10 Trick Castings That Totally Fooled You
Can't wait to see Jared Leto's Joker? Enjoy both minutes of him then.
Actors hate being typecast, though they can use it to their advantage. Bruce Willis will often pay the bills by sleepwalking through blockbusters like A Good Day To Die Hard or Red 2, which allows him to go do juicer work with Moonrise Kingdom or Looper.
Typecasting is also a way for audiences to know what they’re getting when they buy a ticket. If the film stars Jason Statham, there’s a fair chance he’ll be punching people in the face throughout. Occasionally a movie can use the audience’s knowledge of an actor against them, either by subverting their image or outright destroying it.
An actor known for playing a good guy might be playing a secret villain, or they could be set up as the lead character, only to die halfway through. When used correctly this can be a good way to twist expectations; when it’s done wrong, it’s just a cheap gimmick used to mislead the viewing public.
It’s always nice to see a film using your assumptions against you though, and here are ten movies that did a good job of it.
10. Frank Grillo - Captain America: Civil War
In an alternate universe, Frank Grillo would have made an awesome Punisher, but he was snapped up to play Brock Rumlow instead. Grillo’s one of the few actors who could be a convincing threat to Captain America despite his character having no superpowers, and after Rumlow is badly scarred by the events of The Winter Soldier, the stage was set for epic revenge.
He then becomes the villainous Crossbones, who helped assassinate Steve Rogers in the comic. This led to fans believing Cap might die when he faces off against Rumlow, but they needn’t have worried; Crossbones is dead within the first ten minutes.
He gets a great fight scene before trying to kill Cap in a suicide bombing. Thanks to Scarlet Witch’s quick reflexes she contains the explosion and tosses him away, although this doesn’t work well for the people around him when the bomb does go off.
Crossbones was kind of a red herring character here, though his death does play a part in fracturing the Avengers.
9. Samuel L. Jackson - Deep Blue Sea
One of the best examples of trick casting is the enjoyably daft shark movie Deep Blue Sea. The plot has scientists engineer smart sharks to develop a cure for Alzheimer's – because that sounds like a good idea. The shark's escape and hunt down the crew, and it’s up to badass financier Sam Jackson to lead them to safety.
After all, he’s the biggest name in the cast and his character is an avalanche survivor; of course, he’s going to take charge. He even gathers them together for an inspiration speech; he’s rudely interrupted when a shark jumps out of the water and rips him apart, though.
This scene works for many reasons. Jackson’s role is essentially a decoy, designed to misled the audience into thinking he’s the hero, only for him to get cruelly snatched away before he does anything.He's shocking and hilarious at the same time.
8. Byung-hun Lee - Terminator: Genisys
Terminator: Genisys kept a tight lid on its story for awhile, and chances are it would have stayed that way if it wasn’t for a weak reaction to the first trailer. It looked like a lame reheating of the other movies, and the story didn’t look especially gripping. They even appeared to be reusing the T-1000 – this time played by Korean actor Byung-hun Lee – as the villain.
The studio probably panicked at this indifferent response, so they released another trailer where they spoiled the whole thing, including the twist that John Connor was the new Terminator. Genisys still would have sucked, but at least this revolution would have been a shock to anyone walking into the cinema blind.
In the movie, this means the poor T-1000 is reduced to a secondary villain, and despite being nearly unstoppable before he gets destroyed without fifteen minutes here. A shame, since Lee brought some genuine menace to a movie in dire need of some.
7. Drew Barrymore - Scream
It’s an old trick, but an effective one; cast a name actor, splash them over the poster and make it appear they’re the lead, even though they die within the first act. In slasher movies, it’s a famous trope from Psycho, where Janet Leigh is the lead until she meets a bloody end halfway through.
Scream borrowed this tactic for the opening scene, casting Drew Barrymore as a teen menaced by a serial killer. Since she was the biggest name and is front and centre on the poster, it seemed safe to assume she’d be sticking around for the duration.
Nope; she’s killed and gutted by the end of the scene. This established Scream wasn’t messing around, and it up's the stakes for the rest of the characters. Barrymore was actually offered the lead originally but opted for the opening scene instead, realising just how memorable it could be if it was pulled off right; smart choice.
6. Harrison Ford - What Lies Beneath
Harrison Ford hasn’t played many villains throughout his career, and tends to stick doggedly to heroic characters. His role in What Lies Beneath didn’t look like anything out of the ordinary, other than the fact his character admits to having had an affair to his heartbroken wife.
