10 Previously Great Movies That Have Dated Horribly
Cinema has been around for more than a century and in that time has evolved from a static actuality to action packed spectacles with CGI. No matter the technology, a truly great film will not fall victim to time. For all of its studio staginess, The Wizard of Oz still provides the same amount of vivid magic and imagination as it did in 1939. A Charlie Chaplin film such as The Kid or City Lights still has the sweetness and humanity that transcends sound and color. In that time, however, some films have fallen victims of age. They seem antiquated or outdated by todays standards. All the following films fall into several of the same categories. There are the message films in which it acts like an afterschool special. Then there are the special effects or action films that does not compare to modern quality. In a sense, these also fall into the category of innovation becoming a cliché. There are also different standards of humor and action, or the way we look at humor and action that older films just seem to not fit. The following films are classic films that do not hold up or pass the test of time... 10. The Magnificent Seven
It makes sense for there to be a western remake of Akira Kurosawas The Seven Samurai. The samurai genre, especially the way that Kurosawa tackled it, was inspired by the Classic Hollywood western. But Seven Samurai also invented the men on a mission trope in which one person goes out and collects a group of distinct individuals with their own personalities for a common goal. Films such as Oceans Eleven and A Bugs Life follows this motif. So, if John Sturges has the formula of one of the greatest films of all time with a genre that makes sense, then why does it not transcend time like its predecessor? Well, it falls for a lot of the standard Hollywood tropes. Unlike a John Ford, Sturges does not let the film breathe with real life characters. Each character is a caricature. Look at Kurosawas original film. The film is close to three and a half hours long. The first half is devoted to character development of the Seven. Sturges does not do that but replaces it with Classic Hollywood buffoonery. Everything fells overblown even with the star studded casts which has become a precedent for these types of film. But, the biggest problem is that compared to the original, Seven Samurai despite being a full 90 minutes longer does not ever feel overlong or pretentious the way The Magnificent Seven does.
9. Rebecca
Despite Alfred Hitchcocks terrific career, only one of his films has ever won Best Picture at the Academy Awards. Ironically, it feels the least Hitchcocky film for the master of suspense and that includes his comedy Mr. and Mrs. Smith. But, thats because Rebecca is the results of the two big heavyweights in the movie industry clashing. This was Hitchcocks first American film and his first film with David O. Selznick. Hitchcock was one of the first widely known auteurs in the Western world while Selznick looked at himself to be the filmmaker. The results are a good film but one short of a masterpiece. Rebecca has all the makings of a classic. It features a moody, gothic atmosphere with the charisma of Joan Fontaine and Laurence Olivier to lead the helm. It even has references to lesbian behavior that was subtle enough to get by the censors. I think thats why this film is such a disappointment. It has all the hallmarks and themes from the original material to make a true Hitchockian classic. Scenes such as the interaction between Joan Fontaine and Judith Anderson are some of the best back and forth conflicts on film. But, that is the most disappointing part of the film. All the signs were pointing towards an early Hitchcock classic like Notorious or The 39 Steps but parts were so muddled and overlong that it felt imbalance with the moments of brilliance and moments of boredom.
8. Dr. No
There are presently 23 films in the James Bond Eon franchise, making it the most long lasting and viable franchise of all time. Dr. No was the film that started it all. It featured the slick cars and the suave, debonair attitude of Sean Connery and all the hallmarks that would become the James Bond franchise. But, with all of the other Bond movies and the various spoofs and parodies that have befallen the franchise, Dr. No indeed seems like a franchise starter and a very lackluster one at that. This is a good example of an innovative film seeming like cliché. With the Austin Powers franchise especially, this film fell close to self parody. There is a very tongue in cheek feel for the whole film like the filmmakers knew they were making silly fluff but it does not work as well as it does in the other films. The follow-ups of From Russia with Love and Goldfinger plays as more naturalistic films while still having the fun of a James Bond film. In addition, it looks like a cheap film which will not be true with all the subsequent films. Depending on the order and what age you begin watching these films, Dr. No will seem below the standard of the franchise especially in the pantheon of the best Bond of them all; Sean Connery.
7. The Lost Weekend
The story of the making of The Lost Weekend proves to be much more interesting piece of cinema than the actual film itself. Famed director, Billy Wilder, had quite a difficult time working with alcoholic pulp novelist, Raymond Chandler. The film is not necessarily Wilders indictment on Chandler but his trying to explain to himself what Chandler was going through. However, the film falls into the category of the message film that feels too much like an after school special. Subtlety in Classic Hollywood films have never been their strong suit. The Lost Weekend is the perfect example of that. All the components of that makes up the film makes it quite watchable. But, the problem is the over the top storyline and message. Billy Wilders direction gives it the gray overtones that shadow an alcoholic especially with the neon signs passing through a person motif. Ray Milland also does a good job portraying a man struggling with demons. But, once again my problem is the portrayal of a bumbling drunk that seemed too exaggerated to be effective. My father was an alcoholic and I could not find truth in the film. Look at a recent film portraying alcoholism called Smashed. That film is perfect portrayal of alcohol dependency and the struggle to keep off it. But, that does not mean that The Lost Weekend was totally lost.
