10 Surprisingly Great Movies From Summer 2016

Star Trek Beyond expectations.

Star Trek Beyond Pete S Dragon Lights Out
Disney, Paramount & Warner Bros.

There's no getting around the brutal truth that this past summer has been one of the most underwhelming and disappointing in recent memory, if perhaps ever.

On the other hand, while approximately nobody was surprised that movies like Captain America: Civil War, The Jungle Book and Finding Dory ended up scoring strong acclaim, there were more than a handful of successful films that soared high above most expectations.

From massive tentpoles to low-budget horrors and everything in-between, many of the summer's most satisfying movies came from surprising places, and prove that while Hollywood is by its nature unpredictable, it doesn't always have to result in crushed hope (looking at you here, DC).

In short, if you gave these movies a miss because they didn't look all that great, you might want to give them a second look. Here are 10 surprisingly great movies from summer 2016...

10. The Shallows

The Shallows Blake Lively
Columbia Pictures

What We Expected: Ninety unbearably campy minutes of Blake Lively not acting and serving as nothing more than eye candy while she faces off against an unconvincing CGI shark.

What We Got: An uncommonly tense shark movie that dares to take itself seriously and is infinitely more compelling as a result. Sure, Likely is extremely easy on the eyes here, but director Jaume Collet-Serra doesn't overdo it on the lingering bikini shots, and perhaps most surprisingly, Lively carries the film extremely well with her committed performance, considering she's the only significant character in the entire movie.

It's not quite as convincing in its third reel showdown (which does admittedly go a little CGI overkill), but on the whole The Shallows delivers nail-biting suspense, terrific visuals and a surprisingly strong central performance.


9. Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising

Bad Neighbours Zac Efron Seth Rogen
Universal Pictures

What We Expected: A near-pointless sequel made solely to line the pockets of those involved, lazily rehashing the original premise to highly diminished returns just as happened with the wildly unnecessary Hangover sequels.

What We Got: More 22 Jump Street than The Hangover Part II, Sorority Rising exhibits enough self-awareness to one-up the original's premise by introducing a rowdy band of sorority girls (led by Chloƫ Grace Moretz) and laying a welcome feminist twist on top of the frat house comedy formula.

There are some absolutely killer gags here (especially one about Jews and ovens), it moves the original's characters on in an interesting and entertaining way, introduces a new host of hell-raisers, and at least matches if not betters the first film. What more could you want from a comedy sequel that sounded so transparently lazy from the outset?


8. Nerve

Dave Franco Nerve
Lionsgate

What We Expected: A trashy tech-thriller which casts 20-something actors as unconvincing teenagers while delivering laughably outdated, trite social commentary on the smartphone generation.

What We Got: It's definitely rough around the edges, but Nerve is also a surprisingly on-point thriller about the dangerous potential of modern technology, feeling very much of-the-moment while delivering solid lead performances from Emma Roberts and Dave Franco (even if, yes, they are hilariously aged out of their roles).

A lot of the credit goes to Catfish directors Henry Joost and Ariel Schulman, who are clearly well-acquainted with modern tech and translate that through to the movie's flashy style superbly, aided by a pulsing synth score and beautiful neon cinematography.

Even during its sillier moments this one's an absolute blast and has the early makings of a cult classic. Wait and see.


7. Lights Out

Lights Out Teresa Palmer.jpg
Warner Bros.

What We Expected: Yet another bust for talented lead actress Teresa Palmer, delivering generic shocks, predictable jump scares and a supernatural back story you can't even begin to give a damn about, while brutally wasting Maria Bello in a supporting role.

What We Got: Palmer finally gets a solid leading role and acts the hell out of it here, for what may seem like generic horror fodder is a surprisingly effective little chiller that makes the most of one of humanity's most common fears: the dark.

It's an extremely simple concept and proves that sometimes a basic, elemental premise can be so much more gratifying than complex, effects-driven scares.

It's not without the occasional groan-worthy jump scare, but the characters are uncommonly smart for the genre, the family drama actually works, Maria Bello gives a strong performance as Palmer's mother, and at only 80 minutes in length, it doesn't outstay its welcome for even a moment.


6. Florence Foster Jenkins

Florence Foster Jenkins.jpg
Paramount Pictures

What We Expected: Meryl Streep doing her Meryl Streep thing...playing a person almost nobody's heard of or interested in, while directed by the infuriatingly inconsistent Stephen Frears and co-starring a never-hammier Hugh Grant. It's pure Oscar bait and Streep will probably end up with a nomination regardless.