It becomes clear by the end there’s more to it than that, and it’s revealed he murdered his ex-lover when she threatened to ruin his life. To protect himself he tries to kill his wife when she learns the truth; she has to fight back with a little help from the ghost of her romantic rival.
While Ford’s character is a little more dubious than normal, no one knew he was playing an out and out villain. He’s pretty great at it too, playing the character with smug detachment until his wife gains the upper hand.
In retrospect, it might have been a good thing Ford hadn’t played many bad guy roles since it allows the twist here to be a real surprise.
5. Arnold Schwarzenegger - The Expendables
Any child of the eighties or nineties used to wonder who’d win in a fight; Arnie or Stallone? After all, it was Rocky against The Terminator, Rambo versus Commando, Oscar versus Kindergarten Cop. It never happened, though, and by 2010 the odds of it appeared remote.
Then the movie gods smiled on us, confirming that Arnold would appear alongside Stallone in throwback action film The Expendables. The mind raced at the possibilities, and the trailers played up their inevitable showdown.
Only it never happens. Arnold was still Governor at the time, so he worked on the movie for precisely six hours. After thirty years of hype, their scene amounts to two minutes of lame in-jokes, which was a bitter disappointment to their fans.
They later teamed up for two more Expendables movies and Escape Plan but watching two sixty-something dudes trade friendly barbs wasn’t the explosive experience audiences were hoping for, or the one The Expendables sold them.
4. Sigourney Weaver – Alien
That’s right, Ripley. All the way back in 1979 Sigourney Weaver was an unknown actress, cast in a supporting role in a horror flick. Actor Tom Skerritt was the biggest name in the cast, and since he was playing the captain everyone just assumed he was the star.
Ripley is just part of the ensemble for the first two acts, but as crew members die – including Skerritt – she gradually takes on a leadership role. She’s ultimately the last survivor of the movie, and would go on to become one of the most iconic characters in sci-fi.
It’s easy to underestimate how surprising this was back then, since everyone is now familiar with how awesome Ripley is. An audience walking in blind had no way of knowing this, and the unpredictably just added to the tension.
3. Jason Statham - War
Jason Statham was pretty comfortable as an action star when he signed on for War, which pits him against Jet Li. He plays a vengeful cop chasing Li’s legendary assassin, who previously killed Statham’s partner and family years before.
So far, so formula.
War has a couple of tricks up its sleeve, though. One is that Li actually is Statham’s old partner, who surgically altered his face to become this assassin so he could avenge his wife. The other is that Statham is the one who betrayed him, and he was secretly in league with the villains all along.
Statham’s movies have a very predictable formula - punch, shoot, drive fast - so to watch one that breaks away and reveals he’s a bad dude is a bold move. War isn’t even that good, but it gets bonus points for expertly subverting expectations.
2. Jared Leto - Suicide Squad
1255786Recasting the Joker was always going to be a huge deal, and there was much excitement when Oscar winner Jared Leto took the role. Sure, he gives off douchey rock star vibes in real life, but the man knows how to act. The marketing for Suicide Squad heavily focussed on Joker, releasing numerous photos and trailers that seemed to make him look important to the story.
To be fair David Ayer always stated the Joker wasn’t the main threat, but it’s doubtful anyone walking into Suicide Squad expected just how little of the character there was. Leto has maybe ten minutes of screentime total and just disappears about halfway through.
Fans were annoyed, not only be his lack of screentime but by how little the Joker actually affects the story; if all his scenes were deleted, events would turn out the same way.
Even Leto was annoyed by this, feeling he – and the audience – were mis-sold on the character’s importance.
1. Steven Seagal - Executive Decision
Steven Seagal was riding high in 1994. His first five movies were huge hits, he was one of the biggest action stars on the planet and he was commanding large fees. How times change. Still, the makers of Executive Decision decided to use his status to pull a fast one on audiences.
The story involves a hijacked plane, which a team of soldiers has to infiltrate and seize back. The trailers and posters made it look like a two-hander between Seagal and Kurt Russell; Russell would be the uptight brain and Steven the kickass brawn. Instead, the movie does an epic rug pull, with Seagal having to sacrifice himself in the first act to prevent damage to the plane.
It’s a real shocker and anyone who expected a Seagal action flick must have utterly stunned. Looking back it was a little sneaky of the producers to promote Seagal’s role so heavily, especially when he doesn’t even set foot on the plane. That said if they hadn’t maybe his surprise death wouldn’t have worked so well.
Can you think of any other movies that mis-sold an actor's involvement in the story? Share them in the comments below.