6. The Mummy
5. The Gentleman's Agreement
Gregory Peck is the epitome of the standup individual with his role as Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird and especially his role in the Elia Kazan message film, The Gentlemans Agreement. The reason why it is called a message film is that it is a film in which the obvious message is clear. It is not okay to be anti-Semitic. The film plays like the inspiration to the book Black like Me in which he is a reporter who changes his name to a gentile name to see how different people treated a man who is suspected of being Jewish. The film was made by Elia Kazan who is one of the greatest American directors who would alter go on to make A Streetcar Named Desire and On the Waterfront. But, with The Gentlemans Agreement, his usually naturalistic style is replaced with a stuffy story that drowns in its own pretentiousness. It is not a great movie which is saved by Gregory Peck but it certainly feels like an important movie. The modern day equivalent of the film is that of a film that is trying to vie for an Oscar like Crash or The Blind Side. It doesnt breathe like some other message films like a Guess Whos Coming to Dinner. Maybe it needs to be celebrated for the risks the film takes in 1947 but, for a modern audience it felt overly obvious.
4. Easy Rider
The film that defined its generation does not hold up because it is exactly the film that defines its generation. It so perfectly encapsulates its time that for todays viewer it is quite dated. It is a representation of hippie, nonconformist culture and it is structured in the way a nonconformist would structure it. With today, it feels like travelogue through the road as psychedelic rock plays throughout the film. Easy Rider is quite a bizarre film. Made by Dennis Hopper, it was not unusual for him to be on some sort of narcotic during the filming leading to some of the strange characterizations. In a modern way of looking, this is quite a pretentious film in which Hopper and Fonda stroke their egos as they pursue Fondas hobby of riding. The making of the film seemed to make a much more interesting film than the results as it dealt with the contentious Hopper with his crew, actors which included knives being pulled and actors pretending to talk to his dead mother.But, its influence on New Hollywood and the way it broke the greatest actor of that generation, Jack Nicholson, leaves a significant mark on our culture.
3. Mrs. Miniver
Historical context provides many reasons why a film would be made. In the effective Alfred Hitchcock film, Foreign Correspondent, there seems to be one additional scene at the end that is straight World War 2 propaganda. The Academy Award winning film, Mrs. Miniver is the ultimate example of a film made exclusively for propaganda. The whole purpose of this film about a upper middle class housewife struggling with her family participating in the War, is to revel in the Winston Churchill ideal family and collective family cohesion. Because it is a film made to persuade, a lot of the portions of the film felts quite contrived. Its purpose is obvious and quite up front. Despite strong performance from Greer Garson as the title character and Walter Pidgeon as the patriarch of the family, the over sentimentality overshadows any of the performances that stood out. And that is a disappointment because Garson gives it her all in a performance that deserves to be in a more memorable film. But, its hard as a modern viewer to personally connect with a family that felt like a Hallmark, cookie-cutter family in which everyone is nice and valiant. Then again it is a film to persuade rather than as a piece of true art.
2. Animal Crackers
The Marx Brothers are without doubt comedic geniuses with each brother having their own specific strength to form a cohesive comedy tandem. Groucho, the de facto leader of the group, was known for his smart wit and dry one liners. Harpo has a Chaoplinesque quality combined with a childhood innocence that makes his mischievous smile all the more endearing. And then there is Chico whose persona as a immigrant who would do anything to make a quick buck becomes endearing to many of the viewers who come from similar situations. They are without a doubt classic comedians but a lot of their early film work struggle to live up to their brilliance. Animal Crackers is considered one of the greatest comedies of all time. Yet, it is a very weak film in their filmography. The early Marx Brothers films were adaptations of their stage work. They would take their act on the road and build up enough material to fill a feature length movie. But, with that idea, the entire film feels staged like a theater show. That is a problem with a lot of early film work in the 1900s. But, the film medium has moved along way since then and Animal Crackers did not make the jump. In addition, The Marx Brothers were never known for their cohesive story. But, their better works such as Duck Soup succeeded based on its biting satire and A Night at the Opera actually found a plot. Animal Crackers fails to deliver that and the vignettes thus fall flat.
1. Breakfast at Tiffany's
There is no more iconic image than that of Audrey Hepburn in Breakfast at Tiffanys. If you walk along the streets of New York, there is bound to be a street merchant that is selling a framed photo of Hepburn. It is a staple of pop culture and cemented Hepburns status as a pop culture, fashion icon. Yet, people forget what the film is really about. In fact, I dont think that most people who so revere the life of Holly Golightly really remember that the film is a sad, depressing feature about the world of high class prostitution. And that is the major problem with the film in todays standards. It sanitizes the world that we are suppose to be living in and makes it something to be desired and liked despite the fact that there are numerous attempts to commit suicide. Blake Edwards, whom I never liked as a director, does not know how to find the balance between his broad style of comedy and drama. And that is very striking with Breakfast at Tiffanys. This film is the ultimate example of a clash of generations in terms of entertainment value. And I didnt even mention Mickey Rooneys ill advised role as an Oriental Man.