What We Got: A terrifically entertaining turn from Streep in an unexpectedly engaging and heartfelt portrayal of a fascinating figure. Perhaps the movie's biggest success is in capturing the human essence of its title character, and on a broader level realising our universal desire to be known, loved and express ourselves. It's not about how well you do it, it's simply that you do it with feeling.

Plus, Hugh Grant gives possibly the best performance of his career as Jenkins' husband, even if it's really Streep's show all the way.


5. Pete's Dragon

Pete S Dragon
Disney

What We Expected: A remake of a dubious classic that's hardly particularly good or well-known in the first place, sure to waste talents like Robert Redford, Bryce Dallas Howard and Karl Urban, with a director who has zero blockbuster experience. To make matters worse, the atrocious marketing campaign will probably make it a box office bust too.

What We Got: A tender, calm, surprisingly affecting little adventure flick that, while an undeniable financial bomb, makes good use of director David Lowery (Ain't Them Bodies Saints) to deliver a perfect compromise between art-house quiet and blockbuster bombast.

Though the adult characters save for Redford feel a little underserved, the relationship between boy and dragon is terrific to watch, with lead Oakes Fegley conveying the tragic heartbreak of loss and beauty of friendship.

Sadly it may be destined for nothing more than cult status like the original movie, but it also happens to be a rare remake that improves significantly on what came before.


4. Don't Breathe

Don T Breathe Stephen Lang
Screen Gems

What We Expected: A competent if forgettable little horror flick from the director of the competent if forgettable Evil Dead remake that'll do fine business on the VOD circuit but be quickly forgotten once the summer is over.

What We Got: A surprisingly nimble, terrifying thriller that delivers incredible performances from Jane Levy and Stephen Lang in particular, while director Fede Alvarez serves up one of the most stylish entries into the genre in quite some time.

What could've simply been an efficient exercise in working out the audience's adrenal glands dares to go further by thickly layering on a ton of moral ambiguity that makes the young vs. old showdown that much more compelling. Far more than a gimmicky thriller about a blind man facing off against a gang of youngsters attempting to rob him, Don't Breathe is a terrific showcase for both performers and director.


3. The Conjuring 2

The Conjuring 2 Nun Vera Farmiga
Warner Bros.

What We Expected: A perfunctory sequel that mines decent work out of Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson but largely coasts on the success of the original, rehashing its core narrative while failing to carve out a distinct personality for itself, and inevitably setting up a third film of course.

What We Got: A rare horror sequel that damn-near matches what came before it, touting an entertaining new setting and daring to dig down deep with its characters for an arguably overlong 134 minutes but in turn investing us deeply in these people.

Farmiga and Wilson are terrific as expected, though it's young Madison Wolfe who runs away with the movie as protagonist Janet. James Wan directs the hell out of it as you'd hope for, and in introducing the demon Nun character, gives horror its most memorably horrifying villain in quite some time. Just try and forget that damn painting scene.

On the strength of this, The Conjuring 3 doesn't seem like such a bad idea.


2. Star Trek Beyond

star trek beyond spock bones
Paramount

What We Expected: Director J.J. Abrams being replaced by Fast and Furious' Justin Lin suggests Beyond will deliver the requisite action but probably at the expense of basic logic. Plus, Simon Pegg is a fairly inconsistent screenwriter and has never written a movie of this scope and magnitude before, so it could easily be a bit of a mess.

What We Got: A surprisingly satisfying romp that basically plays out like an extended episode of the 1960s TV show. Pegg's script warmly embraces an old-school tone that plays-up the fun and downplays the gritty seriousness, while avoiding ham-fisted references to classic Trek (a major issue in Star Trek Into Darkness), giving both Leonard Nimoy and Anton Yelchin touching tributes, and introducing a terrific new heroine by way of Sofia Boutella's Jaylah.


1. Barbershop: The Next Cut

Barbershop The Next Cut.jpg
Warner Bros.

What We Expected: An immensely belated sequel few actually asked for, milking its fanbase dry for every drop it's worth while likely recycling prior gags and attempting to thrive off the modest success of the two prior films. Plus, there aren't enough movies aimed at the "black demographic", so they'll take whatever trash studios vomit at them and filmmakers don't need to put any effort in, right?

What We Got: It may be arguably earnest to a fault, but the third Barbershop movie is, against the odds, arguably the best entry into the franchise. The laughs come thick and fast and the performances are solid across the board, but what really takes this to an unexpected dimension is the deep-seated engagement with real-world issues.

Gang violence and institutional racism are taken to task without subtlety but with plenty of heart, and so what could have been unbearably corny is instead a rare second sequel that really works (and an even rarer second sequel that improves upon both prior movies).

Which movies caught you off-guard with their surprising quality this summer? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.