12 Amazing Premises Wasted On Underwhelming Horror Films

Horrifyingly disappointing.

Brightburn Elizabeth Banks
Sony Pictures

Horror is a genre that is absolutely full of great concepts and when these are realised well, they make for absolutely great viewings. To name a few recent examples, films like Saw, Final Destination, The Witch, The Killing of a Sacred Deer, It Follows, Train to Busan, Tucker and Dale Vs Evil, The Lighthouse, Get Out and The Cabin in the Woods fully did their amazing concepts justice.

That being said, on the other side of the coin you've got an enormous number of great premises that were wasted on weak horror movies. When it comes to films there are few things more infuriating than wasted potential and as such, these following horror films were about as irritating and frustrating as viewing experiences can be.

If anyone wants to remake any of these, bring it on. Maybe then these excellent ideas the great movies they deserve...

12. Escape Room (2017) And Escape Room (2019)

Escape Room
Sony Pictures Releasing

Premise: Both films are about deadly escape rooms. The 2017 one concerns a group of friends out celebrating a birthday who visit an escape room that's actually a death trap. The 2019 one sees six strangers participating in a much larger-scale game for a cash prize.

Escape rooms are very popular right now and a deadly one is a great idea for a movie, but unfortunately neither of these films quite did the idea justice.

The 2017 film, which is fairly low-budget and small-scale, is a weak movie which suffers from awful pacing, a lack of thrills and bad writing and acting. It's the kind of thing which might just about fill the bill if you need something to watch something on Netflix and have literally nothing else to do, but otherwise it's a poor use of time.

The 2019 film is quite a bit better and is easily the best film on this list, but it still wasn't as good as it could've been. It runs out of steam towards the end and is heavily undermined by its PG-13 rating.

Still, a sequel for the latter film is imminent, so perhaps we'll see this premise done better soon. Just please make it R-rated.


11. Would You Rather?

Would You Rather
Periscope Entertainment

Premise: A woman (Brittany Snow) competes in a sadistic game of Would You Rather? in order to win a cash prize.

This one has a terrific concept and looked set to be one of the best movies in the mostly weak Torture-Porn genre, but unfortunately it was (mostly) another dud.

The trouble with this one is that it's just really boring. The games are unimaginative and repetitive and it's mostly just people sitting at a table doing the same things over and over again.

Factor in the irritating twist ending and flat directing and there's very little reason to bother with this one. It is disturbing and can't be faulted for that, but thanks to the lack of a compelling script it's all just shock for shock's sake and is ultimately unpleasant without ever being enjoyable or rewarding.


10. Sadako Vs. Kayako

sadako vs kayako
Kadokawa

Premise: The ghosts of the Ring and Grudge franchises (the Japanese versions) face off

This was teased as an April Fools joke in April 2015, but was later confirmed to be a real production.

It's certainly a rather irresistible concept and felt like exactly what both these franchises needed given the creative slump they'd been in for ages, but unfortunately Sadako Vs. Kayako is just very 'meh'.

It's not the worst film you'll ever watch but it's just a bog-standard ghost story in the end that isn't very scary at all. The similar Freddy Vs Jason just about worked because it tapped into the camp, silly potential of the story but this one has no such self-awareness and plays this fairly ridiculous story completely straight and this undermines the entire film. The ending is very annoying as well.


9. Frozen (2010)

Frozen Movie 2010 Cast
Anchor Bay

Premise: No, not that Frozen. In this high-concept, low-budget horror-thriller, three college students (Emma Bell, Shawn Ashmore and Kevin Zegers) get stranded on a ski lift and have to somehow find a way off it. If they fail, they will freeze to death.

With its terrifying premise, not to mention some very good marketing indeed, Frozen looked like a good thriller but unfortunately it founders in the end.

One of the main issues is that writer-director Adam Green failed to pull off the story in a believable way. Everything about the film's scenario feels so avoidable and the characters are constantly behaving in stupid, illogical ways, making it hard to take the film seriously.

