10 Sacred Films That Should Never Be Remade

Please, Hollywood - never remake any of these.

Imagine you€™re a film studio executive. Your job is to pick the movies that will make millions and put them into production. And an established brand name with a ready-made audience can be a tempting proposition when you€™re in such a position. That€™s why we get so many reboots, remakes, sequels and spin-offs to existing properties; a recognisable name can put bums on seats like nothing else. If a film was a massive hit at the box office, even if a long time has passed since its initial release, you can be fairly confident that people will flock down to the multiplex to see a new take. Heck, even if an older film didn't make much money at the cinema, but later became a cult classic on DVD, Hollywood will eventually try to cash in by producing a new version. The problem with this is simple: some films are perfect. They can€™t be remade any better than they were originally made. Yes, audiences will probably still go see them out of intrigue, but they€™re not going to happy when they witness a shoddy rehash of one of their favourite movies. Remakes often make money, but they rarely make audiences happy. Indeed, they often do the very opposite, inspiring bitter vitriol in articles, comments sections and lengthy discussions down the pub. Here are ten examples of films that Hollywood should never even consider remaking, unless they deliberately want to enrage us all in exchange for an easy buck...

10. The Goonies

You can see why this would be tempting. Richard Donner€™s The Goonies has everything €“ a set of young likeable characters, a fun sense of adventure, and a memorable name that€™s endured for years in our memories already. Indeed, if The Goonies had been made more recently, it probably would have become a franchise and spawned a whole series of follow-ups. Even now, talk of sequel or reboot to the original rears its head every few years. However, what happened in 1985 is best left in 1985. They could never find a cast to match the original Goonies, and political correctness would probably mean that Sloth would be written out. With cinema the way it is now, they€™d probably stuff a Goonies reboot with CGI, as well. No thanks. Additionally, at the age of 85, Richard Donner is unlikely to direct this one himself, and there€™s no one else who stands a chance of remaking his family adventure classic. Leave well alone, Hollywood, and think carefully before green-lighting that rumoured sequel, as well.

9. Back To The Future

Back To The Future lends itself to a reboot, in some ways. With thirty years now passed since the original, a new version of Robert Zemeckis€™ time-travelling sci-fi flick could leap forward another thirty years and predict what 2045 would look like. However, Michael J. Fox is Marty McFly. Christopher Lloyd is Doc Brown. The Back To The Future movies are synonymous with the year 1985. No one else could inhabit those roles in the same way, and seeing a DeLorean land in real-life 2015 would only serve to highlight how dull and colourless the cinematic landscape has become since the 1980s. A remake would probably take Marty to a gritty dystopia rather than a world where Biff has simply become a bigger bully. No one wants to see that, especially when the original trilogy remains a hugely enjoyable viewing experience. The Back To The Future films told a complete story. If anything, they went even further than they had to by adding the Wild West element in Part III. We don€™t need any more than that. That's just being greedy.

8. Harry Potter

The Harry Potter film series began with The Philosopher€™s Stone in 2001 and ended with The Deathly Hallows Part 2 in 2011. For ten years those films were regular box office moneymakers for Warner Bros., raking in over $7 billion at the global box office. For now, the executives at Warner Bros. are content with making a Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them trilogy. Give it a few years after that trilogy has ended, though, and they€™re bound to consider pressing the big red reboot button on The Boy Who Lived's cinematic saga. They really shouldn€™t, though. This wouldn€™t just be one remake, but eight. While it might be fun to see The Philosopher€™s Stone made in a less cheesy way, eight remakes in ten years is nobody€™s idea of fun. Audiences went on a journey with Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint, but they might not be willing to hand over another $7 billion to see the same stories retold with different actors and updated special effects. By all means, Warner Bros. should continue making movies in the wizarding world. They€™d be silly not to. But please, guys, leave the original films alone.

7. Airplane

Airplane! may not look like a box office smash by today€™s standards, but, bringing in over $80 million gross was a massive success. You can see, then, why Paramount might want to squeeze a bit more cash out of the Airplane! property. It has become a cult classic since its release, so a big budget remake could capitalise on that, surely. Sorry, I won€™t call you Shirley again. The groan you let out in reaction to my lame attempt at reusing the "Don€™t call me Shirley" gag there is symptomatic of why an Airplane! reboot wouldn€™t work. We know these jokes already, and jokes don€™t tend to be better the second time around. The original had a perfect script from Jim Abrahams, David Zucker and Jerry Zucker. Leslie Nielsen was on the form of his life in the lead role. There€™s not an ice cube€™s chance in hell that a reboot could repeat the trick. And if you can€™t do it better than the first time (as the sequel showed), you simply shouldn€™t do it again.

