, ultimately it distracts from the fact that the real issue is the lack of justification. Plenty of great movies have come from slight sources; the eighteen page short story We Can Remember It For You Wholesale became Total Recall. The Hobbit is long just for the sake of it, with each movie serving as a TV episode in a series rather than being a film that works in its own rights. Its defenders may be keen to implore people to wait to see the whole picture, but no one had to wait until The Return Of The King to find out if The Lord Of The Rings was good. There was no need for The Hobbit to be a trilogy and it seems increasingly apparent there was no way for it to work that way either. What could be cut? Anything added to the films with no reference to the books (dwarf-elf fan-fiction), all the small scenes turned into a big action beats (barrels and Smaug) and a lot of the appendices stuff that is only internally relevant. There's a great fan-cut in this idea. Which movies do you find too long? And which ones do you love despite their length? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.