Frozen has some tense moments and one great, genuinely shocking death scene but other than that most of it just the characters sitting on the ski lift and bickering with each other. Thanks to this, as well as the awful structure, uneven pace and Emma Bell's terrible performance, Frozen is ultimately a let-down.


8. Triangle

Triangle movie
Icon Film Distribution

Premise: A woman tries to escape a killer on an abandoned cruise ship while trapped in a time loop.

If you want to see a time-loop horror film done well, check out Happy Death Day. That might not be a great film but it is a solid one and thankfully it's considerably better than this nonsensical misfire.

Triangle starts with promise (just like many of the films on this list) but just gets stupider and stupider as it goes along and fails to ever really be scary.

It also resembles the time loop at the centre of its story in the worst possible way. It's repetitive as hell and by the time it ends nothing has really changed, making this a thoroughly unsatisfying viewing experience.

The film's R-rating and Melissa George's strong leading performance keep it watchable up to a point, but for the most part this is just pretty bloody annoying.


7. Brightburn

Brightburn Attack
Sony Pictures Releasing

Premise: A couple raising an extraterrestrial child as their own discover that he has superhuman powers. Unfortunately, he isn't using them for good.

Being one of the most mainstream superhero horror movies to date, Brightburn was one of 2019's most anticipated horror films but ultimately it just blew it.

It's the kind of film you largely forget ten minutes after finishing it.'Bad Guy' by Billie EIlish, which was probably the most iconic song of last year, plays during the end credits and that's genuinely the most memorable thing about the movie.

Brightburn is little more than a deeply, deeply mediocre horror film with predictable story beats and pretty much nothing in the way of scares. Meanwhile, the over-powered villain means there's little suspense either.

It's unfortunate that James Gunn was only the producer. If he'd written or directed this it's likely Brightburn wouldn't have been quite so aggressively forgettable.


6. The Hunt

The Hunt
Universal Pictures

Premise: Several people are released in a hunting ground where they are hunted down and murdered by members of the elite.

This was the most controversial film of 2019... despite not actually being released that year. Thanks to worries about its gun violence themes and some apparent criticism from Donald Trump, the film was shelved.

Given the promise of its premise that was a bitter disappointment, so it was great to see that The Hunt would finally be released in early 2020. But was it worth the wait? Not at all.

It's still hard to believe that such a by-the-numbers film could've caused so much trouble. Not only had people Completely misunderstood what it was about beforehand (it's not a film about killing Trump voters - the Trump voters are the protagonists and the film's villains are elite liberals) but it's actually pretty tame in the end and is an overall weak thriller.

After an amazing opening 15 minutes The Hunt devolves into a rote, two-dimensional kill-fest with too little dark humour or actual tension to work. It's a disappointing movie whichever way you cut it and definitely not one of Blumhouse's finer movies.


5. The Bone Collector

The Bone Collector
Columbia Pictures

Premise: A quadriplegic detective (Denzel Washington) works with a NYPD cop (Angelina Jolie) in order to stop a depraved killer.

Serial killer Whodunnits are pretty irresistible and this was blessed with a wonderful cast, but ultimately the actors are so, so much better than anything else in the film.

Basically, this is one of quite a few movies - such as Man on Fire, Deja Vu, Safe House and Flight - where Denzel Washington happens to be completely brilliant but the actual movie is pretty weak. Overall, it feels like an underwhelming, lazy rip-off of The Silence of the Lambs.

Since this also has some stylish visuals and shocking death scenes, this really could've been so much better so it's a shame that the final product was so underwhelming. It's hopelessly ridiculous, the villain is laughable and it's just, in general, very bland and doesn't have enough suspense.


4. Holidays

Holidays Kevin Smith
Vertigo Entertainment

Premise: An anthology of eight horror shorts from eight different filmmakers, each corresponding to the following holidays: Valentine's Day, St Patrick's Day, Easter, Mother's Day, Father's Day, Halloween, Christmas and New Year's Eve.