6. Groundhog Day

Groundhog Day is a film that already exists. It is perfect. Bill Murray is perfect in it and Harold Ramis wrote and directed it perfectly. It€™s perfect. Again, though its domestic cinematic gross of $70 million is small fries compared to what a big comedy hit can make nowadays, it was a sizeable success then and remains so now. The universal love for Groundhog Day could be enough to convince executives to try and milk more money out of the property by remaking it. But how could they? Due to the nature of the film, we€™ve already seen its story told numerous times in several different ways. We€™ve witnessed Bill Murray live the events of Groundhog Day again and again. 38 times to be precise. It's a film that remakes itself as it goes along. Murray and Ramis wrangled every last joke out of that premise. There€™s no need to tell us that story again. Although there€™s no shortage of comic actors and comedic screenwriters these days, there's no pairing in cinema today could match the number of laughs that Ramis and Murray managed to find in Groundhog Day. So please, Hollywood, don€™t try.

5. The Shawshank Redemption

The Shawshank Redemption is on a lot of people€™s lists of their favourite movies. Again even though it wasn€™t a massive hit on its initial release in 1994. On American screens, it made under $30 million. But since then, it€™s earned a huge adoring fanbase via re-releases, home entertainment and word-of-mouth praise. If they made it again, it€™d probably make much more money than it did the first time around. But that€™s not a good enough reason. Some thought has to go to the fact that the original Shawshank simply couldn€™t be better. Frank Darabont€™s story was hugely emotionally engaging, and both Tim Robbins and Morgan Freeman gave career best performances as the prison inmates who became firm friends. Could a new script match the original? Could any actor produce a better performance in Robbins€™ or Freeman€™s role? Would we care about the story as much seeing as we already know the ending? The answer to all three of those questions is no, so the wise thing would be for Hollywood to leave Shawshank alone, and just be happy that the film found success after its cinema release.

4. The Shining

Pairings in cinema don€™t get better than Stanley Kubrick and Jack Nicholson. Working together on the adaptation of Stephen King€™s novel The Shining, this duo€™s collaboration created one of the best horror movies of all time. For a lot of people, it is the best. Horror being horror, a sort-of remake of The Shining already exists. A 1997 TV mini-series sought to top Kubrick€™s visual tale of the Overlook Hotel by re-adapting King€™s novel for the small screen. Although it earned a few decent reviews, The Shining TV show hardly has the classic status of the film. And that€™s the problem. The Shining is such a classic film that remaking it would be an impossible endeavour. Whoever directed it wouldn€™t be as good as Kubrick. No casting could match Nicholson. No scares could top the original. Even a shot for shot remake €“ a la Psycho €“ would be pointless. All that would do is serve to remind us of the original Shining film, an enduring fright fest needs no retelling.

3. It€™s A Wonderful Life

Jimmy Stewart as George Bailey is one of the best performances in cinema history. Frank Capra€™s 1946 film It€™s A Wonderful Life is a Christmas Carol type narrative, where a guardian angel shows suicidal businessman George all the lives he has touched and encourages him to keep living one fateful Christmas Eve. Ultimately, George€™s family and friends band around him to bring him back from the brink. It€™s a classic. It€™s a must-watch every Christmas. It€™s un-remake-able. The reasons are the same as they often are €“ the original film is perfect. How could anyone do it better? Sure, it could add colour, but that would hardly make up for the fact that someone else would have to play George Bailey (and they already did that to the original version and it didn't work). There are plenty of talented actors about, but no one could top that performance. Not even Chris Pratt. It€™s best left alone, then. Even the idea of a belated sequel, which did the rounds a few years ago, seems fated to fail in matching up to the original. There€™s already been one remake €“ 1977 TV version, It Happened One Christmas €“ let€™s hope there€™s never another.

2. The Godfather

Speaking of unbeatable performances, there€™s no way that any living actor could play a better Vito Corleone than Marlon Brando or Robert De Niro. Nor, for that matter, could anyone a better Michael Corleone than Al Pacino. For those reasons €“ and many others €“ The Godfather series should never be remade. The Godfather series is the magnum opus of Francis Ford Coppola€™s career. The first two films were so good that he couldn€™t even top them himself when it came to Part III. Another filmmaker could never, ever repeat this excellence. All we€™d get was a pale imitation, which isn€™t on anyone€™s wish list. Although it€™s easy to be envious of a parallel universe where The Godfather Part III somehow lived up to the high bar of expectations raised by The Godfather and The Godfather Part II, it€™s not worth remaking two classic films to try and improve on a disappointing third instalment.

1. The Lord Of The Rings

The Lord Of The Rings trilogy came at the perfect time. Peter Jackson had a vision for the films, and he shot the entire series €“ save for a few pick-up shots €“ over 274 days in one big block. This audacious plan won the trilogy a record-breaking 17 Academy Awards. You couldn€™t repeat that trick. You just couldn€™t. In fact, when Peter Jackson tried to, with The Hobbit prequel films, he ended up with three movies that didn€™t stand up to the originals. Splitting the book into three novels and overindulging in CGI meant that The Hobbit didn€™t succeed on quite the same level as The Lord Of The Rings. If Lord Of The Rings was ever made again, it would surely go the same way. Too much modern CGI would spoil it, but an attempt to directly reshoot the original would just seem pointless. And the cast have become so synonymous with their characters that any other portrayals of the likes of Frodo, Gandalf and Gollum would just feel weird. We€™re sure New Line will consider it one day, but a Lord Of The Rings remake truly wouldn€™t work. Which movies would you hate to see remade? Let us know in the comments...

Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.