10 Sequels That Ruined Great Movie Endings
Let's just pretend X-Men finished with Logan.
It's no secret that movie sequels are a tough cookie to crack. There's a line every director has to walk when crafting a follow up, between giving the audience more of what they loved the first time round and delivering a story that's new, fresh, and able to carry on the franchise in a natural way.
The MCU has nailed this formula, but not every series is so lucky. Hell, the reality is there's plenty of big names out there that only received a sequel because the producers who owned them wanted to line their pockets with more filthy riches, and couldn't have cared less whether or not the story itself demanded extending.
These are always the most frustrating sequels to watch, as the writers are forced to bend over backwards to come up with a contrived reason for them to exist in the first place. Sometimes they pull it off and the film is good enough to justify the messiness, but other times a writer will dig up the ending of an amazing film and bastardize its corpse just so a sequel can be made, ruining something good in the process.
10. Blues Brothers 2000
Blues Brothers 2000 is a sequel that makes you question the thought process behind any Hollywood movie. The 1980 original was a cult darling, inspiring an entire generation of Halloween costumes, but why after 18 years did John Landis and Dan Akroyd decide a follow up was necessary? Hell, a bunch of the original actors had passed away, and the studio was interfering at every step, but they pushed on, believing in the story they wanted to tell.
Sadly, that story was pretty damn terrible, and as you might have guessed considering it's here on this list, pissed all over the climax of the last film.
The first Blues Brothers was funny and irreverent, but had stakes thanks to the titular brothers' attempts to pay off the tax bill of the orphanage they were raised in. This is their "mission from god", and they manage to pull it off before getting arrested by what appears to be the combined might of every police force in America.
2000 picks up 18 years later as Akroyd's Elwood is released from prison to find out his brother his dead, his friend is dead, and the orphanage he went to jail for was destroyed.
Yay?
9. Men In Black 2
Men in Black is the kind of Hollywood blockbuster they just don't make anymore. Not only was it an imaginative visual spectacle back in the day, with a now-iconic sense of style (and a killer theme song) that was instantly recognisable, but it was full of heart.
In comparison to other movies in the franchise - like 2019's International - the world of Men in Black was grounded and tactile, and the characters were surprisingly nuanced.
I'm not saying it was Taxi Driver or anything - after all, the first film sees Vincent D'Onofrio playing an alien bug squeezed into a man's skin, and all the comic-book style acting that comes with a role like that - but the flick brought the emotion in the dynamic between the two leads.
There was a genuinely poignant arc to Tommy Lee Jones' Agent K especially, who ends the movie by retiring and returning to live a normal life, unsure whether spending his life looking out to the stars has meant he's let everything on Earth pass him by.
It's a tender moment... one which the sequel wastes little time in undoing by bringing K back into the fold because more aliens needed shooting.
8. Kick Ass 2
Kick Ass 2 should never have been made. Yes, the story continued in the original comics series, but that didn't mean there had to be more films. After all, the first flick was markedly different from its source material, and cut away most of the rougher edges in favour of a more hopeful ending where Dave gives up his desire to be a hero and lives a regular life.
It's not just that Kick Ass 2 upends that resolution, but that it does it in the nastiest way possible. The development of all the characters ranges from asinine to downright ugly, as Dave's father is killed, he loses his girlfriend, and Chris from the first movie transforms from a bumbling idiot super-villain into a psychopathic rapist.
Despite being major changes on the surface, none of these developments actually add anything, and they don't even succeed in being button-pushing like they were in the far edgier source material. Instead, it ruins the characters established in the first film while losing the grounded sense of humanity that made it so successful.
7. Rambo: Last Blood
In a way, you could argue that pretty much every movie after the first Rambo (which wasn't even called Rambo) actively worked against its ending. The original is all about the titular character dealing with the effects of war after returning home, but the sequels turned him into a big ol' war machine.
The thing is though, for the most part they get away with it by being bloody good action movies. Sure, they might be a departure, but at least they're well made, fun, and undeniably turned Rambo into a household name.
The fourth movie wasn't everyone's cup of tea, but it had heart, calling back to the prior movies and giving the character a sense of closure, as he puts the killing behind him to live with his remaining family.
For some reason, 10 years later the world decided it needed yet another film starring 73-year-old Stallone ripping the hearts out of the chests of bad guys, and Rambo: Last Blood was born. Despite its title referencing the first film, it has nothing in common with it, and functions purely as a forgettable, generic action movie.
You could have brought Rambo out of retirement for a considered send-off, but this sours the natural ending of 2008's picture for a plot so bad, the creator of the character disowned it entirely.
6. Blair Witch 2: Book Of Shadows
Blair Witch is one of those long-running franchises that's still relying on the affection people have for the very first film. Over the years there have been two stabs at continuing the brand through sequels, but these were decades apart because the first try shat the bed so much it almost ruined everything.