Anthology horror films are very hit-or-miss and many of them fail to work. Basing each short on a different holiday was a great idea so it seemed like Holidays might buck that trend, but sadly not.

The problem here was that the film's producers just didn't get a satisfying round-up of short films. The Father's Day and Halloween shorts (the latter of which was made by Kevin Smith) are definitely the best ones but they're still not outstanding.

Meanwhile, the Valentine's Day, Christmas and New Year's Eve shorts have some good ideas but the execution is very flawed and they're overall mediocre. Worse still, the St Patrick's Day, Easter and Mother's Day shorts are painfully dire.

On the whole, this is not worth your time and fails to provide a single great short. Good horror anthologies do exist, such as Dead of Night, Trick 'r Treat and V/H/S 2, so go watch one of those instead.


3. Countdown

Countdown movie
STX Entertainment

Premise: An app which tells you how long you have before you die starts appearing on people's phones.

The idea of a killer app was a very strong one, so it's a shame that it was wasted in one of 2019's worst horror films.

Idiotic, unscary, poorly made and thoroughly dull, this one is basically exactly like all those terrible studio horror films we got all the time in the 2000s: a PG-13 jump scare-a-thon with no subtext, tension or atmosphere.

The main idea is completely mishandled as well, since the villain behind the app is a silly demon and the entire thing is impossible to take seriously. What makes the inadequacy of Countdown even more frustrating is that there were two potential easy fixes.

Firstly, it could've tapped into the wacky nature of the story and been done as a horror comedy; after all, Countdown's biggest asset was that it was actually quite funny at times, so it could've played to this strength.

Secondly, if it was to be done as a straight horror, it should've had a human villain and gone down the slasher route; that would've worked far better. Alas, it wasn't to be.


2. Truth Or Dare

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

Premise: Some luckless teens are caught up in a deadly game of Truth or Dare.

A deadly game of Truth or Dare is a very good idea for a horror film, so it's a shame it appeared in one of the worst horror films of the latter 2010s.

Similarly to Countdown, the writers fatally undermined the film by having supernatural villains instead of human ones. Ghosts playing Truth or Dare immediately felt very silly and if this had been a death game movie like Saw with human villains, it could've been so much better.

It's also a completely awful film in every possible way. The writing, directing, PG-13 death scenes and woeful jump scares are all bottom-of-the-barrel awful and it has one of the most annoying sequel-bait endings in recent memory. Meanwhile, the film's unintentionally hilarious ghosts could be some of the worst villains ever committed to film.

It is a completely dire one-star movie... and, unfortunately, a sequel's in development.

This was directed by Jeff 'Kick-Ass 2' Wadlow, who really needs to be kicked out of Hollywood already. After all, this wasn't the last time he would waste a great idea...


1. Fantasy Island

fantasy island
Sony Pictures Releasing

Premise: Some guests on an island where people's greatest wishes come true soon find these dreams turning into nightmares.

Thanks to the excellent premise, Fantasy Island looked very interesting. And it was, to some extent, since it's unsusual for any movie to be as bad as this, so this is a rare breed of horror film.

The directing is awful, scares are non-existent, the plot twists are horrendous, the screenplay is stupid, manipulative, disjointed and infuriating... truly, this is something else.

This could've been something really surreal and psychologically unnerving but it shoots itself in the foot at every turn. For example, one of the trailer's best scenes presented the scenario of a character wishing for revenge on a school bully only to be presented with the former bully in a torture chamber, which isn't what she wanted.

This could've been a great set-piece but thanks to the abysmal writing and inexplicable PG-13 rating (which prevents it from ever being violent or disturbing), in the final film this scene goes absolutely nowhere. Fantasy Island is basically one scene of wasted potential after another... for two bloody hours!

Basically, it's the epitome of a horror film wasting a great premise.


Watch Next


Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.