Blair Witch 2: Book of Shadows doesn't only crap all over the ending of the movie it followed, it craps all over the audience that cared enough to slug through this borefest. It systematically strips away all the uniqueness of the original, swapping out the found-footage framing for a generically shot horror movie, while ignoring the ambiguity of the Witch herself by explaining the lore in the most mind-numbing way possible.
That's bad enough, but the cardinal sin is that it reframes the first film as just that: a movie. The sequel clarifies that Heather and the gang's footage was all fake, a fictional movie that was released that inspired fans to venture to Burkittsville.
5. Freddy Vs Jason
Freddy Vs Jason isn't a bad movie. The monster mashup does everything it says on the tin, and while the film as a whole might not be amazing, there's some great ideas in there, along with some spectacular fight sequences. Once they get going and start beating the s**t out of each other, you kinda forget all the dumb, bad parts.
It's just a shame it was only made possible by completely disregarding Wes Craven's New Nightmare.
During its final years, The Nightmare on Elm Street series was in dire straits. Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare was one of the worst things since unsliced bread, a complete embarrassment for the once great series. Consequently, in order to reclaim the legacy of the project he started, Wes Craven returned for one final Nightmare movie.
Instead of picking up the baggage of the sequels, this flick went down a new direction, crafting a story where Craven's original Freddy flick was only a movie, and the entity of Krueger was haunting lead actress Heather Langenkamp. It re-contextualised the entire series, ending it on a meta, terrifying note - but a note that was immediately undone so more sequels could be made.
4. The Descent Part 2
Neil Marshall's The Descent has one of the spookiest horror endings ever. After fighting for her life in a cave full of monsters, lead Sarah claws her way to freedom and flags down a car. After a jump scare though, it's revealed that she never escaped at all, and hallucinated the victory. Instead, she's still stuck deep in the cave, with only an imagined vision of her dead daughter to comfort her, as the monsters close in.
Sadly, that ending was only included in the UK cut of the film, and the US received the 'happier' version where Sarah actually does escape. The general consensus was that the UK cut was the intended edition of the movie... but all that changed when a sequel was greenlit and brought Sarah back.
This new movie confirms the escape as canon, and then contrives a reason to put Sarah back into the cave, to endure another round of pain and suffering. It retreads everything from the original, bringing back characters just to kill them off again, and overall diluting the power that the original ending held for more of the same.
3. X-Men: Dark Phoenix
Back in 2018, rumours swirled that Fox - in anticipation of the Disney merger - would cut their losses and bury X-Men: Dark Phoenix (along with New Mutants). That didn't happen of course, but after it came out, a lot of fans wondered whether it might have been the better decision.
Dark Phoenix is watchable, but it's a jumbled mess of ideas, poor execution, and not in any way a satisfying climax to this decades-old superhero franchise.
However, it was made even worse because it essentially served as an unnecessary follow-up to Logan, which perfectly tied off the story.
Sure, that movie was set in an adjacent universe from the main series, but that doesn't mean it still didn't function within the context of those previous films. Arguably the best X-Men movie Fox has produced, Logan was mature and melancholic, acting as a heartbreaking, yet hopeful, send-off for one of the most iconic characters in the genre.
The X-Men movie timeline is wild, and even though it's never clear how much it was connected to the previous films, Logan still honours their legacy and rewards an audience's investment. Dark Phoenix doesn't actively undermine that ending, but it merely existing sours the legacy, and stopped it going out with a bang.
2. Resident Evil: The Final Chapter
The Resident Evil movie franchise can eat me.
It's one of the only series in history that has actual contempt for the people who care about its story and watch each sequel. Every new instalment continually said "f**k you" to the continuity established in the last, so by the time Resident Evil: Retribution finished on an epic cliffhanger, fans probably shouldn't have expected them to actually follow up on it in the sequel.
Sadly, the idea of that cliffhanger was too juicy to not want to see fully realised. The penultimate movie ends on the promise of humanity's last stand - a bunch of iconic video game characters finally united, former villains becoming heroes to help the larger cause, thousands of monsters about to ravage the last safe haven (which also happens to be the goddamn White House!) - and everyone waited on baited breath to see how it would be resolved in the next flick.
Of course, years later The Final Chapter came out, and immediately skipped over the battle. Instead of indulging in it, it begins with the fight already over, everyone but protagonist Alice dead, and barely an explanation as to what happened.
Thanks, I hate it.
1. Alien: Resurrection
Originally, I had Alien 3 on this list. It existing at all flies in the face of Aliens' hopeful climax, but killing off Newt and Hicks is just about justified by giving Ripley herself a proper send-off in one of the most spectacular sacrifices in cinema history.
Alien: Resurrection, on the other hand, has no redeeming story beats that hit that level, and every second actively undermines everything that came before. That's because the filmmakers had to bring back Sigourney Weaver's Ripley, and did so by cloning her (along with the alien embryo inside her). Consequently, her sacrifice in the previous flick is rendered moot, and it was all in service of bringing back the character as a dumb human-alien hybrid thing.
The film itself was terrible, but it's made worse because it disrupted a perfectly natural ending for the franchise.